Review: Four Seasons Resort Nevis

Review: Four Seasons Resort Nevis

NAME: Four Seasons Nevis
LOCATION: Charlestown, St. Kitts & Nevis
DATE: July 2023
REVIEW RATING:
BEN SAYS: The Four Seasons Nevis is an often overlooked luxury resort. It's private, has beautiful pools, a large beach with calm water, friendly service, several dining outlets, and lots of other amenities. This property is worth considering for a Caribbean getaway.
35
EXTRA PERKS AVAILABLE Enjoy breakfast, upgrades, & more

Want to take advantage of Four Seasons Preferred Partner benefits, including a space available room upgrade, complimentary breakfast, a hotel credit, and more? Contact Ford ([email protected]) for more details. He may even be able to help if you already have a stay booked.

We recently spent a long weekend at the 189-room Four Seasons Nevis. This was a special trip for us, as it was the first time we took our son, Miles, on a vacation that involved getting on a plane and traveling to another country. This was the perfect trip for those purposes, since Nevis is pretty easy to get to.

Honestly, prior to this trip I knew very little about the Four Seasons Nevis. We had visited the Park Hyatt St. Kitts many years ago, and St. Kitts and Nevis are one country spread across two islands (Nevis is around 36 square miles, with a population of around 11,000, while St. Kitts is around 100 square miles, with a population of around 40,000). Having been to St. Kitts, I was curious to see what Nevis is like, and how the Four Seasons compared.

Well, I was pleasantly surprised by Nevis and the Four Seasons. The island is quite charming and off the grid, in a good way. Meanwhile the Four Seasons has a sense of place, the friendly Four Seasons service you expect, great dining options, nice pools, and a large beach.

Booking the Four Seasons Nevis

First let me say that in the interest of full disclosure, Ford (and a few other travel advisors) were invited by the Four Seasons for this stay, so our room was complimentary (though we paid for incidentals). We were invited during the annual Sea Turtle Week at the property, which is a cool effort that the hotel participates in. Since Ford was invited to also bring me and our son, we figured it was the ideal first opportunity for Miles to take an international trip.

Opinions expressed are my own, and of course you’re welcome to skip this review if these kinds of hotels aren’t up your alley. The two major trip reports I’m writing before and after this exclusively have points hotels that I booked at standard rates.

With that out of the way, if you’ve traveled since the start of the pandemic, you probably know that luxury hotel prices have skyrocketed in the past few years. Along those lines, the Four Seasons Nevis actually seems to represent relatively good value.

For the dates of our stay, the rate was around $600 per night before taxes and fees. Admittedly July is off season, but as a point of comparison, that was slightly lower than the rates at the Park Hyatt St. Kitts and even Westin Grand Cayman (I know comparing the property to Grand Cayman is pretty random, but I’ve always been confused by the pricing at that property, and wonder what I’m missing?).

Even during the busy season, the Four Seasons Nevis can sometimes be booked for under $1,000 per night before taxes and fees, putting the pricing in line with the above two properties.

The best way to book any Four Seasons hotel is through a travel advisor affiliated with the Four Seasons Preferred Partner program. When booking through Preferred Partner you pay the same rate you’ll find directly on Four Seasons’ website, but you’ll receive extra perks, including the following:

  • A room upgrade, subject to availability
  • Complimentary daily breakfast
  • A hotel credit to use during your stay

Four Seasons Preferred Partner is generally combinable with promotions being offered directly through Four Seasons, including advance purchase rates, free night offers, and more. Note that booking Four Seasons properties through Preferred Partner is better than booking through programs like Amex Fine Hotels & Resorts. Why?

  • With Preferred Partner you have the option of room service breakfast in place of restaurant breakfast
  • Upgrades are prioritized for Preferred Partner bookings, given that it’s Four Seasons’ own proprietary program (and the value of an upgrade can be significant)
  • You can combine Preferred Partner perks with virtually any rate on Four Seasons’ website (other programs don’t allow you to stack promotions in the same way)

You can’t beat getting all of these extra perks just for booking through an eligible travel advisor. Note that Preferred Partner bookings can also be made for the Four Seasons Private Retreats at the property, which consist of villas that can be booked by the night. Ford is happy to help book Four Seasons properties through Preferred Partner, and can be reached at [email protected].

Four Seasons Nevis location & transfer

I think one hesitation that people have with traveling to the Four Seasons Nevis is that they assume it’s hard to get to, since Nevis doesn’t have an airport with “major” commercial service. Fortunately the process is actually quite easy.

If you’re wanting to visit the Four Seasons Nevis, plan on flying into Robert L. Bradshaw International Airport in St. Kitts (SKB). There are nonstop flights to there from the United States, including on American Airlines to Miami.

The Four Seasons then arranges transfers from the airport to the resort, at the rate of $200 per adult roundtrip (or $100 per child). What does the transfer entail? Well, once you exit immigration at the airport, you’ll be greeted by a Four Seasons employee. From there, your bags will already be taken, and then you’ll be driven to Christophe Harbour, which is a roughly 20 minute drive.

Transfer to Four Seasons Nevis
Boat to Four Seasons Nevis

Once there, it’s a roughly 20-minute speedboat ride from St. Kitts to Nevis. There’s a limited selection of complimentary drinks onboard, including beer, soda, and water.

What’s cool is that the boat drops you off directly at the Four Seasons’ pier, so it almost feels like you’re arriving on a private island. On the dock you’re met by Four Seasons staff, and then escorted directly to your accommodation, where your luggage is also delivered.

Four Seasons Nevis arrival dock
Four Seasons Nevis arrival dock

Honestly, the whole arrival experience is pretty seamless. From clearing immigration at the airport to arriving in our room took just over an hour, which isn’t half bad.

Four Seasons Nevis property layout & lobby

The Four Seasons Nevis is a gorgeous property that’s spread out over 350 waterfront acres. It’s a treat just to walk around the property, and oddly I felt like the weather was actually nicer there than in Miami in July. In terms of layout, the property reminded me a lot of the Four Seasons Hualalai, given the beautiful paths along the water.

Four Seasons Nevis walkway
Four Seasons Nevis walkway
Four Seasons Nevis property
Four Seasons Nevis walkway

The guest rooms are located in roughly a dozen different cottages, each of which is two stories. It gives the resort a great outdoor and residential feel, since there aren’t any interior hallways to walk through.

Four Seasons Nevis property

The hotel’s lobby (referred to as the Great House) is basically in the center of the hotel, and is a modern, open-air space.

Four Seasons Nevis lobby

The lobby has plenty of seating, so this can be a great place to sit down and get some work done in the shade, if you’re looking for a change of scenery. As a guest you could come to this property and barely even visit the lobby, though, given that you’re taken directly from the arrival pier to your room.

Four Seasons Nevis lobby
Four Seasons Nevis lobby
Four Seasons Nevis lobby

Four Seasons Nevis one bedroom suite

We were assigned room 313, which was a one bedroom suite located in the Coconut Walk cottage, on the ground floor.

Four Seasons Nevis room exterior

The suites at the Four Seasons Nevis are generously sized, and seem to basically be the equivalent of two guest rooms. Upon entering the suite, the living room was straight ahead.

Four Seasons Nevis suite entryway

The living room featured a huge couch (which can be converted into a bed), a dining table with four chairs, and a TV.

Four Seasons Nevis suite living room
Four Seasons Nevis suite living room
Four Seasons Nevis suite living room

There was also a minibar setup, with complimentary coffee and tea, plus a variety of drinks and snacks for purchase.

Four Seasons Nevis suite living room
Four Seasons Nevis suite minibar
Four Seasons Nevis suite minibar
Four Seasons Nevis suite minibar

There was also a lovely welcome amenity, consisting of a bottle of sauvignon blanc, some sweets, fresh fruit, and an edible turtle, made of chocolate and marshmallows.

Four Seasons Nevis welcome amenity
Four Seasons Nevis welcome amenity

Back near the entrance was the smaller of the two bathrooms, which was still huge. It had a sink, a walk-in shower, a tub, and a toilet. This is a great suite for families, since you have two full bathrooms.

Four Seasons Nevis suite second bathroom
Four Seasons Nevis suite second bathroom

There was then a door separating the bedroom from the living room. The bedroom featured the typical uber-comfortable Four Seasons signature bed, a couch, and a TV (and in our case, also a crib).

Four Seasons Nevis suite bedroom
Four Seasons Nevis suite bedroom
Four Seasons Nevis suite bedroom

The main bathroom had double sinks, a walk-in shower, a soaking tub, and a toilet.

Four Seasons Nevis suite main bathroom
Four Seasons Nevis suite main bathroom
Four Seasons Nevis suite toilet

Toiletries were in reusable containers and were from Diptyque.

Four Seasons Nevis suite toiletries

It was also adorable how many cute little touches they left around the room for our son, like the rubber duck. Awww…

Four Seasons Nevis rubber duck

Unfortunately he was much more interesting in exploring every possibly dangerous part of the room, and seeing if he could do any damage…

“Boy, that’s a really interesting shelf!”

The room also had a huge outdoor space, with two separate areas. Each featured two loungers and a dining table with two chairs.

Four Seasons Nevis suite terrace
Four Seasons Nevis suite terrace

Since we were on the ground floor, we had a gate through which we could directly access the lawn, and we were then just a short walk from the beach and the pools.

Four Seasons Nevis suite terrace

Housekeeping was provided twice daily, and was thorough. Furthermore, Wi-Fi was fast and complimentary.

All-in-all, we thought the rooms here were great. Our suite was spacious and practically designed. However, admittedly this hotel doesn’t have uber-modern rooms with remarkable design, as you might find at some of Four Seasons’ newer resorts.

By the way, one other cool thing to note, which I really appreciate. The Four Seasons has shared washing machines in each cottage, which you’re free to use any time (and there’s even detergent and dryer sheets). Being able to wash your clothes for free at a resort is awesome, and something I wish we’d see at more hotels.

Four Seasons Nevis laundry facility

Four Seasons Nevis pools

The Four Seasons Nevis has a very strong pool game, as there are three pools to choose from.

The Limin Pool is specifically for adults, and is definitely the nicest. It’s an infinity-edge pool overlooking the Caribbean Sea, and has palm trees and vegetation all around it.

Four Seasons Nevis pool
Four Seasons Nevis pool
Four Seasons Nevis pool

The next pool is the Calypso Pool, which is specifically intended for families. This is the biggest pool, and also features a 25 meter (83 foot) swimming lane. We went swimming here with Miles, and he really enjoyed it (as did we)!

Four Seasons Nevis pool
Four Seasons Nevis pool
Four Seasons Nevis pool

Finally, the third pool is the Soca Pool, which is fairly similar to the Calypso Pool. It’s intended more for relaxing, so while it’s not explicitly only for adults, you can expect that it’ll be between the Limin Pool and Calypso Pool in terms of the vibe.

Four Seasons Nevis pool
Four Seasons Nevis pool
Four Seasons Nevis pool

It’s hard to beat the total amount of pool space here, and I feel like even if the hotel were busy, the pool areas wouldn’t feel overcrowded.

Four Seasons Nevis beach

The Four Seasons Nevis is located on Pinney’s Beach, which runs for a few miles uninterrupted. The Caribbean Sea water is calm and clear, and the sand is soft, with no sargassum. While perhaps not as picturesque as Grace Bay in Turks & Caicos, it’s a very nice stretch of beach.

Four Seasons Nevis beach
Four Seasons Nevis beach
Four Seasons Nevis beach
Four Seasons Nevis beach

The sunset from the beach can be pretty breathtaking as well!

Four Seasons Nevis beach sunset

Four Seasons Nevis spa, gym, tennis, and golf

As you’d expect, the Four Seasons Nevis has an impressive spa. We didn’t get any spa treatments this trip (since we were traveling with our son, and that kept us very busy), but you can find the spa menu here.

Four Seasons Nevis spa

Right next to the spa is the gym, which has pretty modern weight and cardio equipment, and it’s a good size for a resort.

Four Seasons Nevis gym
Four Seasons Nevis gym
Four Seasons Nevis gym
Four Seasons Nevis gym
Four Seasons Nevis gym
Four Seasons Nevis gym

Perhaps what’s most impressive is the number of tennis courts you’ll find at the resort. There are nine tennis courts, including hard, clay, and grass courts, as well as a basketball court and a pickleball court.

Four Seasons Nevis court
Four Seasons Nevis court
Four Seasons Nevis court
Four Seasons Nevis court
Four Seasons Nevis court

Also, I’m not a golfer, but the hotel has an 18-hole golf course, so this could also be a popular destination for those who are into that.

Dining at Four Seasons Nevis

The Four Seasons Nevis has a few on-property dining outlets, including the following:

  • EsQuilina is where the resort serves breakfast, and then in the evenings it’s transformed into a Mediterranean restaurant for dinner; next to this is Crowned Monkey Rum Bar
  • On The Dune is the resort’s beachside restaurant, serving lunch and dinner; this also has an adjacent bar
  • Mango is the resort’s Caribbean restaurant, and it serves dinner

All-in-all I found the food quality to be very good, though prices are also high (but in line with what I’d expect at a luxury Caribbean resort nowadays). Let’s go over each of those options.

Four Seasons Nevis EsQuilina

EsQuilina is located just off the lobby, and has a modern design, with both indoor and outdoor seating. The restaurant is a good size, and has traditional dining tables, booths, counter seating, and an outdoor terrace.

Four Seasons Nevis EsQuilina Restaurant
Four Seasons Nevis EsQuilina Restaurant
Four Seasons Nevis EsQuilina Restaurant
Four Seasons Nevis EsQuilina Restaurant
Four Seasons Nevis EsQuilina Restaurant

Breakfast is served at the restaurant daily from 7AM until 11AM. There’s a buffet option, or otherwise you can order off the menu. We had the buffet each morning, which we enjoyed.

Four Seasons Nevis EsQuilina Restaurant

The buffet had a great selection, ranging from fresh fruit, to yogurt, to veggies, to cold cuts, to bread and pastries, to pancakes and waffles, to some other sweets, to several hot dishes, like eggs, bacon, potatoes, fish, etc.

Four Seasons Nevis breakfast buffet
Four Seasons Nevis breakfast buffet
Four Seasons Nevis breakfast buffet
Four Seasons Nevis breakfast buffet
Four Seasons Nevis breakfast buffet
Four Seasons Nevis breakfast buffet
Four Seasons Nevis breakfast buffet

There was also a mimosa and bloody mary station, included with the buffet.

Four Seasons Nevis breakfast buffet

The buffet also has an omelet station, so you can have cooked to order eggs.

Four Seasons Nevis breakfast buffet

I enjoyed an iced coffee each morning, along with a veggie omelet.

Four Seasons Nevis breakfast coffee
Four Seasons Nevis breakfast omelet

Miles enjoyed trying pancakes for the first time, though he’s not sure exactly how he feels about them… I think.

“Hmmm…”

In the evenings, the space transforms into a Mediterranean restaurant, and you can find the menu here. We had dinner here one evening, and the meal started with freshly baked bread plus a sun-dried tomato dip.

Four Seasons Nevis EsQuilina dinner

We decided to just split several things, including the Mediterranean platter, keftedes, beef carpaccio, and smoked gambas. We enjoyed everything we tried, and given where we were, I thought the execution was good.

Four Seasons Nevis EsQuilina dinner
Four Seasons Nevis EsQuilina dinner

Also, next to EsQuilina is the Crowned Monkey Rum Bar. We never ended up having a drink here, since it’s indoors, and we wanted to enjoy the outdoors as much as possible (also, we weren’t drinking much, because we had Miles to take care of!).

Four Seasons Nevis Crowned Monkey Rum Bar
Four Seasons Nevis Crowned Monkey Rum Bar

Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune

On The Dune is the Four Season Nevis’ open-air restaurant right near the beach, serving lunch and dinner. The restaurant has plenty of tables, as well as bar seating.

Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune Restaurant
Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune Restaurant
Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune Restaurant

You can find the lunch menu here. At the beginning of each meal, we were offered some delicious pita flatbread with hummus.

Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune lunch

Over the course of our stay we had the island spiced mahi club with a side of squash and cashews (yum!), the shaved kale and toasted quinoa salad, and the Greek salad with chicken.

Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune lunch
Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune lunch
Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune lunch

On The Dune also has a bar even closer to the beach, which is a great place to grab a pre-dinner drink. You can find the bar menu here.

Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune Bar
Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune Bar
Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune Bar

I had a rum punch here, which seems to be the most popular drink at the resort (goodness, it’s strong!).

Four Seasons Nevis On The Dune Bar drinks

Four Seasons Nevis Mango

Mango is located at the far end of the resort, and is my favorite dining outlet on property. For one, I love the setting of the restaurant, as it’s open-air and directly overlooks the Caribbean Sea.

Four Seasons Nevis Mango Restaurant

Just about all tables have views of the water, and there’s also a couch area where you can relax and have a drink before or after dinner.

Four Seasons Nevis Mango Restaurant
Four Seasons Nevis Mango Restaurant

You can find the dinner menu here. When we visited, Ford had a rum punch, while I had a dirty martini (which was surprisingly one of the best dirty martinis I’ve ever had, and that’s saying a lot).

Four Seasons Nevis Mango drinks

There was some delicious cornbread brought out at the start of the meal.

Four Seasons Nevis Mango dinner

To start, we split the Nevis peak salad.

Four Seasons Nevis Mango dinner

Then for our mains, we had Chef Xavi’s volcano curry and the crusted catch of the day.

Four Seasons Nevis Mango dinner
Four Seasons Nevis Mango dinner

While the food was delicious, my single favorite thing about Mango was the live music. I adore live music in bars and restaurants, and will go out of my way to visit places that have that. So to have truly awesome music throughout dinner was such a treat. The two ladies performing are literal rockstars, and I’d pay to see them in concert any day (except I don’t like crowds… so maybe I’ll just have to come back here?).

Four Seasons Nevis service

Service was one of the highlights of the Four Seasons Nevis. While Four Seasons is known for great service, I find that service in the Caribbean can be hit or miss sometimes, so I wasn’t sure what to expect.

Honestly, I found virtually everyone we interacted with to be incredibly friendly. Some employees particularly stood out. A special shout to Kimisha at Mango (she was so friendly, and her smile could light up a room) and Demar at On The Dune (who couldn’t have been kinder when interacting with us and our son at lunch each day).

Honestly, there were so many other great employees, but unfortunately I didn’t get everyone else’s name. This is such a family friendly resort, which was much appreciated.

Who should visit the Four Seasons Nevis?

The Four Seasons Nevis exceeded my expectations, and in some ways I think it’s a hidden gem. When you think of high-end tourism in the Caribbean, you might think of Anguilla, St. Barts, etc. Nevis doesn’t cross most peoples’ mind unless you specifically have a reason to consider it.

Who should consider the Four Seasons Nevis? I think it’s an awesome property for anyone who is looking for a quiet, relaxing, luxurious vacation. Nevis is a charming and small island, and there aren’t even any traffic lights or buildings that are more than a few floors on the entire island. I find that really cute, since Nevis is in my opinion more interesting to drive around and explore than your typical Caribbean island, given how different it is.

That being said, if you’re looking for a huge scene, endless restaurants packed with half of the Upper East Side, etc., Nevis probably isn’t for you. This isn’t like St. Barts, where the “rich and famous” go to be seen. Personally I think that’s a big selling point of this property, but I think it’s important to at least clarify that, given that Four Seasons typically has pretty high end clientele.

Bottom line

The Four Seasons Nevis is a great luxury Caribbean resort if you’re looking for an easy, quiet getaway. Nevis isn’t a destination that most people think of, since it’s a small island with fairly limited tourism. That being said, I’d seriously consider this resort if you’re a fan of Four Seasons and like the Caribbean.

The resort sits on a beautiful piece of land with amazing views of the Caribbean Sea. The property has great pools, a huge beach, lots of activities, friendly service, and good food and drinks. There’s something really magical about the setting of this property that words can’t do justice to.

I’d say the only downside to this property is that it’s not a cutting edge Four Seasons design-wise, both in terms of the buildings, and in terms of the interiors. Still, I find the design to be tasteful, and the rooms and grounds are very well maintained.

What do you make of the Four Seasons Nevis?

EXTRA PERKS AVAILABLE Enjoy breakfast, upgrades, & more

Want to take advantage of Four Seasons Preferred Partner benefits, including a space available room upgrade, complimentary breakfast, a hotel credit, and more? Contact Ford ([email protected]) for more details. He may even be able to help if you already have a stay booked.

Read Four Seasons reviewsAthens, BostonCap-Ferrat, Costa Rica Peninsula PapagayoDenverDesroches Island, Florence, Fort Lauderdale, GenevaHualalai, KyotoLanai, Los Angeles at Beverly HillsLos CabosMadrid, Maldives at Landaa GiraavaruMaui, MegeveMiamiNapa Valley, Naviva, NevisOahu at Ko OlinaParis, Punta MitaSan Francisco at Embarcadero, ScottsdaleSeychelles, and Surfside

Learn about Four Seasons deals & offersAnguillaAthens, AtlantaAustinBahamasBora BoraBostonCap-FerratCosta RicaDubaiFort LauderdaleHawaiiJackson HoleLondonLos CabosMaldives, Minneapolis, Nashville, NavivaNew YorkNapa ValleyNew OrleansOrlandoPalm BeachParisPhiladelphiaPunta MitaSan FranciscoSanta FeSeattleSicily, Tamarindo, and Vail

Learn about Four Seasons basicsFour Seasons Preferred PartnerFour Seasons Private Retreats, Four Seasons YachtsFour Seasons Private JetFour Seasons travel agentsFour Seasons loyalty program, and maximizing value at Four Seasons

Conversations (35)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Michael M Guest

    Did you encounter any bulls or cows on the beach at night? Pre-pandemic I stayed here as part of a wedding party, and we had a party go late into the night. In the early morning hours several of us were in the ocean, when a literal herd of cattle got in between us (in the ocean) and our clothes / possessions. We had to wait what seemed like hours for the huge bulls to...

    Did you encounter any bulls or cows on the beach at night? Pre-pandemic I stayed here as part of a wedding party, and we had a party go late into the night. In the early morning hours several of us were in the ocean, when a literal herd of cattle got in between us (in the ocean) and our clothes / possessions. We had to wait what seemed like hours for the huge bulls to wander off before we could get out of the water, get our clothes and get back to our rooms. Strangest travel experience ever - but definitely a lovely resort.

  2. Grey Diamond

    The room is really... not my style. I mean, it looks like a set from The Golden Girls.

  3. nomad_dc Guest

    @Ben Would mind clarifying this statement?

    "You can combine Preferred Partner perks with virtually any rate on Four Seasons’ website (other programs don’t allow you to stack promotions in the same way)"

    Amex FH&R allows you to stack promotional rates as well (like book four nights get the 5th night free). Also, some Four Seasons hotels allow for in-room breakfast when booking through Amex FH&R.

    Plus the 5x points per dollar spent (on...

    @Ben Would mind clarifying this statement?

    "You can combine Preferred Partner perks with virtually any rate on Four Seasons’ website (other programs don’t allow you to stack promotions in the same way)"

    Amex FH&R allows you to stack promotional rates as well (like book four nights get the 5th night free). Also, some Four Seasons hotels allow for in-room breakfast when booking through Amex FH&R.

    Plus the 5x points per dollar spent (on prepaid rates) and the guaranteed 4:00pm checkout might be worth mentioning when comparing the two programs, as some people might derive greater value of these over the prioritization of room upgrades (which I suspect most people won't be upgraded to a suite, at least those of us who are not bloggers or travel agents)

    But maybe I'm missing something...

  4. Charlie Guest

    Did you visit nearby Golden Rock Inn? It was owned by Brice Marden who died last week, and the central pavilion and terraces were designed by Ed Tuttle. So it has lovely Amanjiwo vibes and is great for a meal.

  5. Jason Guest

    I don’t think people go to the four seasons Nevis “to catch up on some work” or “get some work done”. Most people come to these places to escape.
    Also, it’s not really that under the radar. I know people who’ve gone there since the 90s

    1. Chris Guest

      Not remotely true. My wife and I both work from home so we go to a lot of these destinations and work. While we may not work 40 hour weeks there, we are both still taking meetings, calls, zooms, etc.

  6. mark Guest

    I looked at the pictures again. It is indeed heinous, just tacky and second-hand throughout. Looks like a second-tier Grand Hyatt in a second-tier tropical location. Almost every picture is 180 degree opposite luxury. Very surprised 4S lets this property use the name. Again, 10-15 years ago it was one of the top resorts on the planet. This looks junky.

    1. Got Bit Guest

      Looks very much like it did after the hurricane of several years ago that wiped the place out. Also, there's no mention of the sand flies that bite, which were in ample supply on all the beaches we visited on Nevis. So, unless the Four Seasons has some special program, all who go for the beach would be better off going somewhere else.

  7. Mark Guest

    Excuse me Lucky, where is the turtle content?

  8. Jamie M Guest

    Great review Ben. It is nice to see some for hotels in the Caribbean which are more accessible for a quick trip from the US.

    One question. As beautiful as many of the islands are, some have not historically been very welcoming of the LGBT community, notwithstanding the recent decriminalization of gay sex in many, St Kitts and Nevis among them. As an out couple traveling with your son, did you ever feel uncomfortable or...

    Great review Ben. It is nice to see some for hotels in the Caribbean which are more accessible for a quick trip from the US.

    One question. As beautiful as many of the islands are, some have not historically been very welcoming of the LGBT community, notwithstanding the recent decriminalization of gay sex in many, St Kitts and Nevis among them. As an out couple traveling with your son, did you ever feel uncomfortable or have any issues with staff, etc. while visiting the islands? I know you feel strongly about being authentic when you travel. Would love to hear about your experience.

    Thanks!

  9. Janet 3 Guest

    Looks alot nicer than the one I stayed at in Vail. When I left there I swore if never stay at another one for that kind of money. We weren't greeted by anyone, nothing!! Looked at us like 'what are you doing here'. Terrible

  10. Zac Guest

    how would you compare this to the park Hyatt across the pond? Since they are priced accordingly do you think there is value of enjoying a few days in both to take advantage of both islands?

  11. Matt Guest

    The room decor is quite heinous, I hate to say!

    Four Seasons, in my deep personal experience, has become a rather cynical chain. I always feel like capital extraction is winning out over any semblance of true or meaningful hospitality.

  12. Daniel M Guest

    Hi Lucky. I love your blog, but keep in mind that this review violated what you promise readers. The language is right there at the top of your Reviews page: “While we often enjoy the benefits of our earned elite status, we avoid press trips, and pay for all our own travel (with either cash or miles).”

    1. Daniel M Guest

      Are you going to respond Lucky? I don't think I'm being unreasonable with my statement. Perhaps you just need to stop staying that you pay for all of your own travel and change your promise at the top of the Reviews page. Thanks.

  13. Steve M Guest

    Lucky, I love your blog and reviews.
    However, this one reeks of entitlement.
    Sorry.

  14. JC Guest

    2020 was “many years ago?” Haha.

  15. Anthony Diamond

    "That being said, if you’re looking for a huge scene, endless restaurants packed with half of the Upper East Side, etc."

    What if we *are* looking for high end resorts that have fun, interesting, lively, interactive crowds, food and beverage venues, etc, and combine that with good physical plant, good service, etc? Interacting with fellow travelers in an exciting setting is one of the joys of travel IMO. I feel like many hotel reviews are...

    "That being said, if you’re looking for a huge scene, endless restaurants packed with half of the Upper East Side, etc."

    What if we *are* looking for high end resorts that have fun, interesting, lively, interactive crowds, food and beverage venues, etc, and combine that with good physical plant, good service, etc? Interacting with fellow travelers in an exciting setting is one of the joys of travel IMO. I feel like many hotel reviews are lacking information on that front. Would love a list of these kinds of properties globally.

  16. Jerry Diamond

    I'd like to hear more about what you did in Nevis outside the resort. It's always intrigued me, and I'd really like to visit, but I'm not sure why.

    1. InternationalTraveler Gold

      I stayed in Nevis for two weeks during the pandemic in a private accommodation. The island has genuine friendly and helpful residents. My host put it as “good in everything but not the best in anything “ among the Caribbean islands. I suggest to rent a car to explore the island.

      We had a fantastic dinner at Golden Rock Inn as well as visited the Montpelier plantation where Diana stayed after breaking up with...

      I stayed in Nevis for two weeks during the pandemic in a private accommodation. The island has genuine friendly and helpful residents. My host put it as “good in everything but not the best in anything “ among the Caribbean islands. I suggest to rent a car to explore the island.

      We had a fantastic dinner at Golden Rock Inn as well as visited the Montpelier plantation where Diana stayed after breaking up with Charles. The beaches are not fantastic but very tranquil. The only negative is that I found quite a bit of trash being thrown away carelessly.

  17. John Guest

    My wife and I stayed there for a week in May. Lovely property, lovely people and I'd stab someone for more of their mango pancakes.

  18. Ryan Guest

    Nice to see reviews for non-points and credit card affiliated brands - there is life outside of hotels owned by mega-chains like Marriott, Hilton and IHG!

    Based on your comment about the Grand Cayman, I presume you haven't been to GC recently. In GC, Marriott has the Ritz, Marriott Resort, and the Westin. By now, you know how the cookie crumbles. The Ritz aims high, the Westin aims right under it, and the Marriott aims...

    Nice to see reviews for non-points and credit card affiliated brands - there is life outside of hotels owned by mega-chains like Marriott, Hilton and IHG!

    Based on your comment about the Grand Cayman, I presume you haven't been to GC recently. In GC, Marriott has the Ritz, Marriott Resort, and the Westin. By now, you know how the cookie crumbles. The Ritz aims high, the Westin aims right under it, and the Marriott aims for whats left.

    The problem in GC is the Marriott Resort beach literally washed away. Like hurricane shave completely eroded it. What used to be a generous beach with a pool reinforced by a cement wall that faces the beach, now has water right under the stairs, and has even eroded the sand from underneath the stairs.The Marriott advertising literature, photos, Instagram - everything would indicate they have a nice, even generous beach. To makeup for the lack of beach, they have a free shuttle. Then, the Ritz Carlton is (2) buildings. 1 building is across the street and connected by aerial walkway to a beachfront building. The Ritz beachfront building is mostly residences, but also has expensive (on points) rooms like penthouses, multi-room suites, etc.

    Whats the Marriott and the Ritz got to do with the Westin? If you are burning points in GC, or paying out of pocket and you want to stay in a building that is beach front and doesn't require spending big bucks for a upgraded room at the Ritz; the only option is the Westin.

    Any Bonvoy member researching their options in GC will quickly see they don't want to stay the Marriott Resort (which has interior hallways that are dated, musty smelling, along with no beach). They then realized they don't want to spend what the Ritz is asking. So they end up at the Westin.

    As a result, I believe the normal point/cash inventory at this Westin is over-consumed, generally. The GM of the Marriott Resort is quoted in multiple news publications, as he has discussed the challenges that mother nature presents, and how GC should invest (more) in beach rehabilitation.

  19. mark Guest

    very surprising pictures. looks like a mediocre Grand Hyatt or JW Marriott. 10-15 years ago this was one of the top resorts in the world. I believe it was severely damaged by a hurricane, and it looks like it was redeveloped on the cheap.

  20. Don Guest

    I liked the photo with Miles looking at the shelf. I pictured him thinking...... " The design of this is all wrong. Dad, did you bring the drill and the circular saw?"

  21. Endre Guest

    Hi Ben,
    As a parent myself, I'm curious about your thoughts on showing Miles' face on social media. We started out by blurring our child's face in our posts, but we're starting to wonder if we're being overly protective. I'm glad you three enjoyed your trip!

  22. TL Guest

    How was it as a gay couple? I'm getting more disenchanted the more I travel - even Bali kinda sucked - and I would not have chosen St Kitts & Nevis.

  23. Sean Guest

    Thanks for this. Considering a few nights the FS Nevis tacked on to our stay at PH SKB. How are facilities / activities for kids? Anything to speak of at all? Will have our 5yo in tow. Thanks!

    1. Ben Schlappig OMAAT

      @ Sean -- The hotel has a "Kids For All Seasons" club, which Four Seasons has at most of its properties. While we don't have a kid old enough to use it yet, I know Ford's clients who have kids old enough to use these clubs rave about them. They have a very nice setup for the club, and it has a playground, an indoor space, and more. I think the Four Seasons Nevis would...

      @ Sean -- The hotel has a "Kids For All Seasons" club, which Four Seasons has at most of its properties. While we don't have a kid old enough to use it yet, I know Ford's clients who have kids old enough to use these clubs rave about them. They have a very nice setup for the club, and it has a playground, an indoor space, and more. I think the Four Seasons Nevis would be a great complement to the Park Hyatt St. Kitts, and it's quite easy to get between the two. Enjoy your trip!

    2. Sean Guest

      Awesome. Thanks for the feedback.

  24. RH_NYC Guest

    Thanks for the review Ben! Love that you're traveling with Miles already. By any chance, does the resort offer (and did you take advantage of) babysitting services?

    1. Ben Schlappig OMAAT

      @ RH_NYC -- Yep, the resort does offer babysitting, and it was reasonably priced. We used it one night to go to dinner while Miles was asleep, as we were curious to test it out (obviously a first for us). It was a great experience, and the hotel does a good job managing the whole situation.

    2. Yosef_S Guest

      I've often been curious about the babysitting service offered by hotels/resorts but have never actually tried it. Would you consider writing a separate post discussing the whole thing in detail?

      Thanks!

    3. Eric Guest

      Second that - would be a very interesting dedicated post

    4. Chris Guest

      We used it for 12 hours a day for 5 days at the rosewood mayakoba and was excellent.

Featured Comments Most helpful comments ( as chosen by the OMAAT community ).

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Ben Schlappig OMAAT

@ RH_NYC -- Yep, the resort does offer babysitting, and it was reasonably priced. We used it one night to go to dinner while Miles was asleep, as we were curious to test it out (obviously a first for us). It was a great experience, and the hotel does a good job managing the whole situation.

3
nomad_dc Guest

@Ben Would mind clarifying this statement? "You can combine Preferred Partner perks with virtually any rate on Four Seasons’ website (other programs don’t allow you to stack promotions in the same way)" Amex FH&R allows you to stack promotional rates as well (like book four nights get the 5th night free). Also, some Four Seasons hotels allow for in-room breakfast when booking through Amex FH&R. Plus the 5x points per dollar spent (on prepaid rates) and the guaranteed 4:00pm checkout might be worth mentioning when comparing the two programs, as some people might derive greater value of these over the prioritization of room upgrades (which I suspect most people won't be upgraded to a suite, at least those of us who are not bloggers or travel agents) But maybe I'm missing something...

2
mark Guest

I looked at the pictures again. It is indeed heinous, just tacky and second-hand throughout. Looks like a second-tier Grand Hyatt in a second-tier tropical location. Almost every picture is 180 degree opposite luxury. Very surprised 4S lets this property use the name. Again, 10-15 years ago it was one of the top resorts on the planet. This looks junky.

2
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,163,247 Miles Traveled

32,614,600 Words Written

35,045 Posts Published

Keep Exploring OMAAT
  • February 22, 2022
  • Ben Schlappig
76
Review: Four Seasons Hotel Madrid