What United Really Screwed Up With Their Latest Viral Incident

Earlier I shared the video of a passenger being physically dragged off last night’s United flight between Chicago and Louisville. The flight was overbooked and United needed to reposition a crew to Louisville, so they needed to have some passengers get off the plane. One guy refused, so the police were called. He still refused to get off, so they dragged him off the plane, to the point that he started bleeding.

The whole situation is terribly humiliating, and could have been avoided… I’d argue on both sides. However, mainly United should have never let it get to this point. Courier-Journal has a story about what apparently happened in terms of the airline offering compensation:

Passengers were told at the gate that the flight was overbooked and United, offering $400 and a hotel stay, was looking for one volunteer to take another flight to Louisville at 3 p.m. Monday. Passengers were allowed to board the flight, Bridges said, and once the flight was filled those on the plane were told that four people needed to give up their seats to stand-by United employees that needed to be in Louisville on Monday for a flight. Passengers were told that the flight would not take off until the United crew had seats, Bridges said, and the offer was increased to $800, but no one volunteered.

Then, she said, a manager came aboard the plane and said a computer would select four people to be taken off the flight. One couple was selected first and left the airplane, she said, before the man in the video was confronted.

So the airline offered $400 in compensation, and then raised it to $800 after no one took the offer. That’s a lot of money, and it always surprises me how people don’t go for such high offers (I suspect it’s because people fear that there are all kinds of terms associated with the vouchers, just as there seem to be “catches” with just about everything involving airlines).

The passenger was repeatedly asked to get off the plane, but refused:

Bridges said the man became “very upset” and said that he was a doctor who needed to see patients at a hospital in the morning. The manager told him that security would be called if he did not leave willingly, Bridges said, and the man said he was calling his lawyer. One security official came and spoke with him, and then another security officer came when he still refused. Then, she said, a third security official came on the plane and threw the passenger against the armrest before dragging him out of the plane.

The two issues with this situation

I wasn’t intending to be dismissive of this guy’s situation earlier, and I realize that’s how it may have come across, and for that I apologize (I started writing the post at 4:45AM, before I had my first cup of coffee). I see too much of this garbage, and I guess I’m unfairly desensitized to this. The thing that makes this different than other situations we’ve seen is that this passenger wasn’t removed for doing anything wrong (usually passengers are removed for bad behavior), but rather because United overbooked the flight.

I see two distinct issues here:

  • United didn’t do everything they could to solicit volunteers, and this situation was entirely avoidable
  • Once an airline decides you’re going to be removed from a flight, there’s nothing you can do, and it’ll only end poorly for you; right or wrong, this is a sad reality of the times, and the police will back up and enforce whatever decision the airline makes

What United and most other airlines should do differently

For better or worse, airlines overbook, and that’s nothing new. It’s a calculated business decision they make because they know that on average a certain number of people don’t make their flight. However, sometimes their projections aren’t correct, and more passengers make the flight than they were expecting.

In this case there was the added complication of them needing to position a crew to Louisville. I assume this was a last minute decision, which made the overbooked situation even worse. This was likely the necessary and right decision, or else a flight the next day would have likely been canceled.

At that point they need people to get off the plane, and this is where the real problem arises:

  • Airlines are required to ask for volunteers in exchange for compensation, though the regulations make no requirements as to how often they ask for volunteers, how much they raise their offer, etc.
  • At that point they can involuntarily deny boarding to passengers; technically the passengers should be entitled to cash compensation, though typically the airline won’t tell them that’s an option, and instead will just give them a voucher

This is the bigger issue, the way I see it. The airlines are allowed to make a business decision to oversell a flight. If they make that business decision, they should also be required to suffer whatever the consequences are of that. Is it right to make a business decision to oversell a flight, and then kick someone off against their will? Shouldn’t they have to raise the offer until someone accepts it?

This isn’t just United, but the same is true at most airlines. I guess part of the problem is that the front line employees aren’t really given much authority or incentive to avoid involuntarily denying boarding to passengers. So often they just make one quick announcement asking for volunteers, and if that doesn’t work, they take passengers off against their will.

That system is sort of screwed up, in my opinion. Even in a case like this, I imagine if they had explained the situation clearly and raised their offer, they would have gotten volunteers, and this whole situation could have been avoided.

Bottom line

This situation, and any involuntary denied boarding situation, is completely preventable. The problem is that airlines don’t give frontline employees the incentives or tools to make sure they only voluntarily deny boarding to passengers. So if the situation had been explained better or the offer raised, I imagine this whole situation could have been avoided. You see people kicked off planes all the time for how they act, but in this case the guy did nothing wrong, other than want to fly in the seat he paid for.

In this case the police was essentially acting on behalf of United’s revenue management department, rather than dealing with someone who did anything wrong.

But there’s still a lesson here for passengers, which is that for better or worse, protesting on a plane won’t end well for you. I’m not saying it’s right, but it is the reality. It wouldn’t have gotten this guy to work the next day, but at least it would have helped him avoid a bloody face.

Yeah, it’s pretty bad when you book a seat on a flight, do nothing wrong, and somehow end up getting physically dragged off the plane by three police officers.

This story is clearly resonating with many people, and is becoming a bigger deal that I first anticipated — see further thoughts in this post.


This has been a quickly-moving story with myriad updates. The full coverage of the United incident from the One Mile at a Time team is as follows:

Conversations (209)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Tachyon_OGG_SBA_IAD Guest

By the way, as for the 'bumping for emergency' scenario. I've already seen that one play out for a 1K work colleague several years ago. He was overseas visiting Toshiba sites for training when his wife had a brain blot clot and went into a coma. It took 3 days for UAL to find him space out of Narita back to SFO and home. UAL won't clear space for anybody... unless it's Munoz and his kids wanting to go skiing. (this was written up in LA Times the other day) But, it appears that UAL is staffed with sociopaths. Which confirms what we already suspected. In this case the abuse they regularly pile onto their customers spilled over into violence.

0
‼ 0
M.E.K. Guest

@Msvl - Please note that United Express crew nor employees never touched the man. Airline employees/crew members did not physically interact, intervene, or engage, in any way with Dr. Dao. It was the ORD cops. @The Real Deal and @L.L. - As stated below, I'm a retired flight attendant (I loved my job), and my hubby's a pilot (airline shall go unnamed). I can't thank you enough for your words of reason. I'm spitting mad, as I'm sure you'll see. I've just had to vent at these idiots, so pardon all below, none is directed at you or those of you who show reason. I'm glad you understand that by law and DOT regs., Dr. Dao was required to comply. Period. I do think that UAL's subsidiary contractor Republic Airlines (dba/aka United Express) should have handled it much more diplomatically, and offered the max $ right off. But, I also think ORD cops should have been much more blunt before being brutal. I've seen them in action. E.g. "We take you off the plane in handcuffs by force, and you'll be arrested and charged with a federal offense (which is true) or you can walk off the plane peacefully, no charges." I just needed to get this out. QUESTION: Any of you experts work, now or ever, in any front line capacity (crew scheduling, crew member, gate agent, ramper, flight planning, etc.) at any airline? Or are any of you FAA non-bureaucrats? I'm a retired flight attendant, married to a pilot of almost 30 yrs., who flies at a major U.S. airline. 1. Fl.3411 was Republic Air., not UAL, however Oscar M.(best CEO at UAL in decades, and he makes a fraction of the scumbags before him) is making no excuses "the buck stops here"-Muñoz. He takes responsibility because UAL contracts them out of necessity (unless people would rather drive from places like Louisville to ORD aka. Chicago O'hare or take a cab). 2. Fl.3411 was NOT oversold. Contrary to quotes by Bridges. I know, I have access to and have seen the bookings. Even if it had been, EVERY AIRLINE, ALL, EVERY CAR RENTAL CO., EVERY HOTEL CHAIN, all... THEY ALL over book. Paying full price for all, I've been "bumped" by all of them. Overbooking, btw, at airlines helps to keep airline tix. prices lower, and keeps more seats filled. Ecologically speaking, millions fewer gallons of jet fuel is expended yearly on millions of empty seats flown. Greedy airlines? Google it, did you know that it costs less to fly now than it did in 1980? Even with bag fees and not even adjusted for inflation. Flat out dollars. What was milk, bread, gas, an oz. of pot? But you "cattle" think that it's a crime for airlines to make a profit at all. So, overbooking and airline profits will help my husband make up for the pension he lost when his and all the other U.S. airlines went bankrupt during Bush's great recession. Yup. You get to fly (and don't quote me walk-up shit ticket $) and bitch about bags, while my husband and I will receive his gov. pension of $789.00/month after 33 years of flying at a major airline. Greedy airlines. But you're all the experts, right? 3. Republic Air. (aka/dba UA Express) should have offered the max. allowed, $1350 + hotel, right away. I agree, and that amount is governed by the D.O.T. Google it. So that agent, ethical or not, COULDN'T HAVE offered more, though should have offered it right off the bat, in cash. 4. The deadheading crew ( term for "positioning crew" for the majority of you idiots who can run an airline already) were not commuting, crew scheduling didn't screw up, the crew didn't need to ride as the result of "piss poor planning", and they could not have taken a different means of transport for the following reasons: A. Deadheading crews: NEVER EVER RIDE ON ANOTHER AIRLINE, DL on UA or vice versa, AA on DL etc. @KR - Charter flights are NOT a common solution. They don't ever happen, except for charter airlines, like World or Tower (both gone, I think). And, NO, chartering a small jet? Deadheading crew happens every day, hundreds of times a day, with every airline in the world. My husband does it at least once a month. Sometimes it's scheduled and sometimes the need arises. It's never a crew "screw up" or bad planning. Shit happens. B. They could not have been driven by rented car or van, as suggested by some other posters on soc. media. Again, minimum crew rest times: Chi-Louisville: Drive= 5+ hrs. Fly= 51 mins. Do you feel rested after 5 hrs drive? Do you want those pilots flying you after a night spent in a car? How much outrage would result over a crash the next day from Louisville due to pilot fatigue, had the pilots been driven vs. flown to Louisville? Do you think the public would have thought those 4 seats for the crew would have been better occupied by the crew or 4 pax. who could wait to get to Louisville the next day? I've been in the position, many times, due to holds on weather when I and my crew have timed out (I've had a duty day of 16 hrs., then ATC lifts the ground stop at 15 min. after I've timed out). That would mean that another crew might need to be deadheaded to, say St. Louis, since my crew and I couldn't work the return flight back out on schedule due to FAA min. rest regs. That might mean involuntary pax. bumping. Piss poor planning? Fraud? Screw UAL? Sue UAL? Crew scheduling screw up? There are any number of reasons the Louisville flight may have needed the other crew. With 100% certainty I can tell you that no airline would just bump revenue pax to whimsically deadhead crew if there weren't a crucial reason, and of all the things that can go wrong at an airline, I can tell you that crew scheduling is almost never one of them. That aspect is a VERY tightly run operation. At all U.S. airlines. That's because if there's any one thing that will shut an airline down, that's a big one. The FAA is on pilot regs. like "white on rice". Usually only what are called "irregular ops", or unplanned events such as weather delays causing duty times to exceeds maximums allowed by FAA regs. will cause such last minute things as sudden deadheads. Myself, and every crew member you'll ever meet, ask them, will tell you that they've been deadheaded at the last minute due to these situations. And pax. have been bumped, sometimes involuntarily. I've been bumped after being seated as a pax. And when asked to get up and leave, I do.Even once when I paid full fare, but was chosen because I'd paid a low-fare ticket. And when I've politely had to ask a pax. to vacate a seat after they've accepted the offer (which Dr. Dao did initially), they've acquiesced. Maybe not happily, but I didn't have to call airport security. I wouldn't have wanted to, I can assure you. I was horrified to watch the vid. of Dr. Dao being dragged off, I doubt he understood that, in fact by law, he did have to comply. Once on the plane, whether still at the gate or not, whether it's to vacate a seat or open an emergency exit or extinguish a cigarette, by federal law, you do have to comply with crew member instructions. Period. BTW, ORD cops are notorious for salivating at the prospect of getting to "enforce". No one wants to call them. I know Dao couldn't have foreseen the brutality with which the ORD cops were going to extricate and drag him. I don't minimize that. @James- No, you officious moron, the crew did not screw up. They didn't just 'decide' to deadhead (that's "position" since I'm sure you have no clue what that term means). They didn't decide to just bump Dao or any other pax. Oscar M. has stated that UAL will revise and increase dramatically the amount and manner of compensation offered to travelers to alter their travel plans when the need arises to free up seats. He's stated that aviation police will never be called again. So that means that someday, you may find yourself seated in 21A, awaiting push-back when the drunk jerk beside you starts to pick a fight with someone, maybe you or he starts calling his wife a "fuckin' whore" then punches her in the side of the head (unless that's a common practice in your home and you have no problem with it). Yes, it happened on one of my flights; and you may be stuck in their row. While still at the jet bridge with time to make the call for cops, the guy could escalate, as often happens, but maybe only verbally getting more abusive. Enough reason to get cops yet? If not now, what's it going to be like in 3 hours over Kansas? Still, as a flight attendant, do you think we're going to ask him to leave? FYI, also, after 9/11, the pilots cannot get involved. How likely do you think he'll be to comply with the crew members' instructions? Especially after seeing that "the cops will never be called", plus he's now seen that he can successfully refuse. Do you think we'll call the cops, or should we just let you handle it? James? Oh yeah, this too. Did you know that most airlines, especially United, may under critical circumstances if necessary, bump another passenger on a full flight for you, if you suddenly have a life & death situation and need fly? Odds are slim now. I imagine that if your mom or wife or kid is in an accident and maybe they are mere hours from death, and you're 2000 miles away, now you'll just have to wait until you can get a seat on the next flight with availability. I'm not being melodramatic. You wouldn't believe how many people fly either for either sudden bereavement reasons or family emergency crises. They used to always get precedence when it came to bumping any pax.

0
‼ 0
Myron Stelmaschuk Guest

Dao will be the highest paid mixed martial artist of all time. Record 1 loss by KO

0
‼ 0
Jerry Guest

Why did United wait til the last minute to take passengers off of the plane?

0
‼ 0
Human_Race Guest

Lucky Has a Bias on this issue, doesn't want those freebie airline perks to disappear.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published