United Bans Two Year Old For Not Wearing Mask

I’m conflicted on this one. On the one hand, I appreciate a zero tolerance policy, but on the other hand, this wouldn’t have been an issue on Delta.

Two year old’s mask compliance causes problems

A family with a two year old daughter was supposed to fly United Airlines from Denver to Newark this past Friday. Here’s what we know about what happened, based on the family’s version of events and videos:

  • The family wanted to go to New York to see friends and family, and go to Rockefeller to see the tree; “it’s a tradition [they] also wanted [their] two year old daughter to experience”
  • The couple has Premier Silver status with United, so they “always” fly with the airline; they apparently flew with the daughter four times already during the pandemic, without having issues
  • The two year old (who turns three in April 2021) wasn’t cooperating with wearing a mask, so they ended up asking the family to leave the flight
  • The family wasn’t happy about this, and once off the plane the dad asked to be rebooked on another flight in first class (even though they weren’t in first class to begin with), and at that point they were informed that they’re banned from United
  • While the mom claims they’re “banned forever,” that’s unlikely to be the case; bans over mask compliance apply for as long as a mask policy is in place
  • Since bags weren’t taken off the plane, they would only have their bags returned to them a day later

⁣Here’s the video, which starts with the mom crying over what happened, then shows what happened onboard, and then shows what happened at the gate, after they got off the plane:

https://www.instagram.com/p/CIrTQenp2YX/

Is the family or United in the right?

When you step back, it understandably seems ridiculous to kick off and ban a family because a two year old wouldn’t wear a mask. With that in mind, I have a few general thoughts:

The family flew the wrong airline

The mother makes the point that the World Health Organization (WHO) doesn’t recommend masks for children up to five years of age. This is true, and as it’s described by the WHO, “this is based on the safety and overall interest of the child and the capacity to appropriately use a mask with minimal assistance.”

One thing to consider is that the family flew the wrong airline. Delta’s policy explicitly says that “children under the age two and young children who cannot maintain a face covering are exempt from the mask requirement.”

Meanwhile United has no such exception, simply noting that “children younger than two years old are exempt.”

This comes down to airline policy, but the truth is that they should have known United’s policy coming in (and it’s also something you have to agree to during check-in).

Could the family have done more?

Let me fully acknowledge that getting a two year old to do something they don’t want to do is difficult. In that very moment I think the parents were doing everything they could.

However, I get the sense that they could have done more to practice and prepare. Traveling with young kids if tough enough under normal conditions, let alone when you have to force them to wear a mask for extended periods.

It seems like this is something that should be practiced extensively in advance, but I get the general vibe that maybe that wasn’t happening at this family:

  • The dad can’t seem to keep his mask over his nose… why is this so hard?!
  • The dad pulls the “99% of people survive coronavirus” card, in justifying his daughter not being able to wear a mask
  • Let’s keep in mind that the family was violating New York’s quarantine requirement to begin with by taking this trip

Maybe I’m wrong, but I doubt the daughter had spent much time practicing mask wearing, outside of airplanes.

Should United have let this slide?

While I’m generally extremely pro-mask, I can’t help but wonder if the airline should have perhaps let this situation slide. Like I said, this wouldn’t have been an issue on Delta, the child wasn’t seated next to a stranger, and the parents did seem to be trying (in this moment).

There is obviously an element of theater here when one airline considers it to be safe for a two year old to not wear a mask, and another doesn’t.

This probably didn’t need to turn into such a big deal. However:

  • Big companies often lack flexibility, and have a culture of rigid rules; when we’re talking about safety, that’s probably a good thing
  • If you make an exception for a two year old not wearing a mask, where do you stop making exceptions?

Airlines for the most part have done an amazing job with mask compliance (more than in any other crowded spaces), and that largely comes down to a consistently enforced zero tolerance policy. When you start to let things slide, minor as they might be, where is the line drawn?

Bottom line

United Airlines kicked off and then banned a family because the parents couldn’t get their two year old daughter to wear a mask.

On the one hand, this seems a step too far, when Delta has a special exception for situations like this. On the other hand, I can also appreciate that whatever policy is in place needs to be consistently enforced, because it’s a slippery slope.

What do you make of this mask situation?

Conversations (112)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Oldo Guest

I don’t get why everyone including flight staff doesn’t just ignore anyone not wearing a mask. Especially toddlers. (Maybe even allow a democratic passenger vote in that case). Better, Just let it go. This is true kndness to others. And no danger to anyone. Especially in light of science that purports the infinitesimal chance of infection being less than a crash. Airlines are rife with information of air filtration and recirculation evidence for claiming how it is impossible to become sick on a flight, not only since the beginning of the ‘pandemic’ and even before

0
‼ 0
Ruth Stein Guest

This is why I’m trying to figure out the airlines to fly. I can’t fathom anything more selfish, absurd, and nearsighted than a flight full of adults being terrified of an unmasked 2-year old. KIDS ARE VERY LOW RISK AS COVID SPREADERS. How selfish is it for adults to put this kind of thing on toddlers. I would literally lose it. My 2 year old is not a danger, she’s not in danger, and I am never making her wear a mask. Adults who would require her to wear one are pathetic human beings with zero empathy.

0
‼ 0
Tressa Guest

I am in the same situation as this family, but I know the policies at each airline. I, too, am premier with United but know I can't fly the airline with my newly turned two-year-old. My son was one when the pandemic started and it was against ALL recommendations for a child his age to wear one. Now, two is here and he needs to wear one anywhere we go (which isn't a lot of places). We have done everything from practicing, to buying his favorite character masks, to calling his pediatrician for advice. Practice doesn't make perfect in this situation for us. We are booked for a ski trip in February and will fly on Delta. We're making multiple connections to do so (even when United has a nonstop flight) but this is also a first world problem and we need to comply with the policy of the airline and keep those around us safe.

0
‼ 0
Francis Guest

Hard, but fair. Great professionalism shown by the UA employees.

0
‼ 0
Ray Gold

I love how having a 2 year old here is considered by many as an excuse to act like arses. The people needed to be banned based on the adults behavior. Yes, I had a child, that didn’t give me freedom to be a jerk. When my child acted out we left stores or wherever we were. I didn’t start ignorant conversations with clerks why MY privilege would override others shopping experience. This isn’t about the child, it is an action based on the parents behavior. And you anti-maskers are as ignorant as the pig in the White House and the idiots still supporting him. America really is showing the world how stupid they are.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published

Keep Exploring OMAAT