Qantas Threatens To Hire Low Cost Pilots

Qantas is ready to move forward with “Project Sunrise,” and the airline doesn’t seem to care whether their pilots are onboard with it or not.

Qantas’ “Project Sunrise” A350 flights

For years Qantas has been talking about how they’d like to be able to fly nonstop from Melbourne and Sydney to London and New York. They call this goal “Project Sunrise,” and these would be the world’s longest flights.

Qantas has made good progress on this, and in late 2019 the airline announced that they’ve selected the A350-1000 for this “mission.”

Airbus has essentially proposed adding an additional fuel tank to the A350-1000 while also increasing the maximum takeoff weight, which would give the A350-1000 the range it requires.

Qantas has decided on the A350-1000 if they move forward with Project Sunrise, but up until now they haven’t fully decided on whether they’ll move forward with the project or not. The airline has until the end of March to finalize their order with Airbus, assuming they want to commence flights by early 2023.

Pilot negotiations are proving tricky

Before the March 2020 deadline, one important issue that Qantas has tried to finalize is their agreement with pilots for these flights.

Qantas has been negotiating with their pilots union, AIPA. Discussions center on productivity and efficiency gains, and when we’re talking about flights this long, there are quite a few points to negotiate:

  • Can Qantas use the same pilots across the A330 and A350?
  • How many pilots will be required for these ultra long haul flights? Ultra long haul flights usually have four, but should these flights have even more pilots, given how long they are?
  • How will those pilots need to be split up between captains, first officers, and second officers, given the different wages? Is one captain, one first officer, and two second officers sufficient, or do these flights need more senior pilots?
  • What should the pay scale look like for pilots who fly the A350?

Qantas is looking for some concessions from pilots, claiming these new flights would lead to more pilot jobs and promotion opportunities. But the union is playing hardball.

Qantas doesn’t actually care what pilots think

On Thursday, Qantas International CEO Tino La Spina sent an email to pilots, essentially threatening to hire new, lower cost pilots altogether if they couldn’t agree to the terms management wants:

“We will be left with no viable alternative but to have Sunrise flying performed by a new employment entity that can provide the cost base we need for this important business opportunity.

To be absolutely clear, this is not our preferred option. And we know that flagging this will not be well received by many of you. But we want to make sure you have all relevant information when you are weighing a decision.”

The issue seems to come down to second officer pay. Qantas is offering a mild pay increase and improved conditions to existing pilots, but wants to be able to pay future second officers (the most junior pilots, who will largely work as relief pilots on these flights) less.

At this point Qantas is saying that they’ll offer a wage package directly to pilots to vote on, if they can’t get anywhere with the union. The logic is that presumably individual pilots would accept what’s a better deal for them, while the union cares more about the pay and working conditions for future pilots.

The head of the pilots union has responded with the following:

“The approach that Qantas is now showing publicly has been a characteristic of these discussions and shows how this business would apparently prefer ultimatums at this critical juncture to building consensus.”

If Qantas can’t get anywhere directly with pilots, they’re even threatening to hire a new group of pilots altogether who would exclusively operate these Project Sunrise flights at lower costs.

Bottom line

It seems like Qantas is ready to move forward with Project Sunrise, regardless of whether the pilots are onboard or not.

On the surface I find the “we’ll just hire people cheaper than you if you don’t want to do it” approach to be off-putting, especially given the extent to which the airline industry is seniority based. That means employees largely don’t have the option of realistically switching companies if they’re not happy with what they’re being offered.

That being said, I’m not fully privy to where both parties stand at this point to know for sure whether the pilots or management are being unrealistic here.

Conversations (34)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Harry Guest

Being an international airline, it would make sense yo me if flight crews were paid 50% in locally relevant wages and 50% in those of the destination

0
‼ 0
UpperDeckJohnny Guest

Its all about fatigue, not skill. As a passenger flying a 20hr flight, who would you rather rely upon for quick decision making: A 50 year old captain who hasn't slept too well out of a bed, or A 30 year old who can sleep on a clothes line and be instantly able to respond. A few years' experience is all that is required, not a lifetime which started on vastly different equipment with no IT/AI, irrelevant instrumentation and unresponsive power units. There are a congress of accidents where an autocratic senior training captain has been directly responsible for events resulting in disasters, notably Tenerife where a junior officer raised a warning, which the captain overruled, resulting in the collision of two 747's on the runway.

0
‼ 0
JimLahey Guest

Union haters are such hypocrites. If your jobs were ever threatened with a cheaper, less experienced work force you all would be outraged. Hopefully that doesn’t happen, and hopefully if it does you don’t have a crowd cheering “good job management, keep screwing your experienced, well paid employees that want to stand up for their career”.

0
‼ 0
Rudi Guest

Well for all of you who are saying good for Qantas and screw the union.. Get ready. Pilots delaying and canceling Qantas flights from. Left to right. There are things where you cant afford to be cheap and this is one of those.

0
‼ 0
Aviation First Responder Guest

I love how all these commenters completely ignore the fact that the company wants crew to work more than 24 hours straight - as a normal duty. They can pretend it’s only about the money, but the reality is- they want crew ( cabin & pilot) to do massively long and fatiguing tours of duty including night flying and with the impact of Jetlag, without properly investigating the long term impact on the crew. Three “test” flights on different aircraft and without real world duties involved does not give an accurate indication of how this would work logistically and what impact this type of flying would have on the crew’s health. They want an agreement in place to pay less and have given no indication of the rest times, gaps between flights, crew numbers, or whether there will be limitations on how many of these types of flights can be done in a row. Pilots are at least semi-protected ( for Now!) by FRMS and CASA limits. Cabin crew have no such protections and when an emergency happens and the aircraft goes down: it’s the cabin crew that need to be able to assess the safety of the situation and get you out. The Enterprise Agreements ( negotiated by the unions) are often their only protection. There is no duty limit for Australian cabin crew under the law. Flying to London then turning around 24 hours later to go home is already a possibility. EU regulations prevent cabin crew based there from being flown until they drop. We have no such protections under Australian Legislation and the Style of negotiation we see demonstrated here By Qantas management does not indicate any level of understanding of the actual jobs of pilots and cabin crew. Do as we say or we’ll find someone else to exploit in your place. This is not something to be proud of in an Australian Company.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published