The Andaz Maui Is Playing Sneaky Games With Award Availability

The Andaz Maui is probably one of the most popular Hyatt properties, both among those looking to redeem World of Hyatt points, and also among Globalist members looking for a special trip.

The Andaz Maui struggles to manage expectations, and plays games

Understandably the hotel has a hard time managing expectations sometimes. In the past the hotel has even sent proactive emails to Globalist members essentially telling them not to expect an upgrade.

While I can appreciate that struggle, this hotel also seems to go out of their way to play games. Over the years there have been all kinds of instances of the Andaz Maui playing games with award stays.

For example, a few years back they imposed an imaginary seven night minimum stay requirement on award stays, while that minimum wasn’t there on cash stays.

That’s just one example, though there are plenty of others as well.

The Andaz Maui’s latest award availability game

Reader @jace_mckenzie points me to the latest game that the Andaz Maui seems to be playing. Here’s the thing — some of the Andaz Maui’s games in the past have breached the World of Hyatt terms, but what they’re doing here is technically completely legitimate. It’s not within the spirit of the program, though.

Essentially the Andaz Maui is only allowing bookings using points for stays of 8+ nights

If you want to stay 1-7 nights, the hotel simply doesn’t sell base rooms.

So it’s pretty apparent that this restriction is in place at the Andaz Maui to try and prevent award redemptions, because there simply isn’t another logical explanation. Award stays have no blackout dates as long as there’s a standard room available, so by not having standard rooms for stays of 1-7 nights, they’re getting around that.

What I don’t understand here

The Andaz Maui has long done everything in their power to prevent people from booking award stays. What’s not entirely clear to me is why. It’s my understanding that with Hyatt (and most other global hotel chains), hotels are reimbursed in one of two ways for award stays:

  • Assuming the hotel is full (or nearly full), the hotel is compensated roughly at the average daily rate, so there’s no loss to the hotel for having award guests
  • Assuming the hotel isn’t full, the hotel is compensated some smaller amount that’s above the marginal cost of cleaning the room, but that’s about it

The Andaz Maui seems to have consistently high occupancy, so I can’t quite figure out why they’re so opposed to award stays? Anyone have any insights, is my understanding of how this works incorrect, or what? Feel free to email me instead if you have any anonymous info to share on this.

My only thought is that they have a huge number of award redemptions and often find themselves in situations where they’re mostly full, but not quite full enough to get the average daily rate reimbursement, in which case I can see why they’d be frustrated.

How to get around the Andaz Maui award restrictions

Some report booking stays of eight or more nights, and then phoning up World of Hyatt to shorten the length of their stay. Sometimes this might require hanging up and calling again, but it does seem to be possible, especially if you are a Globalist member with access to a My Hyatt Concierge.

Bottom line

The Andaz Maui playing games with award availability is nothing new. I’m still not sure I understand exactly what their incentive is for doing so, but I’d love to understand, because it would explain a lot about the economics of hotel loyalty programs.

The good news is that it still seems possible to book stays of eight nights or more, and then later you can hopefully modify those stays to beat the hotel’s ridiculous rules.

If you’ve tried to redeem points at the Andaz Maui, what was your experience like?

Conversations (54)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Meg Guest

nothing available at Andaz in March for 9 nights

0
‼ 0
Adam Guest

The Andaz Maui isn’t alone. Try using a weekend night certificate at The Waldorf Maui nearby. They have near complete availability, but they don’t have any ‘standard rooms’ at the hotel so you can’t use their certs. @Road Dog - just leave without checking out and leave the ‘do not disturb’ hanger on the door. I rarely stop at the desk when I leave any hotel anymore. You’ll get the statement via email and can call if anything is wrong.

0
‼ 0
Road Dog Guest

I've been planning my honeymoon for some time, but Andaz had an 8-night minimum for points redemption (not to mention they only offer garden/parking-lot views for points bookings). We really only wanted to stay for 7 nights, and I figured it would be fine to book the minimum 8 nights and only stay 7. Well I dragged my feet booking, and just today realized that Andaz now has a 9-night minimum for points bookings (at least in May 2021--when we wanted to book). I called Hyatt to make my reservation and asked, "What would happen if I booked 9 nights but only stayed 7?" Yes, I'd be blowing 30k/points/night for each night I didn't stay there, but it's still ultimately cheaper than paying cash. The rep spent over 30 minutes speaking to her manager as well as calling the Andaz Maui to confirm with me, "If you check out early you will forfeit the points AND be charged the full cash rate for your room for each night you checked out early." The Hyatt representative seemed flabbergasted that this was their policy. While it's within a hotel's right to do so based on Hyatt's terms, she said it was the first hotel she was aware of that actually enforced this policy. Most would simply be fine keeping your points and letting you check out early. To be quite honest, it's hard for my fiance to get off work. The 7-day honeymoon would be perfect. We could probably swing an extra day, but two days seems like a big stretch. I'm also not sure how burned out we'd be staying in one location for 9-days (even if it's Hawaii). I'm almost reconsidering a change to the Hyatt Regency in Maui, where I get actually book an Oceanview Suite with points (7 nights at 280k vs 9 nights at 270k for standard Andaz room). I was just hoping for more of a "honeymoon" and upscale experience at the Andaz vs the Regency.

0
‼ 0
El Guapo Guest

Tried looking for 1-7 nights for May of 2021 and nothing.

0
‼ 0
Rob K Guest

Let us not forget the "property development view" rooms they now have on their site, for $577 a night. Such a steal to listen to construction noise and have a view of hunky burly construction workers (maybe that's the angle they're taking on those rooms?) and I tried to redeem one night there for May 17th and they said "NO ROOMS AVAILABLE" yet they have plenty of those lovely development view rooms available. I guess I'm lucky, got to stay there 3 nights with my signup bonus on my Hyatt card about 5 years ago.. was the best 3 nights hotel stay in my life.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published

Keep Exploring OMAAT
  • May 15, 2021
  • Ben Schlappig
52
Review: The New Andaz Maui Villas
  • December 7, 2020
  • Ben Schlappig
14
Review: Andaz Munich, Germany