What’s The Logic Behind The In-Flight Electronics Ban?

Update, 6AM Tuesday — Further details have been announced by DHS, please read this post for more information.

Update, 10PM Eastern — The Associated Press is reporting the electronics ban will apply to flights from Amman, Abu Dhabi, Cairo, Casablanca, Dubai, Doha, Istanbul, Jeddah, Kuwait City, and Riyadh. Developing.


What a bizarre day…

Earlier I posted about how Royal Jordanian announced that in-cabin electronics would would be banned on flights to/from the U.S. starting tomorrow, March 21, 2017. With the exception of cell phones, all electronics would have to be checked through to the final destination.

Electronics-Ban

As more information emerged, it became clear that Royal Jordanian wasn’t just misunderstanding some policy, but that they were in fact following some sort of directive, which is apparently impacting people traveling from 13 different countries to the U.S.

What have airlines & authorities said about the electronics ban?

What makes this story even stranger is that Royal Jordanian has in the meantime deleted their Tweet about the electronics ban, instead Tweeting that more information will be announced soon.

At the same time Saudia has posted about the new policy (though only in Arabic). What the heck?! The communication here is just horrible — can passengers traveling to the U.S. on Royal Jordanian tomorrow show up with electronics in their carry-on, or no?

EgyptAir has also been asked about the ban, and responded by saying that they only issue airline tickets, and to ask the “corresponding authorities.” Helpful. 😉

https://twitter.com/EGYPTAIR/status/843950012467953664

The Department of Homeland Security has only released a statement saying that “we have no comment on potential security precautions, but will provide any update as appropriate.”

I understand that they don’t want to reveal what the threats are, etc., but you’d think it would at least be in everyone’s best interest to outline the policy, so that travelers can prepare properly.

What’s the logic behind the electronics ban?

While there has been a lot of speculation about what the actual policy is, I haven’t seen too much discussion about what the logic behind such a policy could be. I’m sure I’m not the only one who is scratching their head, trying to understand this better.

Let me be the first to say that I’m horrible with technology and am also not a security expert. So I’m talking out loud here, and am hoping some of you (who are actually experts in this area) can chime in, so we can all better understand what’s going on.

Is the fear that a bomb will be masked as an electronic device? This has long been a fear, and is usually solved by requesting that all electronics be powered on during a security inspection. Heck, I have to do this every time I go through a secondary inspection.

Furthermore, if the fear is that bombs are masked as electronic devices, then how is having them checked solving anything? At least in the past, some bombs have been detonated in the cargo hold using a timer.

Furthermore, let’s keep in mind that in the past there were regulations banning lithium-ion batteries from being checked in the cargo hold. I don’t personally know how real that risk is, though if the ICAO put out a directive regarding that in the past, I assume there was some merit to it. Are airlines now supposed to encourage passengers to check lithium-ion batteries?!

Is the fear that an electronic device will be used to somehow hack an aircraft system? If that is in fact a possibility, couldn’t that also be done from a smartphone? What’s the logic behind banning an iPad Mini but not an iPhone 7 Plus?

If only passengers traveling on certain routes are being banned, what’s to prevent them from traveling though a third country to get to the U.S.? For example, instead of traveling from Amman to New York they could travel from Amman to Frankfurt to New York, and then bring on those horribly dangerous laptops and iPads?

Everything about this situation seems so poorly executed:

  • I understand them not wanting to reveal possible risks, but they could at least communicate the policy clearly so that passengers can prepare properly
  • I’d love to know what I’m missing about how this could possibly be enhancing safety; according to the ICAO there’s a risk to checking lithium-ion batteries, so how are we safer by telling people they can’t carry-on an iPad Mini, while saying that an iPhone 7 Plus is okay?

Please chime in, security experts — I’m sure I’m not the only one who is curious!

Conversations (67)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Eric Green Guest

i bet u a bottom dollar that if the rest of the worlds leaders and our are doing that they have some sinester plot the order to do that came from somewhere somebody at the top do we or dont we have the right to know if all of us knew what was really going on we could have a chance to fight back i guess all that just part of the big picture just another cover up to what they are really doing know what i mean

0
‼ 0
Catherine Guest

I have exactly the same questions, particularly as they are now talking about expanding this ban to include other countries, and I do fear it will someday include all countries and airports. Henry Young gave a good answer, except he still didn't address the question of why the devices would be okay in checked luggage. It seems as though anyone developing these types of devices would soon look to remote detonation to overcome the carry-on luggage ban. I can't think that this is something business travelers will support for long. I know that my laptop is my office and it would definitely be a hardship to have to risk it being damaged or lost in the checked luggage.

0
‼ 0
DORIS A LAKE Guest

I just want my kindle, is that so much to ask? I am on 14 hour flight with just my smart phone for company. I do not like reading on smart phone. If I have battery that is size of cell phone, I guess that will be allowed?

0
‼ 0
Shivam Guest

This may interest all of you. This is a twitter reply from Qatar. They offer the same services as Emirates do! (1) You may OPT to carry your devices on board the first leg up until before boarding your onward flight to the States, Shivam. They will be collected and secured by our staff at the gate. However, to avoid delays during transit, we still HIGHLY RECOMMEND that restricted devices are checked in at the point of origin especially if you have a short connection. Our staff at the check-in will assist. Hope this clarifies. (2) Hi Shivam, passengers traveling with Qatar Airways can use their device(s) both on board into Doha, while in Transit, and up until they board their connecting flight to the United States. At the gates, all unauthorized devices will be collected from passengers, safely and carefully packaged and secured, and put inside the checked baggage compartment of the aircraft. To avoid any delays during boarding for US-bound flights, we recommend that all the devices are put in a secure bag and checked-in at the point of origin, particularly for passengers with short transit times. Hopefully this answers your question.

0
‼ 0
Shivam Guest

Ryan - I’ve had a couple of laptops now that when put in sleep mode, don’t actually go to sleep and become very hot. I wouldn’t want that going into the hold and causing a fire. -- Sounds like Windows Laptops or Surface Pro's ;) Hahaha Mine does similar sometimes! Yaz - For example I will be allowed to travel from Australia to Uae bt after tht I will have to book my laptop… ---- Well interesting, if its a short connection flight they will ask or recommend you to just check in from the first flight unless it's Emirates which has a nice facility to let you use it exception when you are on the plane and take the device during boarding which I'm surprised no one else has done! I have a Qatar flight to USA soon and I wished Qatar did what Emirates did - would have at least saved me some time, allowed me to work and also would have reduced the risk of theft that is very common in checked in bags that are both wrapped and/or unwrapped. Craig Simonian --- (talks about different electronics being banned and some allowed). I think it's generally as simple as this. Any phone that is smaller than an iPhone 7 Plus will be allowed since the iPhone 7 Plus is an iPhone and belongs to the iPhone 7 family (its a bit bigger) but accepted. It's also very popular so is accepted as a phone. Period. I'm quite surprised they aren't allowing headphones. Quite sad. I hope they dont stop my normal Sony headphones from going. I guess I better make sure I have my iphone and Pixel in-box headphones ready in case they ask for my simple but still large Sony Headphones out. I do have a couple of questions though : 1) In case you did travel with a laptop on a non Emirates flight for the first leg of your trip - and then had a quick transfer - what would they do to get your laptop checked-in ? Send you out to miss your flight ? Or some way to move your laptop or electronic device via bubble wrapping and boxes? Would that apply for all airlines ? Same for headphones and other devices ..... 2) How long will this last ? Sounds like this may go long with Canada and France joining in soon! France would join in very quickly since it has been frequently attacked over the years. Australia may want to join too after the Sydney Attack...wait wait! India should join immediately! Mumbai was attacked too! .. Wonder why this is just USA ...and more importantly why is UK on the list ? Hasn't UK been safe most of this time ?

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published