Finnair Intends To Acquire 19-Seat Electric Aircraft

The airline industry will have to become more sustainable over time. We’re now seeing airlines introduce additional sustainability initiatives, including in some cases offsetting flights, and committing to having more fuel efficient fleets. Beyond that we’re seeing the development of new aircraft technology, and airlines are increasingly expressing interest in electric aircraft. Here’s the latest such case.

Finnair expresses interest in electric aircraft

Finnair has signed a Letter of Interest to acquire up to 20 of Heart Aerospace’s ES-19 aircraft. These electric aircraft each seat up to 19 passengers, and will have an all-electric range of 400 kilometers.

Heart Aerospace ES-19 aircraft

Heart Aerospace is an aerospace startup based in Gothenburg, Sweden, and the plane is currently under development, with plans for it to enter commercial service by 2026.

As Anne Larilahti, Finnair Vice President of Sustainability, describes this development:

“Finnair believes electric aviation will be one of the tools for the future of flying. It will help to promote responsible and sustainable aviation especially on short routes, in an era where climate change will increasingly dominate the agenda.

We want to be actively involved in developing and implementing new technologies which enable carbon-neutral flying.

Solving the climate challenge of flying is essential so that the social and economic benefits of aviation can continue. Many of the measures require collaboration across industries in tandem with partners playing a key role in our ongoing sustainability work.”

Finnair is committed to halving its net CO2 emissions by the end of 2025 and achieving carbon neutrality by 2045. In order to accomplish this, the airline is focused on improving fuel efficiency, reducing aircraft weight, combining different modes of transport, emissions trading, and sustainable aviation fuels.

This is very cool, but…

Obviously the focus on this kind of technology is awesome and commendable, and a more sustainable future for aviation is a marathon and not a race. With that in mind, I have a couple of different thoughts.

First of all, I wouldn’t read too much into the “letter of interest.” Ultimately this seems to me like a mutually beneficial publicity stunt — Finnair is showing its commitment to the environment, and it makes Heart Aerospace look good to be backed by a major airline. I doubt Finnair is putting down much of a deposit, especially in this current environment.

Beyond that, I’m not sure I entirely get how this fits into Finnair’s fleet planning?

  • This plane seats at most 19 passengers, while Finnair’s current smallest plane seats 68 passengers
  • While an electric plane concept is awesome, realistically how practical is it? It seems the plane has a range of 400 kilometers, so how long will it have to charge between uses, and how many markets does Finnair serve where a 19-seat plane makes sense?
  • It’s great when it’s advertised that a plane can greatly reduce emissions and save money, but that comparison is only valuable when compared to a similar plane

Airbus is developing zero-emission commercial aircraft that are high capacity, and those are practical in the sense that they could actually replace existing planes.

Airbus is developing zero-emission commercial aircraft

However, some of the other initiatives we’re seeing don’t seem quite as practical. For example, United Airlines revealed that it plans to operate 200 electric air taxis. I mean, I guess that’s cool, but that doesn’t really do much to help make United’s fleet more efficient, it just means the airline is trying to expand into a new industry, and compete with the likes of BLADE, Uber, etc.

United Airlines plans to operate up to 200 electric air taxis

Similarly, I suppose that Finnair may be looking to expand into new markets that can’t currently be served, because otherwise I’m not sure how practical this would be.

Bottom line

Finnair has expressed interest in ordering up to 20 ES-19s, which are 19-seat electric aircraft that could enter service by 2026. It’s awesome to see technology like this being developed, though the logistics when it comes to airline operations are still a mystery to me.

19-seat planes with an electric range of 400 kilometers don’t seem to do much to replace any existing aircraft Finnair may operate, which at a minimum have roughly at least four times as much capacity.

What do you make of Finnair’s interest in these electric planes?

Conversations (28)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Richard A. Guest

I could see this plane working well for services to the Isles of Scilly, Shetland to Fair Isle, Orkney to Shetland, Glasgow to Campbeltown, Oban to various Inner Hebrides. Presently run by Twin Otters, BN Islanders, Saab 340s, plenty of wind power to recharge packs, tidal in some spots, solar at Scilly. The reduced noise of electric propulsion would be another bonus at these sensitive locations.

0
‼ 0
CraigTPA Guest

While the concept of electric planes is fascinating and holds a lot of promise, I still think that biofuels offer more and faster return on investment in terms of CO2 reduction.

0
‼ 0
JS Guest

I do agree that a 19-seat plane with 400 km does not make any business sense for Finnair. There is only a handful of routes that it would suit. Additionally, there is absolutely no indication that operating an electric aircraft would be more economical - on the contrary, it is bound to be a lot more expensive, given that the technology is so new and still under development. However, Finland does have a government run by a green party plus several green-ish parties, and Finnair is majority government-owned. Additionally, many of the current domestic routes are not profitable even as they are, but they are operated with the help of government subsidies. Finnair actually abandoned several routes recently and they have just been awarded to other companies through government contracts. The center-left-green politics seem to drive a slightly contradictory policy of maintaining good connections to the smaller, remote cities while also penalising all forms of traffic due to emissions. So I could actually imagine the government pouring tons of money into acquiring a couple of small electric planes for the purpose of moral gain. Of course this has no practical impact in the big picture, but who cares.

0
‼ 0
Milo Guest

@jcil Agreed with mangoMan; your first comment nailed it. IMHO, until we have the next revolution in battery technology and propulsion technology, it is all but a pipe dream. The carbon footprint from mining lithium and other REM required to make the batteries, transporting the mined lithium and other REM to the factory to make the batteries, and processing expired batteries are often (if not purposely) overlooked when discussing EV's. Not to mention how volatile lithium is. Remember the fiasco regarding lithium batteries during 787's launch. Now imagine lithium batteries are your main source of power. Also, the biggest leap in aviation thus far happened when we went from propellors to jet engines. But present day jet engines require combustion that is not possible with electricity, so the only propulsion method currently feasible with electricity is electric motor propellors. How effective and scalable are electric motors in generating thrust remains to be seen. I won't be surprised if we see lightweight electric aircrafts (like an electric Cessna) or electric helicopters going mainstream within the next decade, but electricity will be a no-no for airliners with current propulsion technology. Beyond electric motor propellors, the next revolution in propulsion technology could likely be electricity generated plasma thrusters, but those are perhaps decades away. Currently, electric thrusters are available on small spacecrafts like satellites for attitude control. But those require very low power output. To provide enough thrust for an aircraft, you need electrical power (mega-watts) far beyond what present day batteries can handle. If we make breakthroughs in nuclear fusion technology, perhaps a fusion reactor would be the perfect power source for large scale plasma thrusters.

0
‼ 0
AD Diamond

I would suspect that they will do some sort of hot swap on the batteries so the plane doesn't sit. The issue is when they get diverted to an airport that is not equipped with either replacement batteries or charging equipment. You're not going to plug the plane into an ordinary 220 outlet.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published