Uber’s New Tattletale Feature: A Necessary Evil?

Uber rolled out a safety feature yesterday that’s both very necessary, and sure to cause a lot of controversy among drivers.

Setting the scene…

If you take ride shares with any frequency, you’ve probably been in a situation where you had safety concerns about the driver’s actions:

  • Was the driver texting while driving?
  • Was the driver running red lights or stop signs?
  • Was the driver being aggressive or exhibiting road rage?

I can’t count the number of times I’ve been in this situation, but I didn’t really know how to handle it:

  • If it’s not that serious, I feel uncomfortable asking the driver to change their behavior; after all, I’m in their car
  • In many situations I also feel bad giving them a bad rating (since their ability to continue using the platform relies on having a good rating), unless their driving was truly egregious

Fortunately Uber has now implemented a feature allowing you to tattletale on a driver without making it awkward.

Uber now lets you report safety concerns

For those in the US and Canada, Uber has just added something to their “Safety Toolkit,” allowing riders to report safety incidents during their rides.

Once you’re in the safety toolkit (which you can access by clicking on the blue shield symbol during a ride), click “Report Safety Issue,” and then you’ll be able to share the details of any safety concerns you have about a trip you took.

When you do this:

  • The driver will only be contacted after the ride with the feedback
  • A member of the safety team will contact the passenger

Presumably they aren’t going to fire a driver after one complaint, but this is a good way they can pick up on patterns, should a driver consistently get the same complaint.

This is great for passengers

Uber increasingly has a focus on safety, largely because it helps them with regulators when they’re having battles over their operating license in various cities.

As far as I’m concerned, this is no doubt a positive development. It allows you to share your concerns in a non-confrontational way.

Drivers are going to hate this

Many Uber drivers hate passengers. Now, I assume this isn’t actually a majority of drivers, but rather just those who hang out online and discuss Uber. Some drivers seem to essentially think that passengers are all cheap morons who will do anything for Uber credit.

For example, Twitter user @sergioaved writes how he already received one of these safety notices from Uber, and it went about as well as you’d expect.

Uber wrote to him:

We received feedback from one of your riders expressing concern with traffic maneuvers and phone use on a recent trip.

As explained in our Community Guidelines, serious or repeated claims of poor, unsafe, or distracted driving can result in loss of access to the Driver app.

We appreciate your understanding.

He responded:

It’s a lie for cheap passengers to get $5 Uber credit. It’s fraud committed by Uber passengers putting my livelihood at risk. Over 3000 trips, 4.93 rating, tell that passenger to go screw themselves. Tell that passenger to stop defrauding Uber.

Uber responded:

Thank you for providing additional details. When these trips happen, we are not in the vehicle. As a result, outreach to both parties is standard practice. Our feedback to you isn’t designed to be accusatory in nature. Our goal here is to simply make sure you are aware of the type of feedback you received and hear your side of the story as well.

And he responds:

My records speaks for itself, over 3000 rides, hundreds of compliments and Uber sends me fraudulent passenger garbage, typical Uber. If it’s not an accusation, why are you bothering me with fraudulent passenger feedback. I’m an independent contractor according to Uber, stop being judge, jury and executioner. Go deal with your cheap passengers trying to get a free ride!

So yeah, I’d say this is going to go really great…

Bottom line

I appreciate Uber adding an option to provide feedback to drivers when unsafe behavior is noticed. I would report this not because I’m a passenger looking for Uber credit, but rather because I just want to provide feedback and contribute to any overall patterns for the driver.

I’ll take it a step further — I don’t think Uber should offer riders any credit when they use this feature to report drivers, because I think that creates a counterproductive incentive to use the feature.

Even with good intentions, I fear this will only make some drivers resent their jobs even more.

Riders and drivers — what do you make of Uber’s new safety feature for reporting drivers?

Conversations (59)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

M c Guest

Uber pays very little to their drivers and Lyft even less, so when they pick up a rider that doesn't tip, they are losing money instead of making money. I have noticed more and more lately that riders are not tipping. They will rate you with 5 stars but not tip. Is it because they are being over charged or just cheap. I stopped driving because of this and if something doesn’t change more and more people will stop driving when they see it isnt worth it because they are not making any money. Also these companies should have a better grip on these drivers that are scamming people.

0
‼ 0
Mike Guest

Half of my passengers are in my car because they wrecked their own car, don't know how to drive, or are drunk. The other have are parents without car seats for their babies. None of them should get a say so about whether I'm a safe driver or not.

0
‼ 0
D P Guest

I've been driving for Uber for almost 4 years with a good rating, and because passengers can now fraudulently report something that never happened is cruel. Uber just takes their word for it and sends the driver a generic message. I got one of those messages where a passenger lied and said that I was a reckless driver when I've got nothing but 5 star ratings about 95% of the time (you can't please every passenger). I had to call Uber to set things straight because they didnt know the circumstances of the ride. You'd have to be in the car to see what's really going on. Sometimes the drivers make mistakes but that's only because we're human. No one drives perfectly all the time, and passengers expect that. You have to also take into consideration the drivers around you. That sometimes can effect how you drive as well, but the passengers don't see that. We as drivers sometimes get yelled at or the passengers are being disrespectful to your car because it's not theirs, and we have to take that abuse. It's called giving good customer service. I help load things into my car because in the past, passengers have tried to break my seats, seatbelts, trunk door, and damaged the trunk floor and sides by just shoving their luggage and/or bags into it. Uber doesn't care about that either. My car gets trashed almost everytime I drive, and I have to spend hours cleaning it so I don't get a bad rating for having a dirty car. Uber needs to step up more and protect it's drivers, and they need to fix their navigation platform.

0
‼ 0
Pete Guest

I never tip the driver they don't know until long after there gone. Great Uber benefit for riders & we save $$$$ thank you Uber

0
‼ 0
AustynSN Guest

As a driver, I do have a problem with this. Not because people can complain, but because Uber tells us NOTHING about the actual complaints. Sometimes when driving, we might make an error in judgement; others we might do something that seems a bad choice, but was necessary due to the actions of another driver, but the passenger couldn't see it from the back. The complaints are always just a generic message about traffic maneuvers or such and the only feedback I've ever gotten was about not taking corners too sharply. (Something COMPLETELY subjective based upon the individual, as well as traits of the vehicle.) They should give the driver a transcription of the complaint with any identifiable information (Pax name, time/date/pickup/destination of ride) redacted. We can't improve if we really don't know what we're doing wrong.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published

Keep Exploring OMAAT