Qantas Cracking Down On Hand Luggage

The big benefit of checking in online for a flight when you don’t have any luggage to check is that you can usually bypass the check in experience completely. This means not lining up for check in, and not having to speak to any airline staff until you reach the boarding gate.

I travel Hand Luggage Only virtually all the time now, so use online check in wherever I can. I love arriving at the airport and breezing through security straight away.

When I’m at the gate for boarding, I often notice that plenty of other passengers have little paper tags on their hang luggage that indicate the airline has checked that their hand luggage complies with weight and size requirements and is suitable to take on board.

If you check in online and skip check in, you still need to ensure your hand luggage fits within the size and, if applicable, weight limits, but in my experience, airlines very rarely check this at the boarding gate unless your bag looks to be obviously too big.

All airlines have size restrictions for hand luggage (after all, those overhead bins are only so big), and some also have weight restrictions for hand luggage.

For frequent flyers who use online check in, they may regularly exceed the weight limits for their hand luggage without even realising it. I would even go so far as to say that some may use this method to purposely exceed the weight limits because they know they can get away with it.

On full service airlines, I’ve never had a bag weighed or measured.

I couldn’t even tell you exactly what my hand luggage weighs (I don’t pack my bags with bricks or anything, though).

Qantas

Qantas is an airline that has rarely, if ever, weighed hand luggage at the gate. But they have now realised that online check in passengers are exceeding the hand luggage weight limits, and are cracking down.

They have started weighing all passengers’ hand luggage on certain flights, and are forcing those passengers over the limit to gate check their hand luggage.

This is much to the frustration of their valued frequent flyers, who are being delayed by this cumbersome process both when boarding, and at the other end, waiting for their luggage on the belts.

Qantas has claimed the reason for these random checks is both to ensure each passenger has their fair share of overhead space, and from a safety perspective, because cabin crew members were injuring themselves lifting overweight luggage into the overhead bins at the request of passengers.

I was recently on a Nile Air flight in Egypt, and we boarded via a bus to a remote stand. When I got to the bottom of the stairs to the aircraft an elderly lady tapped me on the shoulder, pointed at her cabin bag and motioned for me to take it up the stairs for her.

I happily agreed but when I picked it up it was so heavy I struggled to even carry it up the stairs. While it was within the size limits goodness knows what was in it.

I estimate it would have weighed well over 15kgs / 33lbs. But it could have easily weighed 20kgs / 44lbs. There was absolutely no way this woman would have been able to lift it into the overhead, and I pity the back of the cabin crew would she would have been tasked with doing it for her.

Bottom line

I’m sure I’m guilty of exceeding hand luggage weight limits in the past. I rely on the fact that most airlines do not weigh bags at the gate, and know that size wise, my bag or bags are within the size restrictions.

If an airlines did charge me for exceeding the weight limit, I would just suck it up and check my bag or pay any excess fee knowing that I had ‘gotten away with it’ so many times in the past.

While frequent flyers will grumble at Qantas being so strict with this, Qantas already has a very generous hand luggage policy, as they allow two full size cabin bags on most flights, weighing up to 7kgs / 15lbs per bag.

And no crew member should be injuring their backs lifting over weight bags that passengers can’t lift themselves.

Do you think it is fair for full service airlines to randomly weigh hand luggage?

Conversations (49)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Reuben Guest

I've had two QF flights in the last two days with a big backpack, and no questions asked. I almost always put it under the seat infront, but I had a bulkhead row today so it had to go in the overhead locker.

0
‼ 0
Bagoly Guest

I agree that Easyjet has the best policy: so long as you can lift it (and it satisfies the size limits) it's OK, which avoids unreasonable demands on crew and other passengers. Limited space is dealt with by whether passengers have paid for premium seating. What I find odd is the variations within the legacy carriers. E.g. BA 23kg (* 2 even in Economy - they explicitly say that the smaller bag can be that heavy!), IB 10/14, AF 8/12, CX 7/10/15, JAL 10, but LH 8, and SQ as well as QF 7kg. Who in E.g. LH Business Class has each bag less than 8kg (the policy says that the class means two bags, not one heavier one) ?? Those limits are ridiculously low, and in Business Class it's not about maximising income from checked bag fees. Make the limit at least 15kg, and then enforce.

0
‼ 0
StevenA Member

Well for too long the main offenders have been the high tier FF’s the ever “entitled” who already have a generous baggage allowance - crew are constantly injured by inconsiderate passengers who only care about themselves - Can you imagine all of those overloaded lockers coming down in a crash - I guarantee all of the lockers weigh more than the placarded weight limits - but who cares right ? Until you sustain a brain I jury? Who cares then ?

0
‼ 0
Miles Guest

They should just charge everything by the Kg, like you buy veggies at the shop. Checked luggage 2$ per kg, carry on bags 4$ per kg. Pay for what you bring.

0
‼ 0
Robert Wise Guest

Boarding a United flight at Newark the gate agent suddenly started to tell us to check EVRRY bag ! I only had a little wheel bag but no exception. I got on the plane and sat down and to my spitting nails annoyance people were ignoring the mandatory check bags and on top of that there were humungous bags in the overheads already. Dont tell me United dont know how much the overheads will take and should have planned to take every oversize bag to the hold. To add insult to injury when I got to Houston and waited forever for my bag it arrived wet inside and out because the baggage handlers left the bags out in the pissing rain as revenge for have to load extra bags. Basturds !! I complained but all they said was Oh, Dear ! Ridiculous And the airlines wonder why people hate them. I bet Cathay, SQ, etc dont treat their customers like that

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Keep Exploring OMAAT