Did An EVA Air 777 Nearly Crash Into A Mountain After Departing LAX?

It looks like the EVA Air 777-300ER flight this past Friday morning from Los Angeles to Taipei had quite a bit of excitement, and it wasn’t the pilots’ fault… at least not initially.

The weather in Los Angeles wasn’t good, and the 777 was departing towards the east (rather than towards the west, out over the ocean). The pilots read back the instructions they understood from ATC, which ended up being incorrect, though ATC didn’t correct them. Then ATC was shocked when they saw the plane was headed in the wrong direction, though it took the pilots over a minute to correct their course, putting them on a heading towards a mountain range and an Air Canada plane. Per ABC7:

That sent the airliner toward the mountains above Altadena, as well as toward the flight path of an Air Canada plane that had just taken off.

Audio traffic indicates the same controller realizing the problem and telling the airliner to “Stop your climb” and several times to head southbound.

“EVA 015 Heavy, what are you doing? Turn southbound now, southbound now. Stop your climb,” the frustrated controller says after the plane apparently does not heed her initial instruction.

Several times the controller tells the pilot to head south. More than a minute later, she is still trying to get him to change direction.

The EVA crew eventually pulled up and got onto the right flight path.

Most concerning is that the flight apparently just missed a mountain range by a few hundred feet. Per JACDEC:

According to ADSB tracking data, flight BR 15 barely cleared the mountaintops and was flying just south of Mt. Wilson Observatory (5,715 ft) at an altitude of about 6,250 ft. before the flight gets back into safe airspace. The Boeing 777-300 then picked up its assigned route and landed safely at Taipei 14 h 17 min later.

The FAA is formally investigating this, so I’ll be curious to see what comes of the investigation. Based on the ATC transcript, though:

  • The controller told the pilots to turn to a heading of 180, though it didn’t seem to transmit whether it was supposed to be a left or right turn
  • The pilots repeated that they should turn left heading 180, and they weren’t corrected (it appears they were supposed to turn right to that heading, so if ATC had been paying attention to their read back, this could have been avoided)
  • The air traffic controller uses a lot of non-standard phrases — rather than telling the plane to turn to a specific heading, the controller says “what are you doing? turn southbound,” so it’s possible there was something lost in translation

Per Flightradar24, here’s the flight path the plane took on departure:

eva 777

Fortunately, everything ended without incident, though it seems this was a fairly close call, given that the plane apparently only cleared a mountain by about 500 feet.

(Tip of the hat to Andrew B)

Conversations (40)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Daniel Bubb Guest

I have over 14 years of flying experience, an ATP license, and am familiar with the Los Angeles airspace. This controller should have been relieved of duty by another controller or asked for help immediately. As Mr. Radtke says, maybe she was working a longer than normal shift. She had the EVA, Air Canada, and American Airlines pilots nervous. You could hear the stress rising in their voices. The EVA pilots were totally confused. Telling pilots to turn southbound is not helpful, especially when they are flying IFR at night and in bad weather. I can only imagine the TCAS and GPWS alarms going off at the same time, which would be enough to concern any pilot. The controller should have told EVA 015 to "turn right heading XXX and climb and maintain 7,000." Yes indeed, let's thank our lucky stars that this did not end up in disaster!

0
‼ 0
Michael radtke Guest

Hi all, First lets count our stars this didnt turn out worse. I am retired FAA 33 yrs atc. This event started out from the Socal atc radar dept controller female(race doesnt matter) radar identifing eva 015 and telling aircraft to turn left instead of right. Its 1:30 am did the controller work a day shift then back for the midshift? Fatigue and roatating shift work plus lots of overtime add up to a toxic brew. Maybe she is used to 95% of the time departing rwy 25 off off lax turning left south for climb, then west on course. She initiated this event then had to scramble to seperate the air canada plane from eva air. Im sure the eva air pilots were overloaded, in weather, heavy rain, tcas alert for air canada, listening to atc flustered transmissions, confusion, now getting terrain ground proxmity alerts. You also dont tell an ifr jetliner in weather to turn south. You give explicit left/right and heading to fly. Turn southbound is something to telll a small vfr aircraft. Im worried about the state of affairs at the FAA. From what i saw my last few years in ATC., there should be great concern. Controller accountability for errors needs to return, no more slap on the wrist atsap program, true consequences for errors needs to be addressed. We are very lucky here. The pilots need to follow tcas and ground proxmitity warnings, take flight action, then tell atc reponding to alert . The warning systems will keep the planes safe. Only sloppy controlling, one person on a midshift, bad management actions will put them together.

0
‼ 0
Russ Guest

Additionally, it came within several hundred feet laterally to the TV towers on Mt Wilson that are nearly 1000 feet tall.

0
‼ 0
AlexS Diamond

I think both parties are at fault here... but I am concerned about why the pilot took so long to turn south. It's possible that the pilot was getting tired of the controller getting it wrong and correcting herself so he maintained current course thinking that's what she intended to say. BUT standard procedure is to ask for clarification if there's a misunderstanding. It could also have been due to radio interference. I don't know the location well, but traditionally radio transmitters are located in the hills/mountains. Both SouTH and NorTH have a "TH" at the end and it's possible the pilots weren't able to clearly hear the instruction. At some point in the "go southbound!!!!" conversation, a new NUMERICAL heading should have been issued. That would have clarified everything. Ambiguity is not something to mess with. ...but I'm armchair quarterbacking here -- I have a ~100 hours behind the yoke of a PA-46-500TP, VFR only and not much else.

0
‼ 0
Loc Smith Guest

Pilot: 'Should I turn left, right?' Controller: 'Right!' Then the pilot took a right turn.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published