Cause Of Deadly EgyptAir Crash Finally Revealed?

Oh EgyptAir…

EgyptAir’s Mysterious Plane Crashes

EgyptAir has historically had a not-amazing safety record, and perhaps most alarming has been that the cause of two crashes remains unknown. This is concerning because airlines can’t do anything to improve safety if they’re not able to (or are unwilling to) figure out or admit what happened.

The two crashes that stand out are the following:

  • In 1999 EgyptAir 990 crashed enroute from New York to Cairo; most international investigators agree that the relief pilot intentionally crashed the plane, while Egyptian authorities strongly dispute that
  • In 2016 EgyptAir 804 crashed enroute from Paris to Cairo; up until now the cause has been unknown, with Egyptian investigators insisting that a bomb detonated onboard, though international investigators have disputed that

It’s incredibly mysterious that the cause of a plane crash as recent as 2016 can’t be determined. Then again, a 777 disappeared into thin air just a few years prior to that, so I guess nothing is out of the realm of possibility.

Anyway, it looks like we now have a better sense of what caused the crash of EgyptAir 804.

EgyptAir 804 Basics & Theories

EgyptAir 804 was scheduled to fly from Paris to Cairo on May 19, 2016, and was operated by an A320. The plane crashed into the Mediterranean Sea, and killed all 66 people onboard.

Up until now Egyptian authorities have insisted that a bomb went off on the plane. They’ve based this on traces of TNT being found on the bodies of victims, though since bodies were in seawater for several weeks, other authorities said it was normal for traces of such explosives to be found. Furthermore, these were never found on the bodies of French victims that were returned to the country.

International investigators have disputed this theory all along. They say that a smoke detector in the forward lavatory went off, and that shortly before the crash passengers moved towards the back of the plane, suggesting there was a fire near the front of the plane.

Some Clues As To What Really Happened

The Wall Street Journal has revealed disturbing findings from an investigation into what happened to EgyptAir 804.

The issue seems to stem from the fact that Egyptian authorities were in charge of the investigation (since it was an EgyptAir plane), and they’ve withheld key information from other investigators.

They simply insisted that a bomb brought down the plane, but were unwilling to share a lot of their findings, citing the secrecy of their counterterrorism inquiry.

Now a French judicial probe has been completed (since French citizens died on the plane), which paints a very different picture of what happened. They have determined that maintenance and safety lapses left the plane unsafe to fly in the days before it crashed. Specifically, a leak of oxygen in the cockpit preceded a fire that likely disabled the plane.

According to this investigation, automated messages from the A320 involved in the crash reported serious mechanical errors on the final five flights, and those were largely ignored by the airline.

The pilots on these flights never mentioned the issues in post-flight reports, even though these issues should have set off alarms inside the plane. The EgyptAir ground technician also said that neither the airline nor the pilots informed him of these issues. On top of that, investigators are questioning if the EgyptAir technician in Paris who inspected the plane was qualified to service aircraft in Europe.

According to the documents from the investigation:

“The plane should have been checked during its four previous flights, and should not have left Cairo after the appearance of repeated faults that were not reported by successive teams.”

It’s clear that the Egyptian officials have been trying to block this investigation to such a great degree. In May 2018 the French and Egyptians met in Cairo, and French authorities were allowed to view aircraft debris, but not touch it. The French asked for a copy of the plane’s cockpit voice recorder, but Egyptian authorities refused, citing it as a secret criminal investigation.

But as it turns out, information was even being withheld between French investigators. France’s air crash investigation bureau held a backup copy of the data for quite a while, but refused to share it with the French judicial probe, arguing that they promised Egyptian authorities that they wouldn’t. So arguably that delayed the investigation by about 18 months.

Bottom Line

While I’ve enjoyed my flights on EgyptAir, it’s always disheartening and irresponsible for an airline (or perhaps country in this case, since EgyptAir is state owned) to be more focused on covering up problems and fault, than to focus on making the airline as safe as possible (in fairness, Boeing could be described in a similar way at the moment).

I’m happy to see that we’re getting closer to finding out what really happened to EgyptAir 804.

(Featured image courtesy of Aktug Ates)

Conversations (43)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

roger ellis Guest

Re: Egyptair 804 - crashed due ethanol. I read this Egyptair 804 article with interest. This report is only partly true, because oxygen needs a fuel to burn, and a flightdeck does not have much of that. The real problem was that Muslim airlines carried (carry) eau-de-cologne (ethanol) on the flightdeck for ritual hand washing, and this ethanol was stored on top of the oxy mask (a convenient shelf in a cockpit devoid of shelves). I warned all the authorities about this back in 2012 after the similar Corendon cockpit fire. I warned the NTSB, Boeing, CAA, FAA, AIIB, Airbus and the French BEA. I even had Mr Lawrence of the NTSB on my flight, after the Corendon fire, and told him all about this - but nothing was done. So four years later, when Egyptair 804 went down, I immediately knew what had happened. But all the authorities have refused to acknowledge my letters, and the London School of Economics aviation safety project wrote to say they would delete all my correspondence. All those people on Egyptair 804 died due to political correctness - because the authorities would not comment upon, let alone challenge, the customs of Muslims. So there you have it - all of these incidents, crashes and deaths were caused by eau-de-cologne, which should never be on a flight deck next to oxy masks. And the real problem now is, that due to Covid many other airlines are now taking hand cleanser (ethanol) onto flightdecks for handwashing. So the dangers of ethanol on flightdecks have just multiplied 100-fold, and so we may well have another needless cockpit fire in the air. How many more people need to die, before someone acknowledges this problem? We have a real safety threat here, and nobody will discuss it - absolutely nobody. .

0
‼ 0
Kjeld Wetlesen Guest

STEP 8: Now it is time to reveal the cause of the crash of MS 804. The old argument declaring Meteorites a useless conspiratory is no longer valid. In previous comment (7) wrong data in the Cassidy paper was nailed. Cassidy is predicting 59,000 years will pass before we see a collision between a meteorite and an aircraft. With better data quality Cassidy was replaced by the Wessel model where 59,000 years becomes 1,400 years. With green light we can go ahead analyzing and defining the cause. Often in aircraft disasters, there is only one defining cause. MS 804 WAS BROUGHT DOWN BY A METEORITE To verify the claim we only need one source, i.a. ACARS (Aircraft Communications Addressing and Reporting System) is an automatic error reporting system which receives and sends error messages to the pilots and an on-ground station, without any interference from the pilots themselves. Here are the ACARS messages received right around the time of the accident and most important in the correct sequence: 00:26Z3044 ANTI ICE R WINDOW The first ACARS error message concerns the de-icing system on the right side of the cockpit. De-icing of windows is also known from modern cars. It consists of a row of small metal wires embedded in the window. By running an electric current through the wires, the windowpane is heated up and the ice melts. Here you could get the idea that the window had broken. 00:26Z 561200 R SLIDING WINDOW SENSOR Not all windows in the cockpit are fixed. There are sliding windows on both the right and the left side. The error message points to an error in the right sliding window. 00:26Z 2600 LAVATORY SMOKE At the same minute, the ACARS reported errors by the windows and smoke in the lavatory, which is located directly behind the cockpit. 00:27Z 2600 AVIONICS SMOKE The minute after smoke was reported in the lavatory, more errors are detected in the systems that are in avionics, which are gathered at the back of the cockpit. Avionics is an umbrella term for the multitude of systems used for monitoring and controlling modern airplanes. 00:28Z 561100 FIXED WINDOW SENSOR Now there are also an error in the fixed window on the right side. 00:29Z 2200 AUTO FTU FCU 2 FAULT One of the two autopilot systems reports errors. 00:29Z 2700 F/CLT SEC 3 FAULT The second autopilot reports errors. If the front window was broken, the pilots would have been subject to a hurricane four times more powerful than a category 5 hurricane. On CVR, which records sound and conversation in the cockpit, the word “fire” can be heard as the last thing said by the pilots. Both pilots die and the plane crashes into the Mediterranean Sea. Captain B. Svendsen, retired chief pilot and flight instructor: “What’s interesting here and can perhaps support your meteor strike theory is the ONLY word «FIRE» from the CVR. […] I would imagine that’s the only word, if any at all, there might be time to say if you’re hit by a meteor in flight (hit the pressurized fuselage).” ACARS does not receive more messages,

0
‼ 0
Kjeld Wetlesen Guest

STEP 1: I am back almost one week later than expected due to medical reasons. But now I continue my take on was happened on board MS 804 the night on almost 4 years ago. The cause to the crash is not found and Egypt Air, who owned the aircraft that crashed, has closed the investigation and blocked any access to the wreckage which is buried deep in the sea. I am convinced a Meteorite hit MS804 and destroyed the flight deck. My explanation is always rejected and the argument for rejecting can be found in a paper prepared by Willian A. Cassidy for NTSB investigation in the TWA 800 disaster. In that paper William A. Cassidy predict the frequency of meteorites hit aircrafts is one event in 59,000 years. The problem with the Cassidy paper is that the data used by William A. Cassidy are in many cases wrong and if you use wrong data you will get wrong results. Let us have a look on the data errors I claim are in the Cassidy model.: 1) Only events in the air over USA minus Alaska and Hawaii are included in the model, therefore 96 % of the Earth are left out 2) Only meteorites making damage on USA mainland are included. Since the beginning of flying, William A. Cassidy can only find 13 events in almost 100 years 3) The footprint of small and big planes is too little. Cassidy has footprint for a big plane 93 m2 where Airbus 380 is 845 m2 according Airbus 4) Cassidy do not count aircrafts on the ground. The airline idutry will urgently need a revised model and I have made one “The Wessel-model” and instead of 59,000 years per event, the Wessel model predict 1,400 years. The Cassidy model is not any longer a show stopper and the true story about MS 804 can be told.

0
‼ 0
red_robbo Gold

@ Kjeld Wessel Wetlesen : As boring and ridiculous as your whole presentation, I'm afraid.

0
‼ 0
Kjeld Wessel Wetlesen Guest

@red_robo: Thanks for your comment. I totally agree with you. Conspiracy theory is boring.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published