Why I Have ZERO Sympathy For U.S. Airlines Whining About Gulf Carriers

For over two years now, the “big three” U.S. carriers have been trying to stop the “big three” Gulf carriers. The basis of their claim is that Emirates, Etihad, and Qatar, have been violating the Open Skies agreement because they’re government subsidized, and therefore the playing field isn’t level.

Qatar-Airways-A350-02

They argue that it’s not fair that a reciprocal agreement causes them to have to compete head-to-head with airlines that are really big government vehicles.

I haven’t been very sympathetic towards the arguments the U.S. carriers make. Many people have assumed that it’s because I love the glitz and glam of the Gulf carriers, and don’t think of the impact it has on U.S. jobs, etc. That’s not the case. My main issue is that the U.S. carriers are making their case so poorly, to the point that it really feels to me like they’re targeting and bullying three airlines.

Etihad-Arrivals-Lounge-Abu-Dhabi - 1

For example, here’s the latest ad from the Partnership for Open & Fair Skies, which is the annoying lobbying group that the U.S. carriers use:

Let’s ignore for a moment that…

I want to stick to the core of my issue with their argument, so let’s forget that:

  • Emirates, Etihad, and Qatar are massive customers of Boeing, which unarguably helps the U.S. economy and generates lots of jobs
  • Emirates, Etihad, and Qatar are substantial employers in the U.S.
  • Emirates, Etihad, and Qatar bring a lot of people to the U.S., which boosts the U.S. economy
  • U.S. carriers argue that subsidies of all kinds are terrible, when in reality they’ve gotten these as well, ranging from profiting off of the Essential Air Service program, to unloading pensions when they went through bankruptcy
  • U.S. carriers argue that 1.2 million American aviation jobs are at risk, all while U.S. carriers are turning record profits in spite of these “evil” Gulf carriers
  • The real risk facing the U.S. carriers is the ultra low cost carriers like Norwegian, which in some cases have questionable business practices (when your company is based in Ireland, but you’re flying out of France and the UK with Thai crews)

I could go on and on, but that’s all besides the point…

The real problem: the U.S. carriers are running an unfair smear campaign

The U.S. carriers could try to make a legitimate argument that government owned and/or subsidized airlines shouldn’t be allowed to participate in the Open Skies agreement, which is intended to be a free market policy. I think that would be an argument worth hearing.

The problem is, that is not the argument they’ve been making in any way, shape, or form. Instead they’ve picked three airlines to bully the hell out of.

Is the problem that some “subsidized” airlines (which they define as airlines where the government has a big equity stake) are participating in the Open Skies agreement? If that’s the case, why are they bullying just three airlines? There are dozens and dozens of government owned airlines participating in this agreement.

What about Saudia? What about Kuwait Airways? What about Air China? What about Air India? What about Singapore Airlines?

Kuwait-777-Business-Class - 1

The further argument that’s made is that Emirates, Etihad, and Qatar are based in small markets, and a vast majority of their passengers are connecting onwards to further destinations. First of all, I’m not sure where in the Open Skies agreement that’s stated as something that’s not okay, but even so, isn’t the same true of Kuwait Airways and plenty of other airlines? And have you seen how low Kuwait Airways’ fares are? If that’s not considered to be capacity dumping, I don’t know what is…

What makes me really uncomfortable with all of this is that the U.S. carriers have picked three very easy, liked targets, and are trying to make a point about them, even though this is a much bigger issue. But U.S. carriers have never addressed the bigger issue, because it’s more than they can (or want to) handle. So instead they run a public smear campaign.

The hypocrisy of all of this

We’ve heard from the U.S. carriers that Emirates, Etihad, and Qatar threaten 1.2 million American aviation jobs. They’re lobbying the government to stop these airlines.

If that is in fact the case, how can American with a straight face partner with both Etihad and Qatar, the two airlines that are supposedly trying to destroy them.

How about Delta partnering with Saudia, which is similar? Heck, what about Delta buying a stake in China Eastern, a government owned airline? How can Delta argue that government subsidized/owned airlines are bad, and then invest in one?

China-Eastern-Business-Class-777 - 103

And let’s talk about Alitalia, which hasn’t turned a profit in a long time, and won’t turn a profit any time soon. They’re an airline that absolutely lives in a fantasy world (their survival plan is that ove the next two years they’ll decrease their fleet by 20% and increase revenue by 30%… as one does), but they keep getting bailed out. As reader Leonardo explained, there’s a simple reason for that:

The banks which are supposed to lend money to Alitalia are Intesa SanPaolo and Unicredit, the 2 biggest banks in Italy with massive political implication and infiltration. Alitalia has survived so long because of political reasons (nobody in the parliament wants to be responsible for 12,000 job losses and leaving the country without a carrier), so they force the banks to keep the airline alive. Of course the banks know they will not have any ROI, but in exchange for saving Alitalia, they will benefit from favorable policies which they need in other situations and which the parliament will approve for them. Beside, most of the debts of Alitalia are towards other Italian suppliers, which won’t see a dime if Alitalia goes bankrupt. Therefore, the economic circle will keep spinning, for everybody’s benefit. For non-italian it might sound hard to understand, but unfortunately it makes quite sense here.

alitalia-777

Bottom line

The U.S. airlines could make a legitimate argument about how government owned or subsidized airlines shouldn’t be part of the Open Skies agreement. They’d have a really hard time making that point, given that this includes so many airlines, but the point could be made.

What I have no respect for, however, is that they’re instead trying to conveniently bully three airlines in the name of patriotism and protecting U.S. jobs. It’s hypocritical that they single out Emirates, Etihad, and Qatar, when Kuwait, Saudia, and many other airlines are also government owned and primarily connect passengers traveling between different countries.

Furthermore, if the real problem is subsidized airlines, let’s talk about China Eastern, which Delta bought a stake in, and Alitalia, which is a textbook example of an airline that’s subsidized and is unlikely to ever turn a profit.

The core of my issue with the argument made by U.S. carriers is that they haven’t actually made an argument — instead they’ve just run a patriotism campaign that’s lacking facts. If you have a legitimate problem with subsidized airlines, then make that point. But stop singling out and bullying three airlines because it’s convenient.

Conversations (75)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Chris Guest

Lucky, I just posted a fairly length comment. However it may come across, just know that I am with whatever you say. U S carrieirs are crap and I'm sick of their complaining. Chris

0
‼ 0
Chris Guest

I'm sure many others have said the same thing. But here it goes... No one enjoys flying U.S. based carriers because their customer service sucks. Truly and completely their customer service SUCKS! I've been an international traveler for many years and U S carriers are a joke. They hire these flight attendants who believe that we the customer should be greatful to be flying on their plane. They loook down on us and treat us, the passenger, with contempt. F- them!!! Meanwhile middle eastern and European airlines hire professsionls who view the customer as an asset and someone to be held in high esteem. They know that the customer is the one who makes or breaks the company and ultimately their livelyhood. TDLR -- American and North American Airlines view passengers as annoyances while European and Middle Eastern airlines view customers as people to be treated with respect and dignity. The levels of service are indisputable. If American Airlines have trouble with any perceived subsidies the middle eastern airlines are getting, they should first look at their own horrific levels of customer service first. Peace out.

0
‼ 0
AlexS Diamond

Let's not forget that the US3 have benefitted greatly with government assistance in the form of bailouts, tax breaks, and subsidies. I believe United and Delta still enjoy great tax breaks, not sure about American.

0
‼ 0
Daunt Member

This is very simple: if you are Qatar, so 99% of the country is Doha, you have big interests in having your airport becoming a global hub. An airport makes money and creates employment, plus having many people connecting flights implies having many of them, soon or later, making a stopover, forced or not. That means, bringing more money to the country. So, if you are Qatar, subsidizing your airline is a way to make the country grow, because you are just capitalizing your country's position at the center of the World. All this fuss about competition, in my opinion, is ridicolous. There are so many sectors where competition, on a global scale, is compromised. How about US farmers getting subsidized to grow and sell underpriced corn, so that some countries prefer to import it rather than producing it locally? I think airlines are a country's shop window. I am Italian, and I am forced to see the national airline becoming a joke (ok, here you are a little too harsh, AZ business plan is basically to get rid of some expensive old contracts and unprofitable routes, which is a ballast that won't allow the company to grow. You also failed to explain how the agreement with Air France and Delta basically limited the long range routes of the company, which are the only cash sources): in my opinion, it should get as much government money as deemed necessary: if we are a country with immense tourism potential, then it makes sense to turn the national airline into a showcase of the national excellence fields. Losing 1bn per year, who cares when you feed the national economy with tourists, and give an easier time to national businessmen to travel abroad and promote the export products? It seems that the sectors are subsidized only when certain countries have something to earn, otherwise the fair competition is summoned.

0
‼ 0
Ryan Guest

Lucky - one of your main arguments is don't just pick on the big 3 ME government-owned carriers, what about other government owned carriers? This isn't the point - the shareholder in the equation is irrelevant - who owns the airline essentially doesn't matter, and doesn't provide the airline with any benefit. The issue people had/have with Emirates/Qatar/Etihad was the argument that they received interest-free loans, free land for buildings, perhaps oil and related services. These, if proven, are very real, and have very serious consequences on the airline market. And, importantly, it has been revealed that Etihad did in fact receive these benefits. Etihad has access to a secret, interest-free $US3 billion loan from the Abu Dhabi ruling family that required no repayments until 2027. So their shiny new fleet, which you very much appreciate, was basically gifted to them. And it is reported that Etihad benefit from substantial free sponsorship (Etihad is the major sponsor of English Premier League team Manchester City) cost of which was covered by Abu Dhabi Govt. The report also mentions Emiratisation subsidies and PSO routes, which appears to correspond to the Essential Air Service program. Arguably, the chiefs of US airlines are responding to these types of issues which may also affect Qatar and Emirates (probably to a lesser extent as it was quite well established. However, perhaps it too benefited in the 80's, 90's when it was finding its feet). So I firmly believe competition is a great thing and it does raise the bar. But this shouldn't discount any valid concerns companies have with respect to their competitors.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published