American Airlines Tells Crews To Stop Futzing With 787 Window Dimmers

Not all heroes wear capes. Some just write memos to flight attendants…

The Boeing 787’s frustrating window dimmers

There are many areas where new aircraft technology benefits customers, like quieter engines and better fuel efficiency. However, there’s one area where new aircraft technology doesn’t benefit customers — that’s the Boeing 787’s window dimmers.

The Boeing 787 has bigger windows than most other aircraft, which is awesome. However, Boeing decided to eliminate the traditional shades that you pull up and down, and instead replaced them with dimmers. These dimmers can be extremely frustrating, and it’s one of the reasons that I prefer the Airbus A350 to the Boeing 787.

What’s so frustrating about the 787’s window dimmers?

  • Even in the fully dimmed mode, it never gets quite as dark as it would with traditional window shades; if the sun is on the side of the aircraft you’re on, expect to feel some heat from it
  • Crews can control the window dimmers centrally, and can put the dimmers to their maximum setting and “lock” them, so that you don’t even have the option of looking out the window
  • Even when the window dimmers aren’t locked, I find the process of controlling the dimmers with buttons to be clunky at best

I noted my frustration with this in a recent review of United’s 787-9 business class.

I don’t love the 787’s window dimmers system

American tells crews not to “lock” window shades

As noted by @xJonNYC, American Airlines has sent out a memo to flight attendants reminding them not to lock the window dimmers on the Boeing 787, because “it’s important that each customer at a window can control their own experience.”

Here’s the full memo:

Customers sitting in the window seats enjoy watching take off, landing and even spotting landmarks from the sky. The Boeing 787 windows are larger and have unique controls for window shades. Recent feedback about customer experiences on this aircraft is that the windows are being fully dimmed and locked by flight attendants, leaving customers frustrated that they are unable to control the window features from their seat. Do not lock the window features on the Boeing 787. It’s important that each customer at a window can control their own experience.

On behalf of myself and all other avgeeks, THANK YOU!

American is instructing flight attendants not to lock 787 window dimmers

Why do flight attendants control the 787 window dimmers?

For anyone wondering why flight attendants would try to control the window dimmers, I suppose there are two possible explanations:

  • One is that flight attendants think it provides a better experience when windows are dimmed and mood lighting is turned on; I believe some flight attendants genuinely think that way
  • The other is that flight attendants want to keep the cabin dark in order to encourage people to sleep so that they can provide less service; this is definitely the case for some flight attendants

I’ve flown millions of miles, but I’ll never take for granted the miracle of flight, and how gorgeous the world is from several miles up. While I get everyone is different, I’m always in genuine disbelief when people keep windows fully closed during takeoff and landing, even when they’re not watching a show or trying to sleep.

Who wouldn’t want to enjoy this view?!

Bottom line

American Airlines has told flight attendants on Boeing 787s what us avgeeks have been thinking for a long time, but have largely been afraid to say — stop trying to control the window shades on the 787!

Now, whether or not flight attendants read the memo and/or actually follow it is a different story…

Anyone else love this American Airlines memo as much as I do?

Conversations (122)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Linda Guest

I had this happen on a flight back and forth to Turkey from Miami. .The flight attendant could unlock individual windows and did that on request.

0
‼ 0
Jon Guest

I was an Avgeek in the 1970's, long before the term was invented. I even got my private pilot's license in 1979 at age 23. I would have become an airline pilot, were the conditions in 1980 as they are today. Anyway, despite my long experience in flying the world, I have never taken flight for granted, and must have a window seat to see the wonders of clouds, sunset, geographic landmarks, cities. On a recent 14 hour flight, JFK to Tokyo Haneda on American Airlines' 787-9, I was looking forward to seeing far northern Canada, far northern Alaska (Brooks Range), Nome, St. Lawrence Island, etc. But about 1 1/2 hours out of JFK, I could not lighten my window. Yes, the crew had locked them in the dark position. I was miserable. At first I thought it was just my window, but I realized that it was the entire aircraft, and now I read online about this. It was awful. About 2 PM New York time, it would have been, they darkened the cabin and expected people to become sleepy I guess! Horrible! I couldn't see Alaska. Very disappointing to this big geography guy. Would avoid taking 787 in the future for just this reason! Shouldn't be permitted! Yes, flight attendants probably want to have less to do, from a sleepy dark cabin! Phoooey!

0
‼ 0
Dan Guest

I fly the 787. No one has ever mentioned that they dim the windows so they dont have to work as much. The meal services are provided on a schedule. The lights are usually dimmed to give folks an opportunity to sleep on the plane so that they can begin acclimating to their destination time zone. On the 767 and the A330 the lights were dimmed at the same times. People didnt raise the shades on those airplanes even though they could because they wanted to sleep or they respected those around them. I have to say, I enjoy working international and never want to have to work domestic trips again. People are far more polite and considerate on the international flights. Also on long haul flights most of the time is spent over an ocean with not much to see anyway.

0
‼ 0
Deb Guest

We have only flown on a 787 once, from Tahiti to LAX. The crew locked out the window and air controls. It was a miserable, dark, hot flight. We have avoided flying on a 787 ever since. I get airsick and need to be able to see out the window, even if just a little.

0
‼ 0
Paul Guest

Look. I realize that public opinion is split on this issue. Some people are photosensitive albinos and want their window shades down (whether or not they're sleeping) while some people want them open because they enjoy the views and/or the natural light to help keep alert while reading. But what I HATE HATE HATE is flight attendants trying to dictate to passengers. We are not stupid, we know that flight attendants want window shades closed to make the passengers sleepy, so they don't have to respond to people asking for drinks or snacks. Whether or not the window shade is open or closed should be the decision of the passenger sitting next to the window. END OF STORY. Flight attendants have NO AUTHORITY to tell you what to do with your window shade -- except during takeoff and landing when the shades should be open, in order to see out the window to facilitate an emergency evacuation.

1
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published