Which Credit Card Should You Use At Hotels? Here’s The Math…

Which Credit Card Should You Use At Hotels? Here’s The Math…

7
In the interest of full disclosure, OMAAT earns a referral bonus for anyone that’s approved through some of the below links. The information and associated card details on this page for the Hilton Honors American Express Aspire Card, and American Express® Green Card have been collected independently by OMAAT and has not been reviewed or provided by the card issuer. These are the best publicly available offers (terms apply) that we have found for each product or service. Opinions expressed here are the author's alone, not those of the bank, credit card issuer, airline, hotel chain, or product manufacturer/service provider, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities. Please check out our advertiser policy for further details about our partners, and thanks for your support! The offers for the Ink Business Preferred® Credit Card, and Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card have expired. Learn more about the current offers here.

I’m often asked by readers which credit card they should be using to maximize points for a given hotel stay, or if there’s an overall best hotel credit card.

Typically recommending which credit card is best for a particular bonus category (like dining, grocery stores, gas stations, everyday spending, etc.) is easy. That’s not really the case when recommending which credit card to use at hotels, though.

The added wrinkle with making this recommendation for stays at chain hotels is that you don’t just have to consider which credit cards broadly offer the best bonus categories for travel, but you also have to consider whether the hotel brand you’re staying at has a co-branded credit card that offers bonus points for stays at that specific brand.

In this post, I want to look at the most rewarding credit cards for hotel spending in general (regardless of the brand you’re staying at), and then compare that to the bonuses offered by specific co-branded hotel credit cards.

The most rewarding cards for hotel spending

Broadly speaking, what are the most rewarding credit cards for hotel spending? For this section, I’m excluding co-branded hotel credit cards. That’s because I’m looking at the cards that offer the best bonuses on hotel spending in general, rather than the best bonuses for a particular brand of hotel.

So, which major rewards cards offer bonuses for hotel spending? Note that the rewards for spending are calculated based on my valuation of transferable points currencies, and I’m only including cards that are still open to new applicants.

1. Chase Sapphire Reserve®

Reward for hotel spending: 6.8% (4x points, which I value at 1.7 cents each)
Card annual fee: $795

Learn more about the Chase Sapphire Reserve, apply for the Chase Sapphire Reserve.

2. Wells Fargo Autograph Journey Card

Reward for hotel spending: 6.5% (5x points, which I value at 1.3 cents each)
Card annual fee: $95

Learn more about the Wells Fargo Autograph Journey, apply for the Wells Fargo Autograph Journey.

3. Ink Business Preferred® Credit Card

Reward for hotel spending: 5.1% (3x points, which I value at 1.7 cents each)
Card annual fee: $95
Things to be aware of: This is a business card, and the 3x points is limited to the first $150,000 in combined purchases in bonus categories each account anniversary year

Learn more about the Ink Business Preferred, apply for the Ink Business Preferred.

4. American Express® Green Card

Reward for hotel spending: 5.1% (3x points, which I value at 1.7 cents each)
Card annual fee: $150 (Rates & Fees)

Learn more about the Amex Green, apply for the Amex Green.

The information and associated card details on this page for the American Express Green Card has been collected independently by OMAAT and has not been reviewed or provided by the card issuer.

5. Citi Strata Premier® Card

Reward for hotel spending: 5.1% (3x points, which I value at 1.7 cents each)
Card annual fee: $95

Learn more about the Citi Strata Premier, apply for the Citi StrataPremier.

6. Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card

Reward for hotel spending: 3.4% (2x points, which I value at 1.7 cents each)
Card annual fee: $95

Learn more about the Sapphire Preferred, apply for the Sapphire Preferred.

Several credit cards offer 2-5x points on hotel spending

The most rewarding co-branded cards for hotel spending

As you can see above, there are cards that offer anywhere from 2-5x points per dollar spent on hotels, with a return that I value at anywhere from 3.4% to 6.8%.

Can you get a better or worse return when using a co-branded hotel credit card? To be comprehensive, let’s look at the co-branded credit cards issued by Choice Privileges, Hilton Honors, IHG One Rewards, Marriott Bonvoy, World of Hyatt, and Wyndham Rewards. First let me share how much I value a point in each of these currencies (and of course let me emphasize that everyone should use their own valuation of points):

  • Choice Privileges — 0.6 cents each
  • Hilton Honors — 0.5 cents each
  • IHG One Rewards — 0.5 cents each
  • Marriott Bonvoy — 0.7 cents each
  • World of Hyatt — 1.5 cents each
  • Wyndham Rewards — 0.7 cents each

To keep things fairly simple, let’s look at the co-branded credit card(s) from each of the hotel groups that offers the highest return on hotel spending (keep in mind the main reason to get hotel credit cards could be for the elite status and free night certificates that they offer).

Choice Privileges

The Choice Privileges Select Mastercard offers 10x points on Choice spending, which I value at a return of 6%. This is quite good — it’s not quite as good as the rewards offered on the Chase Sapphire Reserve, by my valuation, but is otherwise very competitive.

I wouldn’t use Choice’s credit card for hotel spending

Hilton Honors

The Hilton Honors American Express Aspire Card (review) offers 14x points on Hilton spending, which I value at a return of 7%. This is excellent, and beats the return on spending offered by all transferable points cards.

The information and associated card details on this page for the Hilton Honors American Express Aspire Card has been collected independently by OMAAT and has not been reviewed or provided by the card issuer.

I use the Hilton Aspire Card for my Hilton hotel spending

IHG One Rewards

The IHG One Rewards Premier Credit Card (review) and IHG One Rewards Premier Business Credit Card (review) offer 10x points on IHG hotel spending, which I value at a return of 5%. This isn’t quite as good as the return on spending offered by some transferable points cards, though others may feel differently based on their valuation of points.

Earn bonus points for hotel spending with IHG’s credit cards

Marriott Bonvoy

The Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant® American Express® Card (review), Marriott Bonvoy Bevy® American Express® Card (review), and Marriott Bonvoy Business® American Express® Card (review), offer 6x points on Marriott hotel spending, which I value at a return of 4.2%. This isn’t as good as the return on spending offered by some transferable points cards.

That being said, some may wish to still use a Marriott co-branded credit card, since there aren’t many other ways to efficiently earn Bonvoy points. Furthermore, keep in mind that the Bonvoy Bevy Card offers 1,000 bonus points per eligible Marriott stay for cardmembers.

Earn bonus points on spending with Marriott’s credit cards

World of Hyatt

The World of Hyatt Credit Card (review) and World of Hyatt Business Credit Card (review) offer 4x points on Hyatt hotel spending, which I value at a return of 6%. While not quite as good as the return on spending offered by the Chase Sapphire Reserve, some may still wish to use on of these cards, due to the additional rewards of spending.

I use the World of Hyatt Card for my Hyatt hotel spending

Wyndham Rewards

The Wyndham Earner Business Card (review) offers 8x points on Wyndham hotel spending, which I value at a return of 5.6%. This is good, but not quite as good as the return offered by the Chase Sapphire Reserve.

I wouldn’t use Wyndham’s credit card for hotel spending

Crunching the numbers on hotel spending

Everyone will value points differently, and those with different points valuations may also come up with different conclusions. As you can see, based on my valuation:

What’s surprising is that co-branded hotel credit cards largely don’t offer a better return for stays at their “own” hotels than some of these cards do.

Based on my valuation of hotel points, I’d argue that Hilton Honors is the only program where it generally makes sense to use a co-branded credit card rather than a transferable points card. I can also see merit to doing this with World of Hyatt, given the additional perks for spending, but it’s not some slam dunk.

The information and associated card details on this page for the Hilton Honors American Express Aspire Card and American Express Green Card has been collected independently by OMAAT and has not been reviewed or provided by the card issuer.

Earn 14x points on Hilton stays with the Hilton Aspire Card

Other considerations with hotel spending

There are other potential considerations when deciding which card to use when staying at a hotel:

It could be worth earning a Hilton free night reward

Bottom line

In many cases, you’re actually not best off using a co-branded hotel card for your hotel spending, counterintuitive as it might be. Hilton and Hyatt have especially good co-branded hotel credit cards, where it can be worth spending money on their cards at hotels. Otherwise, you’re generally best off using a transferable points card for your hotel spending, with the Chase Sapphire Reserve nowadays being the most lucrative card.

What’s your go-to credit card for hotel spending?

The following links will direct you to the rates and fees for mentioned American Express Cards. These include: American Express® Green Card (Rates & Fees).

Conversations (7)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Kevin Guest

    In order for the comparison to be comprehensive, you would also have to evaluate the various free night certificates that come with the hotel cards, and the annual fees of the cards.

  2. Californiadreamer Guest

    Chase has a couple of Marriott cards, including the Marriott Bonvoy® Boundless Credit Card and the Marriott Bonvoy® Premier
    Plus Business Credit Card. Should they not be evaluated somewhere in the mix?

  3. Jetport Member

    Good a post overall, but I really would like a second "easy use" valuation for the transferrable points currencies for all points valuation articles. For those of us who don't plan to use our points to fly international business class with a secondary or middle eastern airline, transferrable points aren't worth nearly what OMAAT and other points sites claim they are. Maybe a "jump through hoops international business class" valuation and an "easy redeem valuation"...

    Good a post overall, but I really would like a second "easy use" valuation for the transferrable points currencies for all points valuation articles. For those of us who don't plan to use our points to fly international business class with a secondary or middle eastern airline, transferrable points aren't worth nearly what OMAAT and other points sites claim they are. Maybe a "jump through hoops international business class" valuation and an "easy redeem valuation" like simply using the points for their highest valuation with the issuer or transferring them for easy use like to hotel brands.

  4. Tony Guest

    My main quibble with your analysis is on the economics of using Hilton cobranded Aspire card at Hilton hotels. A Hilton point generally isn't worth 0.5 cents by a not-insignificant amount, so I'd say, other than at Hyatt hotels, none of the cobranded hotel cards is worth using, unless you need to accumulate hotel status points to reach your status level with the hotel chain.

  5. Eric Guest

    What drives your high valuation of ultimate rewards? I would say Hyatt is one of the most valuable transfer partners and both the chase sapphire reserve and Hyatt cards earn 4x

  6. NK3 Diamond

    Other options:
    Citi Custom Cash 5x. Based on the above valuation of 1.7 cents/point, this would be 8.5% return. The 5x earn is up to $500 per billing cycle, but front desk usually allows you to split payments. Also foreign transaction fees.
    Venture X and Citi Premier both offer 10x for hotels booked through their portal. Both have similar programs to FHR, though IME not as many options. With VX you can combine...

    Other options:
    Citi Custom Cash 5x. Based on the above valuation of 1.7 cents/point, this would be 8.5% return. The 5x earn is up to $500 per billing cycle, but front desk usually allows you to split payments. Also foreign transaction fees.
    Venture X and Citi Premier both offer 10x for hotels booked through their portal. Both have similar programs to FHR, though IME not as many options. With VX you can combine with the $300 annual credit. And Citi Premier has an annual benefit of $100 off of $500 spent on a hotel through the portal.

  7. Peter Guest

    If you have any status with AA and any credit card with AA, the AAdvantage Hotels portal can be a great deal. With the Citi AAdvantage Executive Card you earn 10x points (1x base/LP and 9x bonus) on the $ amount spent. Then each hotel offers its own set of additional miles, which are elevated offerings based on if you have any status or any credit card with AA. Sometimes portal pricing is way too...

    If you have any status with AA and any credit card with AA, the AAdvantage Hotels portal can be a great deal. With the Citi AAdvantage Executive Card you earn 10x points (1x base/LP and 9x bonus) on the $ amount spent. Then each hotel offers its own set of additional miles, which are elevated offerings based on if you have any status or any credit card with AA. Sometimes portal pricing is way too inflated and I'll book direct (not just an issue with AA's portal of course). Sometimes it's basically equivalent (or within, say, $10-20) and you can get a significant amount of additional AA base miles/LP. Plus you may get a 20% or 30% LP bonus if you have earned 60k or 100k LPs with AA in the last 6 months.

    Here's an example from an upcoming stay I have (rounded the #s) in a major European capital at a luxury hotel not associated with a major chain.

    Rate is ~$500 for flexible rate/breakfast included (was same price as if booking direct) + 10,000 base miles.

    So I get 5,000 miles from the AA Executive Card ($500x10) plus 10,000 extra base miles from the booking. I'm currently in the 20% LP bonus so I'll get 12,000 LPs (120% of the 10,000 base miles from the booking) plus an additional 500 LPs from the credit card spend (at $1/base mile/LP). All in that's 15,000 miles plus 12,500 LPs on a $500 booking.

    That's 30 miles per $, plus LPs. And they are AA miles which, yes, are not as flexible as MR or UR but are still valued by this site at 1.5 cpp or $225 in value. For purposes of this example, can value the LPs at $0 (although obviously valuable if chasing status).

    Let's say I booked the same through the Chase portal and got 8x points - that's 4,000 UR points or $68 in value. Or the Citi portal and got 10x points - that's 5,000 TY points or $85 in value. Doesn't come close, and that's without even considering AA status.

    Is every deal "this good"? Nope. And if you value staying with major chains (I do not) or perks with major chains (have status through credit cards, I don't value the perks at all), then AA Hotels may not be for you. But if you are a casual traveler staying ~15-20 nights a year in places where you want to stay and are not loyal to a major chain, the AA Hotels program can offer some incredible value.

Featured Comments Most helpful comments ( as chosen by the OMAAT community ).

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

NK3 Diamond

Other options: Citi Custom Cash 5x. Based on the above valuation of 1.7 cents/point, this would be 8.5% return. The 5x earn is up to $500 per billing cycle, but front desk usually allows you to split payments. Also foreign transaction fees. Venture X and Citi Premier both offer 10x for hotels booked through their portal. Both have similar programs to FHR, though IME not as many options. With VX you can combine with the $300 annual credit. And Citi Premier has an annual benefit of $100 off of $500 spent on a hotel through the portal.

1
Peter Guest

If you have any status with AA and any credit card with AA, the AAdvantage Hotels portal can be a great deal. With the Citi AAdvantage Executive Card you earn 10x points (1x base/LP and 9x bonus) on the $ amount spent. Then each hotel offers its own set of additional miles, which are elevated offerings based on if you have any status or any credit card with AA. Sometimes portal pricing is way too inflated and I'll book direct (not just an issue with AA's portal of course). Sometimes it's basically equivalent (or within, say, $10-20) and you can get a significant amount of additional AA base miles/LP. Plus you may get a 20% or 30% LP bonus if you have earned 60k or 100k LPs with AA in the last 6 months. Here's an example from an upcoming stay I have (rounded the #s) in a major European capital at a luxury hotel not associated with a major chain. Rate is ~$500 for flexible rate/breakfast included (was same price as if booking direct) + 10,000 base miles. So I get 5,000 miles from the AA Executive Card ($500x10) plus 10,000 extra base miles from the booking. I'm currently in the 20% LP bonus so I'll get 12,000 LPs (120% of the 10,000 base miles from the booking) plus an additional 500 LPs from the credit card spend (at $1/base mile/LP). All in that's 15,000 miles plus 12,500 LPs on a $500 booking. That's 30 miles per $, plus LPs. And they are AA miles which, yes, are not as flexible as MR or UR but are still valued by this site at 1.5 cpp or $225 in value. For purposes of this example, can value the LPs at $0 (although obviously valuable if chasing status). Let's say I booked the same through the Chase portal and got 8x points - that's 4,000 UR points or $68 in value. Or the Citi portal and got 10x points - that's 5,000 TY points or $85 in value. Doesn't come close, and that's without even considering AA status. Is every deal "this good"? Nope. And if you value staying with major chains (I do not) or perks with major chains (have status through credit cards, I don't value the perks at all), then AA Hotels may not be for you. But if you are a casual traveler staying ~15-20 nights a year in places where you want to stay and are not loyal to a major chain, the AA Hotels program can offer some incredible value.

1
Kevin Guest

In order for the comparison to be comprehensive, you would also have to evaluate the various free night certificates that come with the hotel cards, and the annual fees of the cards.

0
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,527,136 Miles Traveled

39,914,500 Words Written

42,354 Posts Published

Keep Exploring OMAAT