The FAA, Boeing, And US Airlines Are Starting To Look Ridiculous

Just over 48 hours ago a Boeing 737 MAX crashed in Ethiopia, making it the second of the aircraft type to crash in a few months. We don’t know exactly what happened, though we know there are similarities between the two crashes, and we also know that some software updates will be released soon, later than initially promised.

There are nearly 400 Boeing 737 MAX aircraft, operated by nearly 60 airlines. Over the past 48 hours we’ve seen country after country ground them, and we’ve also seen many airlines voluntarily ground them.

At this point every major Boeing 737 MAX operator outside of North America has grounded these planes, either voluntarily or by request from the government. Every. Single. One.

Yet none of the US or Canadian operators of the plane — American, Southwest, United, Air Canada, and WestJet — have grounded their planes, voluntarily or involuntarily (it’s debatable whether United should or not, given that they operate the -9, and the -8 was involved in both accidents).

The airlines that have grounded their planes presumably haven’t taken the decision lightly, as it’s going to be very costly. They haven’t done this because they absolutely know something is wrong with the plane. Rather, they’ve grounded the 737 MAX because they don’t absolutely know that something isn’t wrong with the plane.

Modern aviation is so incredibly safe, so to see two of the same types of new planes crash so close together should be concerning, if nothing else.

But at some point doesn’t the US (and to a lesser extent, Canada) come out of this looking ridiculous? Boeing is standing behind their plane. The FAA is standing behind Boeing. American and Canadian airlines are standing behind the plane. It’s the US and Canada against the world, it seems.

Are they actually 100% certain that there’s nothing systematically wrong with the 737 MAX, including the way pilots are trained to fly it? Do they think the concerns of every other relevant aviation authority in the world are unfounded? If they even have the slightest concern about the integrity of the plane, shouldn’t they put lives ahead of profits?

Even if they stand behind the plane, I’d be willing to bet that public opinion will otherwise cause these planes to be grounded.

Just look at the news, it’s constantly being talked about.

Just look at the Twitter timelines of these airlines, and you’ll see that almost every single question is from people asking if they’re scheduled to fly a 737 MAX, and if they can change flights.

Just go to an airport. I’ve heard a countless number of reports today of people at airports overhearing questions about whether they’re flying one of those “bad planes.”

The US FAA has long been the gold standard for aviation safety, and has been the organization that others have followed. How much credibility do they lose when dozens of other authorities temporarily ground the plane, and they do nothing?

I also don’t understand how US airlines think they’re going to win in this situation. Unions at American and Southwest are calling for the planes to be grounded.

This isn’t just going to fade away, and in my opinion the longer US airlines and/or the FAA wait, the worse they look in all of this. I’d say American looks especially bad here — at least Southwest is letting people rebook onto different planes, while American isn’t.

What do you guys think — do you think US/Canadian airlines and the FAA will eventually be forced to change their tune here, or do you think they’re sticking to their guns?

Conversations (141)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Ken phillips Guest

The FAA does not belong in federal government. It is an industry trade association at best. Completely owned by industry, shown time and time again at the cost of human lives. Eliminate FAA, give regulation to NTSB for safety and EPA (to develop sound and pollution limits on the hell that Americans on the ground are paying for all of you jet setters to have your NextGen superhighways). The defense industry, Boeing in particular, is too powerful and needs to be broken up. They should not be running government agencies, it's ultimately to the destruction of American freedom and civil rights.

0
‼ 0
Eskimo Guest

After almost a month, preliminary report points to MCAS. To all those idiots who stood by Boeing and FAA thinking that grounding is overreacting, shame on you. Shame of WN, AA, UA, you really put profit before people, even your own pilots and crew. Shame on FAA, you completely lost the public trust. Tip hat to CAA in China for being proactive and put safety first. Funny how I now trust Chinese carriers more than US carriers (if DL had them, they would still fly them).

0
‼ 0
Aaron Guest

It may not be just a software fix to resolve the issue. From what I read, MCAS is used because the aircraft is inherently unstable due to the new engine on the old airframe changing the center of gravity. So, would you take the aircraft when a "fix" is issued, assumming there are completely no bugs in the fix and all situations are taken into account...

0
‼ 0
Theo V Guest

Interesting to see all commenters died after POTUS called Boeing CEO and ordered immediate grounding. Sorry folks, but safety has and will always have to come first when it comes to public transportation. 787 was grounded, problem was fixed and the bird has had how many tens of thousands of flights without an incident since? Sensible minds prevailed, with 43 countries taking the lead in safety over USA and Canada, and now let's leave corporate beancounters in Chicago to let their own engineers to find a fix which was for one or another reason hidden from the training manual. I'm 100% sure the fix will be found and that MAX 8 and 9 will be in service for decades to come. Sadly, that safety will be achieved on the account of 349 people that died when 371 planes were flying in the air (371 minus JT610 and ET302). May their souls rest in peace.

0
‼ 0
RH Quan Guest

Just because a bunch of third world countries grounded their aircrafts doesn't mean the US is required to follow suit

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published