As I wrote about yesterday, Japan Airlines Mileage Bank has made a terrible change to their program when it comes to redeeming miles on Emirates. Up until last week the best way to redeem miles for travel in Emirates first class was through Japan Airlines Mileage Bank, as they have a distance based award chart that’s quite lucrative.
While the redemption rates haven’t changed, they made a major change to the value you’ll get out of your redemptions. Specifically, as of November 22, 2017, Japan Airlines Mileage Bank adds carrier imposed surcharges to Emirates award tickets originating in the US. We’re not talking mild surcharges, but rather a roundtrip first class ticket from the US to Dubai would cost you $1,600 more than it did a week ago.
That’s awful, though unfortunately in many ways Mileage Bank may still be the best program for booking Emirates first class awards, since there’s not another program with comparable redemption rates.
Live and Let’s Fly correctly points out that there’s a way to avoid the carrier imposed surcharges. Basically the carrier imposed surcharges for Mileage Bank awards on Emirates reflect exactly what Emirates would charge on a revenue ticket. Carrier imposed surcharges are highly dependent on the market in which you’re originating, which is nothing new.
Emirates first class mezze service
So while you’ll be charged these surcharges out of the US, you won’t be charged them out of all other markets.
For example, you could fly one-way or roundtrip from Hong Kong to New York and not pay any surcharges:
Or you could fly from Sydney to New York and not pay any surcharges:
Or you could fly from Colombo to New York and not pay any surcharges:
Or you could fly from Tokyo to New York and pay just $154.20 in surcharges:
Sure, there’s potentially some value there, but ultimately the single most important aspect of a redemption is that it gets you where you need to go, and that benefit is largely lost with the above if you’re based in the US.
I should note that it could make sense to now make a Mileage Bank one-way booking from somewhere else to the US as you often wouldn’t pay those surcharges. However, the way I see it you lose quite a bit of value in the process. For example, an award covering a distance of up to 10,000 miles would cost you 105,000 miles, while an award covering up to 20,000 miles would cost you 155,000 miles.
Let’s say you wanted to fly from New York to Colombo and back. You could redeem 105,000 miles for the one-way ticket to New York in first class and not pay any surcharges, or you could pay an extra 50,000 miles plus pay the surcharges and get it roundtrip. Perhaps it’s now a better deal to book just a one-way, though this certainly doesn’t allow the level of award ticket maximization that was previously possible.
This is still a shame, though I do think it makes sense to clarify that you can still redeem Japan Airlines miles on Emirates without paying surcharges… it just won’t necessarily be where you’re looking to come from and go.
Since US-based people have like thousands of times more chances to accumulate miles than those living in the rest of the world, I think they can live with that.
Oh lucky, you always whine when a company close up your loopholes. There's a reason why they do that. Its smart business to keep people like you from ripping them off.
That's great news, then! All non-US residents have to do now is just to preposition themselves outside the US.
Meanwhile the rest of us from Asia give out a sigh of great relief.
Is there a surcharge for Milan to JFK?
@schar - most EK F tickets are sub 7k
too much of a hassle, why would i wanna originate in another place to "come back"to the US and have an extra leg open?
Easier to suck it up and pay the $1600, which is penny change compared to the full price of a First Class Emirates ticket 20K-30K
@Airways and Travels
I'm based in Amman so while this is a devaluation it's not as bad as those in the US. About $800 for the YQ EK for biz round trip from there to the west coast. $800 more than before but 80k SPG + $800 for round trip business with one short stop on a great product still seems like the best option for people based in the middle east looking to travel back and forth to the US in biz.
On r/t tickets originating in an area with no YQ EK does not collect fuel surcharge on either direction. Would that be different for r/t award tickets?
Ben - Isn't the problem here that Emirates is charging JAL the fuel surcharge who is passing it on to the customer? If that's the case, it's really Emirates who I would be pissed at.
I tend to book awards one way coming back home anyway. This way I can utilize my SWUs on the outbound, especially since AA flights one way to Asia are usually cheap.
Another option is to book your outbound on another airline/currency. Then fly EK on the return.