Yesterday afternoon I flew American Airlines first class from New York to Miami. I had the unthinkable luxury (well, at least on US airlines) of an empty seat next to me, though it came at the expense of someone else’s upgrade. This is the first time that I’ve personally witnessed something like this on American, so it’s certainly an isolated incident…
An empty seat next to me in American first class
American offers unlimited complimentary upgrades to elite members within the United States, along with in select other markets. As a result, it’s exceedingly rare to find an empty seat in domestic first class, since it would mean that there aren’t any elite members in economy.
I don’t remember the last time I’ve seen an empty seat in first class on a mainline domestic American jet. Perhaps a few times I’ve been on a regional jet during a very off peak period where there were some empty seats, but that’s still rare.
Anyway, yesterday I was flying from New York to Miami on a 737-800. As boarding wrapped up, the seat next to me was still empty. Okay, presumably there was someone who booked this seat but then didn’t show up. In this situations it’s typically policy that the gate agent will come onboard and upgrade the next person on the upgrade list who is seated in economy. I find that American is quite consistent about this, and it’s rare for gate agents to not follow policy.
To my surprise, on this flight the door closed, but that seat stayed empty.

Why didn’t American clear the upgrade list?
On this flight there were passengers on the upgrade waitlist who hadn’t cleared, so the lack of a person being cleared wasn’t because there was no one eligible for the upgrade.
Now, the upgrade list was one of the more unusual ones to begin with, given that number three and number nine on the list cleared. I’m not sure what exactly happened here. Did number one and two on the list reject the upgrade? Did numbers four through eight reject the upgrades, or was number nine just not correctly linked to number three?

I think the next logical question is whether the first class seat next to me was left empty due to laziness on the part of gate agents, or was there another explanation? There’s only one possible (excusable) explanation I can come up with for why the upgrade wasn’t cleared. Even before the flight left, it was showing an on-time departure but an arrival 18 minutes behind schedule, presumably due to a longer than usual flight time.

For gate agents, the number one priority is getting a flight out on-time, so perhaps there was pressure to get out this flight as soon as possible, especially with the anticipated arrival delay.
For what it’s worth, I confirmed with the crew that the seat wasn’t inoperative, so that’s not the reason it stayed empty.
Someone tried to self-upgrade during the flight
At roughly the halfway point of the flight, someone came up to the row I was seated in and said to me “do you mind if I sit here?” I responded “I don’t mind, but you might have to take it up with the crew.” After all, I didn’t pay for the extra seat, so it’s not really my business.
So he took a seat there and then started reading a book. I’d say within about 30 seconds, the friendly first class flight attendant showed up, and the conversation went something like this:
Flight attendant: “Sir, what’s your original seat?”
Passenger: “I was in 17D, but there’s someone in my seat, so I need a different one.”
Flight attendant: “Sorry, there’s someone in your seat now?”
Passenger: “Well, the guy next to me is spilling over into my seat, he’s very large, it’s really not comfortable.”
Flight attendant: “I’m sorry, I can’t have you sitting here. But if you’d like, I can try to find you another seat in economy.”
Suddenly he was very happy with returning to his exit row aisle seat, and didn’t need her assistance to move anymore.
Bottom line
I had an empty seat next to me in American first class yesterday, even though there were passengers on the upgrade list. American usually does a good job with clearing the upgrade list per the company’s policy, and I don’t remember the last time that I’ve witnessed something like this.
It was a weird flight when it came to upgrades, between the order in which upgrades were cleared, as well as a first class seat staying open.
Have you ever seen an American gate agent not clear upgrades when there were no shows?
Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.