Dear Hotels: Stop With Your Currency Conversion Scams

“Would you like to pay in [local currency] or US Dollars?”

It’s a question virtually anyone with a US-issued credit card has been asked when checking out of a hotel abroad.

When you’re using your credit card abroad, you should always pay in the local currency. Always. I don’t even know why hotels offer the option of paying in another currency, since there’s zero upside to paying in USD. Why?

  • Many credit cards have no foreign transaction fees nowadays, which usually use a market conversion rate (or very close to market)
  • For cards with foreign transaction fees, you’ll typically still be charged the foreign transaction fees for things billed in USD outside the US (because it’s about where the purchase is processed and not necessarily the currency in which it was processed)
  • The currency conversion rates hotels use are terrible

So while I’d love to see hotels suggest guests pay in local currency (since a lot of people don’t realize they’re better off paying in local currency than USD), I’m happy when they at least give the option of which currency to pay in, which they almost always do (and should).

But not yesterday when checking out of the Hilton Queenstown. I was given my bill, which showed everything in NZD. The total was 1,163NZD, and when I signed the credit card slip I noticed he had billed me in USD — the total was 806.96USD. The slip even said the rate included a commission of 2.05%.

Currency-Conversion-Scam-2

So just how far off was the currency conversion? Using today’s exchange rates, 1,163NZD should be 762.57USD.

Currency-Conversion-Scam-1

Instead I was charged 806.96USD — that means I was overcharged by $44.39, or 5.8%.

I called the associate out on it and asked why he didn’t give me the option of paying in NZD. He said “oh, they train us to just charge in the currency of the card.” I explained to him that not only does that translate to a terrible conversion rate, but the receipt even said there was a further 2.05% fee. His response was “are you sure?”

Unfortunately I was in a rush to catch my flight, since there was one person working at reception on a Monday morning after the hotel was sold out for the entire weekend, and I had to queue for 20 minutes before I was helped. I also didn’t want to delay the people behind me. I’ll be following up with the hotel, though, on principle, and ask them why they’re training their employees this way.

Hilton-Queenstown

To the major hotel chains: I really wish this is an issue you’d tackle globally. I stay with hotels like Hilton, Hyatt, Starwood, etc., because I expect they train certain standards globally to avoid scams. Sure, some major hotels have hidden/ridiculous resort fees, etc., but would it be too much to ask that the major hotel chains train their individual hotels about this “scam,” because it’s costing guests a lot of money?

Anyone else face these currency conversion scams at hotels?

Conversations (64)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Virginia Guest

My experience in Haiti hotels and restaurants is to do the math. These places make up their personal exchange so that the customer loses whether they pay in local currency or Haitian goudes. Example: My hotel restaurant bill lists both local and USD but... they used 75goudes per usd(rate is 71g/usd) so the local amount is too high. Basically in this case if you donot pay with usd you are charged too much. They will bill Visa in goude amount based on their higher personal rate and still make more when Visa uses the 71g/usd rate. Total scam...

0
‼ 0
Anthony Guest

I am being forced by MEPS to pay a 4.99% markup on my credit card to convert to USD. The cashiers say the machines do it automatically, which it does, because I watch them use the machine. 2/3 of merchant it lets me choose between USD and JOD, but 1/3 of merchants just goes straight to USD with the 4.99% markup. On the receipt, it even says I "have been offered a choice to may in my currency..." but it's a lie... there's no choice. Where is the class action lawsuit again the credit card companies?

0
‼ 0
Jim Guest

They train their employees that way because it's more profitable for them. They get part of the commission and the acquirer gets the rest. Win-win for all parties involved except the customer.

0
‼ 0
dwonderment Guest

This hits a sensitive nerve with me as this is nothing more than additional profit center for hotels that prey on unsuspecting guests. I stopped staying at the Hilton South Wharf in Melbourne,Australia over the practice years ago and I actually liked the hotel. The first time I accepted their office management apologies about the confusion of the agents not asking me what currency I want to be billed in. Of course they billed me in American dollars ka ching! The receipt said I authorized it and it is a final sale/transaction! Lie Lie Lie The second time I froze the charges on American Express and my stay was refunded by American Express and I never returned to the hotel in principal Hilton seems to be heavy into the scamming and it has damaged their reputation as has the credit card surcharge fee I look at Hilton as evil and avoid them now. They helped start the cancer and now its spread to some of the other hotel brands properties and even restaurants!. There is a huge price to be paid for dodgy business practices and they know damn well what they are up to! Its time to get main stream media involved in the fraud Bottom like unless you are pro active they will rarely ask you how you want to be billed but simply bill as to what gives them the best kickback Let the educated traveler beware its a corporate entity picking pockets like a thieves in the street Shame on all of them ! Hilton Pickpocket International

0
‼ 0
chris Guest

Dear Brian, I thought best to respond one by one. 1. Yes or No. Does your hotel permit guests to choose to pay in NZ Dollars on their foreign credit cards? Yes a guest can pay in NZ dollars or local currency. It is their choice. They must select a button on the machine to chose which currency they would like to pay. 2. Yes or No. Do you understand that if you force guests to pay in their home currency on their credit cards you are forcing them to pay a higher exchange rate and commissions than they would otherwise pay? We do not force the customer to pay in NZ dollars or their local currency. The choice is yours. You must select it at the time of transaction 3. Yes or No. Do you understand that not giving guests a choice on dynamic currency conversion is a breach of your agreement with the credit card issuer? We do not force the customer to pay in NZ dollars or their local currency. The choice is yours. You must select it at the time of transaction I hope that clarifies your concerns. I am also a traveller and recently bought some items at the airport duty free and had the same options provided when I paid. It was my choice if I wanted to pay in the local currency of that country or if I wanted to select to pay in my local currently, NZ dollars so that when I got the receipt it stated an exact amount that I would then see on my bank statement at home. Russell, I appreciate you asking to get the correct information before reaching a decision, I trust you would agree by giving a customer the control of the decision, we are providing them options of what they prefer. We do hope to have the opportunity to host you during your visit to Queenstown. Kind regards Chris

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published