United Airlines' JF...
 

United Airlines' JFK Return Is Imminent: What's The Strategy, Though?

50 Posts
20 Users
3 Reactions
780 Views
Posts: 41111
Admin
Topic starter
(@lucky)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago
[#20492]
wpf-cross-image

United says it's on track to return to JFK in 2027, but between slot uncertainty, a crowded transcon market, and Delta's ground product, the strategy still isn't clear.


49 Replies
Posts: 513
Diamond
(@peter_)
Member
Joined: 10 months ago

The real question is whether BlueSky is providing sufficient value to B6 and/or how much UA is proposing to give B6 for the slots. I'm sure the lawyers for the bondholders are already complaining to the company about potentially giving UA any slots (although absent a covenant breach, it will just remain as complaining).


Reply
2 Replies
Diamond
(@1990_)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 1960

Ah, true, lawyers do be lawyerin’…but, the real, real question is slots and gates, specifically at that new Terminal 6… which along with the new Terminal 1 (both delayed. Regardless, ‘I’m jacked. Jacked to the ti…’ —The Big Short.)


Reply
Diamond
(@peter_)
Joined: 10 months ago

Member
Posts: 513

I saw Air India announced yesterday they too will move to T6 in 2028. So there's a T4 lounge up for grabs I suppose.


Reply
Posts: 83
Platinum
(@splane21)
Member
Joined: 5 years ago

Maybe they won’t have loyalty in JFK but what about the United loyalists in SFO and LAX who need to fly to JFK. They are two separate markets. Additionally I’m sure there are United loyalists in Manhattan that would fly from EWR or JFK to help fill flights


Reply
1 Reply
(@Jason)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 1377

SFO and lax loyalty will largely fill the flights. Plus there are enough people in the NYC region who have UA accounts for whom jfk flights will be convenient that this should be fine. Anything beyond lax or sfo I have a hard time seeing how they would work. All of United's other hubs are served well from
Lga and ewr. So it'll be interesting.


Reply
Posts: 206
(@shoeguy)
Joined: 7 years ago

Hi Lucky,

By the time UA exited JFK in 2015, the "ps" service was aboard two-class cabin aircraft featuring what was then United's pre-Polaris business class cabin, the bones of which remain on the 757-200s still flying with UA, and Economy (with several rows of extra legroom seats).

The original ps format was First Class, Business Class, with that extraordinary row 9 at the exits which had unlimited legroom, and the back of the aircraft (Economy) was all Economy Plus (extra legroom).


Reply
2 Replies
Diamond
(@benjaminkohl)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 142

None of UAs current 757s still have those bones - all of the PMUA 757s (including the p.s. planes) were retired in 2020. All of the 757s UA flies now are PMCO planes with the rolls royce engines


Reply
(@shoeguy)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 206

The legacy UA 752s are all gone and were retired a while back. The 757s (-200s and -300s) left in the UA fleet today are all legacy CO aircraft. PS for a time transitioned to ex-CO aircraft refitted with the updated interiors in the few years before UA withdrew from JFK.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 7773
Diamond
(@tim-dunn)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

you can be certain that UA execs will keep saying they have a plan to re-enter JFK - until 2027 passes and they aren't there.

no rational person can explain why B6 would transfer slots to UA so that UA can compete on B6' best routes - perhaps the only ones that make money,
and AA and DL have zero reason to give UA an inch - and DL has already shown its hand in scheduling EWR-LAX which will certainly be the first of far more routes that DL can start.
none of the big 4 are willing to give up anything. Adding anything has to be part of a strategy that is so much bigger than a single airport and also where there is no way that the "attacked carrier" can respond.
That is exactly the strategy behind DL's TPAC and west coast expansion. DL is much healthier financially than UA, has larger, far more efficient and capable aircraft, and has non-airline advantages including Amex and the refinery which UA simply can't match.

There is no way that UA can succeed at re-entering JFK without paying a far higher price from both AA and DL -and probably B6 - than UA can gain.

but let's also be clear that Kirby has promised and tried alot and failed at even more - including and esp. EWR and ORD


Reply
8 Replies
 NJG
(@NJG)
Joined: 3 weeks ago

Posts: 1

The plan was to return to JFK for the S27 schedule, but two things are working against it: XLR and "Coastliner" delivery delays (what airplanes is Delta deploying in that market that are "far" more efficient than than the 321neo?) and gates in T6.

UA is about a dozen or more short on XLR/Coastliner deliveries as compared to what they expected about a year ago. XLRs for the rework delays and the Coastliners for a major paint defect and associated warranty work. Without those airplanes they will not go into JFK. In the meantime the slots UA is acquiring from JetBlue and other airlines (there are more) will continue to be operated by the existing carriers.

The first phase of T6 is allocated to the T1 and T7 carriers that need to move out so the existing buildings can be decommissioned. UA will follow.

No doubt Delta will continue to retaliate. For now United is really the only compettior in its weight class.


Reply
 Jack
(@Jack)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 75

To paraphrase Ronald Reagan, “The nine most terrifying words in the English language are: 'I'm a management consultant, and I'm here to help.'” See also McKinsey’s vaunted Hunter strategy for Swissair.


Reply
 Jack
(@Jack)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 75

Ugh, posted under wrong comment


Reply
 Mark
(@Mark)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 488

So DL can add two domestically-configured flights against premium UA product LAX-EWR, but UA can’t enter JFK transcon markets with a true premium product with approximately 10 flights a day?

UA is the largest carrier in NYC by passengers, and with the most NYC passenger revenue, the largest carrier in the Bay Area, and a large carrier in LAX and Southern California in general. I don’t think you need to worry about UA.

And you’re saying Kirby has had more failures than successes? You lose even more credibility when you make statements like that.

One, as Kirby himself has said many times, if you don’t make any mistakes you’re not trying hard enough. And two, DL is one that has cut 12 routes out of NYC as they faller further behind there and fly a large number of substandard 767s on a large number of premium routes.

Your concern is misplaced.


Reply
Diamond
(@tim-dunn)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 7773

Mark,
it is precisely UA's size in NYC (including EWR) but its lack of size at JFK that is the problem.

You and even UA execs can't grasp why B6 would choose NOT to give up any of its JFK slots to a carry that is going to start service - without a JV - on B6' highest profit routes.

and the argument that AA can't make it at ORD is beyond laughable given that UA would be the 4th largest airline at JFK.

post covid, Kirby has been swinging for the fences and missing whether you want to admit it or not. Pre-covid and post covid strategy is very different.

And DL has only begun to warm up w/ what it will add if UA enters JFK; AA will do the same.
UA is simply not in a position to win a contest w/ its two biggest competitors - and they BOTH will be working to ensure UA's failure.

Sometimes the smartest thing to do is realize what you have achieved and be satisfied w/ it rather than shooting for something that you are certain to fail at.


Reply
 Mark
(@Mark)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 488

UA has been “swinging for the fences and missing” since COVID? Huh?

Just in the last quarter, UA pax revenue grew faster than DL’s (18% vs 15%) while DL’s costs grew faster, resulting in the second quarter this year where UA has been more profitable than DL. Especially impressive considering DL’s temporary fuel advantage and temporary advantage with the AMEX revenue agreement.

Kirby placed a huge bet with one of the largest aircraft orders in aviation history during the depths of the pandemic and during the MAX grounding, getting unbeatable pricing, especially considering the prices DL paid for the smaller orders placed years later.

Now UA is set up with a huge structural advantage into the next decade, leaving DL scrambling to add TPAC routes that drag down overall performance and that have to be funded by capacity cuts in NYC.

DL is the one that made the wrong bets earlier in the decade and they’re now paying the price as UA moves ahead with all the momentum they have.


Reply
 Jack
(@Jack)
Joined: 3 weeks ago

Posts: 1

I’m just here to read, but can this Tim guy please give it a rest? Delta rocks. It’s the greatest airline in the fucking galaxy. We get it. You can go now.


Reply
Diamond
(@tim-dunn)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 7773

it is not simply that "DL rocks and everyone else sucks"

It is the hypocrisy of UA and its fanbois saying
1. AA can' win at ORD because it is so much smaller but UA can win at JFK as the 4th largest of 4.
2. B6 is going to give "us" UA slots and let us grow in their most profitable markets
3. "we" UA are the largest airline in NYC but the feds and competitors should let us grow w/o limit at JFK because EWR isn't part of NYC even though we incessant brag that UA is the largest airline in NYC.

To use the words of one of the simpletons, "make it make sense"


Reply
Posts: 58
Platinum
(@747-400)
Member
Joined: 3 years ago

I am a management consultant who worked on the project ("Revenue Squared") that recommended abandoning JFK and focusing premium transcon flying on EWR (among many other initiatives). It was a good recommendation, and I completely agree with Ben that their return still doesn't make sense.

They have no flow traffic there and are at a major disadvantage compared to AA, DL, and B6 on these hyper competitive transcon routes. Their loyal flyers are all at EWR, so I guess they are targeting the SFO/LAX-origin passengers headed to New York, who Kirby believes prefer JFK over EWR, because it is more prestigious (or something?). I just have a hard time believing that there are that many people who care much about JFK over EWR, particularly since it is a longer drive from the places in Manhattan where most of the high-yielding pax are going.


Reply
7 Replies
 JB
(@JB)
Joined: 8 years ago

Posts: 859

You'd be surprised at how many people prefer JFK rather than EWR when flying to NYC, mostly because of prestige or they think that JFK is more convenient (despite that not necessarily being the case). I agree with your points, and I too was skeptical at how many people this could apply to. Having lived in NYC and frequently traveling there, I know that EWR isn't too far away.

But I know so many people who fit in this basket, many of whom are wealthy fliers or fly for business into NYC (some of whom are even locals). Many of the people I know fly in premium cabins, yet they won't even consider looking for flights out of EWR. This doesn't apply to everyone, but it does apply to more people than you would think. The general population just doesn't know that much about airlines.


Reply
Diamond
(@rebel)
Joined: 1 year ago

Member
Posts: 862

"I am a management consultant who worked on the project ("Revenue Squared") that recommended abandoning JFK and focusing premium transcon flying on EWR (among many other initiatives). It was a good recommendation, and I completely agree with Ben that their return still doesn't make sense."

You might not want to brag about such a blatant & costly mistake. That decision cost UA lucrative, exclusive corporate travel deals. Were you not aware that many of those high-yield customers were heading to the Hamptons? Ever try to drive from EWR to the Hamptons?

Flows? Your research didn't demonstrate that NYC feeds itself? Let me guess you worked for BCG the same gang that recommended de-hubbing IAD, DEN and/or LAX. Pure genius. Thank heavens BCG and their UA CCO were shown the door six months after Kirby and his team came to UA.


Reply
 snic
Diamond
(@snic)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 1119

There's an enormous part of the NYC metro area that is simply not served well by EWR: all of Long Island, Westchester County, and southern Connecticut (including the financial hub of Stamford). The slog to get to EWR from those areas is long, constantly full of traffic jams, and very expensive (distance and bridge tolls). It's just insanity to say that EWR and JFK are equal, even for travelers from the west coast. Not all of them are going to Manhattan. And don't forget that there are plenty of people who live in those regions who would fly UA if they had the opportunity, but who simply will not schlep out to EWR if they can avoid it. And they can, by not flying UA.


Reply
(@pointsandmilesdoc)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 76

As someone based at LAX who frequently flies to Manhattan for leisure, I choose whichever airport is the least expensive, and it's frequently EWR. Honestly do not care which one I fly into or out of.


Reply
(@mwsulliv)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 2

Clearly this "management consultant" is not an NYC resident -- some of the wealthiest, most populated parts of the region (i.e. the "premium passengers" they cited) are on Long Island (the Hamptons, Great Neck, etc.) with a population of 8 million. Additionally, Brooklyn has 2.7 million residents (vs. Manhattan's 1.6 million), in some of NYC's most expensive neighborhoods (Cobble Hill, Park Slope, Williamsburg, Greenpoint).

No self-respecting New Yorker from Long Island or Brooklyn is schlepping across two rivers to EWR. United effectively forfeited this entire market of 10.7 million people when it pulled out of JFK.


Reply
Diamond
(@peter_)
Joined: 10 months ago

Member
Posts: 513

Yep. This is the correct take.


Reply
Gold
(@chrisnyc)
Joined: 1 year ago

Member
Posts: 34

The main problem with EWR is that it is hard to get to/from by train (irregular service from Manhattan, JFK has two subway stations plus the frequent LIRR to Penn and Grand Central). And at certain times of day, you specifically want to take a train to/from JFK or EWR since the taxi will take much longer. I once got out of a taxi en route to EWR since the traffic into the tunnel was horrendous and I would have missed my flight (went to Penn Station and just barely made my flight). That is why I prefer JFK.


Reply
Posts: 26
(@Pedro)
Joined: 3 years ago

But what about the poor baggage handling metrics?


Reply
Posts: 1480
(@George Romey)
Joined: 6 years ago

Years ago UA had LHR, ORD, SEA, SFO, LAX, IAD, MIA (as a tag to SA) that I remember. Probably more beyond that-I seem to remember SJC. I would imagine transcons to LAX and SFO (maybe SAN or SNA) and LHR. Possible SEA and other major European cities.


Reply
3 Replies
(@Jason)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 1377

United's peak was around 2000/2001. 3x flights to lhr, 6 or 7 each to lax and sfo, São Paulo/ Rio, Caracas, Tokyo, Buenos Aires, Boston, Seattle, and United express to Boston, Philadelphia, and Baltimore, and multiple flights to Dulles. with multiple frequencies. Occasional weekend service to San Juan and chicago. In 2001 for a hot second nonstop to Hong Kong, which was very empty and discontinued after 9/11. A flight to Miami came along after 9/11 when they discontinued the nonstops yo São Paulo and Rio. That was it. Never more than 30-35 flights or so. Hardly the behemoth people like to talk about. By the time they pulled out in 2015 it was 6 flights a day to lax and sfo. That was it.


Reply
 JB
(@JB)
Joined: 8 years ago

Posts: 859

I flew United Express from JFK to JAX (Jacksonville, FL) nonstop back in 2011. The flight was operated by a turboprop.

I was originally supposed to fly B6 (connecting off an EK flight, booked through EK), but was rebooked onto UA by EK as my original flight got cancelled.


Reply
(@Jason)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 1377

A turboprop could not make it, physically, that distance. That did not happen. Also I worked at United in the group that decides where the airline flew. I can definitively tell you that United offered no such flight. Not in 2011. Not ever


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 3
 NYCG
(@NYCG)
Joined: 4 years ago

United will be investing in the ground experience at JFK T6 (United Club, Polaris Lounge), book it. It will not be going back into JFK half-cocked.


Reply
6 Replies
Diamond
(@maxpower)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 1367

they seem to be a little behind on all their (book it) T6 lounges if they're starting routes in 2027?


Reply
Diamond
(@parnel)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 173

The nightmare of JFK is connections, United has NONE, so it's just point to point flyers 😔.
Also EWR has been heavily invested in, and it's got an awesome on time performance, something that won't happen at JFK.
Just put those coastliners into EWR and customers will come 👍


Reply
Diamond
(@maxpower)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 1367

United's connections aren't in JFK though they could connect with a few star partners. The connections, as noted, are on the west coast for flyers that prefer JFK over EWR.

But again, this isn't about connections. LAX/SFO-JFK has more than enough local demand. JFK connections aren't really worth much as evidenced by Delta's inability to keep a lot of their big dot to JFK connections alive.


Reply
(@yoloswag420)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 932

If people are connecting, why would United want to route them via JFK instead of EWR?

At JFK, would be basically nothing that they couldn't already better serve from EWR.


Reply
(@Jason)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 1377

It's mostly about people going between NYC and SF/LA. Some onward traffic to Hawaii, Australia, Asia, and some smaller western points. It's not at all about people making connections at JFK


Reply
 snic
Diamond
(@snic)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 1119

Where are they getting the slots?


Reply
Posts: 28
(@cbchicago)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Cash strapped Jet Blue will be selling JFK slots to raise capital. OMAAT post about United are all hearsay and rehash. United will be just fine on whatever they do.


Reply
Posts: 144
(@brianna-hoffner)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

I hope they do it. JFK is so much easier and cheaper to get to for lots of people. The AirTrain-NJT-Subway option for Newark means a 3 seat ride on public transport is the default; whereas for JFK it's 2. Uber and Lyft fares from lower Manhattan are almost always $30 higher for EWR vs JFK.

More importantly, will the fresh baked cookie of my PS dreams be making a comeback?


Reply
Posts: 34
Gold
(@chrisnyc)
Member
Joined: 1 year ago

Kind of cool seeing a UA Airbus with a German flag and registration -- I gather pre-delivery? Is the airport Hamburg Finkenwerder?


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 1048
Diamond
(@stanley-c)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

I totally agree with Kirby for sure that pulling out of JFK was a blunder by United. As Ben has pointed out before whatever the reason may be but being able to operate flights at New York JFK is prestigious. Newark airport is more or less just convenient for those on the west side of Manhattan. Had a conversation with someone about this back when Continental was still around. That Continental fanboy loved Newark and how New Yorkers prefer to go to Newark airport instead because JFK airport was shabby in comparison.


Reply
Posts: 15
 R2ro
(@r2ro)
Member
Joined: 4 months ago

Also, United clearly didn't understand the huge psychological barrier of crossing two rivers for anyone in Brooklyn or Queens or the rest of the Long Island. Sure, EWR/JFK/LGA are in the same market generally speaking but this is a huge market and the nuances matter.


Reply
1 Reply
 Ross
(@Ross)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 585

But then, there's the sophistication from knowing it's really an estuary.


Reply
Posts: 585
 Ross
(@Ross)
Joined: 12 years ago

Makes me want to become an airline dilettante so I know what p.s. means. Thought it might be "pretty sh****y," especially when 757 was mentioned, but maybe not. I think of JFK as a place to connect to Europe, so why would I want to use United when it's the eastern end of their network? The suggestion is that people who are already there, want to connect at LAX or SFO for flights to Asia. Like, where in Asia must you stop in California, because no nonstop is available from JFK?


Reply
Posts: 30
(@sushicat)
Member
Joined: 2 months ago

UA will win. UA will lose. Who knows and who cares, 555! What matters is if I win. Will UA at JFK mean lower fares, better products and services for me? I haven't seen any analysis from that most-important standpoint. More competition is generally good, but we are talking about an oligopoly.


Reply
4 Replies
Diamond
(@stanley-c)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 1048

@Sushicat This is why it matters. If UA pulls out of the market then it means less competition and a continuation of higher fares with crappy service and soft products. If there is more competition, then U.S. airlines may actually provide better products with actual service in order to compete instead of seeing them chatting away in the galley and berating customers for pushing the call button.


Reply
(@sushicat)
Joined: 2 months ago

Member
Posts: 30

You assume a UA JFK return will mean UA, DL, B6 and AA lower prices and offer better services. I think B6's survivability is the key to the future of this market.


Reply
Diamond
(@stanley-c)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 1048

@sushicat and you assume not. You mentioned about lower fares mean something to you. So, even if UA offers fares that are lower by ten or twenty dollars that does suffice what you want.


Reply
Diamond
(@tim-dunn)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 7773

Everyone wants something they don't pay for - but UA is a for-profit company - just like every other airline - and someone has to pay for what they give you below their cost.
For AA and B6, it is shareholders and banks who keep subsidizing AA and B6 losses - or at best - breakeven operations.'

UA is run by a better mgmt group who understands that they have to make money.

Sure, you can subsidize a particular city or airport w/ high enough profits somewhere else - and UA could do that at JFK

but JFK is a big enough airport with 3 players far bigger than what UA can be at JFK and none of them have any reason to cede anything to UA and lots of reasons to fight like all get out to keep UA from succeeding.

Remember, UA has failed at JFK before; nothing competitively is any better now that it was a decade ago and, if anything, there are 3 credible competitors that have plenty of reason to keep UA from succeeding.

again, how can UA succeed at JFK as #4 if they really believe that AA is doomed at ORD as a smaller #2. Both cannot be true.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards