Alaska Doesn’t Want To Pay For Delta’s Growth In Seattle

One of the best sources of drama in the airline industry in 2014 was “the battle in Seattle” between Alaska and Delta.

I won’t provide a rundown of the situation again, other than linking to the previous post and sharing the below GIF, which I think sums it up perfectly.

Real-Housewives-Reunion

We haven’t seen a lot of public drama between the two airlines lately, and that’s probably simply a function of the fact that they’ve both been profitable. With oil prices where they are, they’re both probably fairly complacent. So as much as I’ve been looking for the drama, clearly Bravo’s “Real Airlines Of Seattle” TV show has been on break.

Until now.

What are they bickering over? Basically Alaska doesn’t want to pay for a new international arrival facility, which will mostly benefit Delta’s passengers. And they plan on attending the Port of Seattle commission meeting today to voice their displeasure.

Alaska-737

Via the Puget Sound Business Journal:

“Virtually none of our customers are going to use that facility, but they’re going to pay for most of it,” said Joe Sprague, Alaska Air Group Inc. senior vice president of external relations. “The people using the international facility, they need to pay for the facility, and if the price tag is too high, they need to bring the price tag down.”

The price tag Sprague is referring to the cost of the planned upgrades to Sea-Tac’s international arrivals facility, which he said has almost doubled to $608 million.

“The intention is for vast majority of funding to come on the back of domestic customers who would never use the facility,” he said.

The payment system uses what are called “passenger facilities charges,” or PFCs, essentially a per-head tax on passengers moving through the airport. These are a common way of paying for capital investments.

The way Alaska sees it, not only is the new international arrivals facility too expensive, but he’s also afraid this will take away funding from projects which would benefit Alaska.

What’s Delta’s argument for the facility?

But Mike Medeiros, vice president of Delta Air Lines’ Seattle operations, said that it’s about time some of the PFC money goes to international carriers’ needs.

“The international arrival facility was built in 1973, and since that time, not a dollar has gone into that arrival facility,” he said. “We think it’s high time that the international side of the business gets a little attention as well.”

Medeiros warned against raising costs for international carriers so much that Sea-Tac is no longer competitive with other West Coast gateway airports, which also want the business of big international carriers like Delta.

“If you burden international carriers with the entire cost, and make it such that user fees aren’t competitive with with other airports up and down the West Coast,” he said, “it’s highly likely that with a higher cost structure, airlines will choose to depart and arrive international flights somewhere else.”

This is an interesting one, and I have to say I side with Delta on this one…

Here’s how the FAA describes the Passenger Facility Surcharge (PFC):

The Passenger Facility Charge (PFC) Program allows the collection of PFC fees up to $4.50 for every boarded passenger at commercial airports controlled by public agencies. Airports use these fees to fund FAA-approved projects that enhance safety, security, or capacity; reduce noise; or increase air carrier competition.

It is intended for capital improvements to the airport, so it’s not airline specific. And I don’t think there’s any arguing that more international traffic could have a huge impact on the Seattle economy. So it seems like the right move to make a capital investment rather than taxing international airlines more.

Now I’m not sure about the cost involved here. $600+ million sounds like a lot, though I don’t really have a sense of scale on these kinds of projects.

That being said, as such, I think investing money to improve services for international airlines and passengers is a great idea. Though I also see why it sucks for Alaska… but such is life.

What do you think? Is it fair to spend most of the surcharges that Alaska is bringing in on something that will ultimately benefit their competitor?

Conversations (23)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

CapHillVagabond Guest

Keep in mind what Delta did to CVG. Delta decided to make Cincinnati a hub, convinced the city to underwrite and funnel huge amounts of money into building a new terminal, and then promptly pulled out after their merger with Northwest, leaving not one but two dead terminals (much like those dead malls you see pictures of floating around online). While I don't trust any airline to do right by anyone, I trust interlopers like Delta even less than the hometown guy like Alaska who at least has a stake in the local economy.

0
‼ 0
Richard Guest

This is nothing new for Alaska. Here in Phx, Delta operates out of the larger, newer Terminal 3 (which will be getting a renovation to the tune of $590M) where Alaska is happy as a clam to remain in the much smaller and older Terminal 2. They still have the original Phoenix mural from when Terminal 2 opened in '62!

0
‼ 0
JonathanYUL Guest

I can see why Alaska wants to protect its domestic customers, but added international capacity can only benefit the consumer in the end. If the fee tops out at $4.50, that is a bargain. I live in Montreal where the Airport improvement fee is $25 every time you depart, and $4-$8 for transit passengers. Yes we have beautiful new airport facilities, but we've certainly subsidized it heavily over the years. (International and trans-border facilities were the primary beneficiaries of the investments, but every departing domestic passenger also pays the fee). I don't think $4.50 is a major factor in air travel, even with all the fees we have to pay. But if it climbs to $25 or more, it could become a deterrent to those just transiting through.

0
‼ 0
Rui N. Guest

@Glenn: PFCs can only be used by projects that the FAA approves (following the guidelines that @Steven L. posted).

0
‼ 0
Zach Guest

For starters, Alaska isn't the pretty princess everyone thinks can do no wrong. Having dealt with them both directly and indirectly from an airport operations point of view, these folks are as much crooks and back-stabbers that Delta is, just on a much smaller scale. Believe me, I know. When something doesn't go their way, they throw a temper-tantrum, much like a 3 year old and they will turn around and stab you in the back just like Delta would. Again, believe me, I've seen it from the station manager down to their working staff. That being said, this is just another AS "poor us, look at us, we are being bullied" piece. Nothing is going to change. It's not going to affect AS proper in any way. In fact, just today, I watched Horizon, which is part of AS, pull plane after plane after plane into S4/5 from the Canadian arrivals.Granted they aren't going through customs since they are pre-cleared, but their customers still need to transit the facility. Not to mention the SJD/CUN/PVR flights that do fully use the facility. Delta can't even say they have the largest amount of international arrivals. They currently have 8. While I don't technically count Canada as being international since they pre-clear, every single flight still has to deplane at the customs facility and utilize the baggage system prior to those folks returning "stateside". AS is the largest user of the facility by far. All of these don't even include the other international carriers, such as BA (2x), EK, NH, LH, KE, H4, FI, OZ, and seasonally DE. And of this list, three are their partners. Don't forget as well that AS has asked in the past that the Port of Seattle bend over backwards for them, only for them to change their mind. The A gates were remodeled, bill mostly footed by the Port and were to be directly benefited and used by AS. AS turned around and said nah, we are good down here at C/D and (eventually) N. Brand new concourse and much better looking than anything AS has, and now DL, US, SY, and UA are the users of the facility. But I get why AS is so heavily liked. They are the underdog. They are the invaded. This is a story that we love. We don't like it when someone is doing well. We like it when someone has their back against the wall. We like a story line that shows the big bad wolf being beaten down and hammered. That's how we were raised. That's how we like to see the world.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published