Senator Durbin’s “Protect Your Points Act” Could Change Miles & Points

Here in the United States, we’ve seen the government take a closer look at airline loyalty programs in recent times, with Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg launching an investigation into airline frequent flyer programs.

The reality is that this is a massive industry that’s largely unregulated. So while I personally probably don’t want the government to regulate these programs too closely, I also think it’s totally fair to do an investigation, given how these programs have historically slipped under the radar.

Along those lines, we’ve just seen some interesting legislation introduced, which I’m pretty skeptical of, frankly.

Basics of Dick Durbin’s new “Protect Your Points Act”

Senate Majority Whip Dick Durbin, a Democrat from Illinois, has just introduced the “Protect Your Points Act,” which is legislation that’s described as strengthening consumer protections by requiring greater transparency from airlines’ frequent flyer, points, and loyalty programs.

This bill would give the Department of Transportation (DOT) and Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) increased oversight of these programs. Here’s how Senator Durbin describes this legislation:

“I understand the practicality of airline rewards programs—I’m a participant myself. But without adequate oversight, airlines are taking advantage of their customers by offering grandiose rewards, only to change the terms and conditions without consumers’ knowledge. My new legislation, the Protect Your Points Act, would require one thing from the airlines – transparency. To be clear, my bill would not eliminate your airline rewards programs or regulate the value of your points or miles. My bill only requires the airlines to play fair. If these programs are as valuable to consumers as the airlines claim they are, the airlines should have no trouble taking these simple steps to make them more transparent.”

The “Protect Your Points Act” would give the DOT and CFPB the authority to:

  • Prohibit airlines from including provisions within their frequent flyer programs’ and airline co-branded credit cards’ terms of service that reserve their right to make changes at any time without notice to consumers, and instead require them to provide at least one year’s notice to consumers of any changes to these terms of service, or any actions that would devalue or jeopardize accrued points
  • Require airlines, within 90 days of enactment, to prominently display on every page of their website a disclosure of the financial value of one point/mile, updated in real time, so that consumers may more easily compare the value of points across different airlines
  • Require airlines, within one year of enactment, to display airfare and add-on pricing concurrently in dollar value and points/miles value, without consumers needing to alternate between the two, so consumers can easily compare the worth of their points; further, it would allow consumers to pay for airfare and add-on services in any combination of points or dollars
  • Ban junk fees related to points/miles by ensuring that consumers are allowed to transfer points to family members or other participants in the same program, and prohibit airlines from charging fees to do so
  • Prohibit airlines from limiting the number of points/miles that can be transferred to another traveler’s account and ensure that any points/miles remain of equal value once transferred
  • Prohibit accrued points/miles from expiring

It’s worth keeping in mind that Senator Durbin is the same person behind the Credit Card Competition Act, which aims to limit swipe fees among credit card issuers, and could have a big impact on credit card rewards.

This new bill is aimed at frequent flyer program rewards

My take on this points-focused legislation

As I said at the beginning of this post, I think it’s fair for the government to at least be looking into frequent flyer programs, given what a large industry this is, and how it has largely been unregulated. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with that.

That being said, I have concerns with this legislation. I don’t understand some of the logistics of this, and I think some of this could harm consumers. Let me hit on a few of the points that stand out to me.

For example, the bill calls on airlines to display on every page of their website what the financial value of one point or mile is, so that consumers can easily compare the value of points from different currencies. I’m sorry, but how are airlines supposed to decide on that valuation? Is the idea to force airlines to make their programs revenue based, and for each point to be worth a certain dollar amount toward the cost of a ticket?

The beauty of airline loyalty programs, and the reason so many of us are into them, is because of the ability to get outsized value by studying them. So should each point be worth one cent toward a ticket, meaning that long haul business class awards would cost a million miles?

Then there’s the requirement to allow consumers to transfer points freely between accounts of various people, to have points never expire, and to allow consumers to pay for all tickets through a combination of cash and points.

I mean, all of those things sound nice, but I’m not sure I understand why airlines should be required to do that? Nowadays virtually every industry has a loyalty or points program of some sort, so why shouldn’t they be required to allow free points transfers, have points not expire, and pay for purchases through a combination of points and cash?

What it comes down to for me is that I appreciate that airlines can use loyalty programs to differentiate themselves from the competition. Different programs have different pros and cons, and as consumers, we should decide which is the best fit for us. Much of this would essentially eliminate the ability for programs to differentiate themselves, by creating arbitrary requirements that largely don’t even make sense.

Durbin claims that this bill would just require transparency from airlines, and for them to play fair. But then so many of these individual points go beyond that. For example, the bill claims that points shouldn’t be able to expire. That goes way beyond requiring transparency and playing fair, but it’s forcing a policy on the airlines. Want to require transparency? How about requiring that airlines prominently post their points expiration policy, require them to notify consumers X number of times before their points expire, etc.?

This bill goes beyond just requiring transparency

Bottom line

Senator Durbin has introduced the “Protect Your Points Act.” While the claim is that this would only require airlines to be transparent and play fair, it goes way beyond that. It would force airlines to not allow points to expire, force them to offer free points transfers, etc. It would also require airlines to post the value of their points on every webpage, but it’s not even clear what that valuation would be based on.

While I’m all for more transparency and the government taking a look at this industry in general, it seems to me like this legislation was written with a lack of understanding of how these programs work.

What do you make of the “Protect Your Points Act” concept?

Conversations (99)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

dee Guest

only trouble when the government gets into anything...like your points and miles....only======Taxes esp with the Dems and Comma La....stay tuned

0
‼ 0
Luke Pereira Guest

This will only lead to taxing you points as income. It might take a year or 2 but they are not interested in helping us, only taxing us

0
‼ 0
DanNJ Guest

When I "achieved" lifetime platinum status on AA from flying 70-100K miles per year, I thought it was cool. My waistline didn't benefit, but our family took wonderful advantage of my heavy business travel rewards with terrific vacations subsidized by all the miles and hotel points that all that waistline expanding travel provided. As I'm closing in on lifetime gold on UA now, I simply don't care anymore. If I get there, fine, if not, fine. There's little actual benefit that I can glean from it, just like the zero benefit I get from my AA plat status. Nothing, zero, nada. Lets talk about reality now. These "loyalty" programs do little to ensure loyalty anymore. My loyalty after 40 years of heavy travel is to the best seat for the lowest price on the most convenient schedule for my needs. My lifetime AA Platinum provides no benefits these days. Our loyalty is to points accumulation to get something seemingly for nothing, whether it be travel, or a free product from some dopey miles promotion. These points programs haven't done a single thing to help airlines improve operational performance, make their flight crews happier, make their passengers get anywhere faster or more reliably, make baggage handling more consistent, or make the horrific airport experience less soul crushing. Whenever I hear about how airlines are "credit card companies that happen to fly airplanes" it makes me sad. This of course, isn't the first time some idiotic politician has decided to scrutinize these FF programs to "protect" the consumer as a veil to potentially view miles/points as income. This notion gets rattled about every decade or so. While I love all the miles/points blog sites like OMAAT et al, they've created a version of points/miles "porn" that both seduces noobies who think they've discovered some novel version of cold fusion, and enrages road warriors who suffer through the grind of actually flying regularly with almost zero benefit from these malignant frequent flyer programs. If the FF programs completely ceased to exist, I'm not sure if most people's lives would change much... mine certainly wouldn't and we fly often on all sorts of airlines. Maybe some of those vapid brain dead instagram travel "influencers" would actually just disappear finally too. And it is true, that these FF programs are like gambling at this point... they have become completely stochastic systems, ie, random in their performance and behavior. The "devaluing" is in fact real. My lifetime platinum status on AA isn't status at all anymore. It used to be a wonderful perk, but now, anybody can get a credit card with AA and get most of the same perks. The airline's middle management, if they could feel shame, should be ashamed they let these programs become so important and integral to the financial health of the airline companies. The airline companies are after all, transportation companies first, but they have unfortunately forgotten that for the most part.

0
‼ 0
Christopher Raehl Guest

Determining the value of points is easy, and every company with a rewards program has already done it, as they carry the value of points issued on their balance sheet as debt. So that provision of the bill jsut requires the airline to disclose that valuation. And if they change their program to reduce the size of the liability on their balance sheet, they would now have to be very public about that change. Agree that the provisions on transfer ability and expiration don't make sense.

0
‼ 0
DCS Diamond

This is from the department of <b>beware what you ask for because you might get it!</b> <blockquote>For example, the bill calls on airlines to display on every page of their website what the financial value of one point or mile is, so that consumers can easily compare the value of points from different currencies. I’m sorry, but how are airlines supposed to decide on that valuation? Is the idea to force airlines to make their programs revenue based, and <b> for each point to be worth a certain dollar amount toward the cost of a ticket</b>? The beauty of airline loyalty programs, and the reason so many of us are into them, is because of the ability to get outsized value by studying them. <i>So should each point be worth one cent toward a ticket, meaning that long haul business class awards would cost <b>a million miles</b></i>?</blockquote> @Ben, why is that a problem or concern when you (and Gary Leff) have claimed for years <b>without evidence</b> that "<i>if a Hyatt standard room is available for booking with cash, then it is also <b>automagically</b> available for booking with points</i>"?! Well, as I repeatedly countered, that claim was always bogus, and now you have just succinctly enunciated why it was bogus. Read on... You see, for any a hotel program to <b>guarantee</b> the ability to book with points every standard room in a property that is available for booking with cash, it would have to make "<b>each point be worth a certain dollar amount toward the cost of a [room]</b>" so that points and cash are <b>equivalent</b> and, thus, interchangeable. No program would let members book with points every available standard room because business-wise it would be utterly stupid. Currently, only two programs allow it and they are able to do it because they made points and cash <b>equivalent</b>. They are (a) Accor ALL rooms and awards, where 2,000 ALL points are worth exactly 40 euros, and (b) Hilton Honors "premium" rooms and awards where a Hilton point has a fixed cents value at each property. Therefore, ANY Accor room or Hilton "premium" room that is available for booking with cash can <b>always</b> be booked with points because in both cases points and cash are interchangeable. However, especially in the case of Hilton's "premium" awards, the extra flexibility can cost you millions of points at the most coveted properties (e.g., WA Maldives). So, to answer the question: <blockquote>Is the idea to force airlines to make their programs revenue based, and <b> for each point to be worth a certain dollar amount toward the cost of a ticket</b>...meaning that long haul business class awards would cost <b>a million miles</b>?</blockquote> The answer is NO and YES: <b>NO</b>, because programs that have implemented <b>revenue based</b>schemes left "loopholes" (that they have been closing!) that still make it possible to get outsized redemption values. <b>YES</b>, premium award rooms/tickets will cost millions of points/miles if <b>each point is made to be worth a certain dollar amount toward the cost of a room/ticket</b>, like HH "premium" awards, and that is also why you, Ben, and Gary Leff must stop <b>gaslighting</b> your readers with the claim that "<i>if a Hyatt standard room is available for booking with cash, then it is also <b>automagically</b> available for booking with points</i>." The claim has always been bogus and will remain bogus until or unless Hyatt institutes a policy that will make <b> each point be worth a fixed dollar amount toward the cost of an award room</b> -- a policy that you have just strongly opposed because awards would cost "a million points", but which you have for years claimed Hyatt had! Now, do you see why the claim was bogus?

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published