What Is A Low Cost Carrier, Really?

Nowadays when I refer to an airline as a low cost carrier, someone usually comments something along the lines of “I don’t know why you use that term, they don’t charge less than other airlines.” For example, I just wrote about WestJet being a low cost carrier, and some commented that, claiming that WestJet doesn’t have cheaper fares than Air Canada. That makes me realize there’s a lot of confusion surrounding how low cost carriers are defined, and that’s understandable, since there’s not really a logical definition anymore. Maybe it’s time to stop using the term.

For example, Southwest is considered to be the world’s largest low cost carrier, despite the fact that they pay their employees extremely well, don’t typically have lower fares than the competition, and don’t charge fees for everything, unlike their competitors. In many ways, this is exactly the opposite of the characteristics typically associated with low cost carriers.

flying-to-havana-10

Instead we’re seeing the legacy carriers, often referred to as “full service airlines” (hah!) charging for carry-on bags, food, seat assignments, early boarding, checked bags, etc.

I think it’s also important to differentiate low cost carriers from ultra low cost carriers. Ultra low cost carriers are those that actually charge fees for everything, have super low fares, pay their employees less, etc. Think of airlines like Spirit, EasyJet, AirAsia, etc.

Spirit-Airlines

According to Wikipedia, here’s the definition of a low cost carrier:

A low-cost carrier or low-cost airline is an airline that generally has lower fares and fewer comforts. To make up for revenue lost in decreased ticket prices, the airline may charge for extras like food, priority boarding, seat allocating, and baggage etc.

The term originated within the airline industry referring to airlines with a lower operating cost structure than their competitors. While the term is often applied to any carrier with low ticket prices and limited services, regardless of their operating models, low-cost carriers should not be confused with regional airlines that operate short flights without service, or with full-service airlines offering some reduced fares.

The important thing to remember is that historically the term low cost carrier has been based on the airlines’ operating costs rather than the services they offer. In other words, a low cost carrier isn’t one that necessarily has lower fares, but rather one that has lower operating costs.

But at this point I’m just not sure how to categorize airlines anymore. I think we can quite easily define ultra low cost carriers, but the line between “low cost carriers” and “full service airlines” is being blurred. Is the Southwest business model really low cost anymore, and is the British Airways and United business model really full service anymore?

What say you guys — do we need new terms for referring to airlines?

Conversations (26)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

vlcnc Guest

British Airways. Nothing else needs to be said.

0
‼ 0
Jason Brandt Lewis Gold

@Lucky ---> I feel your pain . . . nothing is what it used to be (or, "It was all so different before everything changed.") The following is merely my own rambling thoughts . . . CATEGORY ONE (formerly known as "full service airlines"): This category would be composed of all the world's flag carriers, plus -- in the US -- the so-called legacy carriers of American, Delta, United. Though it makes more sense logically to call this category "Flag Carriers," it's more widely understood (by Americans, at least) to refer to this category as "Legacy Carriers." But what actually defines an American legacy carrier? Is it age? being around for a certain length of time? If so, how long? We all refer to AA, DL, and UA as being "legacy carriers," but Alaska and Hawai'ian trace their origins back to 1932 and 1929, respectively -- are they *also* "legacy carriers"? No one thinks of Southwest as a "legacy" carrier, but they celebrated the 50th anniversary of their founding this year (flight operations began in 1971, however). They aren't "full-service" -- no First Class, no food, no assigned seats -- but unlike most others, they *still* don't charge for bags or changes to one's itinerary, etc., etc. And yet . . . Perhaps Category One is entitled neither "Legacy Carriers" nor "Flag Carriers," but simply known as the "Majors" -- that would include airlines such as Southwest, Virgin Atlantic CATEGORY THREE: Ultra-Low Cost Carriers (e.g.: AirAsia, EasyJet, Frontier, Norwegian, RyanAir, Spirit, WOW). Certainly there's no argument here about what constitutes a ULCC. In short, "If they can charge you for it, they will." Let's not forget Spirit floated the idea of pay toilets at 30,000 feet! Clearly it's that large nebulous "middle ground" that's the problem. You can't refer to all of them as "regional carriers," because many have international routes. Perhaps Category One is entitled neither "Legacy Carriers" nor "Flag Carriers," but simply known as the "Majors" -- expanding the definition to include airlines such as Southwest, Virgin Atlantic, and EVA Air (which, to my surprise, is *not* Taiwan's flag carrier). And then CATEGORY TWO *could* be regionals . . . and would include carriers like American Eagle, Delta Connection, United Express (all of which are, in part, operated by SkyWest, Republic, and a number of other regional carriers). That said, while I agree that wikipedia is not the ideal, nor the most accurate, source of information, it did have this to say about SkyWest: "Financially speaking and according to the Airlines for America definitions, SkyWest is a North American major airline. SkyWest however, operates on a regional airline level and is a member of the Regional Airline Association. SkyWest Airlines flies to 213 cities, in 44 states; six Canadian provinces and five cities in Mexico and the Bahamas." Food for thought? Or just indigestion?

0
‼ 0
Krabnov New Member

Low-cost airlines aren't necessarily low-fare airlines. I think there are a few characteristics to (ultra) low-cost airlines: * they operate mainly out of secondary airports or use secondary piers/terminals at primary airports * this enables them to lower their operating costs and apply for huge discounts on airport fees and taxes, claiming that opening a route creates jobs and boosts the local economy * many of them are point-to-point only (like EasyJet, Ryanair) instead of network carriers So my belief is that low cost refers to (efficient) operating costs of the airline, but not to the price the passenger pays for his ticket.

0
‼ 0
Charlie Gardiner Guest

You probably already know but here in Europe you cant beat Ryanair for low cost! I often travel from Spain to Poland and back for 40€. Ok you have to put up with being treated like cattle but if you know what to expect and can put up with it for a couple of hours then its super cheap. Going from Barcelona to Poland and back costs less than a train from Barcelona to Madrid and back, its crazy. Great article keep it up!

0
‼ 0
Austin Guest

Please keep in mind that many (non-sale) Southwest fares (and there are MANY sales) between specific city-pairs equal the legacy carriers' fares because the latter were forced to match the lower fares of the former when it moved into the market. No doubt, fares tend to creep up for all carriers in such markets once Southwest gains a foothold (the Walmart business model) but, on the whole, consumers are generally the financial winners even then. In sum, show me one example of a city that begged Southwest not to expand to their market. Full disclosure, my mother-in-law and uncle-in-law work for Southwest, but I believe my analysis is fair. I fly (and pay for my tickets on) Southwest and legacy carrriers, and rarely is the extra legacy expense worth the so-called legacy benefits.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published