Security Questions On Flights To The United States…

I’m sure I’m not the only one who is curious about this…

Those silly questions on US-bound flights

If you’ve ever flown to the United States from select international destinations (including Europe and South America), you’ve probably dealt with quite a bit of security theater. Specifically, either at check-in or at the gate, there are staff who have to ask you a series of questions. If you pass the “test,” then you’ll typically get a sticker on the back of your passport confirming that you can board the flight.

While the exact details vary, questions typically include:

  • Where are you coming from, and what’s the purpose of your trip?
  • Have you packed your bags on your own, and have they been in your possession the entire time?
  • Has anyone asked you to carry anything for them on the flight?
  • What electronics are you traveling with, and have you had any of them repaired recently?

Just to be clear, this isn’t like flights to & from Israel, where you have trained intelligence officials doing questioning, including behavior detection. Rather these are generally contract workers who largely don’t seem very well trained, to put it politely.

Security stickers from US-bound flights

What I’m curious about…

Am I the only one who has questions about this whole practice of asking security questions prior to boarding?

  • In the years of this happening, and the millions of people who have been questioned, has any sort of risk been averted because of this? If someone had bad intentions, it’s not like this questioning is going to be what gives them second thoughts
  • I can understand the yes or no questions that are asked, but what’s the point of asking where someone has been and how long they were traveling for? The people asking these questions don’t strike me as trained intelligence officials, so are there some destinations that will set off a red flag, is this behavior detection, or is this just some sort of small talk?
  • What happens if you don’t give the “correct” answer, and admit that your bag hasn’t been in your possession the entire time, or that you didn’t pack it yourself, or that you were asked to bring something? Will you simply be searched, or is there more to it?

The whole thing seems like such a massive waste of resources to me. I’m curious if there’s something I’m missing. I don’t know, given how many people get scammed by phone and email thinking that they need to buy Amazon gift cards for the IRS, maybe this does accomplish something?

I also struggle a bit with answering the questions. For example, when you’re asked if your bag has been in your possession the entire time since you packed it, can most people claim with 100% honesty that this is the case? I mean, when you see people in airline lounges, they don’t typically walk to the buffet while dragging their carry-on, so technically it seems that most people don’t. Yet what happens if you were to actually admit that?

Security questions are standard on US-bound flights

Bottom line

Aside from Israel (which takes security a lot more seriously), the United States is the only country I know of to have security questions prior to flights. I’ve always been intrigued by these, so I’m curious to hear what OMAAT readers think.

What’s your take on the security questions on US-bound flights? Have you ever given the “wrong” answer, and if so, what happens?

Conversations (105)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Ray Guest

I have been a United States citizen for several years and have lived in the United States for approximately 39 years. I went on a short leisure trip to France, visiting Nice, Cannes and Monaco between December 28th and January 4 through Expedia. My airline was Air France. I enjoyed my time off during the new year tremendously. On January 4, I embarked my return flight on Air France Flight number AF136 from Paris Charles de Gaulle to O'Hare International. I had approximately one hour of connection time. At check in in Nice, I again informed the attendant to include my Global Entry number (Nexus and TSA pre check) at the luggage check in desk. I checked in one piece of luggage and got the tag and receipt. The airline was already in possession of my Global Entry number. Upon arrival at gate K41, CDG Terminal E2, the lady at the gate checking the passports made a longer than usual pause with me as compared to other passengers in front of me, looking at my United States passport. She particularly asked me about my country of birth (Iran). I told her it was there in my passport. She then asked me if I packed my bags myself, and how many pieces I had checked in. I answered yes and one piece got checked in. She also asked me if I had a laptop in my carry-on to which I said no. I entered the line in zone 4 (per my boarding pass) and once I got to the boarding pass automatic gates the gate lights suddenly turned red from green and an alarm sounded . The lady then announced that gates were locked! I had to wait approximately five minutes for an attendant- a Frenchman of possible African origin- to arrive and unlock the gates. I attempted to use my boarding pass to open the gate but it didn't work as it had been up to this point. The new man who unlocked the gates called me over to the left and I entered a side door. He asked for my passport. Then he repeated the same questions of if I had packed my own bags, and how many pieces of luggage I had checked. He also asked me if I had a laptop. Again I answered all his questions faithfully. At this point, I was getting frustrated. I replied I did packed my own bags, and I had only one piece checked in and I didn't have a laptop. Then he sent me to another lady by the window at a desk. This lady in a very rude and unprofessional way asked me to empty my pockets immediately(!) And ordered me to open my luggage immediately! She also asked me if I had packed my own bags, and how many pieces of luggage I had checked in, and if I had a laptop ! At this point, I was very frustrated. Embarrassed and shaken up. I told her to please hold on as I did what she was asking. Her demeanor was very mean as if she was handling a criminal. At the top of her voice she was yelling at me not to touch the stuff that I took out of my pockets as she was using a device, sensing my luggage contents and my shoes on the table and the palms of my hands. She placed the strips into a machine to analyze me and my belongings. Everyone at the gate was watching her unprofessional demeanor. This was extremely embarrassing to me. When done, she was yelling that I should hurry up. At this point I answered I am doing the best I can allow me to do what I have to do. I kept getting the feeling that I was being treated as a person with a criminal background. When she was finished she did not help me to repack my bags. I was so distracted and distressed that I almost lost my passport that had fallen on the floor underneath this table. A passenger pointed out that I should pick up my passport. This entire event was witnessed by several passengers. Please note that I had told the gentleman at the side door that I had Global Entry and I was TSA PreCheck and I did not see why they were doing this. He didn't take note of what I told him before this demeaning inspection. I had to rush back on the airplane with my shoes halfway on. Once I got into my seat, I was extremely shaken up, agitated and embarrassed. I have never been treated by anyone in any airports like this before. It took me approximately two hours to calm down. I felt extremely violated, shaken up and insulted. The plane was delayed for approximately 45 minutes. The captain announced there was an issue and that was the reason for delay. I was thinking perhaps they were taking out my checked in luggage and they were searching it too! Once the plane got going, at dinner was served and I felt more relaxed. I decided to speak to the head flight attendant on the flight. I located a gentleman by the name of Maxim Matias (LC-2B) as the pursor or this flight. To him I announced that I wanted to file a complaint against Air France a out how badly I was treated at the gate by Air France people. I also told him that once I reached my destination in Chicago, I will be attempting to speak to my attorney about the way I was treated. I understood it was based on my birthplace and country of Origin Iran which was noted on my US passport. I had heard stories about this happening to other expatriates from my country of origin before as well. The purser photographed my global entry card as well as my office business card and added it to the formal complaint. I explained to him that I am a former retired University of Illinois College of Dentistry professor and I don't even have a single speeding ticket. I did not deserve to be treated that way. I also told him that I own a Global Entry (Nexus TSA precheck) card that was given to me after I was vetted by the Department of Homeland Security I filled out the complaint form on an Air France ipad and gave it back to this gentleman. I have photographs of this document. The Purser informed me that the captain will read and sign off on this complaint as well. After I arrived in Chicago, I realized that my checked in luggage had been opened and there was a slip inside showing that it had been checked too. I received an email from Air France the same afternoon, stating they had received my complaint and they were asking me to provide a possible bank account with a bank address in case I will be doing a refund. I have not heard or received any updates from Air France since then and it has been almost one week. I strongly believe this happened due to the fact that lady at zone 4 line entry read my place of birth being in Iran and that prejudged me without any regard for the fact that I was a respected US citizen, with no criminal records on TSA PreCheck and owned a global entry for Global global entry card vetted by DHS just a month or two ago. This event has emotionally bothered me for several days now. I keep getting nightmares eversince. This mistreatment and singling out people based on their birth place should stop immediately.

0
‼ 0
NottaBot Guest

I've traveled to numerous foreign countries. Just returned from Columbia last week. Not one time have I been asked any of those questions before flying to or from the US.

0
‼ 0
Ex-security person Guest

Do you wanna know when and why it started? It started after the 11th of September, 2001, probably the date has already informed you why at this point, I worked for airline security for a major US airline in Bogota, yes we got extensive training we would actually be flown to the airline's HQ for training before we started our job, the training was quite hard and if you didn't pass you couldn't get hired, I think they don't fly people to the HQ anymore because of the cost associated to it but they have trainers who travel to each city to train the job applicants before they start. While the questions may be pesky, it's a requirement by the airline and yes at least in Bogota we were able to catch a lot of people trying to smuggle drugs because of suspicious behavior when interviewed, cause I don't know if you know this, but people who are about to commit major international crimes tend to get pretty nervous and being confronted about it will make it even more evident, there are certain questions which are meant to look for red flags like when, how and who booked your trip, and then as someone else here pointed out, some questions like who packed your bags, content of the bags, bag being in your possession all the time those are questions that in the event that the scanners do find something in your bag will legally hurt you because you already admitted that everything in your bag was yours, you packed it and you have control of your bag all the time, most smugglers when catched will say "it's not my bag" "I didn't pack it" "I didn't knew the contents" "someone put something in my bag while I was unaware" I unfortunately had to deal with people like you and some in the comments who would take it out on us for the inconvenience of being asked questions as part of our job and would make our jobs even more difficult, maybe you should've first tried questioning the airlines themselves as to why they do this and if this really works, instead of making a difficult job more difficult. I used to enjoy the writing in this blog but the sense of entitlement in this particular entry definitely ruined that perception, it just brings memories of how entitled and rude most of the so-called "frequent fliers" were

0
‼ 0
Bill Guest

This is why: https://apnews.com/article/39422ed6bffc40b9bee7c4599c8a19e7

0
‼ 0
Marcus Guest

In your recollection, Ben, do you also get these questions when you use the first class terminal at FRA?

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published