I give up on elite status…

Last night I was on the phone with a friend trying to plan mileage runs, and I spoke five words I never thought I’d say — “I give up on status.” Let me ‘splain.

About a week ago I wrote a post about how I was trying to decide between going for 150K miles with American, which qualifies me for their maximum “Elite Rewards,” or going for Alaska MVP Gold 75K, which gets me higher upgrade priority with Alaska and 50K bonus miles. Assuming I plan on requalifying for Executive Platinum with American and MVP Gold with Alaska, the marginal flying to reach those higher thresholds is totally justifiable and almost a no brainer. For flying 50,000 extra miles on American I’d earn a total of 170,000 redeemable miles factoring in the Elite Rewards, while for flying an additional 40,000 miles on Alaska I’d earn an additional 130,000 miles. How could I possibly turn either of those down?!

So I said “fine, I’ll do them both.” I crunched the numbers and realized that meant I’d have to fly roughly another 150,000 miles this year on revenue flights, given that a vast majority of my travel the first half of the year was on award flights. I started looking at mileage runs, and found some fares between Los Angeles and Beijing via Chicago on American for about $700, and even less when I applied one of the 10% off codes from American’s promotion earlier this week. Not only is that a great fare, but I can do two of those in a week, so can knock out over 35,000 miles in a week and use my American systemwide upgrades to upgrade to business class.

But then I thought to myself that that’s four longhaul flights back to back in angled business class seats with no Wi-Fi, so I’m losing quite a bit of “productivity” by doing that. Then I turned my focus to mileage runs that would encompass the 777-300ER, not just for the fully flat beds, but for the Wi-Fi. Okay, I could pay an extra $200 roundtrip and give up some miles to fly the 777-300ER to Sao Paulo. That premium is worth it to me in theory, but at that point is it really a “mileage run” anymore when you’re paying over six cents per mile?

At that point I got frustrated and just asked myself why I even bother going for status. I have roughly four million miles and points across programs (nothing compared to others, and sadly quite a few of them are Hilton Honors points), and they’re constantly devaluing. So why on earth would I sit myself down on a plane with an angled flat business class seat for almost a week straight so I can start to get close to my mileage goal, when I could be redeeming millions of miles for Singapore Suites and similarly awesome products.

Heck, and even if I didn’t have miles, US Airways is almost always selling miles for 1.88 cents each, and for 90,000 miles you can travel from the US to Asia via Europe with a stopover there. So why would I mileage run to earn miles, when I can for $1,700 outright purchase a business class trip to Asia and even stop in Europe enroute if I wanted to?

It just seems silly. When I started mileage running it made sense on so many levels. I could mileage run at a cost that was 50% lower than it is now, and on top of that the airlines had crazy promotions. When I first started mileage running about eight years ago, there was an offer for 5,000 bonus elite qualifying and redeemable miles per segment flown. For the next several years we saw a double elite qualifying miles promotion almost every year, plus promotions for bonus redeemable miles.

And on top of that I was a cent per mile “purist.” It was all about the almighty cent per mile. I would’ve flown a regional jet from Miami to Shanghai if it meant my cent per mile ratio was 0.01 lower. And on top of all that, I was about 15 and there wasn’t much productivity I was giving up by mileage running (unless you consider posting on FlyerTalk to be “productive”).

But just as quickly as I was about to write off status, I remember where status is almost a necessity — for domestic flying. I have to do a fair bit of domestic travel, and I think that’s really where the value of status shines, between upgrades, priority security lines, priority boarding, priority rebooking, etc. I’d hate to give all that up. And with Alaska it’s even better, since they let you cancel revenue tickets for free and have a generous same day change policy, which is extremely useful for my short-haul travel.

Anyway, my buddy beaubo always makes the case against status, and I’ve always just written his argument off a bit (not him, but the argument). But for the first time ever I think he may be on to something…

Just some random ramblings… anyone else ever feel this way?

Conversations (48)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Peter Guest

One thing not mentioned here is AA GLD vs PLT. One big benefit of PLT is 100% mileage bonus on all flights. I'm lifetime, but we still run for my wife who is about 75k away from LT also, or rather she runs, I go along on awards - where we WANT to go. Generally we'll pay domestic and award high value international. Status, for other than the int'l lounge access intraeurope and the 100% bonus seems not worth the effort to run for EXP, even with the eVIPs. And the extra op-ups you occasionally get on other airlines is moot if you are in front to begin with! Too many miles banked that need burning. Having said that, I'm finally getting to go to Australia, but I no longer have EXP for a taste of Qantas' F lounge. It's not worth an extra $5-10k spend a year, I'm quite sure.

0
‼ 0
Bgriff Diamond

TSA Precheck has significantly reduced my feeling of urgency of getting status, I have to admit. There are still a lot of other nice benefits to status of course, but Precheck and lounge access through Amex Platinum does get a lot of benefit.

0
‼ 0
Greg Guest

Lucky elite status is definitely getting worse by the day. In particular, I believe two of the programs AA and AS are both on a downward trend as well. AA - soon to be merging with US. I would argue that we likely will see the end of systemwide upgrades from any fare, a reduction in the quality of AA domestic F (think US no food on 3 hour flights etc) and other reductions (maybe fewer systemwides or higher copays with miles or no upgrades with miles etc) If I was a betting man, I would believe that in 2 years from now AA Ex Plat status will be less valuable then it is now. AS - I was a MVP Gold for years. However gave up when I switched my loyalty to AA. As a AS MVP Gold or 75K, I would expect an upgrade Seattle-New York, Boston or Washington to be rare, especially when I often fly (weekends, summer holidays and Christmas). AS upgrades are much more consistent on say SEA-SFO or LAX but on a short flight like that I would take a bulk head or exit row and WiFi over a seat if F with no WiFi. You have what 2 or 3 million miles. SPEND THEM. Having the miles and not using them reduces your value to 0 cents per mile. Although redemptions CAN be in the 10cents-per mile ++ range, not using them or using them to go to the places when and where you want to go a more reasonable value is probably about 1.5ish CPM. Spending 6 to get the miles and status JUST IS NOT WORTH IT.

0
‼ 0
VG Guest

It depends on how big you are - upgrades or at least exit row or tourist plus seats are a necessity. However, I think that mid-tier status is fine for my needs. More generally, it is not erosion of status benefits that is the significant trend. The biggest erosion is in the treatment of the hoi polloi - non-status passengers, especially those without affiliated credit cards. I would not like to be treated how I see them being treated on a regular basis.

0
‼ 0
Rick I Guest

I gave up on status two years ago. Just not worth the hassle when free miles are so easy to obtain.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published