In case anyone's wondering, here's the response I received from the GM:
Dear Mr. Lucky,
First of all let me thank you for staying and Andaz Wall Street and for taking the time to write me your feedback.
It is because of guest like you that we can learn about our services and improve them day by day.
Please accept my apologies for the "relaxed" attitude of our night host. This is obviously not the way we want our customers to perceive the Andaz experience.
I have taken the liberty to speak to the appropriate Department Head and I trust him to do whatever is neccessary to correct the incident.
Furthermore, in line with the overall Hyatt GP guidlines you have complimentary breakfast, either through the restaurant or through room service. Given that we have many inclusions in the Andaz experience, such as WiFi, local phone calls and non alcoholic minibar and snacks, we decided to give GP members a 1000 point credit as the special amenity.
Also, we definitly honor the regular GP bed type request. I am sorry for the confusion. You are right, an explanation at the beginning would have helped. While the intention to give you the Deluxe Room (with the glass at the bath tub) was to give you a nice room type, the purpose failed. Again, proper "homework" in the beginning would have avoided the situation.
Mr. Lucky, I am thankful to you that you want to give us another chance and I can ensure you that my team and I will do our utmost to improve on our services.
Please let me know if I can be of any assistance to you at any time.
Looking forward having you back at Andaz Wall Street.
Best regards
Toni