According to a shocking new lawsuit filed on Monday, a man spent 17 days in jail because American Airlines wrongly accused him of a crime he had never even heard of… 14 months after the fact.
Continue reading: American Airlines Traveler Wrongly Jailed For 17 Days For Crime He Didn’t Commit
Share your questions, experiences, and thoughts below.
Sounds like American and Hertz should consider reciprocity and bonus points for combined prison stays. Idiots.
The story reads like the accused did not retain a lawyer until he was already home in Flagstaff. Why wait that long given the circumstances? A lawyer on day 1 may have challenged the arrest leading to the immediate dropping of charges.
Lowe was certainly wronged but proving all the horrible events that transpired were American's fault is going to be difficult. The airline played a small by supplying a photo. The justice system failed him in the worst way but still it followed its own guidelines, as inept as they may be.
American provided the requested information; they didn’t arrest the guy. Mr. Lowe’s beef is with the police and prosecutor who took such flimsy evidence and issued an arrest warrant. Holding American Airlines liable will only dissuade anyone from cooperating with the police in the future.
The police/justice system are very culpable BUT you are not correct according to the gentleman's attorney. It is normal in situations like these for the airline to give the police their entire passenger manifest and boarding video. This was requested of AA. However, they only turned in this guys information leading the police to believe he was the only suspect.
It’s outrageous and makes clear what too many people who live in higher crime areas and are more likely to be mistaken deal with. And they don’t often get the media to tell their story.
So odd he didn’t have a chance to have an attorney upfront.
And goodness May 2020 with so few in the airports you’d think it would be easier to get right. And who flies via DFW to Reno from Flagstaff! Just drive to PHX and get a flight.
@BenSchlappig “And I don’t think that the US Justice System gets everything right”
The US justice system gets a lot more wrong than it does right. From drug laws targeting communities of colour, the prison industrial complex, rigged corporate law, the freedom of the police to act like militias, humiliation of convicts, guilty until proven innocent, the US justice system is rotten from the core and rotten by design. Get rid of the perception that the justice system even wants to get things right, let alone gets them right the majority of the time.
I honestly can't understand how you guys even live in that hellhole, takes so much courage... I'd be scared to even step foot outside.
Coulda been worse if he had rented with Hertz to get back home after his false arrest - he might have ended up as a repeat false offender.
@Aloha Dave
Had it been Hertz rental car he would have only been facing a fraudulent $400 smoking fee.
So he spent 17 days in Jail. Grew some hair on his chest no harm no fouls. You want to blame this on some DFW mall cop ? What’s that have to do with American Airlines ? And the other story 4 flies were in a salad ? Cry me a river.
AA is culpable for providing cops only Lowe's photo instead of the entire footage of fliers boarding the flight to Reno and let the cops figure it out. It is akin to a witness retracted the mistaken identity of the suspect, after the suspect has served jail time. The cops and prosecutor are guilty of jumping the gun and arrested and prosecuted an innocent person without due diligence. Cops and courts are joined at the hip. Lowe failed to understand the judicial system by not demanding to have a lawyer represent him from the get go. His buddies at the party did not assist him in posting a bail and retain a lawyer after the arrest. True friends are those who stick with you in bad times not just party time.
I'm curious what was the actual item shoplifted that led to all this, a $25 shirt? There wouldn't have been an arrest at all for this then if it were at SFO where you can take anything worth under $1k without arrest.
@Lucky he was not punched in the face. He saw someone getting punched in the face.
So AA is like the Hertz car rental of airlines, having law enforcement arrest their customers.
AA has basically replaced UA as the garbage airline.
It the usual procedure is for the airline to turn over the entire manifest and video when the police didn't receive all of the materials they (the police) should have requested the additional material so they could make the most informed decision on an arrest as possible. Again, its the police who made the error, not AA
Reasonable people should reserve absolute opinion until actual facts from credible sources are verified (and not from a travel/points blog). Making the assumption that American Airlines determined that Mr. Shaw was guilty is just irresponsible. In all probability, AA provided specifically what was requested of them in a subpoena request. I'm not defending false imprisonment, as it is inexcusable, but culpability lies w/ the (lack of) execution of due process at multiple levels, not with AA.
Exactly. Demand a lawyer as soon as you are able to after arrest. They will find the details and fight to get you out, that's what they do. Seventeen days without calling for a lawyer to find out why you've even been arrested sounds...strange.
Some employee at AA decided that Lowe should suffer. This person needs to pay.
American Airlines consistently fails to follow their own procedures, constantly. This is just another example, though with much more serious consequences.
Whether it’s boarding times/order, to inflight service, to contacting customer care… and, now including responding to law enforcement… AA consistently provides inconsistent service.
Their inconsistency is one of the few reliable things about this airline, other than mishandled baggage and schedule irregularities…
Something seems very off about all of this. Does DFW not have surveillance cameras and footage, aside from AA’s cameras? We’re there not surveillance cameras in the store that was robbed? You can’t move an inch in a US airport these days without your actions being recorded. Law enforcement relied solely on a single name from a manifest and the image of only one passenger boarding a flight? And why was he unable to have legal counsel from day one? Many things do not add up in this story. It would seem that DFW Law enforcement and the DFW airport are way more liable than AA.
I'm thinking this is not a question of evidence which I'm sure there was plenty of. I'm betting it's those in charge assuming it's a no big deal shoplifter case that they're not so interested in following through because they have plenty of other more serious crimes to deal with never ever questioning that they might have made a mistake.
Well he was in Mexico. The judge didn't even tell him anything. Different set of due process.
If Lowe were black he'd be dead by now. Concierge key status? Let's talk a settlement in the millions. SHAME on AA and DFW and all the law enforcement people involved along the nearly three-week trail.
He will receive a lifetime first class flight like the employees has and a lot $$$$$. I believe he is happy now.
Who thought that you can be charged of a crime without being told what it was? Is that a thing in the US? I thought that was what they did in authoritarian countries, not in a democracy. Time to change the laws.
I think you will find he was not in Mexico but *New* Mexico, where the US Constitution and the due process therein definitely applies.
In what universe is shoplifting a felony?
Oh, Texas. Can they just kick us out of their insane country, please?
This article was posted in the Minneapolis Star-Tribune with a lot more details. It looks pretty damning for American. Someone there clearly had a vendetta against him.
Who pissed in your Wheaties? @AlohaDaveKennedy tosses in a little humor and you go off with a question salad that have zero relevance to his remark? Stay on track. If you have questions, ask in your own post, not in a response. You look like every other moron that can't stay focused.
Just to clarify one mystery of this: It is possible that the jail and judge merely knew there was an arrest warrant from another state, and the man was not facing charges in the state where arrested. For this reason, the only legal question before this judge was whether to extradite this man to Texas...or the judge with 50 arraignments to conduct in 2 to 3 hours that morning was too backed-up to look beyond the only relevant question to be decided that morning (extradition). Thus, this was not a circumstance where the defendant was to have charges read and a plea entered. It would be Texas that would have the specific charges.
Some of the details don't make sense. The law states you must be charged with something within 72 hours. Cops just can't throw you in a hole for 17 days. Does New Mexico not have public defenders? Oh, and other sites report he saw another man punched in the face not him. But the outrageous claim that he was not charged officially within 17 days is crazy. They are not supposed to do that. Why did American Airlines decide to play detective? Why were the cops/DA's so lazy? I hope he wins millions from all the scum that wronged him. Oh, and in case you didn't know, jail sucks. The cops think everyone there is guilty (innocent until proven guilty HaHa!) Every high school senior in this country should be made to spend a week in jail. Scared straight! You will see some jail reform then!
And they will not pay to send him to Tarrent County and Tarrent County isn't going to send cops there to pick up a MISDEMEANOR!
You are supposed to be charged within 72 hours or you go free. Something here smells bad. And it's an effing misdemeanor!
Who ever did this at American Airlines needs to be fired and shamed publicly! Union or not, they need to be canceled in the extreme! This is outrageous!
OK butt wipe corporate lawyer. Cops asked for a MANIFEST, American Airlines own detective Columbo sent video saying here is the guilty one! Without checking anything! My guess, someone at AA had it in for this guy. They need to pay/suffer!
He was charged with something. That's what those arrest warrants from Texas were. The NM authorities were holding him pending extradition to Texas.
"Concierge Key status for life"? I know most of the people who read this website would drool over the idea of getting that status for life. But I suspect that Mr. Lowe will try to avoid ever taking another AA flight or stepping foot in DFW ever again.
Shoplifting can be a felony in any state. I live in a liberal state and the limit for a felony is only $750.
It's so sad to read information so badly and horrible experience that can happen to anyone. This news nor only damage that person reputation. It also damage American Airlines reputation. AA is my favorite Airlines. But it hurts when someone innocent go through that horrible nightmare experience. CL
So much for American exceptionalism and the broken "justice" system..... You write about this, since it was a poor, American Airlines passenger... this happens every day to 100s of people in the US.....
This just doesn’t add up. DFW airport police would have investigated this crime. They would have had no trouble obtaining the entire passenger list if they asked for it. They would have been the ones that looked at the video. They would have issued the warrant based on their investigation. If they issued a warrant without confirming that the shoplifter in the video was Lowe they have some explaining to do. After Lowe was arrested did any of his party friends try to find out what happened to him and why he was arrested? Did he or his friends try to hire an attorney? Did the police in New Mexico contact the DFW airport police or Tarrant County’s sheriff’s department to see if they wanted Lowe held so they could come and get him? Without more information it seems like Lowe was a victim of the legal system and that American had very little to do with it.
Maybe, like Hertz, AA will start having people who didn't fly their airline arrested, just so those who did fly AA have no reason to book away.
Just a marketing idea.