And the newest Skytrax five star airline is…

And the newest Skytrax five star airline is…

20

Skytrax, which ranks airlines with star ratings, recently unveiled their seventh five star airline. The six airlines previously on the list were Asiana, Cathay Pacific, Kingfisher, Malaysia, Qatar, and Singapore. Any guesses as to what the next five star airline is? Maybe Etihad? Emirates? Swiss? ANA?

Nah, none of those. Instead, it’s Hainan Airlines.

And while they’re no doubt a decent airline, I’m pretty sure Skytrax loses all their credibility with that, calling Hainan one of the top seven airlines in the world…

Conversations (20)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. R B Guest

    My experience with HU... 1 of the two times poor attitude in cabin staff. Rough handling of my carry on and snarky. Small seats. Poor looking cabin interior . 6 hour delay due to mechanical problems 2 days ago in Toronto to Beijing.

    Skytrax: they rejected my review, and somehow 77 client reviews seem to give this airline 4.5/5.0 . Something smells funny to me.

  2. Wait Guest

    I guess the general public perception of 'made in china' products contributed a little to the reaction of some people here. As a matter of fact, the Chinese make a lot of cheap craps, and they also make a lot of high quality stuff, which is often overlooked.

  3. Matthew Guest

    Just flew Hanian from XIY to PVG.

    They were wonderful! Brand new 738, full meal in Y on 2hr domestic flight.

    I don't know that they're five-stars, but I was very impressed.

  4. UA_Flyer Guest

    Forgot to add that George Soros provided some initial investment to Hainan Airlines back in 1995, and now still owns a sizable interest in the airlines.

  5. UA_Flyer Guest

    I have flown Hainan Airlines. Looking Skytrax's Five Star list, I have also flown CX, SQ, OZ, MH but not Kingfisher or Qatar.

    IMHO, Hainan is a fairly good airlines. Their business class services and hardware are very good. Y is comparable to SQ, and better than MH, OZ and CX. However, my experience is limited to only a token of flights. I would say Hainan is better than my favorite - United Airlines by...

    I have flown Hainan Airlines. Looking Skytrax's Five Star list, I have also flown CX, SQ, OZ, MH but not Kingfisher or Qatar.

    IMHO, Hainan is a fairly good airlines. Their business class services and hardware are very good. Y is comparable to SQ, and better than MH, OZ and CX. However, my experience is limited to only a token of flights. I would say Hainan is better than my favorite - United Airlines by a mile in terms of cabin services, amenity, etc.

    Hainan codeshores with Brussels Air ( *A Carrier) on Brussels-Beijing route. I had thought about switching my often travelled Brussels trips to the direct Hainan flight (instead of the one-stop LH service) until I realized the amount of EQMs and RDMs I would lose.

    I cannot comment on Haina's frequent flyer program, lost baggage experience, customer services during irregular operations or its website.

    Although I do wonder whether ANA or Swiss are more deserving than Hainan to get on the list, I do also wonder why MH is on the list.

  6. caelus Guest

    THEY BOUGHT THE 5 STARS RATING!!!!!! SKYTRAX IS SO CORRUPTED!!!!!!

  7. Roland Guest

    HU definitely deserves this. Their route network may not be large but their service is exemplary and their hard product on par with five star standards.

  8. Sam Guest

    they are for sure the quality airline of China in terms of domestic service, I haven't flown them international, but I'm guessing the Skytrax people forgot about everything else when they saw the smoking hot FAs.

  9. lucky OMAAT

    @ magiciansampras -- In no way am I bashing them. As a matter of fact, I specifically said that I was sure they were a decent airline. However, there are certain aspects of an airline you can judge without flying them. Take a look at their lounge in Beijing. Take a look at their business class seats. Take a look at trip reports with pictures of their food. It all looks decent, though the product...

    @ magiciansampras -- In no way am I bashing them. As a matter of fact, I specifically said that I was sure they were a decent airline. However, there are certain aspects of an airline you can judge without flying them. Take a look at their lounge in Beijing. Take a look at their business class seats. Take a look at trip reports with pictures of their food. It all looks decent, though the product is in no way on par with the likes of Etihad, which isn't on the list. And that doesn't even account for the fact that they have any truly premium services, like those offered by some other airlines that aren't on the list. So I'm not denying that they're a good (or maybe even great) airline, but no matter how amazing their in-flight service is, I don't see how this can be considered one of the world's top seven airlines...

  10. Skitten Guest

    The award seems to be based on ass-kissing lounge and cabin service, which is usually the stuff Lucky loves, so what is the problem here?

  11. Reader Guest

    Alright haters...look at their website. Tell me if it looks like it belongs to a 5* airline. You don't think that oh, say, Etihad deserves it before Hainan?? HU has a small route network that lacks frequency.

  12. Cdegt Guest

    Hainan air is the best airline company in China. I'm just wondering if someone's bias around this topic which may indicate country like China do not deserve a five star airliner? Maybe I misunderstood. With all due respect, is any person who has never flown with Hainan qualified to make such a statement? BTW: Hainan Air is not a private company. It's a state owned airliner company listed in Shanghai and Hong kong stock exchange.

  13. Gary Gold

    Quite reasonable upgrades with Hainan. And you can convert Wyndham points into Fortune Wings Club miles.

  14. magiciansampras Guest

    Gee, think someone could actually fly with them before bashing them? Who has more credibility, a website that ranks an airline you've never heard of or someone doubting the ranking of an airline they've never flown?

  15. unscheduled Guest

    I personally took flights on Hainan Airlines and Malaysia Airlines, which are both Skytrax five star airlines. To my point of view, Hainan Airlines is way better than Malaysia Airlines in terms of cabin service.

  16. mark Guest

    @Reader What does the fact that they only fly to Seattle from Asia have to do with this?

    Not necessarily disagreeing that they shouldn't get that rating, but an airline flying or not flying to the USA has no bearing on the quality of the product they provide, just the breadth of their network. Asiana don't fly to Amsterdam and Cathay don't fly to Rio. So what?

  17. Helixcardinal Guest

    Can someone who's actually flown on Hainan Airlines comment on its quality?

  18. Monty Guest

    Can't speak to the quality but they just started service to YYZ recently.

  19. Ian Guest

    They are starting flights to Sydney next week from Hainan, via Shenzhen... With only economy an business class. I have flown Shanghai airlines and Air China and each were horrid, but maybe the fact that Hainan airlines is a private company has something to do with it...? I certainly would select ANA or SWISS over freaky Hainan any day...

  20. Reader Guest

    LOL! This must be a joke. Hainan Airline's website is the first signal that they are not a 5 star airline. And don't they only fly to Seattle from Asia? Do they even qualify as a real airline?

Featured Comments Most helpful comments ( as chosen by the OMAAT community ).

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

R B Guest

My experience with HU... 1 of the two times poor attitude in cabin staff. Rough handling of my carry on and snarky. Small seats. Poor looking cabin interior . 6 hour delay due to mechanical problems 2 days ago in Toronto to Beijing. Skytrax: they rejected my review, and somehow 77 client reviews seem to give this airline 4.5/5.0 . Something smells funny to me.

0
Wait Guest

I guess the general public perception of 'made in china' products contributed a little to the reaction of some people here. As a matter of fact, the Chinese make a lot of cheap craps, and they also make a lot of high quality stuff, which is often overlooked.

0
Matthew Guest

Just flew Hanian from XIY to PVG. They were wonderful! Brand new 738, full meal in Y on 2hr domestic flight. I don't know that they're five-stars, but I was very impressed.

0
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
4,788,713 Miles Traveled

27,627,500 Words Written

32,315 Posts Published

Keep Exploring OMAAT