The Sad State Of American Award Availability

I’ve long been an advocate for American AAdvantage. Not because I think American as such is superior to Delta or United, but rather because their loyalty program has been a point of differentiation for them.

I’d like to think I’ve been fair to them, and I’ve encouraged people to fly with them because I truly believed in the value proposition of the AAdvantage program. Has the program been perfect? Absolutely not. But I’ve been willing to forgive the shortcomings because of how great the program was otherwise.

One issue I get a lot of comments about is how abysmal American’s award space is on their own flights nowadays. Back in the day American was incredible about releasing award seats on their own flights, by far the best of any US carrier. Years ago I remember there being saver level award space more often than not, in particular on transpacific flights.

That has changed over time, and American has certainly gotten stingier with award space. But I’ve always sort of forgiven that:

  • “Well, American’s elite program is great, so it’s a small price to pay.”
  • “Who wants to fly American longhaul anyway?” (at least when they used to have their old product)
  • “As long as we have good partner redemption costs, who really cares what international award availability looks like on American metal?”

But now that the program is being devalued, I think it makes sense to revisit American’s award availability for their own flights. I’ve searched a vast majority of longhaul routes for travel in 2016, all the way up to when the schedule opens ~11 months out.

Perhaps the most jarring example of how bad American’s award availability has become is evident when looking at space over the Pacific (to Asia, as well as the new flights to Australia and New Zealand). For all of 2016, American doesn’t have a single saver level first or business class award seat on a single flight over the Pacific. Not. A. Single. Seat.

American-Awards

And that’s looking at all routes to Auckland, Beijing, Hong Kong, Seoul, Shanghai, Sydney, and Tokyo, over a period of ~10 months. At some point you almost have to wonder why they publish saver level award rates for their own flights when that space doesn’t exist.

American-Business-Class
There’s not even saver award space for travel in American’s old business class across the Pacific

It’s sort of sad when you get to the point where Delta can be used as a poster-child for releasing awards on their own flights. Just to give an example, Delta has saver level business class award space on their own flight between Los Angeles and Shanghai almost every single day ~10 months out.

Delta-Awards

That’s just one example, not that Delta is generally great about awards. But fundamentally I take issue with an airline virtually never making saver level award space available in a market. Like, not even one seat a day, or even a seat a week, or a seat a month, or a seat a year…

When British Airways devalued their award chart recently they made a guarantee to Executive Club members, that they’d make two business class and four economy class seats available for awards when the schedule opened:

We guarantee that more than 9 million reward seats will be available on our flights this year, with a minimum of two Club World/Club Europe and four World Traveller/Euro Traveller reward seats on all British Airways operated flights that are offered for sale on ba.com (excluding subsidiaries and franchises).

These minimum guaranteed reward seats will be made available 355 days before the flight and will remain available, if not booked, until 45 days before departure.

British-Airways-A380-Business-Class
At least British Airways guarantees business class award space

Not that the airline is great with award space in general, but I think that’s a fantastic “promise” to make, which gives people an incentive to try and earn points in the program.

In fairness to American, they do have some award space in 2016 to Europe and South America. It’s not great by any means, but at least there’s some.

Bottom line

Personally I still don’t view American’s lack of award space on their own flights internationally as a huge loss for the most part (perhaps except for the new flights to Auckland and Sydney, which I’m excited about), since I’m not dying to take them.

But there’s also something I find disingenuous about publishing a saver level award chart for travel on American but not allocating any seats to that inventory.

Do you have an issue with an airline consistently not releasing any saver level awards in advance across dozens of routes?

Conversations (102)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Juan Guest

I wish I had better news. There are still no save award level seats available over the pacific for the next 7 months! I got tired and stopped searching once I hit September. Its ridiculous. I was platinum for over a decade and now switched to United as of Jan 1st of this year. I should have switched sooner! I have been upgraded to first (complimentary) in 9 out of 11 flights with UA since then. I would not have even been upgraded once with AA since I was not Exec. Platinum. I have 200K miles to burn, but no availability to use them. SO LONG AA, you will not see me on any of your flights for a very long time, if ever again! Oh, an the availability in UA is miles ahead of AA. And when there is space, I can actually fly direct, and not through 3 different cities like AA makes you do to go down to South America.

0
‼ 0
Jay G Guest

Saver awards to South America are ridiculous... AA has a direct flight from LAX to GRU on a 787. When you search for this itinerary, they will send you LAX - IAH - MIA - GRU. Basically to get from anywhere in North America to anywhere South America in less than 3 legs, they're forcing you to book at anytime award levels. Looks like this is the case for pretty much any destination at this point. Even if you can find them, saver awards are useless. It's a joke.

0
‼ 0
T. Hayes Guest

I understand that AA is in business to make money and to please their shareholders. For a while these priorities will probably work, because what can any of us do about it. I suspect, however, that someone in the market will figure out that they can also make some money by appealing to the hoards of disaffected AA patrons. I renounced AA once before when it looked like they were going down the tubes and sticking us on decrepit planes that would scarcely have been acceptable in third world countries. Then came the rollout of their new AA, with bunches of shiny new airplanes on the horizon. So, back I went with a new AAdvantage credit card. Now this. OK guys, it's the old "fool me once shame on you, fool me twice shame on me." I don't think so. I am always willing to give some consideration to a person or a company if they are having a hard time, but seem to genuinely be making an effort. But, as evidenced by these many responses to this issue, it seems perfectly clear that AA has not one whit of responsibility to those of us who purchased their product. I, for one, will no longer be doing business with them and will look for some way to dump my largely meaningless AA miles. Won't happen overnight, but it will happen. AA won't change because of anything I do, but there may be a groundswell here that ultimately AA and its bottom line will not be able to avoid. Question is, will it be too late for AA? Big guys have gone down before!

0
‼ 0
Cassandra Guest

I've been loyal to American for a decade (since I started to travel frequently), and have been Exec Plat for nine out of the last 10 years. I live between NYC and London so travel this route at least every eight weeks. Since the merger, not only have saver awards tickets on American disappeared, so has the ability to advance confirm VIP upgrades. I find the latter especially frustrating, since there's no option to use them on partner airlines even if you would be willing to suck up additional surcharges. With the plan moving to mileage accumulation by amount spent rather than distance flown in the middle of this year anyway (a model European airlines have been doing for a while), the inability to book VIP upgrades and saver awards on American leaves no reason to stay with AA that I can see. I'll be switching to one of the European carriers, who at least offer better lounges with more services this year. I'd rather have a VIP upgrade than a 15 minute express facial at LHR. But, hey, I'll take what I can get.

0
‼ 0
evan torch Guest

All of this will be moot in 2 years or so. When I can get on Delda and get first class RT domestically for only a few dollars more than Comfort Plus, the end is near for all perks at all levels. The raffling off of empty FC and Bus. seats means that soon the major airlines will make these premium seats pay something rather than nothing! So the whole system will come tumbling down; the only question is what lies and deceptions the Big 3 will try to palm off.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published