Questions and Answers

Have a travel related question? Post it here, and I’ll do my best to answer it as quickly as possible.

While anyone can comment on regular blog post, registration is required in order to post a question in this space. Creating your account is free, and you'll be able to see when your question is answered, as well as like comments from other users. And of course, you'll earn status points for offering helpful answers!

This space is intended to be more of a community as well, so please jump in and share tips!

Filter by:

British Airways Avios Awards online cancellation


How to plan a specific trip and get the right points


What happened to LH and LX premium award space???


Recouping taxes if you fly thru LHR on award miles but don’t leave the terminal


Disappearing Lifemiles awards


Large Increases in Award Costs in Delta Skymiles


Cashing in Ultimate Rewards Points Instead of Transferring Them – Am I Missing Something?


Emirates downgraded flight


Alaska Airline Miles – British Airways First Class


ANA Mileage Club – Can’t book a ticket for my partner?


Ask a Question

Everyone can read and comment, but you must login to post a new comment.

Answers (5)

Air Canada or United Mileage Plus?

Air Canada or United Mileage Plus?

  1. cate banfield

    This is a great – thanks so much for the information.
    I have been a loyal Air Canada Aeroplan member for years (live in Toronto) and travel almost extensively with them for business for the past 10 years. However moving to a new job I have to use United almost exclusively now. That said – is it worth me staying with Aeroplan or switching in 2017 to United Mileage Plus? The issue is the new rules that combine the ticket cost with either # segments or # miles flown. Most of my flights are on lowest economy and flying within the US so my question….what is the best program to join to maximize my pointsso I can use for upgrades as often as possible. I do have a few International flights a year which I try to book on star alliance partners.

    One positive – I do put all my business travel T & E (except for my flights) on my personal credit cards so I do spend approx $2000-$2500 p/ month that I can collect points on.

    Big thanks

  2. David W

    If you’ll be flying UA often enough to get any kind of elite status, it might be smart to credit to UA so that you may get some complimentary upgrades. However, you’ll be subject to UA’s revenue based program, earning miles per dollar spent on the ticket, excluding taxes and fees.

    You could continue to credit to Aeroplan but since you are buying cheap economy tickets, I would check the fare class and see how many miles the flight would earn you before making a decision.

    Lastly, Singapore may be a good option to credit to but again, check fare class and earning rates first as some cheap econ tickets earn no miles with SQ

  3. PhatMiles

    For expensive short haul flights, UA wins. In other cases Aeroplan Vs SQ comes in to play.
    If you have status with Air Canada, think about a status challenge with UA. Crediting to SQ doesn’t get you any upgrade though!

  4. MidSouthSkier

    But keep in mind that Singapore miles expire after 3 years, even with activity in your account. See Frequent Miler’s post: [URL][/URL]

  5. Cal

    Are you trying for elite status as well? Keep in mind that there are changes to Air Canada Altitude for 2017. The introduction of Altitude Qualifying Dollars (AQD) means that you have to spend from 3000CAD (Prestige) to 20000CAD (Super Elite 100k) on AC or AC codeshare flights along with the mileage requirements.

Sign in to help answer questions.