Major Starbucks Rewards Changes: Devaluation, But With Elite Status!

Starbucks has announced major changes to its Starbucks Rewards loyalty program. While I can’t say I’m some diehard Starbucks fan, or that this is directly airline or hotel related, it’s still a major loyalty program, and it’s interesting to see the changes…

New Starbucks Rewards Stars earning & elite status

The new Starbucks Rewards program will launch on March 10, 2026. The first thing to note is that we’re going to see the reintroduction of elite status. Up until 2019, Starbucks Rewards had elite status, but then it was eliminated, in favor of everyone receiving the same rewards.

With these updates, there will be the Green, Gold, and Reserve tiers. Gold status can be earned when you rack up 500 Stars in a year, while Reserve status can be earned when you rack up 2,500 Stars in a year.

Gold members earn rewards 20% faster than Green members (1.2 Stars per dollar spent), Stars don’t expire, and they also have a longer window to use their birthday treat. Reserve members earn rewards 70% faster than Green members (1.7 Stars per dollar spent), and they receive an elite card. Elite members also receive access to more double Stars days.

While members ordinarily earn one Star per dollar spent, members have the ability to earn more Stars by digitally reloading their Starbucks card — you can earn 10 Stars for a $30 or more digital reload, and 25 Stars for a $50 or more digital reload.

When it comes to redeeming Stars, redemption options are largely remaining the same, with a new option to get $2 off any item for 60 Stars.

Here’s how Starbucks Global Chief Brand Officer Tressie Lieberman describes these updates:

“We’re redefining the industry with customer-focused benefits that set a new standard and ignite fandom. Starbucks Rewards has always been about creating connection, and we’re evolving the program based on what our members told us matters most, offering faster, more meaningful benefits that make them feel appreciated. This evolution is a key milestone in our Back to Starbucks strategy and will reinvigorate what it means to be a Starbucks Rewards member.”

Starbucks Rewards changes are a devaluation for most

While Starbucks is marketing this as a major transformation of the program that members should like, in reality, I’d argue that this is simply a devaluation for most Starbucks Rewards members.

Why? Well, under the current system, you earn one Star for every dollar spent, and you can earn an additional Star per dollar loaded onto a Starbucks card. In other words, in the end, you can earn two Stars per dollar spent on a Starbucks purchase.

Under the new system, Green members can earn at most 1.5 Stars per dollar spent, Gold members can earn up to 1.7 Stars per dollar spent, and Reserve members can earn at most 2.2 Stars per dollar spent. That factors in the standard Stars earning, plus the ability to get up to 0.5 Stars per dollar loaded onto a Starbucks card (if loading in increments of exactly $50).

Beyond that, I’d say the changes are fairly minimal, and aren’t too meaningful. The company’s loyalest customers will have 30 days to redeem their free birthday treat, which is kind of funny, because those are the people who probably don’t need such a long window for redeeming, given how much they spend at Starbucks.

Meanwhile the new ability to redeem 60 Stars for $2 off any purchase isn’t exactly a great deal, since you could get more value per Star with the higher tier redemptions.

Bottom line

The Starbucks Rewards program is being overhauled as of March 10, 2026. While the company is touting the changes as “delivering more meaningful value, personalization and engagement to members,” I’d argue that’s not quite the case.

Base members are having their Stars earning potential cut by a minimum of 25% (assuming you reload Starbucks cards). Even members of the new Gold tier will earn less than before, while only Reserve members come out ahead.

From a marketing perspective, I do think it’s smart to have elite status, to keep people on the “hamster wheel” and spending. However, I wish that didn’t come in the form of a devaluation for a majority of the membership base.

What do you make of these Starbucks Rewards changes?