London Heathrow Air...
 

London Heathrow Airport Third Runway: The Saga Continues

68 Posts
16 Users
0 Reactions
911 Views
Posts: 41116
Admin
Topic starter
(@lucky)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago
[#17470]
wpf-cross-image

For nearly 20 years, there has been talk of London Heathrow Airport (LHR) getting a third runway. It’s recommended by the government. Then it’s approved. Then it’s blocked by a court. Then it’s approved again. Then it’s blocked again.

Continue reading: London Heathrow Airport Third Runway: The Saga Continues

Share your questions, experiences, and thoughts below.


67 Replies
67 Replies
 E39
Diamond
(@e39)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 323

I wonder how much emissions could be reduced by not needing planes to do holding patterns waiting for landing due to congestion. I hope they get their 3rd runway


Reply
(@AeroB13a)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 3894

Ben, your assessment of the LHR third runway is spot on. The rumbling and rumours are no closer to a conclusion than they ever have been.
There are those who consider that it is essential for the future prosperity of the country, while others fear the population increase locally.
One thing that most people agree upon is that while GB is a signatory to the European Court of Human Rights, the EU intervention will prevent any expansion at LHR.
The EU wishes to exclude GB from any future gains expansion might bring.


Reply
 John
(@John)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 1040

Flip flip Labor. When the other mob were in power, Labor harped on about the rights of newts, voles and red-legged frogs not to be disturbed by an expanded airport. Now that the newts, voles and frogs have cast their votes, Labor is free to ignore them again. Typical Labor.


Reply
(@Nasir)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 141

@Ben
"Even if we see a proposal now, and then a tentative approval, you know there’s going to be endless litigation, and a judge somewhere along the way who blocks something. Then if there’s a change in political vibes, the project will be scrapped as fast as it started. At least that’s my take…"
This is spot on Ben. I couldn't agree more.


Reply
(@Vikram)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 29

Atlanta will get a 6th and 7th runway before Heathrow gets a 3rd runway.


Reply
Diamond
(@creditcrunch)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 657

If the massive infrastructure project HS2 which was railroaded through despite judicial reviews, green campaigners setting up tent city’s and what seems to be an open chequebook on its spiralling costs is anything to go by then if the government wants something then it will happen especially if the taxpayer on the proposed LHR expansion is not liable as this will be paid for by private investment, coupled with a new bill she also mentioned in her speech to effectively stop blocks and judges from stifling developments it will move forward but at what pace who knows.


Reply
 John
(@John)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 4

Part of the opposition is that the runway would not only displace many homes but also destroy a historic town with many old buildings and that alarms many preservationists and historians. I would agree with the article that this probably is not going to happen.


Reply
Diamond
(@uncleronnie)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 1309

There have been 2 Labour and 2 Conservative governments over the last 30 years and only 2 Large Infrastructure Projects completed in that time: Channel Tunnel & Crossrail. Shameful.

Every successive Government in the UK does everything they can do NOT build anything, from roads to schools to hospitals. I expect Heathrow Third's Runway to follow suit.


Reply
(@chris w)
Joined: 6 years ago

Posts: 392

They've waited about 8 years too long to try and get this approved.

It should have been a post-Brexit boom to put the UK "back on the map" but now, with sustainability so much more important than a decade ago, it will never happen.


Reply
(@chris w)
Joined: 6 years ago

Posts: 392

Another factor standing in the way is that BA strongly oppose the third runway as it would increase competition at the airport with more carriers allowing more flights.


Reply
Diamond
(@uncleronnie)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 1309

Meh, almost all of those 1000 homes were bought up by speculators a decade ago when the runway was looking like gaining traction, displacing the families who already lived there. Most of those houses are now rented out to workers from the London area who commute into the City / airport. Now those owners are just waiting for Heathrow Inc to come to along with a chequebook.


Reply
(@AeroB13a)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 3894

Thank you for your assessment UR, you are basically right of course, except for one important fact. In reality GB has not enjoyed a truly Conservative government since Margaret Thatcher.
All none Labour governments since she was deposed by the wet, weak John Major have been, in reality, LibDem affairs.
Only a Reformed Conservative Party under the leadership of Nigel Farage can call themselves Conservative.


Reply
(@AeroB13a)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 3894

Absolutely, BA an EU centric conglomerate.


Reply
(@Yang Jin-Hong)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 30

We'll have GTA 6 before LHR's 3rd runway groundbreaking


Reply
Diamond
(@uncleronnie)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 1309

Farage's Reform Party is the BNP is disguise. Waaay further Right than any true Conservative Party. And no-one ever listened to the LibDems, even when they were sharing power 🙂


Reply
 Wa
(@Wa)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 35

Problem then is you'll have even more planes in a holding pattern. Think of it like a freeway in houston or atlanta. Just one more lane I promise.


Reply
(@ScottF)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 11

The thing is, they don't need to build a full length 3rd runway, if they built a smaller runway that just handles smaller planes such as 320's and 737's it would free up so much capacity for the other runways and wouldn't require such a vast mega project.

Do that, add in another runway at Stansted along with improved fast connections into central London and you can get the same result for 1/3 of the price.


Reply
(@Walter)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 35

What you could do that wouldn't have quite the impact is if you put a rail chord to the southwest of the airport for people from Guildford, Southampton even Bournemouth. This in turn means you could get rid of the car parks to the north and convert them into a 320/737 length runway and use a back loop for taxiing.


Reply
Diamond
(@stogieguy7-2)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 298

Personally, I think that the idea floated here regarding a more modest 3rd runway is probably the most logical and best way to "split the baby" here. That said, one issue not really discussed here - that could doom this proposal politically - is the current housing crisis in the UK....particularly acute in Greater London. Accommodations are very limited and what is available is very expensive. The idea of taking 1,000 dwellings out of the market is bound to create outrage right now, even if there are mitigation plans already drawn up.

And this is in addition to the usual NIMBY crap that makes such projects challenging to begin with.


Reply
Diamond
(@uncleronnie)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 1309

A short runway for narrowbodies doesn't increase available slots for widebodies from the ME. 1/4 of Heathrow is owned by Qatar Corp.


Reply
Diamond
(@neogucky)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 179

IMHO it would be nice to have a third runway, how often do I find flights that are marked with the "find your own freaking way from LCY to LHR", so annoying.


Reply
(@Andrew H.)
Joined: 4 years ago

Posts: 108

As long as The Pheasant stays I’m good with it!


Reply
Diamond
(@cirrus)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 76

Or the next Game of Thrones book.


Reply
(@AeroB13a)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 3894

One is aware that many so called conservatives (LibDems wearing blue rosettes) have long forgotten what true Conservative politics are all about.
Some might consider NF to be too right wing, however, he is a true British patriot and a Conservative, he is a long way from the BNP.
Sadly, far too many so called conservatives have moved unwittingly into the LibDem domain.
GB needs a true Conservative Party, LHR needs a third runway. Possibly the only way LHR will get that runway is if a NF led government gave the green light?


Reply
(@Mark F)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 98

The longer you wait, the more difficult and expensive the task becomes. IMO, the gov't should make a last maximally concerted effort to get the third LHR runway built. If they fail, drop expansion of LHR and prioritize another airport with less opposition to expansion to replace LHR as the regional superhub...or even start with an entirely new airport removed from the population center but with a nearby rail line that can be upgraded to support high speed access to London. This endless cycle at LHR is madness.


Reply
(@vlcnc)
Joined: 10 years ago

Posts: 558

Expanding Heathrow makes no sense. Gatwick is right there and is better suited for this.


Reply
Diamond
(@uncleronnie)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 1309

Getting to Gatwick from anywhere besides South London, Surrey and Kent is a PITA.


Reply
Diamond
(@uncleronnie)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 1309

"or even start with an entirely new airport removed from the population centre but with a nearby rail line that can be upgraded to support high speed access to London"

Is that you, Boris?


Reply
(@Mark F)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 98

Even a blind squirrel finds an acorn now and then. 🙂


Reply
 AA
(@AA)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 93

Yay...lets make the uk even more London-centric, when you still can't even get to LHR by rail from large parts of the country without heading into London and doubling back on yourself.

This is like building the second largest airport in the UK right next to the first, and it is going to get so much resistance (again), not least from the useless mayor, and the loony militant climate idiots (see: just stop oil), it is not going to happen. Again.

See you in another 20 years when it is still being argued about... and hey, there is always Boris Island to argue about again afterwards (which won't happen either).


Reply
Diamond
(@engel)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 95

Build it big. Build it deep. And put in some good restaurants for once.


Reply
(@AeroB13a)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 3894

MF, your suggestion is not as outrageous as many might think and over the decades several alternatives have been suggested.
For example, FAB is requesting flight extension times and alternative aircraft types, etc. Some contend that there is scope for major expansion, however, no local small ‘c’ conservative party MP would dare to even think about supporting such a move. NIMBY’s rule the roost hereabouts.
Many do not believe that the south east is suitable for much more air traffic expansion, loony Labour on the other hand want to be spiteful by imposing more and more south of London.


Reply
(@Dusty)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 974

The older I get, the more I dislike this idea that everything should be preserved for future generations. Sure there's old buildings and a "historic" town, but other than just being old, what's special about any of it? What differentiates it from the thousands of other historic towns and millions of old buildings in the country? This is the line of thinking that has San Francisco preserving parking lots and stick-built Sears catalog homes from the 1930s.


Reply
(@Briggykins)
Joined: 8 years ago

Posts: 18

Really is incredible the amount of things people like to blame on the ECHR. If this gets stopped it'll be NIMBYism that stops it, not the ECHR. Mind you I'm more optimistic than I have been for a while that it might actually happen.


Reply
(@vlcnc)
Joined: 10 years ago

Posts: 558

Not really, very easy by train from anywhere in London which run 24hrs, 7 days a week. I live in North London and have no problems getting there.


Reply
(@bigjinla)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 575

I moved to Longford in 2022 so I could be closer to Heathrow. I love being able to leave my house and walk to Terminal 5. It only takes 15-20 minutes. But a THIRD RUNWAY?!! Are you crazy. Can't we just have a little peace and quiet? People from all over the world think they can just takeoff and land over my quiet little neighborhood whenever they want. I won't stand for it. I won't stand for it. The third runway will cause me a negligible amount of additional noise pollution. Not in my back yard. Sorry! Fly out of Gatwick.


Reply
(@EP150)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 9

This is part of the proposed Heathrow Southern Railway project, with the goal to connect with the SWR at Woking. Agreed that it would be huge for rail access from the SW and should be contingent on any third runway scheme.


Reply
 Pete
(@Pete)
Joined: 10 years ago

Posts: 1588

But the United Kingdom IS London-centric, and has been for centuries. There's no escaping the primacy of the capital, and there's no escaping from the fact that Heathrow is the most convenient airport for the bulk of travelers arriving in the city.


Reply
 Pete
(@Pete)
Joined: 10 years ago

Posts: 1588

Ugh... It's like a Narita/Haneda transfer, only considerably more irritating.


Reply
 frrp
Diamond
(@frrp)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 396

The climate nonsense needs to stop being used as a reason for it to not happen tho.

Also the area around heathrow is an absolute hole, knocking it all down would improve it tremendously.


Reply
 frrp
Diamond
(@frrp)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 396

Gatwick is a nasty cheapo airport tho.


Reply
 frrp
Diamond
(@frrp)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 396

youll have all of them before that absolute embarrasment that is HS2 is finished.


Reply
 frrp
Diamond
(@frrp)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 396

This is the absolute number one reason for having a third runway.

Anything that decreases BAs monopoly would be great because it would force them to not be such a crap airline.


Reply
 frrp
Diamond
(@frrp)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 396

What historic town? Hounslow and the area around heathrow is a horrid area, like an absolute dump of a place. Its long since been taken over by ppl who have no interest in keeping the area looking nice.


Reply
(@AndrewP)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 18

I am not sure this UK government could build the simplest of Lego sets so this is so unlikely. I have a feeling this is just a distraction to make it look like the chancellor is doing something other than trashing the UK economy.

However, expanding Heathrow makes sense to me but is there not the potential to use nearby RAF Northolt as the third runway and lino it to Heathrow via a tunnel similar to how T5 is linked.

I do like Heathrow and prefer it for changing (I live in the north of England) than either CDG (much improved over the years) or the ever worsening Schiphol (why do I always seem to land on THAT runway?)


Reply
Diamond
(@uncleronnie)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 1309

You answered your own question: Northolt would mean planes would taxi for 20 mins like they do at Schiphol.


Reply
Diamond
(@concordeboy)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 1226

Just so ya know, GTA 6 is due to be released September of this year..... 😉

https://www.indy100.com/gaming/gta-6-release-date-trailer-leaks-rumours-map-news-2671019224


Reply
Diamond
(@concordeboy)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 1226

if they built a smaller runway that just handles smaller planes such as 320's and 737's it would free up so much capacity

That's 1970s thinking. Today's widebodies don't use any more runway for their average segment length than narrowbodies do.

787 can easily do 8hrs off of 2000m/6550ft, which is more than enough for all of the Middle East, and even northern India.

Restrict the runway more than that, and you start penalizing the 739s/A321s out there, making it just as difficult for all but the most modern narrowbodies (A220s) or high-powered inefficient birds (A319s/73Gs/7M7s)


Reply
(@vlcnc)
Joined: 10 years ago

Posts: 558

It's not. It's a pretty decent airport and with another runway, I imagine that would mean redevelopment of the terminals too. Gatwick also needs a runway more as it's the busiest single runway airport in the world.


Reply
(@Jack Martinez)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 3

The pent-up demand for a third runway is such that, upon having slots formally open, would exhaust 100% of the. Capacity right away. The temerity is that they need 2 runways today and, in another ten years (when the runway is finally competed), an additional one.

All of the other London airports have just one runway each. As they are privately owned enterprise, the concept of big giantess adding traffic, noise, and pollution prevail. If they were government owned, there would be greater demand for not standing in the way of progress. So it looks nicer to add another airport (which happens to have a runway), than to build another runway. Each airport takes up a massive amount of urban space that would be better suited for other purposes.

This is the problem with Labor!


Reply
(@David)
Joined: 4 years ago

Posts: 55

It's not Hounslow - it's Harmondsworth that would be flattened to make way for the third runway. Plus it's likely that BA's HQ at Waterside would also need to be flattened.


Reply
(@David)
Joined: 4 years ago

Posts: 55

I don't see the third runway as the optimum answer to the problem. The UK needs better connectivity between LHR and the UK train network (south, west and north) to release slots currently used by UK domestic flights, a second runway at Gatwick to provide extra capacity (note NZ is likely to recommence flying from LGW rather than LHR due to slots), better connectivity between LHR and LGW (Cross Rail to Thameslink with a change at Farringdon is currently the fastest way), a review of LHR night time landing restrictions, and more A321LRs and XLRs flying from MAN, BHX, GLA, EDI!


Reply
Diamond
(@mike-c)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 454

Let me get this straight, you can walk to T5 so everyone else now has to take a flying jump? If you move to Luton and use the airport there, the rest of the world could get on with making Heathrow worth using.


Reply
Diamond
(@phillip)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 316

With or without the railway link, the plan is to move all the parking off site to multi story constructions and use electric vehicles to bring people to the terminals. This was to minimise concerns from local authorities concerned about an increase in road traffic locally.


Reply
Diamond
(@phillip)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 316

The government is supporting a second runway at Gatwick too. So this should put to bed all the arguments that expansion should be elsewhere. Airlines want to fly to Heathrow, full stop.


Reply
(@Fulmar)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 13

I wrote my politics degree thesis on a third runway and alternates to Heathrow- in 1973


Reply
(@Barbarella)
Joined: 6 years ago

Posts: 188

Only T4 is really a headache but if you decommission it or assign it to LCCs and build a new terminal between the current complex and the new runway it would be fine.


Reply
(@EP150)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 9

Old Oak Common station is going to help with the doubling-back issue, at least…


Reply
(@Jay Deshpande)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 127

Also, the third runway would run through the Harmondsworth/West Drayton area, where BA's Waterside headquarters is. Considering it was just opened in the late 90s, it doesn't serve their interests to flatten the building and set up shop elsewhere (it's a beautiful building, by the way. Been there personally).


Reply
(@Barbarella)
Joined: 6 years ago

Posts: 188

Let's be honest a hub only works by having both long haul and short haul connectivity + OD demand. This way all markets are funneled in one place. The failure of NRT in Tokyo is a blatant example being too distant from the city center while lacking onward connectivity what it has in capacity vs HND.

There is value in the UK managing to be the gateway to Europe while being out of it, leveraging London's attractivity, and be a strategic platform to connect major Indian cities to a granular number of US and Canadian cities (which ME3 struggle to do). But that requires 1 efficient hub with 3 runways (or 4 like CDG) and strategically located terminals.

The better package would be to add at least a runway each to LHR and GTW close LCY to scheduled flights, close LTN, STN and SEN altogether and improve national connectivity to the 3 remaining airports (express local trains for up to 2 hour journey and subsidized air service from the rest of the country).

Sell that as an overall infrastructure project. This will give an incentive to Virgin to develop as a full carrier increasing competition and business, LCCs will have space to grow in GTW and the lower fares from increased competition can fuel some added airport taxes esp. in LHR international connections to make it worthwhile long term to the British. The Brits are business savvy and the Nimbys don't weigh that much when you tally the votes, the issue is that people that are not at all disturbed by LHR expansion are against it because they feel it's all for London once again. The project is good, the package lacks some lubricant.


Reply
(@usukhkflyer)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 39

Would be sad to lose the 17th century pub in Longford village. A quick walk from the Premier Inn Terminal 5 / Thistle and so much nicer than their own bars, plus you get to commune with airport employees in a historic setting.

I agree with those that say there are other ways to achieve growth. Heathrow isn't convenient for anyone not in West London. Expand the other London airports and make it easier to fly overseas from major other UK airports to not constrain London.


Reply
Diamond
(@uncleronnie)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 1309

@Barbarella: "close LTN, STN and SEN altogether"

DON'T YOU DARE!! I use LHR and LGW specifically so that I don't have to share an airport with a billion Ryanair oiks! Those N / E London airports keep them out of my sight for a reason.


Reply
Diamond
(@grayanderson)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 217

So, when the whole lawsuit was going on a few years ago I honestly don't know why the government didn't just start prepping a report to drop in case they lost (or even just run it before the case). "Fine, here's the report weighing that, we still consider it acceptable, now get lost." I suspect they might have just stripped the requirement if the government had held a functioning majority prior to 2019 (the case resolved in 2020, but at that point there was...a lot on their plate all of a sudden).

Remember, the notional grounds weren't "the expansion is illegal" so much as "the government didn't weigh X concern they're required to weigh", and I suspect it would have been an effective slap at some of these campaigns that use grounds that don't /technically/ bar a project from happening to stop it. I suspect this time it'll be a lot harder to make that stick because all it would (probably) take is a whipped motion exempting the airport expansion from the Paris Climate Accord priority to sink any lawsuit, and the government can lose an absurd number of MPs to the opposition lobby (or nearly half their caucus to abstentions) and the vote would still pass.


Reply
Diamond
(@grayanderson)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 217

Honestly, if they paired this with something to significantly improve connectivity between Heathrow and Kings Cross/St Pancras and Euston (or direct rail connections to the north), the environmental case for pushing folks to bigger planes out of a single airport is probably there. Then again, the politics would be a mess but strangling RyanAir and EasyJet with APD would probably also more than offset the emissions issues (even if it killed one or two of the other airports).

To be fair, I think the "right" answer was to drop a new airport out by Milton Keynes, connected to the WCML and/or HS2, and start consolidating there...


Reply
 JSS
(@JSS)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 1

Let's be honest, LHR was built 96 years ago. Any muppet that moves near airports or under flight paths know full well that noise is a consequence of aircraft movements (the same can be said for the NIMBY's who complain about Sydney Airport as well.....and many other airports that have been around a long time) If you move near an airport suck it up and stop complaining, and governments need to start ignoring the idiots who do.


Reply
Diamond
(@grayanderson)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 217

Now, now...this is why you have multiple terminals and why HEX has First Class 😉


Reply
(@Jay Deshpande)
Joined: 3 years ago

Posts: 127

Well they can ignore those so called "NIMBYs", but that ignorance will only last till they lose their seats. Also, where did West London sign up for a third runway that will end up demolishing a number of villages? It is in the interests of Heathrow to maintain a cordial relationship with its neighbors. This is no way to do it. Clearly you have no idea what it's like to live under the flight path.


Reply