Let me think about this.
Nah.
Might be of value to note that North American carriers were all pretty late adopters of three class cabins. “First class” (besides Panam) in the U.S. always seemed to be akin to the business class products in Europe
I mean, the Delta One Suites on the A350s are basically a flying Pullman roomette and D1 has dedicated security at JFK and LAX. I'd like more consistency of product (i.e. DL cycling out some of the 767 configurations), but I'm not sure how much you can "really" improve on that
This article is almost overwhelmingly from European airlines’ — in particular Air France’s — perspective. There’s almost no discussion of Gulf or East Asian airlines.
This article is almost entirely from European airlines’ — in particular Air France’s — perspective, perhaps because of the transatlantic market, which alone drives a lot of US-origin premium traffic. There’s almost no discussion of Gulf or Asian airlines, which is surprising, given how Emirates and (among East Asian airlines) JAL, to some extent also SQ, continue to lead the way in offering a world-beating F product.
I don't expect US carriers to follow your advice, Ben. Part of the reason is a large number of hubs and not all of them have the same level of demand for very expensive fares. Beyond that, though, business class is much better than most of the now defunct first class cabins whose loss you bemoan. Many of those services were recliner seats, not lie flats, and most (if not all) of them lacked direct aisle access for all seats. Could business class be better? Sure but for most of us, it is very good, especially as compared to the back of the back of the bus. And, most of us will never be able or willing to pony up that kind of money anyway.
The bottom line: if carriers can get back the investment required to install first class seats, deal with scheduling the planes only on certain routes, and still make money, we might see it. Otherwise, we won't.
I'm not one who can justify to myself the cost of a revenue long-haul FC ticket, but I can see why some people might. Like US airlines, Qantas offers fewer first-class cabins than in the past, and they are absent from newer jets. They currently offer 14 F seats on A380 flights to LAX, DFW, LHR, JNB and SIN from Sydney.
First is coming back on the new A350-1000ULR aircraft slated for their flagship Sydney to New York and London non-stop routes, with six seats. Those aircraft will also operate some other routes. I doubt Qantas decided this lightly.
I've flown first on QF12 from LAX (on points, quite a lot of them), and the difference from J was noticeable, I can see why people would pay for it, and I would repeat (for points). On my flight, the cabin was full. Looking at the next few months, award F seats to and from the US are not unicorns, but they are not common. There are none available on QF1 to LHR or SIN.
I suspect there's going to be a halo effect from these extreme long-haul flights, and a second from them offering first class. What that will be worth remains to be seen. Whether QF or the US3 have made the better business decision also remains to be seen.
And that's the problem - if the price differential is minimal, then what is the cache for the target audience? Anyone can rent a limo for the night, and that's why a stretch Lincoln TownCar is now considered crass 😉