Air Canada Axes Its...
 

Air Canada Axes Its Longest Route, From Vancouver To Singapore: What Gives?

48 Posts
20 Users
0 Reactions
3,313 Views
Posts: 41118
Admin
Topic starter
(@lucky)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago
[#20220]
wpf-cross-image

Air Canada will end its Vancouver to Singapore flight in 2027, just under three years after launch. Here's why its longest route is being cut.


47 Replies
Posts: 206
Diamond
(@proximanova)
Member
Joined: 2 years ago

It’s sad that SQ and AC have both come a cropper with regard to YVR-SIN service. Meanwhile UA is going very strong indeed with its double-daily SFO-SIN services… And bear in mind that UA and SQ are about as friendly in the Star Alliance as QF and QR are in Oneworld — in other words, they’re sworn enemies! Is SFO (or SEA, which DL will use as its gateway to SIN) that much more lucrative than YVR?!


Reply
2 Replies
Diamond
(@watson)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 554

A family of four in SF making less than $156,650 is considered low-income, so yes.


Reply
Diamond
(@funkyflapjak)
Joined: 4 months ago

Member
Posts: 87

lol @ asking if SFO is more lucrative than another city


Reply
Posts: 1226
Diamond
(@concordeboy)
Member
Joined: 5 years ago

Not surprised.

I managed to get my hands on a load sheet of theirs, and it wasn't uncommon for them to block 30+ seats in the dead of winter. Presumably, that was justifiable in 2005, but not so much at today's fuel prices.

I also wouldn't be surprised to see the route return once AC receives their A350s, which would be far more capable on the route, and also spread the per-seat costs a bit better... assuming that SQ doesn't return and reestablish the route in its own right.


Reply
2 Replies
(@Parnel)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 226

AC, will not have these 350s till 2030s, and they will be likely high density so they won't be flying to SIN.
AC needs lots of economy passengers to fill it's planes and SIN isn't that market.


Reply
Platinum
(@immortalsynn)
Joined: 12 months ago

Member
Posts: 123

"and they will be likely high density"

Where has Air Canada said that?


Reply
Posts: 85
Diamond
(@baliken)
Member
Joined: 5 years ago

Flew this route earlier this year. I would rather take almost any Asian airline with a stop than fly AC. It is most than just about price. Even UA Polaris is better from NA to Singapore, either nonstop or with NH.


Reply
2 Replies
Diamond
(@parnel)
Joined: 4 years ago

Member
Posts: 174

AC has become a budget airline, so it's difficult to make money flying to SIN if you don't have premium passengers willing to pay. Also for customers willing to pay "premium economy" Singapore has had crazy deals for two years because they have too many PE seats on their special flights from EWR and JFK.
Also SQ has all the connections to Asia, and AC reliability is pathetic which impacts connections.


Reply
 Tom
(@Tom)
Joined: 2 months ago

Posts: 1

I totally agree. At least in eco, meals are tiny. Crew often rude. Definetely prefer SQ, TG or CX. Come to think of it, I'd rather fly Ryanair 😉


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 1974
Diamond
(@1990_)
Member
Joined: 3 months ago

Looked up AC19, YVR-SIN, 16ish hours, which, like the SQ/UA LAX/SFO routes, usually flies up to Alaska then down over the Pacific (west), unlike SQ21/23, EWR/JFK-SIN, which often flies east over the Atlantic, Europe, the Stans, etc., since polar routes aren’t as much an option these days due to Russia and China. I presume from NYC flying up and west to Alaska then down is farther, longer, more fuel, etc. And yet, the return, SQ22/24, SIN-EWR/JFK, goes east up and over Pacific. Kinda interesting, if you’re into that stuff.


Reply
3 Replies
(@Vinod)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 80

SQ35/37 do not go anywhere near as north prior to the TPAC as you indicated. Personal experience as well as looking up flight aware. It has always been pretty much a straight crossing once you take off from LAX. At times, the flights get close to SFO before starting the TPAC.

Maybe I am wrong, but this is what I have experienced.


Reply
Platinum
(@immortalsynn)
Joined: 12 months ago

Member
Posts: 123

"SQ35/37 do not go anywhere near as north prior to the TPAC as you indicated."

Yes they occasionally do, it depends on multiple factors, mostly weather.

I take that flight multiple times per year, and we've been almost as high north as the Aleutians at 17 hrs 30 minutes, and almost straight across re-dispatched over Manila at 15 hrs 40 minutes.


Reply
Diamond
(@1990_)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 1974

I see what you mean, yeah, really straddles the equator. That's a lot of time over the Pacific. Must be bumpy with all the hurricanes and typhoons this El Nino...


Reply
Posts: 36
Platinum
(@seat1a)
Member
Joined: 2 months ago

Flying an ultra long haul flight is very different in reality than on a route map in a boardroom. It’s worth comparing United and how it manages to operate two daily SFO-SIN flights, despite SFO being even farther from Singapore than YVR. Presumably the strength of United’s SFO hub and the connecting traffic it can feed onto those flights makes the economics very different. Sometimes the viability of a 17 hour nonstop flight has less to do with the two cities at either end than everything feeding into them.


Reply
1 Reply
Diamond
(@concordeboy)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 1226

It’s worth comparing United and how it manages to operate two daily SFO-SIN flights

UA didn't *WANT* to have 2 daily SFO-SIN flights. They started with one each from LAX and SFO. The problem is that their 254 tonne 787-9s just do not have the payload-range to reliably fly LAX-SIN westbound, yearround, without unsustainable restrictions. They were routinely blocking more than 6 rows during the winter, while still going out at FVL.


Reply
Posts: 1368
Diamond
(@maxpower)
Member
Joined: 3 years ago

Fuel price is the likely and obvious answer to why the route was cut but I am curious what's happened to AC US-based flow traffic over the last year as the saber-rattling escalated.
i.e. if it's gone up or down.
I'm not suggesting MAGA people are the bulk of their US-based customer set -- I highly doubt that -- but there is increased friction that I'm curious how that's impacted AC.

We obviously already know that far fewer Canadians are visiting the US.


Reply
Posts: 518
Diamond
(@peter_)
Member
Joined: 10 months ago

Obviously they heard the rumor that AA was considering LAX-SIN and decided to immediately axe the route.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 2837
Diamond
(@travelinwilly)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

"Vancouver’s geography is impossible to beat for Asia flying."

Truth. Vancouver has some history as a jumping off point for trans-Pacific flight; CX used to fly SFO-YVR-HKG back in the days where SFO was their only US destination. I flew this route in 1988 back when CX was still using the 747-200s (the 400s weren't introduced to scheduled service until the following year); back then there were five rows of first class, with a smoking "section" in rows 4 and 5, and then another small FC cabin upstairs. Soon thereafter CX got the -400s and started nonstop service to HKG from the US west coast. One can see the seating chart here https://frequentlyflying.boardingarea.com/vintage-airline-seat-map-cathay-pacific-boeing-747-200b/ (note the missing over wing doors 3R and 3L, to allow for more seat density).


Reply
6 Replies
Diamond
(@funkyflapjak)
Joined: 4 months ago

Member
Posts: 87

damn willy you're old as hell dude


Reply
Diamond
(@bradstpete)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 646

@Willy; I well remember the CX SFO-YVR-HKG. Was a travel manager in SFO back in the day and took that journey a couple times.


Reply
Diamond
(@travelinwilly)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 2837

@BradStPete

That's really cool! That was my first flight on CX, and I've been in love with them ever since. It was also during this time that their slogan was "Arrive in Better Shape" (I still have my laminated business card with that slogan on it; they provided those in the FCL in SFO), and they boasted about how their cabin crew was comprised of citizens of all the Asian nations to which they flew.

And now I'm going to go down a rabbit hole looking around my place for old PR literature from CX - that's the blessing / curse of being a pack rat. Thank you for the inspiration! 🙂


Reply
Diamond
(@bradstpete)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 646

@travelinwilly Did you live in the Bay Area then ? Thanks for your reply


Reply
Diamond
(@travelinwilly)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 2837

@BradStPete

I lived in Chicago at the time. That particular trip was on a United award ticket (Remember the nascent days of the frequent flyer programs? Yeah, they were really the golden age in many ways.) that had me routed in FC ORD-SFO-YVR-HKG-BKK-SIN on the outbound, and then BKK-HKG-YVR-SFO-ORD on the return, with the two domestic segments being on UA, the rest on CX. All for 100,000 points pp, and I went with another person, so the entire jaunt cost 200,000 points. These were also the days before 1K was a thing, so Premier Executive was the highest status one could achieve. For the awards, there were basically no capacity controls at the time, so if one found a awards one liked, it was bookable. On this trip, the intra-Asia segments were on the L-1011s. I loved that plane.

Ask more questions! I'm enjoying this trip down memory lane! 🙂 🙂 🙂


Reply
Diamond
(@bradstpete)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 646

@travelinwilly OMG Loved the L10 !!! Not only as pax but I flew for Pan Am for 2 years and would work the L10 from time to time. I was primarily on 74's but the TriStar was a joy to work as well.


Reply
Posts: 606
 RF
Diamond
(@rf)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

It's unfortunate to lose this transpacific non-stop.


Reply
Posts: 71
(@Parnel)
Joined: 2 years ago

What gives?
First, AC is a terrible airline, economy is really bad, premium is not all that premium, and business is barely passable.

Maybe it doesnt matter for a short transatlantic when business has virtually zero service, food is terrible, and flight attendants are nowhere to be found, but that ain't gonna work for a longhaul and flights with decent competition.

Don't forget AC (laughably) tried flying to IST and competing with TK, then DOH competing with QR. Those ended rather quickly


Reply
3 Replies
Diamond
(@joeblonik787)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 34

I'm curious: which North American carrier would you say is better than AC? IME, they're the best of a bad lot...


Reply
 Anna
(@Anna)
Joined: 8 years ago

Posts: 167

United Polaris is better to SIN.
United has Economy Plus whereas AC has a few bulkhead seats.

And then of course are the plethora of Asian choices with a stop to break up the journey


Reply
Diamond
(@baliken)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 85

UA Polaris. And they have a string partnership with NH so for those wanting a connection in Tokyo or Osaka (which we use frequently) they can fly US to Jaoan and then hop on NH for the rest of Asia. UA and AC service and food may be similar. Seat and bedding on UA is much better.


Reply
Posts: 1
(@Guest)
Joined: 2 months ago

Not sure why it was started in the first place?

Both Singapore Airlines tried it twice and now Air Canada.

I feel the planning department saw, rich country, more passengers?

Why not go to Kuala Lumpur for not budget carrier connectivity?


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 4
(@kreative)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

A lot of things failed for it. Its load factor was 60%. It never released award space within reasonable value. Then theres the competitors. You can fly from SEA to SIN direct on singapore airlines. Singapore was more or less the same pricing but more of a layover.

Being star alliance, doesnt seem there was much alliance at all.


Reply
1 Reply
Diamond
(@concordeboy)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 1226

Being star alliance, doesnt seem there was much alliance at all.

And (so far as SQ goes) there isn't.

SQ does not have an immunized revenue-sharing j/v with any of its North American Star Alliance partners, and thus still views them as direct competitors (which they are).

Heck, they only even bothered to codeshare, relatively recently, with United. United's mileage cannot be used to redeem premium seats on Singapore for any transpacific nor transatlantic flight as well.


Reply
Posts: 1
(@orcabill)
Member
Joined: 2 months ago

This flight is a grind, especially in ecomomy. AC best in North America, is not setting the bar very high. Give me a layover to SIN, stretch the legs, get a decent meal. You can get 2 tiks for 1 value flying another carrier into Bangkok or KL instead of AC, where customer service is job #5.


Reply
1 Reply
Diamond
(@baliken)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 85

I will, and do, take Polaris over AC J class pretty much anytime I can. AC is not the best on long haul international in J class. The UA/NH codeshares are quite good.


Reply
Posts: 31
(@james)
Joined: 8 years ago

On September 17, CFO John Di Bert told investors at Morgan Stanley's Laguna Conference that they were looking at capacity cuts as fuel was exceeding the point where they could recover on fares, and gave examples of long-haul Asia-Pacific flights being under consideration for reductions.


Reply
Posts: 39
 ross
(@ross)
Joined: 4 years ago

We'll see how Delta's SEA to SIN goes when they start the service next year.


Reply
3 Replies
Platinum
(@immortalsynn)
Joined: 12 months ago

Member
Posts: 123

Delta has not said that the route will be from SEA, nor have they said that it's starting next year.

All we know, is that they intend to fly to SIN at some point, and likely not from LAX.


Reply
Diamond
(@concordeboy)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 1226

Delta has not said that the route will be from SEA

Delta has been very weirdly coy about where they intend to fly this from.

Like you said, most bloggers and AvGeeks are assuming Seattle, but they've never actually said this. Esposito has just said "not LAX."

Makes me wonder if they may surprise us with something completely out of left field, like flying it from New York. Their 283tonne A359s could do it with no problem, as could A35Ks if they take them at a high enough MTOW.

But then again, DL's still not bothered flying Tokyo nor Seoul out of New York, so there's that.

DTW is still an option. The two highest yielding longhauls in DL's entire network (per Cirium y.e. 4Q25) are both from DTW to Asia.


Reply
Platinum
(@immortalsynn)
Joined: 12 months ago

Member
Posts: 123

"Makes me wonder if they may surprise us with something completely out of left field, like flying it from New York."

Or more disappointingly, watch them fly it as a 1-stop through Narita (like it was before) now that they're serving that airport again.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 184
(@Davisson)
Joined: 14 years ago

Vancouver and Singapore spent have much business demand. Even for folks in Toronto, there are better one stop solutions. And leisure visitors going to south east Asia has many options to choose from.

Seattle and Singapore has more business demand which might be sustainable.


Reply
Posts: 184
(@Davisson)
Joined: 14 years ago

Vancouver and Singapore doesn’t have much business demand. Even for folks in Toronto, there are better one stop solutions. And leisure visitors going to south east Asia has many options to choose from.

Seattle and Singapore has more business demand which might be sustainable.


Reply
Posts: 21
(@YYZPhil)
Joined: 7 years ago

We did Vancouver to Singapore on Singapore Airlines before they cancelled the route and Air Canada picked it up: https://youtube.com/watch?v=cXbWm9uobGs

But Singapore Airlines at least had onward connecting traffic. If SQ couldn't do it successfully, how could AC?


Reply
2 Replies
Diamond
(@jordan-2)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 330

AC connections through YVR?.


Reply
(@YYZPhil)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 21

From what we saw on our SQ flight, the connecting traffic originated in Vancouver and connected through Singapore.

YYZ has much more interesting connections to connect to or through Singapore, like UA1 in San Francisco (which I flew twice in 2018), or Tokyo, or Seoul or Taipei. WS flying to Japan from Alberta is the real experiment, and I'm glad that's continuing.

Also the Singapore Dollar is way over par with the Canadian Dollar now. When I first travelled to Singapore 20 years ago it was a lopsided difference and Singapore was a better draw for tourism. I can see AC serving BKK directly as a business case in comparison.

If SQ can't do it with its premium product, why can AC with its weird pretzel sticks?


Reply
Posts: 28
 ERIK
(@ERIK)
Joined: 6 years ago

VERY BLUNTLY : THERE IS NOTHING LOST .AC IS AT THE BOTTOM OF THE BARREL WHEN PUT UP AGAINST THE ASIAN CARRIERS. END OF STORY


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Page 1 / 2