Been in the lounge a few times since the reopening in November 2023 (I am based in Johannesburg). I was ecstatic that the 3rd party lounge was not an option anymore!
Agree that it feels typical Emirates, but also in a way that is what I expect. The moment you walk in you know you are about to fly EK.
Regarding the food - I reckon the food is of fantastic quality and standard.
Just look at the beef - perfectly medium the way it should be (I suppose with it being in SA they will always be to a good standard). The other options are fabulous too. Often a local-inspired curry as well.
The staff are also amazing. While I agree a barista or barperson would be great, the staff are veryhappy to keep on replenishing your drinks (they never say no! Another typical SA service I reckon) and even make something on order.
And of course, the very good South African wines are always of high quality and vintage.