- The Disruption: Our EVA Business Class award tickets (YYZ–TPE–SIN) for Oct 24 were cancelled. We tried to call the hotline but got no response for 3 hours.
- EVA's Stance: We went to the Carlton St. office at 8:30 AM. The agents refused to rebook us onto any Star Alliance partner flights, claiming they cannot process rebooks on mileage award tickets to other airlines.
- The "Offers": They could only offer non-guaranteed waitlists (for economy) for Oct 23 or 25. The Oct 23 option required an uncompensated overnight transit in Taipei during the typhoon. They also flatly refused Toronto hotel/meal care, citing weather.
- Our Mitigation: To avoid being stranded indefinitely on a waitlist, we spent ~ $9,500 CAD total out of pocket to buy Singapore Airlines Premium Economy tickets home, which forced an unexpected overnight transit layout at Newark (EWR).
Hi Ys0410,
First off, so sorry you had to deal with this nightmare. I'm just a fellow frequent flier who has dealt with more than a few of these situations myself. I think you did your best under the circumstances. Glad you made it eventually. Adding insult to injury, your road to recovery here may take many more months and a bit of effort, but I think you have a good shot. Thankfully, Canada has decent consumer protections. While not perfect, the Canadian Air Passenger Protection Regulations (APPR) are better than the near-nothing we have in the United States. Because your itinerary originated in Canada, you are indeed covered by those protections.
When EVA refused to fulfill their Section 18 duties and left you stranded with no confirmed options (only non-guaranteed economy waitlists past 48 hours), you exercised proper and legally recognized "self-mitigation." Under APPR Section 18(1)(b) and CTA precedent (e.g., Lajoie v. Air Canada), when a carrier fails to fulfill its statutory duty to rebook, the passenger is legally entitled to purchase alternate transportation to complete their journey, and the carrier is liable for the reasonable replacement cost. Buying Premium Economy on Singapore Airlines was a reasonable decision; in fact, since your original booking was in Business Class, opting for Premium Economy demonstrates you actually downgraded cabin class to minimize mitigation costs rather than wildly overspending.
In order to enforce those regulations, you're going to need to file a formal demand letter (Article 18 Reimbursement Claim). Submit a written claim via EVA Air’s online feedback portal (and send a formal copy via certified mail to their Canadian regional headquarters, if they ignore you). Include something like: “Due to EVA Air’s failure to provide confirmed rebooking within 48 hours pursuant to APPR Section 18, we were forced to secure alternate commercial transportation home (YYZ–EWR–SIN via Singapore Airlines) at a total cost of $9,500 CAD.” Also attach itemized receipts for the Singapore Airlines tickets, proof of the original EVA ticket cancellation, and a detailed timeline of your visit to the Carlton St. office. If (let's be honest, 'when') EVA ignores you (wait at least 30 days), or if the airline offers only an insultingly low travel voucher instead of a cash refund, escalate by filing a formal air travel complaint with the Canadian Transportation Agency (CTA).
Keep it simple at first. If EVA actually tangos, they'll likely throw more silly excuses at you. Please don't allow EVA or any airline to get away with any of this. A confirmed ticket is a contract of carriage. Blaming the 'award ticket' was a bad excuse. Once an operating carrier cancels a ticket (cash or miles), their re-accommodation obligations apply equally; federal APPR regulations supersede internal carrier tariffs or Star Alliance alliance rules. On their attempts to just blame the weather (deep sigh), while weather can excuse Section 19 monetary delay compensation for inconvenience, weather never extinguishes Section 18 mandatory rebooking and duty-of-care obligations. Even for a typhoon, if they can't rebook you on their own metal within 48 hours, they are legally required to put you on any available carrier. Force majeure is yet another cop-out here. Don't accept their excuses.
Simultaneously, since you mentioned having a travel insurance policy (hopefully a comprehensive policy, not just a basic one with a credit card; but still, anything is better than nothing), file a trip interruption claim. Explain that the primary flight was cancelled outright, no reasonable alternate routing was provided within 48 hours, and buying replacement common-carrier transport was the only way to complete the interrupted trip. Provide screenshots of the full EVA flights, the typhoon weather warnings, proof that no confirmed business or economy seats were available for days, and a written statement showing EVA refused Section 18 interline rebooking. Explicitly inform the insurer that a formal APPR Section 18 claim has been served to EVA Air. Insurers should pay out under trip interruption policy clauses, and then they subrogate against the airline directly. Filing with insurance doesn't waive EVA's liability; it ensures immediate relief while subrogation handles double recovery. If all goes well, good insurance will likely pay out faster than EVA. Of course, some insurers are... let's say, 'difficult.'
Your scenario is yet another example of why we need meaningful air passenger rights in all jurisdictions (especially the US, where we have few to none). Even in Canada (and Europe) where they have better protections, foreign carriers often treat compliance as optional because enforcement is not immediate, takes manual effort, filing complaints, etc. Until regulatory bodies impose automatic rebook-on-any-carrier rules at the point of disruption with statutory fines for delays, airlines will keep mistreating us and mostly getting away with it.
Anyway, sorry to go off-the-deep-end here. Personally, I care about these types of situations, and recognize they happen more than folks would like or are willing to admit. (Ignore the shills and corporate apologists that occasionally frequent sites like these; they'll try to blame you, which is absurd; it's as if they never get impacted by this stuff. Psh.) I've been burned more than a few times. You win some; you lose some. Don't let it stop you from traveling again. If you feel you need 'professional help' you can sue the airline (even represent yourself in small claims court, which some may advise), but it often costs more than its worth (time and money); besides, then you're a persona non grata with that carrier. Let's not let it get to that point. Ideally, these steps above should get you some results. Rooting for you to get that $9,500 CAD back! Keep us posted on how it plays out.
He's not the only one. My friend was completely abandoned.
His confirmed flight IAH-TPE disappeared from his reservation record (his onward flight to Tokyo remained). He called them more than 30 times over two days without being able reach anyone and they never reached out to him.
You and I have frequently posted each other on OMATT and I find you one of the few with anything useful to say but I have to question your comment regarding suing the airline. I've not heard of any retribution on an airline's part as a result of having been sued. Do you have experience with this occurring?