This is a comment on an old post, I know, but I'm hoping Ben or someone who knows might still see this.
"simply add all of your accounts to a single online log-in, and then you’ll automatically see your points total for all of your accounts listed there." This did not happen for my Wife's account.
Sometime in the past year we successfully combined all her Amex cards/account into one single online log-in but it seems her Amex MR Points are still separated by card. She has something like 227,000 tied to one Amex Biz Platinum & Biz Gold card and then she has another 201,000 tied to a different Amex Bix Platinum card for a different business. ALL cards show under her single login, though.
Is there a way to get all these points combined? We're not crazy about paying 3x $895 for our 3 Biz Platinum cards (including mine) so will probably cancel at least one of hers. We don't want to lose those points, though.