Thai Quarantine Hot...
 

Thai Quarantine Hotel Sues Man For Complaining, Accusing Him Of Defamation

20 Posts
10 Users
0 Reactions
138 Views
Posts: 39871
Admin
Topic starter
(@lucky)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago
[#11950]
wpf-cross-image

Thailand has some pretty wild defamation laws. Last September an American man living in Thailand was arrested and sued for defamation after leaving a negative review of a hotel online. Well, something similar is happening once again, except it involves a quarantine hotel.

Continue reading: Thai Quarantine Hotel Sues Man For Complaining, Accusing Him Of Defamation

Share your questions, experiences, and thoughts below.


19 Replies
19 Replies
(@Dick Bupkiss)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 298

He travels during a deadly pandemic that's raging worldwide, when all public health authorities urge people to NOT travel. Check.

He goes to a developing nation. A hot, humid, tropical place where things like bugs and fungus are common nuisances. It's not like he has no knowledge of Thailand, so none of these facts should be a shock to him. Check.

Stays for free. Check.

This guy got what he deserved. He's lucky that he hasn't (yet) caught the virus.

The pandemic continues to rage because idiots refuse to take it seriously. Here's a perfect example.


Reply
(@greg237)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

@Dick Bupkiss Man, you must think you're the smartest person in the world. Hurr durr "hErE's tHe pErFeCt eXaMpLe." You have no idea why this dude traveled, maybe it isn't for essential reasons, but maybe it is. Judging from his name and his post in Thai, I'd say he's Thai, so it'd be more likely that he had a legitimate reason for traveling. Plus, Thailand isn't doing as badly as the US in terms of COVID.

Even if it isn't the best time to travel, this is still unacceptable.


Reply
Diamond
(@endre)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

@Dick Bupkiss Your name fits That place is worse than a Russian prison.


Reply
 Ann
(@Ann)
Joined: 8 years ago

Posts: 151

Could have been worse. He could've been put up at a Sheraton.


Reply
(@kalboz)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

@Dick people travel at times due to necessity for whatever reason and thus there is a scheme such as the ASQ in Thailand (14-days mandatory Alternative State Quarantine). With population of around 77 million people, the kingdom currently has 83 Covid related deaths. Where I live (Orange County, CA) with population of around 3.25 million, we have nearly 3,800 Covid related deaths so far! Where would you rather be?

@Ann the two Sheratons in Bangkok (SGS & ROS) are some of the best hotels in the Marriott system, especially the SGS. The ROS offers spectacular riverside views and location. Both offer full breakfast at the restaurant as a Platinum amenity - at the ROS is breakfast by the river! But neither is an ASQ property.

Although all hotels should adhere to a minimum standard of sanitary and health requirements, that traveler got what he paid for. For our ASQ quarantine, we had an awesome stay at Le Meridien Bangkok: https://www.flickr.com/photos/kalboz/albums/72157717358138887


Reply
Diamond
(@david-7)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 1024

Baffling how the hotel can claim he’s lying. So did the man bring a worn out door and cockroaches from the USA, through security somehow, just to plant it quarantine hotel so he can defame them? If not, then the cockroaches must have been found in the room, since he’s under quarantine and can’t procure them anywhere else.

Seems like the only ones lying are the hotel.


Reply
(@Craig)
Joined: 13 years ago

Posts: 66

Please do not confuse Thai defamation laws with U.S. defamation law, where truth is a defense. While truth is a defense under Thai defamation law, it's application is limited.
From a Thai legal website: "the accused shall not be allowed to prove the truth of the statement if (1) it concerns personal matters and (2) proving the truth of the matter shall be not be beneficial to the public."
While the argument certainly could be made that he would not be barred from proving the truth of his statements under those 2 limitations, who knows how a Thai court would rule.


Reply
Gold
(@davistev)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Looks like a typical 1-2 star Thai hotel to me.


Reply
 Jose
(@Jose)
Joined: 6 years ago

Posts: 1

@ Greg you wrote "You have no idea why this dude traveled, maybe it isn’t for essential reasons, but maybe it is. Judging from his name and his post in Thai, I’d say he’s Thai, so it’d be more likely that he had a legitimate reason for traveling. Plus, Thailand isn’t doing as badly as the US in terms of COVID"

As you told other don't know the reason why this guy was travelling to Thailand, but on the other hand you said more likely this guy with a legitimate reason travelling to Thailand because he is a Thai. Really? This is the IQ level you have? You are such a hypocrite, you told people don't assume but you assumed. Many people travelling back to their own country doesn't mean they have to but just wanted to see their families instead, I see some people are doing this.....Also, this guy knew that he would be quarantined for 14 days and he had an option to choose pay for better hotels or free, he has the right to displease the condition of the free hotel but why complained if he chose not to pay?

You even said "Thailand isn’t doing as badly as the US in terms of COVID" Please and please don't even use the US as world standard, you are making me laugh. We all know how the US are corrupted and messed up for many things, handling covid just one of many examples because of the government and the people their.


Reply
 T
(@T)
Joined: 6 years ago

Posts: 18

Jose, none of us know why he traveled, but your post is rude and unnecessary. I suggest you read both Greg's post and your own back to yourself once you've calmed down.


Reply
(@experienced-traveller)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

We have been travelling to Thailand twice a year for 20 years and staying in budget hotels, there are many which do not meet western standards , but as one person said above , ''you get what you pay for '' . In usual circumstances , we either look and preapprove our room before paying , or only pay one night and then rebook for longer .....but with quarantine that is impossible .


Reply
 Jose
(@Jose)
Joined: 6 years ago

Posts: 1

@ T .... When you asked me to read Greg's post may be you should talk to yourself before you are trying to judge me. I suggest you to read Greg's and your post back to yourself again and again before you even open your mouth again and read it again when you have a cleared mind.

We knew no one knows why this guy travelled but the first sentence Greg wrote in his post was "you must think you’re the smartest person in the world", and then went on criticizing people for making an assumption and then he made an assumption afterward. Did you get it?


Reply
(@George Andrews)
Joined: 6 years ago

Posts: 2

For God's sake,please,please stop using these idiotic filler phrases:
1 Having said that..
Did you really say that??
2.To be honest.
3.Honestly
4.Frankly.
Either stop lying or just be honest without saying having said that..


Reply
Diamond
(@paolo)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

I don’t know Ambassador Jomtien but assume it’s part of the same group running the Ambassador Bangkok: in Sukhumvit 11, for a brief period in late 70s, early 80s it was one of the smart hotels. Then went into major decline/ cheap group market. These past 2 years it had been undergoing a massive, top-to-bottom renovation. Soi 11 has had some resurgence in the hotel market...at least pre-covid...with the convenience of Nana without the in-your-face stuff of Soi 4.


Reply
 Ron
(@Ron)
Joined: 8 years ago

Posts: 6

Clearly it was a smart choice to escape from the mess in the US and fly to his home country where this covid thing has not been hyped up and has been dealt with effectively, with low to no infection rates and just a few deaths.
The hotel is utterly disgusting for any budget and the guy was right to expose it.


Reply
 Win
(@Win)
Joined: 6 years ago

Posts: 1

It’s not free government pay to the hotel and Thailand people have to pay tax for this.


Reply
(@rtbones)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Several unknowns here, and a few knowns:

1) We dont know why the gentleman traveled.
2) We dont know implicitly whether or not the gentleman took his complaints up directly with the hotel staff, or if he did, when. If he did, we dont know the hotel's response at the time.
3) We do know he chose the free option vice the paid option
4) We dont know if, after seeing the room in person, he had the chance to either change rooms or change to the paid option
5) We do know that if the pictures are accurate, the accomodation indicated therein does not appear to meet most western standards.
6) We do know the gentleman chose to take his argument to social media
7) We also know the hotel appears to disagree with his post or others like it, to the point of taking legal action.
8) We dont know if the gentleman has taken his issues up with the Thai government or its agencies, the entity requiring the quarantine.

So what are our take-aways?

1) If you travel during a pandemic (whatever the reason), be prepared for quarantine, testing, or whatever else the government of your particular destination may require.
2) In such a circumstance, if you have the chance to pay for a required quarantine or services such as testing and choose a free option instead, caveat emptor.
3) If you have a complaint and take it to social media vice other direct options (to the hotel itself, the destination government, police, ombudsman, whatever), do not be surprised if there is some pushback.


Reply
 Bill
(@Bill)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 620

Plenty of countries better than Thailand to go to. While the guy took the free option there should certainly be minimum standards. You know a clean room without fungus and roaches? Now they are trying to sue him? Go somewhere else. Not some place that throws you in jail for negative reviews or saying something negative about the king.


Reply
 Nn
(@Nn)
Joined: 6 years ago

Posts: 1

I saw the hotel’s facebook page posted Dunyawit’s facebook profile picture with his full name and writing a status “please contact us” for 3 days and deleted a post yesterday after many people complained their actions. I cannot understand what are they thinking.


Reply