Review: 13” Macbook...
 

Review: 13” Macbook Air

30 Posts
5 Users
0 Reactions
198 Views
Posts: 39955
Admin
Topic starter
(@lucky)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago
[#604]

Back in my freshman year of college my laptop broke on a US Airways flight (actually, it was crushed in the overhead bin, but thats a different story) and I had a project due the same week. As a result I headed to Circuit City the following morning and bought the cheapest laptop they had,…

Continue reading: Review: 13” Macbook Air

Share your questions, experiences, and thoughts below.


29 Replies
29 Replies
(@The Points Guy)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 10

I got the 13" air and love it. I used to want an iPad but now I see no reason since I don't travel without the Air.
Quick ? - how do you protect it when you bring it as carry-on? I have a jack spade cover, but still worry about it getting messed up.


Reply
(@aanswer)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

@ The Points Guy -- definitely get the iPad. Get an old / gen 1 if you can get it. I've been using it since the first day it came out. Movies on an iPad + Kindle App = airplane awesomeness.

@ Lucky -- I have the 11" Air and it is stunning. Worth the investment.


Reply
 Sam
(@Sam)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 633

You know, they allow you to bring books on planes Lucky...might be an interesting alternative to 30 Rock 😉


Reply
(@heather)
Joined: 11 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

@ The Points Guy -- Totally agree with you about the iPad, just now worth it when you have an Air, in my opinion. I actually don't use any sort of protection, even though I should. I just slide it in the sleeve in my laptop bag.

@ Aanarav Sareen -- I don't see the points in an iPad when you have an Air. The reason I love the Air is because it saves me so much room in my carry-on, so having an iPad would only take up more room.

@ Sam -- Wuts a buk?


Reply
 Mike
(@Mike)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 3

My IBM ThinkPad X40 runs about 8 hours at a time as well. You just put the computer to sleep rather than shutting down and it will "boot" in about 15 seconds.

Oh, I bought it in 2004, and since then I just bought a new high capacity battery and an SSD drive for about $150.

I like the Air but the inability to really upgrade or even replace the battery is a deal killer for me. Lenovo recently announced an ultraportable that supports something like 15 hours of battery life. They have convertible tablets as well for those that sometimes want a tablet but usually need a laptop (I'm not going to argue that it's a great tablet).

For most people, laptops work fine until their operating system gets flooded with junk and slows down and/or their battery dies. In most cases a $50 replacement battery and a re-install of the OS would give the device another 2 years of life.

I like Apple products for things that I plan on replacing every couple years, but not for a major investment. Their track record of not even trying to support old hardware and the battery issue are just too much.


Reply
(@Jonathan)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 15

I am waiting for the next generation Macbook Air to come out later this year. They are suppose to be upgraded with the Sandy Bridge processor which will make it faster. I have a Macbook Pro but will retire it for the Air.

The Air is an excellent laptop for the frequent traveler.


Reply
(@Carlos)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 48

Hey man just like to recommend some nice Mac Applications for you since you may not know them yet... :

Cinch (Really nice keeps windows organized)
Cram (Studying App)
ImageShack Uploader (Batch upload images)
Dropbox, and then make sure to look up Dropbox Encore for Mac

Then also there are all the apps on the "Top 10 Mac Apps" list that you find on Google...


Reply
(@discopapa)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Once you go Mac, you never go back.


Reply
(@steven)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 1

I've heard in the past about Apple laptops having compatability issues with certain software.

There has always been this perception in my head that it would not be a good computer for work and home. (i work in finance, building financial models most the time). I have this perception an apple laptop as being a great thing for photos, artistic stuff, and surfing the net, but not so good for getting work done, like using MS excel and stuff.

Am i wrong? Is it a good work (business type work) computer too? No compatability issues?


Reply
(@Leonard)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 26

I have a MB Air 13. I love the size and portability, I hate the fact there is no backlit keyboard. I don’t understand why they took it away since it was on the first generation.

Yesterday I ordered the new Samsung series 9, it is actually a little light than the MB air and has the same slim design, it has a backlit keyboard. I am not a fan of Samsung and would prefer to keep the MB but the keyboard is not acceptable. I hope I am not disappointed when I get it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8js41Cj0hqI

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=35535


Reply
(@Chris)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 2

@steven: Microsoft makes Office 2011 for the Mac. With Parallels Desktop, you can run any Windows application on your Mac. I use it to run KVS Tool, and it works great.


Reply
(@Brian)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 1

Lucky, did you get the student discount from macmall? If so, could you please give me some details about it? Thanks!!


Reply
(@Hermann)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 23

In terms of size and weight, the MB Air is probably the best out there (forget Netbooks). I (have to) use a Mac at work and privately a Thinkpad X201 (9hrs of battery life) with docking station. While the Mac is a nice machine, I dont like how you need an adapter for almost anything and you´re so bound to and by apples policies.

In general, although this maybe untypical, I like my setup as Mac for stationary work and Thinkpad for travelling around.

@Steven: xls on mac is quite fine, especially since Office 2011.


Reply
(@Blandon)
Joined: 18 years ago

Posts: 15

@Steven: The compatibility issue doesn't really exist anymore. Even if there's not a Mac version of an application you can still use it. One answer is to get something like Parallels which lets you run Windows within the Mac operating system. Another option is to start up directly in Windows when necessary. Try doing THAT with a PC! 😉


Reply
(@Marshall Jackson)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 59

I absolutely LOVE my MacBook Air. I have the 11.1" version. It's just wonderful in every way. Fits right in a file folder slot in my briefcase.


Reply
 Phil
(@Phil)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 33

@Steve - I will second Blandon's comments. I probably do similar work, running derivative pricing models in Excel all day long. I use Mac running Parallels and have never had any kind of compatibility problems.

The thing I love most about Macs is they are just quick and reliable. When you open up a Macbook in 4-5 seconds you are ready to work. With Windoze pcs it can take forever. And things really do not crash the same (I have found iPad a little more buggy and had some crashes)


Reply
(@Jason H)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 25

I have an old PowerPC mac wheezing along, but I will not go back to Apple for a new machine. I can't stand their policies and their cult like atmosphere. I have moved fully to the Ubuntu distro of linux for my other machines. With a VM or Windows emulator I can run anything I need. I just don't see Apple's computers as a viable solution.

As it is, I have a HP Pavilion dm1 that had 8 hours of life running Win 7 and now has 10 hours running Ubuntu. Not to mention it was so much cheaper than a Mac.


Reply
(@Peter)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 73

Lucky - one word of advice: get AppleCare for it. Use a link through macintouch for a discount from amazon. (only if you bought your mac in the last 30 days).

I've been an apple user forever, home and office, and for the laptops the extra warranty is golden, and apple service is 5*. Pays for itself easily with the slightest problem you may have in 3 years. I've had screens, logic boards, ac adapters and all sorts of other things go bad in various laptops. All replaced, no questions asked.


Reply
(@gomike)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 4

regardless of how cool it seems, $1800 is way too much to spend on any computer for word processing and internet, both Dell and IBM have pimped out laptops for well under $1000.


Reply
(@The Points Guy)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 10

@gomike are the IBM and Dell laptops you are referencing even close to the Macbook Air in size? For me, the greatest appeal is having a laptop that is under 3 pounds, slim as can be and boots up instantly. I only paid $1,299 (less 6% coporate discount + sales tax) for my basic MBA and think its a great value.


Reply
(@SeatedinFirst)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 6

For someone who uses their laptop "for internet, word processing, and photos" isn't a "pimped out" MacBook Air overkill? What's wrong with netbooks? A fraction of the cost and if you get one that runs on Linux it's super quick to boot up.


Reply
(@Peter Y)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 16

I have had the same computer for 4 months and absolutely love it. There is nothing in the PC world that matches it in terms of lightness, speed, and portability.

Note with something called "Bootcamp" you can run Windows 7 on it. Although I installed it and find myself using Windows less and less, since it is pretty much the same thing - Chrome, MS Office, etc.


Reply
 Nick
(@Nick)
Joined: 17 years ago

Posts: 88

It kind of pisses me off that they put an old (how many years?) slow processor in the air because imo they don't want to take market share away from the macbook pro.


Reply
(@mauiUAflyer)
Joined: 17 years ago

Posts: 6

I bought a new 13" Air in late December. I really like it. I have a 13" Mac PB at work, but for going out of the country it is problematic to take the company laptop along. The Air really does boot up/awake from sleep really quickly. I've got a WaterField bag, with a sleeve for my 13" MPB; it holds the Air quite well.

I had read the ArsTechnica review of the 11", and thought it a little underpowered. I'm typically running MS Office, Mail, Safari, terminal, and IDL. I have an iPad, which I love, but for doing serious work while on travel, the Air is a better choice for me. The screen looks great for movies, and unlike my 1st gen iPad, it has a good camera for Skype videochats.


Reply
(@tivoboy)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 39

I picked up this newer version when they first came out and love it. YES, I still use my MBP for some tasks, but the MBA13 goes with me everywhere. I still take the ipad and actually think it COMPLIMENTS the MBA13 very well. I use the ipad for reading the WSJ, magazines, uploading images with the camera connection kit, some games, slingbox, etc. What is another .9 lb, when the air is so light.

I hope they take some of the design and technical elements from the MBA and put them into the new MBP15, that will be my perfect computer


Reply
(@Nadia)
Joined: 18 years ago

Posts: 21

I have two friends that destroyed their air by getting liquid on the keyboard. Not a lot of liquid, but it doesn't take much. One spilled milk and the other water. Warranty was voided and replacement is over $1000.

Please keep your diet coke and lime away from the keyboard. Also, on Amazon you can buy a keyboard protector. I recommend you look into this, one day you will be happy you did.


Reply
(@heather)
Joined: 11 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Thanks for all the feedback and suggestions, folks!

@ Brian -- Macmall doesn't have a student discount, though is priced lower than directly from Mac, especially after factoring in no sales tax The three bonus miles per dollar spent was nice too.

@ SeatedinFirst -- Well, I was kind of scared into believing that the basic version wouldn't be very fast, so I was convinced that the pimped out version would make more sense. While it was pricey, so far I'm happy with my decision.


Reply
(@bschaff1)
Joined: 18 years ago

Posts: 28

Perhaps your Toshiba laptop would've treated you better if you had reinstalled Windows after a few years and cleaned up unused files. With the battery failing, that's something you could've easily replaced, but now you're stuck with a computer you will have to mail to mac to get a new battery that will take a week to get back.

$1800 is overpriced for the hardware your get in a Mac and I find the idea of spending another $200+ on an extended warranty to be a fleecing for something Apple should already cover with a 3 year warranty. Also, it's ridiculous what Apple charges for a computer with 2gb more ram. The part costs $25 yet Apple will increase the price by $500 for the computer.

My current laptop cost me under $720 including upgrading the ram. It has 8gb ram, a much faster CPU, a higher resolution screen, and comparable battery life. Along with that it comes with a 3 year warranty, it can wake up in less than 20 seconds, and the tech support is excellent. I have a Dell Latitude E6410.

I'm not saying you were ripped off, but when you spend $1800 for a computer that's still a lesser system than almost any $600 computer on the market I can't think of what else to call it.


Reply
 Des
(@Des)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 1

@bschaff1

Where did you get the idea that Apple charges $500 for an extra 2 gigabytes of RAM? The price is $100 for 4 versus 2 gigabytes on the MacBook Air.

The base $1,299 model provides more than enough capability for the average notebook user.

@ Nick

At the time the MacBook Air was designed, it was not technically feasible to put an i5 or i7 microprocessor inside the machine. Besides, with the speed benefit of SSD memory, the Core 2 Duo processor is quite satisfactory.

Try using the MacBook Air. You'll be surprised how fast it is.


Reply