American is LITERALLY THE WORST AT CHECKED BAGGAGE.
As James S and Gregg note above, their wait times are utterly unacceptable. They never have bags delivered at DCA in under 30 minutes, and JFK and LAX are even worse. Last year my partner and I flew to LAX and, along with several other first class passengers, waited 40 minutes for the bags to start to come out, only to find that our bags weren't on the conveyor.
Went to the baggage counter and handed the claim checks to the woman standing amongst the hundreds of suitcases, who looked around and said "It's over here!" pointing to our suitcases. I actually told her that it's customary in civilized parts of the world to say something along the lines of "I'm sorry," to which she replied "I didn't KNOW your bag was here until you ASKED me." Which didn't really address anything material at all. The one saving grace was another passenger who literally screamed at the woman. I'm not normally for making scenes, but I'll say that in this case, the person who screamed was screaming for many of us. Actually, thousands. No MILLIONS of us. Can you tell I have feelings on this matter?
Please never do another post on AA and checked luggage. This got me feeling all PTSD... 🙂