(Whispering: I mean, oneworld Emerald’s kinda where it’s at… but, you do you… get a few extra milestone awards… eh…)
I think you meant at least 60k points from $60k spend right? You wrote 30k
As an AS Titanium, I'd say in your case it's not worth it. The incremental benefits of having Titanium over platinum are only going to show up if you fly Alaska with regularity, which you don't. Even having Titanium and flying AS all the time, I only get upgraded 75% of the time. Also the day of departure upgrades to business on the long hauls is nice in theory but if you look at the threads on FT, you'll see they are far from a guarantee (Personally I've only hit on 1 out of my 4 long hauls this year). Enjoy the Plat status and save your spend for something else.
Ben, you mention trying to double dip AS and AA status and you also mentioned the other day on your card portfolio post that you keep the Citi AAdvantage Executive Card pretty much only because it offers access to the Admirals Club. Wouldn't it make more sense for you to pursue OWE with AS (given that you seem to value it greatly) and OWS with a non-US airline (e.g. BA silver) for access to the Admirals Club?
Maybe I'm thinking a bit too basic, but given that you only travel J on longer flights and already have AS OWE, I don't really see how status with AA would provide more value than an AS+BA combo.
I've mentioned on other threads, but I'm personally pursuing the 95k milestone to get access to the 10k status points boosts for 2027. Since you get to pick 2 awards at 95k, I'm hoping I can pick that twice and get a 20k bump for next year. The 125k milestone would require a significant amount of non-bonuses spend for me, and I won't put any of that on the card until 2027.
No.
I'm not seeing a ton of value for Titanium status in your case, since you're not flying a lot on Alaska metal. Since the Global Companion Award is based on the anniversary year, I think it would make more sense to spend the $60K in early 2027 to make it easier to earn Platinum next year.
I’m a Titanium based in SFO. Short answer. Not worth it.
The major incremental advantage is global upgrades. But those are very hard to come by. You have to fly AS metal and get lucky. I’m 0 for 4 this year.
I fly a lot of BA and AY. OWE is more advantageous with lounges especially at Heathrow.
I do get marginally more upgrades on AS domestic metal. But even then. They are selling upgrades till boarding on a declining scale. Selling F class underneath titanium members.
I will hit 150k status points cuz summit card and head starts. I will get the 40k boost for next year. But I said. Stop at platinum and spread it around. SAS is my back up to Europe.
You are in Miami. You ain’t gonna use the global upgrades much. And you don’t fly west much. So AS operated upgrades aren’t much either. Ok you get better chances on AA metal too. But those are even harder to get than AS metal.
1. Ben can earn AS titanium elite status and try it out for himself. He can make it a review article. He can even compare AS top tier elite status vs AA top tier elite status.
2. Ben can do his double dip strategy. He can continue to earn his AA lifetime elite status. Ben should be somewhere between AA lifetime gold and AA lifetime platinum. Ben would probably like at least OWS elite status for life (well, lifetime status as long as the program still exists in its current form).
@Ben, "If I put another $60k in spending on my ATMOS card..." is not something most people can do. More power to you, I suppose, if you can drop $60k in the last two months of the year, but for most of us, that's not a viable or realistic option.
That said, I *do* live in an Alaska hub (the SF Bay Area), and Alaska have been my "carrier of choice" since it was Virgin America. I held top-tier status in their Elevate! program and have never dropped below MVP Gold with Alaska. I have been ATMOS Platinum (oneworld Emerald) in 2026 and have, like you, re-qualified for 2027. But I am semi-retired and do not fly as part of my job, and I qualified on the basis (primarily) of old-fashioned butt-in-seat flying. My goal is *not* Titanium, but rather the 95k milestone. As of today, I am slightly more than 3,000 miles away, and with a trip to DCA next month and JFK in December, I'll qualify with miles to spare.
Is it worth it? Time and time again -- even from you -- I hear that having status is increasingly not worth it. But I've been upgraded to (domestic) First 12 out of 38 flight segments on AS and/or AA. On the other 26 flights I've taken on oneworld carriers this year, I was upgraded to Economy Plus / Extra Legroom seats or whatever you want to call it. That is, I only pay for "regular" Economy and on each and every flight get a seat with increased legroom for myself and my wife.
I am Atmos Titanium and closing in on 300k status points this year. I get upgraded 9 out of 10 times on average, and use the miles I earn to effectively fly for free about half the time (or more). It has made cross-country flying much more enjoyable. I can also rollover 80k miles to next year, which makes Titanium a slam dunk in 2027. In short, it's been worth it.
Thanks for ask the articles.
I have been using the same card and have reached over 95k status points so far. I have the same question.
One thing I can choose, that you didn't seem to have in your article, at that level which is 2 awards that can be 10k status points to be applied next year. This means getting an additional 20k status boost in 2027.
I think getting to 95k is better through Atmos than reaching 80k due to the additional 20k status for next year.
Not sure about titanium.
Not worth it in my book once you are Emerald. Unlike Ben, I already had the 60K spend when I hit Platinum to unlock the 100K companion bonus, which used to get a companion to Asia in business class, but no more.
Now even this bonus has become much less valuable. This year has seen a SAVAGE devaluation of AS miles on the routes I want. NYC to Asia in business went from about 100K miles to 300K+ miles. Mid-Atlantic to Freeport Bahamas went from 7,500 miles minimum to 12,500. I'm likely to revert to focusing on American's program next year.
Why not - go for it. What AA status will you be getting this year - Gold?
The 125K points milestone (the last one before Titanium) has a benefit option of a year of Lounge+ membership. That's a $795 savings. Might not benefit you if you've already got Admiral Club membership, but it's an attractive option.
I'm AA Executive platinum, and I booked a flight on Alaska without using any frequent flyer info. Now it won't let me add my AA #, even though it lists AA as an option. Any idea why it keeps giving me an error message?
I'd agree with some of the other comments. I think OW Emerald is really all you need from AS status since you don't fly AS often. I'm titanium with AS and the incremental benefits are great since I fly them regularly, but for you, I don't think it would be worth it. Higher upgrade priority on AA might help a bit, but I think your AA status is above that. Free meal is a fun perk on AS, but that's only on Alaska metal.
Ben, did you end up getting credited Atmos points for your PAL flights? Class bonus as well?
I've thought about doing this as well, double dipping. But the issue is if you fly AA with any frequency, having EP is incredibly valuable during IRROPS, for getting backed up quickly when SHTF. If you had Atmos Titanium flying AA but without AA status, one would not have access to the quick help desk stuff nor would one be eligible for backup flights, etc. This is kind of the issue with the double dip if you need the status for convenience and reliability purposes, I think. But applause to those who have figured it out!
