IMO, adding KIX is accretive and will only help AS maintain their market lead. PPT is a bit of a headscratcher, but as noted, I suspect it will benefit from connecting traffic/loyalty.
AS is doubling down on their international growth strategies just as they paid the highest cost for fuel in the 2nd quarter among large US airlines and that will likely continue. Using 330s for these routes only adds to their disadvantage. but then UA is using 772s to KIX, IIRC.
as for branding and what might remain from HNL, the chances are high that HNL to KIX isn't profitable but they don't have the available planes are the 330s. The chances are getting higher that they will ditch the Hawaiian brand in a few years because they can't operationally execute on it.
DL failed on SEA-KIX. I think AS has a better chance here, given it is significantly more entrenched in the SEA local market than DL is, but KIX is a difficult market for US carriers and for the Japan based ones as well, when it comes to US nonstops.
