Ouch: Flying Blue M...
 

Ouch: Flying Blue Makes Earning XPs Through SAF 50% More Expensive

43 Posts
9 Users
0 Reactions
603 Views
Posts: 41115
Admin
Topic starter
(@lucky)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago
[#20500]
wpf-cross-image

Flying Blue now charges €15 per XP for sustainable aviation fuel contributions, up from €10, making this route to elite status 50% more expensive and less forgiving.


42 Replies
Posts: 3
(@Romanianflyer)
Joined: 8 years ago

Great development! FF status should be for people who actually, you know, fly frequently! Not for those who buy their way there with SAF or credit card sign-up bonuses.


Reply
10 Replies
Diamond
(@travelinwilly)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 2839

Tell us you know nothing about FF programs without telling us you know nothing of FF programs.

NO FF programs are about flying frequently anymore. They are about $$. The AF program has fit this model for eons, just as the rest of them have. Maybe it's different in Romania.


Reply
Diamond
(@1990_)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 1976

Willy, ironically, TAROM, the Romanian carrier, does actually use FlyingBlue…


Reply
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 821

@Willy , that assertion is plainly ridiculous.

While Flying Blue did move to revenue-based mileage earnings years ago, it used to be pretty good at giving status to actual frequent flyers until the very recent introduction of basic fares. That means you now need 90 segments for Gold as opposed to 36.

There are plenty of frequent flyer programmes that continue to reward frequent flying. If you want to have status for travel on AFKL, you can get Elite Plus with 26 segments a year if you choose to credit the flights to Suma.


Reply
(@Romanianflyer)
Joined: 8 years ago

Posts: 3

I know plenty about FFPs, both as a consumer (holding FB platinum status myself since 9 years) as well as from a business perspective.

Of course FFPs are about earning the airline money through incremental sales, pushing pax to fly more with the airline, or them to buy up to more expensive fares to retain/earn status.

The only thing I'm saying is that - at least in European frequent flyer communities - there is a growing displeasure how airlines are increasingly "giving away" status to anyone who is just willing to pay for it through SAFs or getting a certain credit card. Given that such XP bonuses are like easily 5-10x as big as the ones you get in most European countries, you can imagine the resentment of those who do actually earn status by flying. Especially when you see the lounges getting more crowded each month! Just take a look on the FB board on FlyerTalk and you'll find many loyal AF/KL flyers based in Europe who think like this.

Of course, as Lucky has written many times here, you can't really blame AF/KL and FlyingBlue for this. It's a business, and they want to make money. It's as simple as that, as you also concluded in your comment. However, that doesn't mean that we frequent flyers can't still be unhappy about devaluations, or actually welcome changes that make it harder to attain status through non-flying activities 😉


Reply
Diamond
(@travelinwilly)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 2839

"The only thing I'm saying is that..."

Your entire explanation, thoughtful and thorough, was extremely helpful, and I can now fully understand your (and others') dissatisfaction and (totally legitimate) frustration and appreciate it. Thank you for this and taking the time to articulate it!


Reply
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 821

@RomanianFlyer, I think the main issue is that AFKL (and BAIB, plus the excuse for an airline that's VS) are trying to align themselves to the US market in order to make money from credit card fees. LH and most of the smaller European airlines keep themselves focused on the regional market and that's becoming a genuine competitive advantage in FFP terms.


Reply
(@Jones)
Joined: 5 years ago

Posts: 43

@Throwawayname

“ LH … keep themselves focused on the regional market and that's becoming a genuine competitive advantage in FFP terms.”

Are you saying that after all the comments you made complaining about the 2024 M&M changes and suggesting that you were contemplating jumping ship, you are now, almost 3 years later, STILL carrying on with M&M as your main *A FFP?


Reply
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 821

You're confusing me with someone else (maybe even the impersonator below?).

My comment wasn't related to personal experience. The only reason I even have a M&M account is the ITA Skyteam status match I had done a few years back!

I do fly LH a few times a year within Europe because they go absolutely everywhere but I much prefer TP, TK, and A3 when the route works.


Reply
Diamond
(@1990_)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 1976

Throwawayname, if someone's impersonating you, perhaps, consider registering your username on here. (Add a "_" afterwards if "Throwawayname" is already taken...)


Reply
(@Doudidude)
Joined: 3 weeks ago

Posts: 1

I would somewhat disagree on that. While FB miles are purely based on € spent, the status is still largely based on the flights you fly and the cabin in which you fly. If you fly intra Europe in J, for often 800€ to 1200€ you get 30 XP round trip, a lot cheaper than a Transatlantic (NYC, BOS, WAS) one way ticket in J that will also get you 30 XP. On a given flight you will get more XP if you fly the pricier cabin, but that is not universally true across all € spent.
This said, a few well placed SAF purchases could easily get you a Gold or event Platinum status for even less € spent... I see this more as partially closing a loophole that allowed not so frequent flyers to reach higher FB status.


Reply
Posts: 2839
Diamond
(@travelinwilly)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Was there no notice of this change?

If not, it's quite disappointing, and something to which (one would think) the head of the FB program would have been sensitive.


Reply
2 Replies
Admin
(@lucky)
Joined: 13 years ago

Member
Posts: 41115

@ TravelinWilly -- Correct, no notice was provided. And of course you know how I feel about the importance of providing notice of changes (so that members aren't left wondering if something is a glitch or an intentional change). But I'll of course also let others speak for themselves. 🙂


Reply
Gold
(@daniel-b)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 188

I am disappointed that Tiffany did not reach out to you before this.


Reply
Posts: 4
(@anteo21)
Member
Joined: 3 years ago

While I really don't like the idea of changing the rules without any prior notice (something that, unfortunately, is quite typical of Flying Blue, which has implemented several devaluations without warning), I actually hope they would just remove XP from SAF contributions which would of course almost stop any purchases of SAF as we know that most buy this SAF for XP and not for the environment....

Nowadays, obtaining Elite status through SAF contributions has become far too easy, and let's not forget all status matches that have become quite the norm unfortunately. AF lounges are already overcrowded, and anyone willing to spend enough can potentially reach Platinum without even flying so much on revenue tickets, simply by purchasing award tickets and buying SAF contributions.

At the very least, they could introduce a cap on the number of SAF-related XPs that count towards status qualification.


Reply
13 Replies
Admin
(@lucky)
Joined: 13 years ago

Member
Posts: 41115

@ anteo21 -- I see where you're coming from, but let me challenge you on that for a moment. The people buying XPs to earn status are flying less, so they're not the ones crowding lounges. And if you're talking about people buying XPs to requalify for status and then redeem miles, wouldn't you assume that they're typically redeeming for business class on long haul flights, and therefore already get lounge access?


Reply
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 821

'The people buying XPs to earn status are flying less' than whom/what? Anyone doing 89 or fewer cross-border segments in 'basic' per year won't achieve gold status. Buying XPs isn't worthwhile for those flying every other month.


Reply
Admin
(@lucky)
Joined: 13 years ago

Member
Posts: 41115

@ Throwawayname -- People earning XPs through non-flying means are generally flying less on Air France-KLM than people earning XPs through flying means, based on equivalent status. I feel like that's not a controversial take?

And I'm not sure why you'd claim that those flying every other month aren't buying XPs? I'd say there are lots of people flying Air France-KLM once per quarter who may be buying XPs...


Reply
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 821

From my perspective it's not just controversial, it's borderline misleading.

Earning just 2 XPs per segment means that someone who flies every single week may still fall significantly short of an elite level that gets them lounge access. Having to fly every single week means that the lounge access is worth a lot to them, so it makes a lot more sense for them to spend money for XP compared to the occasional flier.

Are you really claiming that XP purchases are somehow more attractive to those travelling every other month than to those who find themselves in basic every 5-7 days?


Reply
Diamond
(@travelinwilly)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 2839

"Are you really claiming that XP purchases are somehow more attractive to those travelling every other month than to those who find themselves in basic every 5-7 days?"

Yes. If someone is travelling every other month in business or the back of the plane and they want to reach Plat, then yes, purchasing XPs is a very attractive offer indeed - more award seats are available, and LP awards are available, too, irrespective of the value or lack of value one may think it provides.


Reply
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 821

@Willy you've simply answered a different question to the one you quoted. There's no debate about whether the scheme may be attractive to some occasional flyers- it obviously can. The question is about whether it's MORE compelling for them than for someone who's got to travel all the time in Y.


Reply
Diamond
(@travelinwilly)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 2839

Your question is all or none. I answered with "some."

Is it "MORE compelling" for them? The answer is yes, for SOME of them.

Is it "MORE compelling" for the segment hopper? The answer is yes, for SOME of them.

You won't ever have a "right" answer, just your opinion. Just like we all have.


Reply
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 821

I don't disagree with that, but to me it's obvious that the segment hoppers interested in SAF XPs will be more numerous than the occasional fliers and that they will undoubtedly be crowding the lounges more by virtue of flying more often... which is something that Ben doesn't seem to realise!


Reply
Admin
(@lucky)
Joined: 13 years ago

Member
Posts: 41115

@ Throwawayname -- Just so I'm following your theoretical example, you're talking about someone who flies one segment, one way, every week, on a basic fare? So not roundtrip every week?


Reply
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 821

I'm talking about anyone doing lots of short haul in economy, especially if some of it is in basic. If it's all in basic they'll need 90 segments a year for gold, if you take away a couple of weeks for Christmas and 5-6 more in the summer holidays you can literally do a return every single working week and still not get lounge access.


Reply
Admin
(@lucky)
Joined: 13 years ago

Member
Posts: 41115

@ Throwawayname -- Obviously neither of us have access to the data to prove this, since it's not public information, but I think the traveler profile you describe -- someone who flies every week, but exclusively on basic economy fares, and exclusively the shortest flights -- simply doesn't reflect a meaningful number of travelers.

For that matter, if this kind of traveler wanted to go for status, they'd be better off just booking the non-basic fare and earning 250% as many XPs, rather than booking the basic fare.

For example, from Paris to Amsterdam I see basic fares of 88 EUR, and light fares of 113 EUR. If you wanted to earn those three extra XPs, under both systems you'd be better off just paying the higher fare rather than offsetting your flight with SAF.

Or what am I missing?


Reply
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 821

Ben, what you're missing is that lots of people who travel for work have terms dictated by their employers or clients. If you're doing a same-day return from AMS for a work meeting, you won't be able to get approval for paying extra in order to carry luggage. In addition to good old parsimony, there are lots of public sector organisations, NGOs etc use 'cheapest available' policies for virtue signalling- I've had to lobby for changing policies which explicitly banned first class train travel even if it was cheaper than second class (this is common in the UK, as long as the traveller is happy to buy an advance ticket and travel a couple of hours after the end of the working day).


Reply
(@Remco de Graaf)
Joined: 3 weeks ago

Posts: 1

Many flying members buy SAF XP/UXP, looking at my member data. Here's the short break down:

- A third of SkyStatus members' XP is no longer flown.
Over the past twelve months, 33.3% of all XP SkyStatus members earned did not come from a flight, mostly from the credit card and SAF, against 22.7% in 2023.

- One in three Platinum years of SkyStatus members was out of reach by flying alone.
In 30.7% of the Platinum years SkyStatus members closed since 2024, flying plus rolled-over XP fell short, and in 20% SAF was needed to reach the threshold.

- For SkyStatus members, SAF was almost always the cheapest XP.
An XP via SAF costs at most EUR 10. On trips where they logged the ticket price, SkyStatus members paid a median of around EUR 25 per XP for a short economy trip and around EUR 40 long-haul, and only short business trips came close, at around EUR 10.

- The higher their status at signup, the more often SkyStatus members buy SAF.
Of the flying SkyStatus members who signed up as Platinum, 67.8% have bought SAF at least once, against 14.3% of those who signed up as Explorer. Of the SkyStatus members who bought SAF in 2024, 78.3% bought again in 2025.

- New SAF buyers among SkyStatus members flew more, not less.
For SkyStatus members who first bought SAF in 2025, flown segments grew by a median 40.6% from 2024, against 14.3% for members without SAF. For repeat buyers, this data cannot rule out that SAF replaces flights.

- Flying Blue does not need to introduce revenue-based status.
For a third of SkyStatus members' XP it already exists. As far as we could establish, Flying Blue is the only program that rewards SAF with no cap, all the way to the top tier.

Full analysis is here: https://skystatus.pro/guide/flying-blue-bought-status


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 6541
(@Eskimo)
Joined: 9 years ago

Tiffany!!!


Reply
Posts: 1
 BBT
(@BBT)
Joined: 3 weeks ago

This has become an all too familiar script. Devalue a program, wait a few months, find another way to devalue it, and repeat. Flying Blue is hardly alone. Numerous frequent flyer programs have followed the same playbook.

I'm sure these programs analyze member behavior after each devaluation and, seeing little meaningful impact, feel emboldened to do it again. But loyalty erodes gradually. At some point, members will stop chasing status, accumulating miles, or going out of their way to remain loyal.

The real danger isn't that members will get angry and leave. It's that they'll simply stop caring. And indifference is far more damaging to a loyalty program than outrage.


Reply
Posts: 24
Gold
(@heatproof)
Member
Joined: 2 months ago

Ouch, that one hurt, AF.


Reply
Posts: 821
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

As someone who had qualified for Elite Plus for 15+ years, I'm really pleased with my decision to relegate FB to a backup programme shortly before the shocking devaluation that moved intercontinental awards from 50k to 85k. I now do virtually all of my revenue flying on *A and have been able to get cheap status matches for 4+ years (AZ, KQ, SK) so that I can still enjoy the perks on the odd cheap short-haul flight and when redeeming (non-FB) miles in premium economy etc.


Reply
2 Replies
(@Eskimo)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 6541

In 10 years you'll run out of *A airlines to match.


Reply
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 821

@Eskimo , they were all from the same *G status which I keep earning. The risk is running out of Skyteam airlines to cycle through, but I'm not going to develop separation anxiety in relation to the Schiphol mice and/or the non-existent lounge at Aeroparque.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 5
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 4 years ago

Another European here. Thank God for this. We are so tired of all those credit card milers taking up award space and ruining lounges for us over here.

Unlike US programmes, FB is clearly reserving benefits for those who actually fly AFKL. I think it's great, lure in Americans who never fly AFKL with a half-baked Visa Signature, then slowly take away all benefits.


Reply
3 Replies
Admin
(@lucky)
Joined: 13 years ago

Member
Posts: 41115

@ Throwawayname -- "FB is clearly reserving benefits for those who actually fly AFKL." That's funny, because Flying Blue is also the only major European loyalty program that lets you earn status without ever stepping foot on the airline (as you can credit SkyTeam flights).


Reply
(@Jones)
Joined: 5 years ago

Posts: 43

@Lucky

Maybe I’m missing something but looking through BA’s website, I no longer see a need to actually fly on BA to progress up the tiers of BA Club


Reply
(@Throwawayname)
Joined: 2 years ago

Posts: 821

Goodness me, I hadn't been expecting someone to impersonate me when choosing (?) this handle!

In my view, there are much better options offered by other European airlines but I appreciate that it's not always easy when you want/need to be flying a specific airline because of their routes and/or your employer's policies.


Reply
Posts: 141
(@Retired Gambler)
Joined: 7 years ago

These offsets are just virtue signaling. Let them all go away!


Reply
Posts: 1
 Stef
(@Stef)
Joined: 3 weeks ago

Same for donation in miles that now gives you less XPs (50%)


Reply
Posts: 2249
Diamond
(@tiffany)
Member
Joined: 12 years ago

Hey all --

On Monday, we updated how many XP you earn on Sustainable Aviation Fuel and charitable contributions. We didn’t handle the rollout well, and the new rate went live with unclear messaging and without notice. While this affects a small share of our members, we recognize for those members it matters a great deal.

The update was part of a continuous review of our elite program. We want to ensure we can keep delivering the benefits and service you expect.

For now, we’re pressing pause. From tomorrow (4 November), SAF and charitable contributions will earn XP at the previous rate, and any contribution made since 2 November will be credited at the prior rate as well. The new rate of €15 per XP begins on 1 December 2026; even at the new rate, no program in the market will recognize SAF contributions more generously than Flying Blue, including on award tickets.

We want Flying Blue to be a program you build your life around. Many of you put a lot of care into planning your flights and status qualification, and we understand your need to have time to make adjustments.

And to everyone who told us why this matters to you: thank you for caring this much about Flying Blue.


Reply
1 Reply
Diamond
(@peter_)
Joined: 10 months ago

Member
Posts: 521

@tiffany Kudos for acknowledging a mistake in a roll out and now giving at least some notice.  Most would not have done that.  I'm sure many here still don't love the new price, but I'll wager that Flying Blue did not invent inflation.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards