Air India Sacks Overweight Flight Attendants Over Safety Concerns

In the US there are no age or weight restrictions for flight attendants, which is certainly a source of laughter for many who criticize the US airline industry. I’ve had an 80+ year old flight attendant, and while she was absolutely delightful, there’s something a bit odd about us being conditioned to believe that flight attendants are actually “flight safety professionals,” when some of them can barely walk down the aisle anymore.

Meanwhile at some non-US airlines, the requirements are quite the opposite — there are height, age, weight, and even appearance requirements. Cabin crew are basically hired as “models” who just happen to provide service as well.

And then there are some airlines which have policies somewhere inbetween. Specifically, Air India is taking a lot of heat after firing 130 cabin crew for being overweight. Admittedly Air India isn’t exactly known for being the most glamorous airline out there, which is why these layoffs are puzzling to some. Air India is claiming to be sacking the crew over “safety concerns.”

British-Airways-Lounge-Chicago-20

This isn’t a new battle for Air India, as they’ve been going back and forth with laying off overweight flight attendants for about a decade now. Via The Washington Post:

The mass grounding is just the latest in a 10-year-long tug-of-war between the airline and its larger flight attendants. Weight limits for Indian flight attendants date back to the 1980s, when Air India began circulating height and weight charts, according to a 2014 opinion by Delhi High Court Judge Rajiv Shakdher.

In 2006, Air India grounded nine female flight attendants deemed “exceptionally overweight,” the BBC reported. “Being grossly overweight does have a bearing on reflexes and can impair agility required to perform the emergency functions,” the airline claimed. The hostesses sued, but a Delhi court backed up the carrier in 2008. The women appealed, only for the airline to fire them in 2009 as the country’s Supreme Court was still considering the case.

Given Air India’s history of laying off overweight flight attendants and the court battles which followed, the airline didn’t fire the last set of overweight crew overnight. Instead, they identified 600 overweight flight attendants (based on their BMI), and put them on a regimen of diet and exercise for six months, at which point they were once again assessed:

“About 130 of them failed the reassessment,” an Air India official told the Telegraph. “We are now declaring them permanently unfit for their job as flight attendants.”

Do I support firing flight attendants based on their weight? No. Is it “unsafe” for flight attendants to have a high BMI? Assuming they pass their medical exam otherwise, I don’t think so.

At the same time, is it reasonable for there to be some restrictions from a comfort perspective? The reality is that aisles do keep getting narrower. Have you tried squeezing through the aisle in 10 across economy on a 777 lately? It’s tight. And if you’re a flight attendant you don’t just have to squeeze through the aisles, but actually have to provide service there, which requires even more space.

Emirates-777-Economy

I’m a bit surprised Air India keeps picking this battle, given that they already get so much bad press and no one is flying them because of their great service. This seems to land them in court every time, so I just have a hard time imagining this is a battle which is worthwhile for them to pick.

What do you think? Is it reasonable for an airline to fire overweight flight attendants over safety concerns? Or what about on other grounds?

Conversations (25)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

John Member

Firstly, I disagree with this sensational headline! They didn't fire them outright. They had a choice of working as ground staff too. Also, they were given a chance to reduce their weights, which I find completely acceptable for a flight attendant to do. I don't think I will feel safe during an emergency at 30,000 feet if the FA is "obese" and runs out of breadth immediately or isn't as quick as an FA should be. Yes Air India isn't the best airline, or even top 20, but people just somehow love to thrash them. Whatever Air India does, suddenly everyone in the world will have an opinion about it. I am sure most of them haven't even flown with them but they just have a preconceived notion that they suck and lets write bad about them regardless of how much Air India tries to get better. I fly to India often, and yes Air India isn't my first option, but it is definitely way way way better than American, Delta and United COMBINED. Atleast they smile, talk politely and not rudely *insert United employee*, serve a decent meal unlike 10 peanuts or 3 pretzels on these pathetic US carriers, and have an IFE on most of their fleet. Even though the selection is mediocre, there is something. American flies decades old flights to Europe, 8-9 hrs flights without any entertainment! Look at the fleet, Air India has more than 20 787s in their fleet, how many MDs, 717s and 757s does Delta have? Heck, Delta has 717s on order! And these US3 carriers are the ones making billions of dollars of profits! Go figure! There is so much politics and bureaucracy around Air India. If removed, it actually has a huge potential of becoming a profitable and a good airline considering its wide network and alliance. I am not saying they are good, I am not even speaking for them or justifying them. In India I'll probably not even fly with them, but please guys they are better than many!

0
‼ 0
Ray Guest

On one flight, there was an FA that was so wide, she couldn't walk down the aisle straight, she had to turn sideways.

0
‼ 0
Mark Guest

Even the older or fatter FAs are usually more appealing than the typical pot-bellied, red-nosed, cell-phone yakking businessman in an ill-fitting suit who is sitting in a premium cabin.

0
‼ 0
Sean M. Diamond

@Red - I won't pretend to know more than you on the health aspect, nor to argue that point. The courts in India also didn't address that point. What the court ruled is that the Government aviation regulator (DGCA) is entitled to set medical standards for crew members so long as those standards do not discriminate unfairly, and that requiring crew to maintain a certain BMI is not discriminatory. The issue is not that Air India is trying to be "glamorous" (to borrow from Ben's words), but rather that Air India has no choice but to comply with the regulator's requirements. It is no different than US air carriers requiring pilots to retire at age 65. They do that because the FAA has decreed that (arbitrary) standard to be their limits and as the aviation regulator, they have the authority to do that.

0
‼ 0
Red Guest

@Sean M BMI is a poor measure that is designed for statistical population analysis, not determining whether an individual is obese. It doesn't distinguish between muscle and fat, for example, so an athletic or muscular person could be obese on the BMI scale while appearing quite trim.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published