A United Airlines employee and customer got into a confrontation, whereby the customer service agent threatened to call ICE on the customer, claiming he doesn’t “act like a citizen,” as flagged by View from the Wing.
Regardless of how either person was acting during this disagreement, that’s completely unacceptable, and this employee needs to be held accountable, in my opinion.
In this post:
United employee crosses the line in fight with customer
There’s an 82-second video posted on Reddit, showing a confrontation between a United Airlines customer service agent at San Francisco International Airport (SFO) and a customer. Here’s what the Reddit user who shared the video wrote:
This happened yesterday at San Francisco International airport. United employee was rude and dismissive with customer so he asks for her name to report her. The employee pulls out her phone and starts to record the interaction. At that moment she says “Maybe we should call ICE on you. You’re not acting like a citizen”. Whatever the f*ck that means… Customer is an American citizen.
The video starts with the United employee pointing her phone at the passenger (who is pointing his phone at her), saying “maybe we should call ICE on you,” later justifying it by saying “cause you don’t act like a citizen.”
As you’d expect, things really escalate from there. The United employee keeps saying “get away” (while not walking away herself), while the guy keeps daring her to call ICE. Another United employee steps in and asks if he wants police to get involved, to which he responds that he wants ICE to get involved.
She then keeps telling him to get “out of [her] face,” while he repeatedly tells her that she’s going to get fired. They then call one another racist, and he says he’s going to sue United, and calls her “lazy as hell.”
This is a really bad look for the United employee
Let’s assume that this guy was just awful and rude to the United employee. It’s entirely possible. Maybe he should even be added to United’s no-fly list for recording an employee, in violation of the carrier’s contract of carriage. The reason I say that is because even so, there’s absolutely nothing that justifies this employee’s actions.
For one, airline employees should be able to deescalate situations. If she felt like she couldn’t resolve this, she should’ve walked away, called a supervisor, or asked for the authorities to intervene. There’s simply no excuse for threatening to call ICE on a customer, claiming he’s not “acting like a citizen.”
Like, is she suggesting that US citizens are consistently well behaved, or what part of his actions aren’t that of a US citizen? It’s particularly sad to see someone who also appears to belong to a minority group saying such a hurtful and incendiary thing, since you’d think she’d have a bit more understanding for how words have meaning, and can hurt people.
For the record, while I have strong feelings about the current state of ICE, this has nothing to do with whether someone is for or against ICE. This woman works in a customer service role. There’s no context in which she should be calling ICE on a customer because she doesn’t like how they’re behaving, let alone when her only logic is that the passenger isn’t “acting like a citizen.”
All that being said, I’m a softie. I hope this woman doesn’t lose her job over this, but I do hope she seriously thinks about the importance of her words, is retrained, and apologizes to this guy. I understand that in moments of rage, people might get a fight or flight response, and say things they don’t mean. But goodness, threatening to call ICE on someone really rolled off her tongue pretty easily…
Bottom line
A United Airlines customer service agent at SFO was caught on video threatening to call ICE on a customer, claiming he wasn’t “acting like a citizen.” He may have very well been poorly behaved. However, this woman needs better deescalation training.
Sticking a camera in a customer’s face (even when they’re doing the same) and telling them to “get away” repeatedly is almost never going to achieve that result.
What do you make of this interaction?
Goid for her! Bet the person didn't look like an American either.
I speak three languages, have google maps set to always show metric, and think it's weird to wear tennis shoes in to a sauna. Perhaps I should call ICE on myself because I don't act like a citizen either.
Threatening to call ICE is really a proxy for threatening to have someone physically assaulted if not murdered, and everybody knows this. ICE’s default is the use of violent force. This lady was trying to intimidate the customer with that.
She needs to be fired or sent back to Africa, whichever is cheaper
Uh, United, should absolutely review this incident, and discipline/retrain their agent.
However, no, more bigotry (your Africa comment) is not the answer. Sheesh.
Sad state of affairs when Supreme Court temporarily tells ICE they can profile by race/ethnicity. Cascades down to making anyone think they can discriminate too
"Have you boofed yet?"
It’s completely unacceptable to threaten to call ICE on someone. You should just do it, full stop. These people are committing crimes and we should all want law enforcement to remove them immediately.
Had me in the first half... *sigh*
Buddy, the customer is a citizen; the United agent was wrongly threatening them. Regardless, one does not need to be a US citizen to travel. (I know you're based in Istanbul these days, so have you ever heard of tourists?)
The fact that two UA employees already name dropped her in the comments is telling.
I am not sure what the drama is here. This is an airport. ICE is a law enforcement agency. If a United agent has any suspicions and feels police, ICE, or a CBP officer needs to get involved, she should absolutely bring them in to resolve this situation.
It begins... the sane-washing of objectively bad behavior.
Lest we forget: Citizenship is documentation; not a subjective 'look' or 'act'...
Ignoring all else, is this how you want your tax dollars spent? Federal agents being called to deal with gate agents on power trips and/or unruly passengers? There already police presence at the airport that this kind of situation can be escalated to.
We have a lot of law agencies fit for different purposes and it’s usually not up to an average person to decide how and when they should engage
That is Evelyn, I use to work with her at the SFO station before I transferred to Houston. She was like that with her fellow coworkers, mean, rude and miserable. Especially to new hires trying to learn the ropes. It doesnt surprise me that she treats the customers like that. I will never understand why people who are unfriendly and mean want to work in customer service positions.
https://www.gettyimages.com/detail/news-photo/airline-employee-evelyn-beck-collects-her-cup-of-coffee-news-photo/1321197215?adppopup=true
That is Evelyn, I use to work with her at the SFO station before I transferred to Houston. She was like that with her fellow coworkers, mean, rude and miserable. Especially to new hires trying to learn the ropes. It doesnt surprise me that she treats the customers like that. I will never understand why people who are unfriendly and mean want to work in customer service positions.
https://www.gettyimages.com/detail/news-photo/airline-employee-evelyn-beck-collects-her-cup-of-coffee-news-photo/1321197215?adppopup=true
Yes, Miss Beck. Anyone who flies out of SFO on a regular basis would know her well. How many times did she call out my id and noted “ahhh, good ol Mr Walnut Creek-the home of the white devils”.
Her union will protect her and she will be back tomorrow.
Yes I recognize her. She is the epitome of pre-merger UA tulip attitude. You know they are very knowledgable and can move mountains *if* they want to.
Honestly I have a bit of nostalgia when one of them works my check-in or flight, kind of like getting to fly a domestic 777 with the old lie flats or...back in the day, boarding a plane still having the sunset orange stripes on the seats.
...Yes I recognize her. She is the epitome of pre-merger UA tulip attitude. You know they are very knowledgable and can move mountains *if* they want to.
Honestly I have a bit of nostalgia when one of them works my check-in or flight, kind of like getting to fly a domestic 777 with the old lie flats or...back in the day, boarding a plane still having the sunset orange stripes on the seats.
Dock her pay or something as a reprimand for this but firing is so extreme - people are too binary in their expectations.
Dave, let's be clear, her unprofessionalism and misbehavior is the problem, not all unions or the concept of organized labor or collective bargaining... *sigh*
Holy cow I totally know her. The last two times I’ve used the premium services check-in/bag drop at T3 she’s been there. Terribly unhelpful and a ridiculous attitude for no reason.
Terminate that employee ASAP.
Hard disagree...she should be fired. Unacceptable.
Oof, not great. Yeah, Ben, I get it, gotta make a buck for the site and all, but, I'd've just let Gary 'handle' this one. More 'his' style. Ya know, rage-bait, etc. (As I said over at VFTW, it's as if he inserted the words 'SF, ICE, black lady' into an ad-lib for the purposes of 'engagement' for a gossip-site.) Anyhoo, you do you, bruther.