An Iranian PhD student at the University of Connecticut named Elika Shams has filed a lawsuit against Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Secretary Kristi Noem, after her student status was terminated without due process. What does that have to do with travel? Well, she thinks that this happened due to a confrontation she had related to a Frontier Airlines flight she had booked, as flagged by PYOK.
In this post:
Iranian student has confrontation at Frontier Airlines gate
On December 31, 2024, a student was scheduled to take a Frontier flight out of Boston (BOS). However, she was stopped by the gate agent, who reportedly demanded that she pay $100 to take her carry-on onboard the aircraft. Frontier is of course known for its strict carry-on allowance, and its punitive fees if you bring larger carry-on bags to the gate than what you paid for.
According to Shams’ version of events, when she questioned the charge for the bag, the gate agent closed the jet bridge door and ended the boarding process. In a moment of desperation, she tried to open the jet bridge door, and said she would pay the fee if she were allowed to board. However, she wasn’t let onboard.
The airline reported her to the TSA, who issued her a warning, but never cited or arrested her. A warning notice is the most basic type of infraction with the TSA, and it’s only supposed to become an issue if someone has repeated issues with the TSA.
Unfortunately this wasn’t the end of the this story. Before we discuss that, though, let me state that I suspect there was a little more back-and-forth before the jet bridge door was closed in front of her. Furthermore, as a PSA, trying to open the jet bridge door when you’re denied boarding *never* ends well.
How this incident may have caused further legal issues
We know that in recent weeks, the Trump administration has been trying to crack down on foreigners with student visas for unclear violations. Shams was among those.
On April 10, 2025, Shams received an email from her university, informing her that the DHS had removed her from the Student Visitor and Information System, which is how international students are tracked. No details were given about what caused this to happen, other than that she had been flagged in a criminal records check.
The only thing that Shams can think of is that this was due to her flight situation, since she didn’t have any other legal run-ins while in the country. As mentioned above, though, she wasn’t cited or arrested in that incident.
While her F-1 visa wasn’t directly revoked, the bad news is that she’s not allowed to attendant school without a record on the Student Visitor and Information System, so this could have eventually caused her to forcibly lose her F-1 status.
Shams is one of four international students who are plaintiffs in a class action lawsuit, claiming that the DHS breached their Fifth Amendment right to due process, without giving any sort of meaningful reason for why their status has been changed. They requested that a court issue an injunction.
However, a few days ago, the Trump administration backtracked on this crackdown, given the questionable legal grounds.
Bottom line
An Iranian PhD student recently found herself impacted by Trump’s student visa crackdown. The thing is, she claims to have never had any run-ins with the law in the United States, other than a confrontation with a Frontier Airlines gate agent, where the TSA was ultimately called. However, the TSA only issued a warning, and not a citation, so this shouldn’t have had any legal implications.
The student participated in a class action lawsuit about this. Ultimately Trump has backtracked on this crackdown, so the student isn’t at risk of deportation.
What do you make of this Frontier situation?
I'm sure if an American threw a fit and tried to force their way onto a plane in Iran, they would have been let go with a warning and continue their studies, work, or vacation as if nothing happened or should happen...
People in America are completely delusional about reality!
Sure, because the USA should be like Iran and hand down the harshest penalties for minor dumb things people do with no consideration of the circumstances? Let's just throw out the bedrock principles of the US legal system and become a theocratic dictatorship? If you want to treat people that way, maybe move to Iran instead of tearing down the US.
An Iranian national tries to force open a jet bridge door after it had been closed and get on a PLANE without authorization! sounds like she definitely needs her visa revoked! Try pulling that crap in Iran as an American and see what happens to you. There are millions of people who would like to study in the US and can act like an adult. We don't need this clown thinking they can do whatever...
An Iranian national tries to force open a jet bridge door after it had been closed and get on a PLANE without authorization! sounds like she definitely needs her visa revoked! Try pulling that crap in Iran as an American and see what happens to you. There are millions of people who would like to study in the US and can act like an adult. We don't need this clown thinking they can do whatever they want. They think the bag fee doesn't apply to them, they FAFO and then try to force their way on to a plane... How do they think this is acceptable as a foreigner? Sorry, not sorry. Goodbye!
If you all don't believe there's more here than what's been reported, you are idiots.
100% correct. Sadly there are those who will take this article as it was intended by the author. That this is the work of Orange Man Bad and his minions. Is it me or am I seeing more of these smarmy, innuendo type articles here? The bias is glaring. Pity.
TDS has gotten to you....
So really the title should be ‘woman attempts to bypass security and unlawfully gain access to aircraft, gets visa revoked’.
These entitled foreigners better start learning to behave in their host country otherwise they're going from the river to the airport.
maybe you need to brush up on the Constitution and Due Process....just a tip.
The US Constitution and ideas of due process apply to US Citizens, not to tourist or illegal aliens.
You are wrong and wrong it’s settled law.
Nope, it applies to everyone on once they’re in America. If it were only for US citizens, all it would take is for an officer to deem you not a citizen. How can you fight back with no due process?
That due process thing's been working marvellously for those held without trial in Guantanamo and elsewhere.
If she can't behave, she can't stay here.
And it sounds like she can't behave.
It takes a special kind of stupid to try to open a jetbridge door, ESPECIALLY when you are a guest in a foreign country. Just asking for a world of trouble.
I moved to the US to attend college. Before I got there I'd read up extensively online on horror stories about airlines, and I kinda decided I would not fly the US legacy carriers. Their reputation preceded them.
One place I lived in was BUF and I was lucky to have JetBlue's 5? a day to/from JFK. This was 23 years ago, I'd fly JL/NH transpacific into JFK with a 4-hour layover, and drag...
I moved to the US to attend college. Before I got there I'd read up extensively online on horror stories about airlines, and I kinda decided I would not fly the US legacy carriers. Their reputation preceded them.
One place I lived in was BUF and I was lucky to have JetBlue's 5? a day to/from JFK. This was 23 years ago, I'd fly JL/NH transpacific into JFK with a 4-hour layover, and drag my bag on the AirTrain over to the Sundrome (lol)
If I were an int'l student now, I'd never touch Frontier or Spirit. Their reputation precedes them.
Frontier agent needing to meet 2024 fee collection target to get a bonus?
Is there any evidence that they binned her visa because of the Frontier incident in December? Or is it possible that DOGE just randomly selected her from a spreadsheet because she's Persian?
You'd think Americans would be happy that people from adversary nations, especially women, are able to get out of the autocratic regimes they live under and come to the US for an education. Instead of bashing her for a desperate and dumb action made in the heat of the moment, have a bit of empathy?
An Op-Ed in a school newspaper gets you snatched off the street by masked agents so this can’t be too big of a surprise …. These days at least … it’s just a warm up folks.
TSA civil action can, like most federal government things, take some time to come to a resolution.
If she pulled on a jetway door, she tried to breach/gain unauthorized access to a secure area. After that, she isn't flying on any airline that day. Also, fun fact, once you no longer have a boarding pass, or have missed your flight, you technically aren't allowed to be inside the sterile side of the airport.
Yes we are, but if she can't behave and follow the rules, she doesn't need to be here. There are millions of other foreigners who can follow the rules and behave. We don't need her!
If you're here on a visa and do something to become involved with law enforcement don't expect a good end. Her behavior tells me everything I need to know about her and it's very good she's been exited out of the country.
"it's very good she's been exited out of the country..."
Read the piece, RWNJ.
1. She is Iranian.
2. She probably sucks as a person.
3. She fly Frontier.
Thanks for your nonsensical trope.
That's all we need to know about her!
Trying to open a jet bridge door is quite a bit more than bag fee drama. The headline is slanted.
A headline straight out of the NYT. No, “bag drama” had nothing to do with a possible deportation. Stupidly opening a closed jet bridge door may have, however.
What I’m absolutely certain of is Frontier goads their customers into confrontations. Frontier is a shameful airline run by shameful people.
The lady doth protest too much, methinks
How can she have forgot basic lessons about dealing with authority figures from her earlier childhood and adolescent times in Iran?
I'd be curious to know what would have happened to her or any other woman or man, had they behaved and argued with "authority figures" in the same way she did in this case, in the US?
My (mistaken or gnorant, perhaps) fantasy is that it would have been a response from (male)...
How can she have forgot basic lessons about dealing with authority figures from her earlier childhood and adolescent times in Iran?
I'd be curious to know what would have happened to her or any other woman or man, had they behaved and argued with "authority figures" in the same way she did in this case, in the US?
My (mistaken or gnorant, perhaps) fantasy is that it would have been a response from (male) authority figures in Iran, far worse and more immediate than a simple TSA "warning."
No one is forced to fly Frontier.
This student FAFO.