Boom CEO Makes Business Case For Supersonic Travel (It’s A Stretch)

Boom is an aeronautics company that’s working on bringing back supersonic passenger air travel. The company’s main product is the Boom Overture, which is essentially intended to be the modern day Concorde.

This is an incredibly ambitious project with a lot of smart people behind it. I have no doubt that bringing back supersonic passenger air travel is possible in terms of the technology. What I’m skeptical about is the timeline, and also the economic viability:

  • Boom hopes for the Overture to enter the service before the end of the decade; just as a reminder, Boeing announced the 777X concept in 2013, and the plane isn’t yet certified, and it’s only an evolution of an existing aircraft
  • Assuming Boom can get the many billions of dollars of funding that it needs, the company will need to sell a lot of planes in order to actually make money on this project, and will need to price the plane low enough so that it’s attractive to airlines

With that in mind, Boom’s CEO has provided an explanation of the business case for the Overture, and it’s… quite something.

Boom CEO sees demand for 1,000+ Overture aircraft

Boom CEO Blake Scholl published a series of posts on Twitter/X, explaining why he thinks that supersonic flight will work at scale for the Boom Overture, when it didn’t work for the Concorde. He points out how only 14 Concordes were ever planned, while he thinks there will be 1,000+ Overtures.

That is a jaw-dropping claim, so how does he justify it? Well, see the below thread…

So Scholl estimates that airlines will “need” 1,000+ Overtures, and that number is “probably too low,” as he sees there being 600+ viable markets. The math behind that is simply that he has taken all of the daily premium seats on profitable routes of over 2.5 hours, then has nearly doubled them (to account for increased air travel demand between now and 2039). Then he has divided those seats by the number of seats on the Overture (64 business class seats), to come up with the “need” for 2,973 Overture flights per day.

In other words, the logic is basically that “if we capture 100% of business class demand on overwater flights of over 2.5 hours, there will be a need for over 1,000 Overture aircraft.” That… I mean… is one way to calculate potential market position. Keep in mind this appears to even be including routes beyond the range of the Overture, where a refueling stop would be required.

Folks, maybe I’m in the wrong line of work. I’m quitting OMAAT, and I’m starting an e-comm business. I’ve done the research, and if I can get just 100% of the existing global e-comm market, I’m going to be a trillionaire!

Boom’s CEO sees demand for 1,000+ Overtures

Why supersonic travel won’t be appealing to airlines

The concept of supersonic travel is no doubt cool, and I trust there are very smart engineers who could make this a reality. It’s all just a function of economics, and that includes there being interest from airlines.

If the Boom Overture were to get to the point where it’s in production, it’s certified, and it’s available at a reasonable cost, I could see some airlines being interested in this in very limited circumstances. Frankly, I see demand being comparable to what it was for the Concorde, in terms of viable routes.

However, the concept of “hey, we’ll just capture all of the existing premium cabin market share” just doesn’t work, and isn’t very appealing to airlines. For one, what happens to the existing fleets of airlines? Like, if United wanted to fly the Boom Overture in all of its lucrative transatlantic markets, what would it do with its existing aircraft? After all, the Boom Overture would cannibalize premium revenue, and make the carrier’s existing flights unprofitable.

Airlines make money in a variety of ways, and it’s not just as straightforward as “oh, airlines make a lot of their revenue and profits from business class, so let’s just fly these all-business class jets, and forget everyone else.” For example:

  • Airlines also make some revenue from cargo, and obviously the Boom Overture wouldn’t have any substantial cargo capacity
  • Airline profitability is also dependent on upsell opportunities, increased engagement in airline loyalty programs, etc., and a supersonic all-business class jet provides fewer of those opportunities
  • Airlines have complex hub and spoke systems they use to build their networks, not to mention joint ventures, which also complicate all of this
  • With the Boom Overture’s range being restricted to roughly 4,000 nautical miles, the plane couldn’t fly virtually any transpacific route, so the actual nonstop range is limiting for the markets where the time savings could be most significant

Scholl was asked exactly this question in response to his explanation of the business case, and his response is essentially that there will be a shrinking of subsonic premium cabins over time, and “economy fares might go up a little, but it will be within the noise of normal fluctuations.”

That… doesn’t make any sense. If you argue that 80% of operating profits on long haul aircraft come from business class, how do you expect for there to continue to be subsonic flights with economy that are profitable? Scholl is basically advocating for a step back in terms of global connectivity, that economy needs to get more expensive, so that rich people can fly supersonic.

Bottom line

Boom is working on bringing back supersonic passenger air travel with its Overture product. The company’s CEO sees demand for 1,000+ supersonic planes, and the logic basically seems to be that if the company can capture 100% of premium demand on profitable routes of over 2.5 hours, then that’s the number we arrive at. Maybe it’s just me, but that logic seems more than a little optimistic…

What do you make of the business case for the Boom Overture?

Conversations (37)
The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.
Comment as a member

Membership is free and takes no more information than commenting as a guest. Earn status points for good contributions, and see fewer ads as your status grows.

Type your response here.

If you'd like to participate in the discussion, please adhere to our commenting guidelines. Anyone can comment, and your email address will not be published. Register to save your unique username and earn special OMAAT reputation perks!

  1. Loading comments…
Recent Comments
The latest from the OMAAT community.

The comments on this page have not been provided, reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any advertiser, and it is not an advertiser's responsibility to ensure posts and/or questions are answered.

Bangka Guest

This will never come to fruition, it's purely a money grab! I see a jail cell in his future...

0
‼ 0
Eskimo Guest

People keep forgetting, his job isn't to build supersonic airliners. His job is getting other people's money to build it. Gamer A380. Trenton 747. Ghana hub. Railroad infringement. Fyre. PAC. Super PAC.

1
‼ 0
Mike Guest

This guy has gotten this far. I think it is cool that he is even attempting something so crazy. It is insane that in terms of flight speed technology, we are behind where we were in 1970s.

0
‼ 0
Miles Butler Guest

Whilst the development and production costs of the 14 Concordes that entered service were never recouped by the Anglo/French governments, articles such as this generally neglect how profitable Concorde was on an operational basis for BA during its peak years. In the late 80s/early 90s the BA Concorde fleet generated 25% of the airline’s profits. That’s a quarter of the profit of one of the world’s largest airlines generated by 7 aircraft… Obviously times have changed and the circumstances that supported that market may no longer exist, but the narrative that commercial supersonic flight has never been profitable is patently incorrect.

0
‼ 0
Pete Guest

Will a range of 4000 nm cut it? That's not enough to make London-LA, let alone NY-Hong Kong. Tech stopd to refuel takes us back to the DC-10/747-200 days, and will erode a significant amount of the time advantage.

0
‼ 0

Save posts to read later

Saving posts is a member feature. Become an OMAAT member to build a reading list you can come back to from any device.

Become a member
Meet Ben Schlappig, OMAAT Founder
5,883,136 Miles Traveled

43,914,800 Words Written

47,187 Posts Published