Ouch: United Launch...
 

Ouch: United Launches "Basic" Domestic First Class Fares, And They're Restrictive

53 Posts
29 Users
0 Reactions
1,212 Views
Posts: 41083
Admin
Topic starter
(@lucky)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago
[#20471]
wpf-cross-image

United has started selling basic domestic first class fares that are non-refundable, charge $199 for changes, skip free seat selection, and earn no redeemable miles. Here's what changed.


52 Replies
Posts: 493
Diamond
(@hbilbao)
Member
Joined: 2 years ago

Unrelated to UA, but I just noticed (maybe i'm just late to noticing) that AC now has basic business class fares too (can't even choose a seat anymore).


Reply
Posts: 1480
(@George Romey)
Joined: 6 years ago

It seems that most domestic first class now are upsells from coach. Will the upsells be considered basic business? If so, and there's less earning potential there's less incentive to buy and just take the chance for a complimentary upgrade if eligible.

From my experience most domestic first class doesn't get bought out right. It's either upsells or complimentary upgrades. I know when I book first outright the cabin is usually wide open. I'll buy if the fare is decent, otherwise, I wait until I get an upsell offer.


Reply
2 Replies
Platinum
(@immortalsynn)
Joined: 12 months ago

Member
Posts: 122

"It seems that most domestic first class now are upsells from coach."

How does "it seem" that?
Particularly since that's not accurate.


Reply
(@George Romey)
Joined: 6 years ago

Posts: 1480

DL reported 84% of domestic first class are upsells or first being bought outright. AA and UA have said similar things. So where do you think all these complimentary upgrades are coming from? Just wander over to Flyertalk. Typical posts "I'm an EXP with 400K LP and was number five on the list."


Reply
Posts: 47
(@Onemiler)
Joined: 4 years ago

I can understand basic economy fares, as some people just want the cheapest seat possible. But Premium Customers? This makes no sense to me. I am not paying a premium price for just the seat. I want the flexibility, I want to pick my seat, I want the lounge access etc. Ofcourse their buy up rate is high. Premium customers want a Premium experience.


Reply
3 Replies
(@James S)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 379

All it does is make you feel worse about your purchase


Reply
(@Greyfin)
Joined: 1 year ago

Posts: 8

don't get wrong, as a consumer I don't like the price effects of the introduction of basic premium in this case, but for the sake of an alternate perspective:

I enjoy the premium seating/space and proximity to front of the plane that comes with domestic biz class seats, but:

1. I don't have strong opinions about which seat I get within the premium cabin (esp for ~4 hour or shorter flights)
2. I'm the type to arrive at the airport with just enough time to go through security and then board (so no lounge benefits for me, personally) since I'd rather maximize my time away from the airport and in the city
3. I have enough "locked in" travel that doesn't need flexibility (not always, though)

It's worked for me, internationally, with the "limited" premium products of airliners like Air Premia/ZipAir/French Bee etc., so I could see a use case for this with domestic premium cabins.


Reply
Platinum
(@immortalsynn)
Joined: 12 months ago

Member
Posts: 122

"I am not paying a premium price for just the seat."

You might not be, but a lot of people happily would.

I'm shocked that the carriers didn't do this a decade ago, because the research was there to show that it'd be well received (from a purchase standpoint, anyway).


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 379
(@James S)
Joined: 7 years ago

"The buy up rates are incredibly high. Consumers know what they are buying, and we disclose it very carefully."

Well this is a lie. You get marketed the basic price every step of the way until you click through and get told you need to pay more for things you got a week ago at that price


Reply
Posts: 298
Diamond
(@tennen)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Frustrating on so many levels. I could (maybe) understand reduced mileage and changes for a fee, but eliminating both is ridiculous.

Also, am I the only one laughing at their "Extra-spacious seat" description? On their A321neo, there isn't enough space for a regular-sized backpack under an FC seat. "Extra-spacious," my butt.


Reply
Posts: 144
 Alec
Diamond
(@alec)
Member
Joined: 4 years ago

Seems like a much bigger risk of both discouraging people to participate in loyalty program and potentially cannibalizing seat from higher fare business seat. If I want a fare that earns miles and an extra leg room seat, I'm not far off from just buying the first class seat here. Still get a free bag and boarding group 1 so not much value in the credit card for the average traveler. Biggest loss from normal economy in this scenario is having to pay $199 to get an ecredit if you want to change flight.


Reply
Posts: 19
Platinum
(@richardhauschild)
Member
Joined: 2 years ago

I feel like with these fare, that they are looking for the LCC crowd. Anyone who cares about status were never going to buy these anyways, so I think it's a little short sided to cheer that people were "buying up". To me, there is never a choice to buy basic.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 860
(@pstm91)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

They can charge "the same" fares as always and then charge higher for all of the usual perks that used to be inclused. Simple as that. Terrible for the consumer.


Reply
Posts: 1948
Diamond
(@1990_)
Member
Joined: 3 months ago

*boo hiss*


Reply
Posts: 80
Platinum
(@this_comes_to_mind)
Member
Joined: 3 months ago

I just don't care. Sure, I want to spend less. But, after years of flying on the cheap, I've saved enough to fly F/J every time for the rest of my life (I only fly for pleasure, now). I know that the F/J I've had before will still be in my price range, particularly with the newer premium heavy aircrafts. And, I can't really be upset, since the big 3 currently don't make a profit from airfares. The charities in my will will just get less.


Reply
5 Replies
Platinum
(@immortalsynn)
Joined: 12 months ago

Member
Posts: 122

...are you drunk-posting?


Reply
(@Florida sunshine)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 81

Call me stupid….. but the airlines aren’t going premium heavy to reduce fares…..but it is because demand and people will pay to fill the seats.


Reply
Platinum
(@this_comes_to_mind)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 80

@Florida sunshine it is basically economics. There are more F/J seats. They will have to be less expensive than they would have been had the continued with smaller numbers of premium seats. Yes, the demand curve may have evolved, but is it that much "more demand"?


Reply
Platinum
(@this_comes_to_mind)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 80

@ImmortalSynn stoned cold sober and you knew you wanted to insult me, go ahead, I don't care


Reply
Diamond
(@1990_)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 1948

@ImmortalSynn gets it. @This_comes_to_mind thinks he's rich to care (as he lives in Ohio...) Nah, we're all just medical emergency away from bankruptcy. You really think you're immune?

@Florida sunshine -- You really should know that 'unbundling' is just airlines squeezing extra cash out of consumers for the same seat. Oh, almost forgot, you're yet another corporate apologist.


Reply
Posts: 217
Diamond
(@grayanderson)
Member
Joined: 5 years ago

Probably the most annoying thing with UA and AA is their insistence on showing Basic fares up front and only then showing you the split afterwards. Delta at least lets you proactively filter.

[I'd like a toggle button for "Shove basic fare up Scott Kirby's arse", but I suspect that's a bit much to ask for..]


Reply
1 Reply
 snic
Diamond
(@snic)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 1119

You could just search on Google Flights first. It has the option to exclude basic economy. They don't have an option to exclude basic first and business fares, but presumably that will come as well after the other airlines copycat this move by UA.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 24
Gold
(@heatproof)
Member
Joined: 1 month ago

Brought to you by the same man who wants universal military conscription and a wealth tax.

He thinks he is so wise and clever while you and I are dumb and need to be managed.


Reply
Posts: 35
(@scott-4)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

This is getting ridiculous, I feel like the rules are always changing and somehow we are always getting nickel-and-dimed. Not just UA but the entire industry. You have to constantly be on our toes and worrying about what's going to change and the hamster wheel of it all is exhausting.

Reminds me a little of what happened with Tulum. It got popular and started going more and more high end and the crowds kept showing up and paying the crazy high prices. Until they didn't show up anymore. People got fed up with it and stopped going. And then the whole destination just sort of imploded. Maybe not a perfect analogy, but the point is that the airlines can only push everything so far and maximize every penny before people will just tune out.


Reply
1 Reply
Platinum
(@this_comes_to_mind)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 80

I am always amazed at flyers getting upset when low airfares go up a little. Airfares have been at historic lows adjusted for inflation. The big 3 don't make money flying. It is as if Big Macs were $2.50 and people are complaining that McDs wants to get $2.65.


Reply
Posts: 527
Diamond
(@pierre-2)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

It will all depend what perks the elites can still enjoy, like seat-prebooking, bags allowance, etc... Think Flying Blue, AF and KL flights without, in the US, the Lounge Access. For a Gold Flying Blue member, the 'Light' fares are mostly fine.


Reply
Posts: 425
Diamond
(@samar)
Member
Joined: 1 year ago

United is the airline of the Big 4 that I will not fly when I have a choice because they are clearly the most anti-consumer (between this, no carryon for BE, and no perks with extra legroom seats). I wouldn’t have a flight planned with them next year if I didn’t have credit I have to burn (and I still have some credit that I reluctantly will have to use up).


Reply
3 Replies
Diamond
(@watson)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 554

No perks with extra legroom seats but they're selectable at booking for Golds unlike DL and AS which require Platinum.

DL also has Basic fares in business/D1.


Reply
Diamond
(@samar)
Joined: 1 year ago

Member
Posts: 425

Forgot to mention you don't even get an improved boarding group if you pay for extra legroom. I laugh when Kirby calls United premium when they don't actually offer a premium product in Economy.


Reply
Diamond
(@watson)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 554

There's nothing premium about extra-legroom economy lol. On any airline.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 272
Diamond
(@retiredatlatc)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

I've just emptied my Aeroplan account of almost 1 million points on a trip for two to Japan and my Everest trip, and then I'm done.

The points game isn't fun anymore and airlines are greedy AF, and when the shit hits the fan again, and it will, they'll come crying with their hands out wanting free bailout money.

I've seen enough of the rest of the world in my 61 years. Flying is not fun anymore and the hastle isn't worth it to me.


Reply
3 Replies
Diamond
(@1990_)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 1948

Safe travels and hiking.


Reply
Diamond
(@peter_)
Joined: 10 months ago

Member
Posts: 507

No reason to stay on the hamster wheel. Earn and burn and break free. Enjoy living your life. If you want to spread your wings again after these upcoming travels, the airlines (and the credit cards and points and most certainly OMAAT) will still be there.


Reply
Diamond
(@jacobin777)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 103

Everest trip? Wow! that sounds so fun! I sincerely hope you have a wonderful time!

I flew from DEL-PAT a few years ago and was able to see a number of the 8000ers by plane all on one flight - including Makalu, Cho Oyu, Dhaulagiri, Manaslu and Annapurna. On the return I was able to see Everest and Lhotse! Oh, I flew ORD-DEL and we flew over Pakistan and I was able to see Nanga Parbat (got a lot of photos). I still need to go through my photos if I can find K2, Broad Peak and the Gashurbrums. Haven't seen them in any of my photos yet.

I really would love to go to Kala Pattar or do the North Col of Everest one day. 🙂


Reply
Posts: 272
(@Fed UP)
Joined: 9 years ago

The race to the bottom... First in the US is not that big of a deal... The biggest benefit is a larger seat in front..... Maybe a free drink (if you drink)... Food is hit or miss, transcend you get something, shorter flights , probably not. BUT its better than a middle seat in Economy


Reply
1 Reply
Diamond
(@uncleronnie)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 1307

“Food is hit or miss” On UA it’s a huge miss! Dogfood tastes better.


Reply
Posts: 1
(@Forgettaboutit)
Joined: 3 weeks ago

This is BS. I've been checking a CLT-EWR flight for awhile now and biz always priced at $449 and now that's the price for "basic." Forgettaboutit!


Reply
Posts: 38
(@Tony G.)
Joined: 1 year ago

If people don't like this new class of fares with the rules, don't buy them. That's the surest way to get rid of them.


Reply
2 Replies
Platinum
(@this_comes_to_mind)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 80

And that's the point. If pax reject this, they go away. If they stay, then pax are OK with it. Every business transaction has both the business and consumer getting some of the surplus. Business always want to get more of the consumer surplus. Can we blame them?


Reply
(@chewy3)
Joined: 2 months ago

Member
Posts: 6

Didn't you read the article? Whether or not you buy these fares the airline will declare victory.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Page 1 / 2