Philippine Airlines...
 

Philippine Airlines Business Class Airbus A350 Review: Great Seats, With Missing Heart

21 Posts
11 Users
0 Reactions
1,097 Views
Posts: 41096
Admin
Topic starter
(@lucky)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago
[#20479]
wpf-cross-image

Philippine Airlines' new A350-1000 business class has excellent reverse herringbone seats and decent food, but broken Wi-Fi and a disinterested crew left the experience short of its potential.


20 Replies
Posts: 1
(@pushmyredbutton)
Member
Joined: 3 weeks ago

Thanks for the review Ben. This has also been my experience in J for the past few months on the A350-1000. Wifi just didn't work, and still doesn't! Maddening. Also had the same issues with the crew. They weren't bad, but they certainly weren't giving any warmth whatsoever.

Hope PR improves for when they're in Oneworld. For now, it's a good value, but certainly not luxurious.


Reply
Posts: 3
 LMC
(@LMC)
Joined: 3 weeks ago

Well, Philippines airlines has never been known nor regarded as one of the best airlines, not even great to say the least especially in this part of the world where it exists the fiercest competitiveness with a number of airlines literally making up the world's top 10 consistently in overall performance & products satisfaction.

However warm & friendly & attentive the crew onboard Philippines Airlines may be, if they have never been voted to be 1 of the world's best or renown where the service quality provided by an airline crew members even becomes its signature & core value that often plays the biggest role in making ppl wanting to fly with the specific airlines again & again, it already gives away very clear indication. Very obvious that the Philippines Airlines crew service quality or the whole work ethics continues to be slacking & nothing seems to be done to uplift the over standards.

Or, perhaps they tried but continued to fail miserably because it's extremely demoralizing when everything u tried to do to make things right, somehow nothing really works to be anywhere near to rivaling their regional counterparts. Well, let's be honest, who can really outshine 2 of the biggest power players, Malaysia Airlines & Singapore Airlines when it comes to their meticulous & simply a class of their own level of services they have mastered for decades?

I kinda get this feeling that Philippines Airlines, a privately owned & operated "national carrier" is never about being among the best, rather, it's just a mode of transportation to transport people from point A to point B. It somehow focuses on very specific markets such as North America with perhaps the most extensive network compared to other SEAsian airliners, which could've been its strongest selling point as the intermediary between two regions, but it's not even the case.

It's not an airline that would come to anyone's mind when it comes to booking the desired flights, at least never mine for sure. It's never a good thing when a company could be all forgotten of its existence unless it's being mentioned all of a sudden.

That whole long line up of wheelchairs awaiting for those in need during disembarking is shocking, just how many disabled passengers were onboard that flight exactly? It better not be the same hideous trick the Indians are so infamous for, the use of wheelchair disguising themselves as physically challenged persons just to enjoy priority boarding with special care, also getting pushed around without needing to even lift a finger!!! Talk about being appalling & low class!


Reply
3 Replies
Diamond
(@mps-in-charlotte)
Joined: 6 years ago

Member
Posts: 44

There likely is a segment of Indian (or Filipino, or whatever ethnic group you fancy to call out today) passengers that use wheelchair assistance as the privileged chauffeur service you describe, particularly when enabled by cultural norms of absolute respect for and deference to elders. And many people who can walk normally in day-to-day life may be unable to handle the long walking distances in airports.

However, speaking from my own experience with family and acquaintances traveling to to/from their native country, I suspect the majority of these passengers see wheelchair service as the next best thing to trying to navigate an unfamiliar, crowded, sprawling airport with the added pressures of limited transit time, language barriers, and wrangling around a multigenerational family.

If airlines that cater heavily to VFR traffic would consistently provide *and advertise* copious numbers of ground personnel speaking the native language who can provide guidance, explain the security and transit process, and even just point the way to gate A16, I think a lot of these wheelchair requests would go away. It could even be just some friendly native language speakers living in the outstation cities who are paid to come to the airport for a few hours before a flight with lots of Tagalog (Gujarati, Telugu, Mandarin, etc.) speakers just for this purpose.


Reply
 Em
(@Em)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 372

My grandmother is not disabled and neither does she lack class. However, she certainly cannot walk the distances required at large airports. Hence we opt for the wheel chair for her during travels. We really don’t care whether we board first or last as long as she is well.

What a git to make such an insensitive and lowly comment. Talk about being uneducated.


Reply
 Neel
(@Neel)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 16

You let yourself down with the last part of your comment. Many elders opt for a wheelchair simply because they are uncomfortable navigating airports. On top of that, most major hubs require a lot of walking—which is difficult for an eighty-year-old to manage, regardless of what other assistance is provided. No matter how well-traveled someone may be, they inevitably slow down mentally and physically with age. The last thing a person needs to worry about at that stage of life is airport complications. I hope that you age well and never have to suffer the indignity of being judged for requiring assistance if you ever need it.


Reply
Posts: 1952
Diamond
(@1990_)
Member
Joined: 3 months ago

Heart? Psh. Naw, hard product still takes priority. I’d much rather be in 1-2-1 J (or 3-3-3 Y) on the A350 over 2-3-2 J (or 3-4-3 Y) on the 773. Though, with all the adobo and lechon, maybe 'heart' was just shorthand for heart...attack?


Reply
3 Replies
 Mick
(@Mick)
Joined: 10 years ago

Posts: 477

I’d tend to agree. I think 3.5 stars seems harsh for a nice flat bed wirh a door for that price.

I LOVE that dinner service finished 75mins in. That’s a huge plus for me. I hate 3 hr dinner services on overnight flights. I’d rather less nice busy efficient servers and a chance to relax than the opposite.

I’m flying the old school PAL biz to Sydney in Jan and I think I’d take it with the big footwells over the cramped a350.


Reply
Admin
(@lucky)
Joined: 13 years ago

Member
Posts: 41096

@ Mick -- Funny enough, at first I was going to give it four stars, but then I felt that was too generous. Let me explain.

I felt like I had to deduct something for the Wi-Fi not working, so that took the rating down half a star. I also felt like I had to deduct something for the crew not being great, so that took it down half a star.

I also try not to give five stars as a default, and instead reserve that for truly exceptional products, like if there's in dine on demand, pajamas, etc. So usually my starting point is 4.5 stars for something that's great, with deductions for anything that falls short, and additions for something truly industry leading.


Reply
 Mick
(@Mick)
Joined: 10 years ago

Posts: 477

Thanks Ben, that makes a lot of sense. In some respects I think 3.5 should be seen as a very good product. 4 amazing. 4.5 - wow! This airline is incredible. And 5 comes once in a blue moon.

I’m loving this PAL series as I’m doing a Tokyo to Syd route myself with the family in January.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 67
 JW
(@JW)
Joined: 8 years ago

Really wished there were some pictures of the 10 abreast Y on this aircraft. No full service carrier was lunatic enough to place a 16” width seat on an ultra long haul plane and here came PAL. No we wonder why they were cheap.


Reply
1 Reply
Diamond
(@1990_)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 1952

That 3-4-3 on an a350 is brutal… I mean, the double-middle on the old 2-5-2 is a ‘crime against humanity’, but none of those are still running anymore, so…


Reply
Posts: 126
 SJ
(@SJ)
Joined: 7 years ago

For all the hype that the airline and its die-hard fans had, this definitely sounds disappointing. Looks like you had better experience on your JFK-YVR flight a while back! Hard product definitely is improved but to not have functioning WiFi on a brand new aircraft is unacceptable.

I’m also disappointed to hear about the service, especially its inconsistency. But when I’ve got bad service on PAL or any high end hotels in the Philippines, it’s usually young and inexperienced staff or it lacks authenticity. But I’ve never felt that I was an inconvenience. Curious, I’m assuming the purser was more senior but were the rest of the crew more junior?


Reply
1 Reply
Admin
(@lucky)
Joined: 13 years ago

Member
Posts: 41096

@ SJ -- The purser was indeed pretty senior, and the rest of the crew at least looked pretty young. So your assumptions are correct.


Reply
Posts: 23
 VS
(@vs)
Member
Joined: 1 year ago

Looking for "heart" in airline service is a fool's errand. A Lie-flat seat, good meal and drink, clean toilet at a good price is all I care for. It looks like this flight meets all my criteria.


Reply
Posts: 285
Diamond
(@quorumcall)
Member
Joined: 3 years ago

Probably the first time I've ever seen "missing heart" used to refer to anything in the Philippines. (On the other hand, very true!)


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 93
Gold
(@art_czar)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

Lufthansa is flying ex-PR A350s with 1-2-1 config bet MUC and SEA for this winter schedule. Do they have the same seats as the ones reviewed here?


Reply
1 Reply
Admin
(@lucky)
Joined: 13 years ago

Member
Posts: 41096

@ Art_Czar -- Nope, those would be the A350-900 seats, which I reviewed here:
https://onemileatatime.com/philippine-airlines-a350-business-class-review/


Reply
Posts: 2835
Diamond
(@travelinwilly)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

I'm a bit surprised by the lack of vegetarian options for the dinner entrées and midflight snacks. I haven't flown PR in decades, due to a combination of an aversion to MNL's airport and the fact that they don't offer a first class product, but one would think they'd still have *something* for the vegetarians in business class (and I'm guessing the back of the plane had the same problem).

It's disappointing to read about the lacklustre crew, as that's an area where PR almost always shines.


Reply
Posts: 38
Diamond
(@ricky_)
Member
Joined: 2 years ago

"I made sure to also choose a Filipino option for my pre-arrival main"; both Arroz Caldo and Beef Tapa are Filipino dishes so you were in luck. I had the Arroz Caldo on my PR business class trip back in 2022 and it was the best thing I ate on the plane.


Reply
Posts: 103
Diamond
(@jacobin777)
Member
Joined: 3 years ago

Thanks for the input. I've been looking into PR once they announced they were going to join One World. OK, certainly not JL or CX in J however sans "soft product", it seems PR check basically all of the boxes I want when I travel in J. I will give them a try once they join One World.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards