Japan Airlines Firs...
 

Japan Airlines First Class Lounge Tokyo Narita Airport Review

42 Posts
19 Users
0 Reactions
258 Views
Posts: 39919
Admin
Topic starter
(@lucky)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago
[#9210]
wpf-cross-image

My flight from Tokyo Narita to Chicago was departing at 10:50AM, though I got to the airport plenty early. I had spent the night at the Hilton Tokyo Narita, so figured I might as well go to the airport early and work from there, have breakfast, etc. I got to Narita Terminal 2 before 6AM,…

Continue reading: Japan Airlines First Class Lounge Tokyo Narita Airport Review

Share your questions, experiences, and thoughts below.


41 Replies
41 Replies
(@adfer)
Joined: 8 years ago

Posts: 5

How does this lounge compare to the ANA first class lounge?


Reply
Diamond
(@jasoncrh)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 624

I flew out of gate 71 in 1998 on Delta's first ever nonstop flight from Tokyo to Atlanta. Prior to that Delta flew Tokyo to Atlanta via Portland. On that first flight, there was a ceremony etc at the gate prior to boarding, but other than that, the gate looks EXACTLY the same!


Reply
 Flow
(@flow)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

@Lucky Does JAL not escort you to the fast-track security lane when you show up to check-in or was it because you got there too early? When I flew ANA, they had a separate check-in area for first class and walked me to a much shorter fast-track security line (which was right next to first class check-in) for premium passengers.


Reply
(@playalaguna)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 37

JAL and ANA 1st class lounges are quite similar with food offerings at the buffets, in addition ANA has an a la carte menu. ANA 1st lounge is smaller and located at the end of a rotunda, while the JAL lounge is larger and more centrally located.

JAL 1st class lounge now has a laminated sheet saying that they are renovating lounges and discouraging non JAL Oneworld Emeralds' visits to limit overcrowding. In typical Japanese style, they do not push back if you politely insist.


Reply
 anon
(@anon)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 520

JL F NRT is most overrated F lounge. Tiny showers barely J class standards. No private areas. Very crowded. bleh


Reply
 Bill
(@Bill)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 620

Yea the loung is not amazing in design but the sushi and views of the planes make up for a lot of that. Still its never going to be The Pier. Its not a lounge i rush to get to but i do get there early enough to get some sushi.


Reply
 Rik
(@Rik)
Joined: 10 years ago

Posts: 5

Given your self admission and proclivity for water bottle theft, I'm surprised you aren't encouraging your readers to swipe the Sake...


Reply
(@Tolly)
Joined: 8 years ago

Posts: 4

It is shameful that Japanese standards for F lounges is so low. I would've expected better from Japan.


Reply
(@donna)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 1579

From looking at the photos, I drew exactly the same impression of how this lounge is very densely furnished. Clearly, no one was there when you were but I’d hate to be there at a peak period when it was filled to capacity. I’d be escaping into the terminal for breathing room.


Reply
(@Justin)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 496

Great shots of those JAL birds! The JAL crane roundel (aka the "tsurumaru") is one of my favorite airline liveries and logos. It was created by a San Francisco ad agency in the 1950s according to Wikipedia. I'm glad they brought it back!

As for the lounge, it looks more like a nice business class lounge than a special first class lounge.


Reply
(@donna)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 1579

To @Rik and all the others who are blaming Lucky for water “theft” and being singularly responsible for the global climate crisis because he takes flights, uses hotels and drinks bottled water. You aren’t being charged to read his blog, if you don’t approve of his livelihood, his views and opinions and his choices, maybe it’s time to move on to another blog where the writers live up to your high standards.


Reply
 Puck
(@Puck)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 1

United's Polaris Lounge blows JAL's F lounge out of the water!


Reply
(@Jmw2323)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 52

Been twice. Meh both times. A shame coming from their home airport.
Will be in NH Flounge this weekend. Low expectations


Reply
 Rico
Diamond
(@rico)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 304

Bowmore 18 Scotch is pretty nice for a lounge. I've never tried it, but it has to be better than Johnnie Walker red.


Reply
Gold
(@gary-leff)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 294

I find the sushi disappointing particularly the rice.


Reply
(@Justin)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 496

I always enjoy transiting in Narita and Haneda. People always talk about how awesome Changi is (and it is), but my favorite international airport is actually the international terminal at Haneda. I love the outdoor observation deck, the elegant architecture and design, the amazing old shopping/restaurant street and of course the dining. Narita isn't quite as nice as the new international terminal at Haneda, but has great dining, shopping for friends and a tranquility and aesthetic that I enjoy and find all over Japan.


Reply
(@Kato La)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 2

@Lucky - You forgot about the complimentary shoe shine via Paul Stuart products available in the bake of the lounge! I know it is not a big deal, but I always have a pair of dress shoes with me, and it is nice to get them shined while enjoying the Japanese cuisine.


Reply
 Rik
(@Rik)
Joined: 10 years ago

Posts: 5

@Gary Just ask for it as sashimi, @Donna I've been reading Ben's work since he worked with Hilary at Travelsort, I use his credit card links and Ford is one of my travel agents. If his blog were a subscription service I would subscribe and gladly recommend it to others. Over the past 8+ years by my calculations Ben has gone through 10,000+ plastic water bottles from his travels. That's a lot of unnecessary plastic. Friends have to be upfront with their friends when they see they are doing something not in their best interest. There is nothing more shocking to me than than traveling to the world's most beautiful places and seeing how much trash is washing up on the beaches.


Reply
 Tony
(@Tony)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 92

Come on, now. Are you expecting Sukiyabashi Jiro sushi from the JL F class lounge? If you want good sushi, go to a restaurant. I definitely wouldn't go 6 hours early to the airport just to have lounge sushi.


Reply
Diamond
(@stuart-2)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

I have used it often and it's usually never crowded....often empty in fact compared to lounges in Hong Kong, etc. It's functional, comfortable, and has the fun beer dispenser that is so Japan. I honestly could give a hoot for the high glitz lounges as I am mostly there for an hour at best. I find the JAL lounge serves the purpose well and provide a functional bridge from check in to getting on the plane.


Reply
(@myriad)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

the thing I remember was the fruit - a tiny plate with one piece each of honeydew, cantaloupe, and pineapple. easily the best fruit I've ever had in a lounge


Reply
Gold
(@andy-11235)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 370

Agree that the JAL lounge disappoints. Amazing in-flight, but the lounge is definitely more in line with their *cough* jv partner.

Honestly not surprised by the hours. Narita famously has some tight operating hour restrictions due to noise complaints from area residents. Besides, you also have to consider the need to get from downtown tokyo to narita -- it's an hour by train, so I doubt there's that much demand for flights that early.


Reply
Diamond
(@batterytraveller)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Although it doesn’t have the sushi bar the first lounge in the satellite is much nicer. Often less crowded and with nice arm chains facing the target. Grab a quick sushi in the main lounge and then head to the satellite.


Reply
 Bo
(@Bo)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 1

This is the busiest first class lounge I have ever been to. I traveled on jl4 on late January. When I got to the lounge, I can hardly find a seat. The dishes were good for a lounge, but far from enough for a first class lounge.


Reply
(@benjamin_n)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

It's an ok lounge, but it's no HKG Cathay experience.

It gets slammed and the staff handles things as best they can. The last few times I was there, it was just too busy to be anywhere near relaxing. People just running for the food and shoveling as much of it into their mouths as quickly as possible... It felt as if they were trying to get as much out of that 30 minutes there as they could.

In the words of Chicago The Musical, '... The whole world's gone lowbrow.'


Reply
(@janeblogs)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Whilst it's not the most spacious lounge, it certainly more than does the job. Recently I have been travelling Sydney Narita New York on JAL which I have to say is a far more pleasurable & convenient experience than flying Sydney LAX or DFW to NYC despite being a little longer. I always have a shower which is perfectly servicable if a little on the small side, then drop my luggage in the holding room, drop my shoes for a shine and then head to the sushi bar which is such a treat it outweighs the crush of the lounge. Besides, it is invariably crushed when I arrive but almost empty when I depart.

I recently checked out the QF lounge in the satellite to see if it might be a better option but I took one look inside and despite having less people, I was very happy to be able to return to the JAL lounge. Frankly the JAL first lounge is no worse and maybe even better than what QF is currently providing at Changi for J & F passengers and certainly the staff is more charming. I do have to say that every visit I go down to the massage place located at the entrance to the satellite and for whatever reason even though I always have at least 3 hours I can never get an appointment, maybe there's some secret to securing space there but if I could make that work then I would be more than happy with the Narita experience.


Reply
 Hiro
(@hiro)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 323

Lucky, there are no early morning departures from Narita due to most passengers travel long from Tokyo and beyond by public transportations. The exception to this is LCCs departing from T3, where most passengers have to spend over-night a day at Narita before.

I'd slightly prefer ANA lounge at Narita for a bit more personalized service and a la carte dining. The sweets selection is also nice as well. However, both are over-crowded during peak times where I'd estimate 90-95% are non-first class status travellers. Very disappointing.

I like what United and Qatar are doing with their exclusive business/first lounges.


Reply
Diamond
(@vancouver-char)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Your reviews are always honest and fun to follow. Somehow, i find JAL Business (at least PVG-NRT-YVR) and their "Sakura' lounges underwehlming; somehow ANA is more with it; Thank You for your interesting reviews


Reply
(@Mike Schemm)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 5

This reminds me of my experience with the ANA First Class Lounge years ago. That and check in was so bad that ANA has since been at the bottom of my preferred airlines. I had used miles for a United First Class return SEA-SIN, with a stop in Narita. I was booked Business Class on the segment NRT-SIN, as ANA did not offer a first class on that route and United First was booked full. I could not get a boarding pass in SEA for the NRT-SIN portion, so first stop in NRT was to get a boarding pass. There was only one agent handling all classes inside customs where I was. That agent was handling a BIG problem with a customer, so the wait was long, but eventually I got my boarding pass. Even though I was "only" business with ANA NRT-SIN, I thought I might be able to get into the First Class ANA Lounge, since I had "paid" for First Class and the rest of my trip was First Class. Couldn't hurt to try. No go. It was annoying, but rules are rules, so only a minor annoyance. But as I left the lounge, I finally put on my readers and looked at the packet United had given me as I stepped off the plane in NRT. What do you know! There was a coupon for the First Class Lounge. I turned right around, gave them the coupon, and was ushered right in. I was there about 15 minutes, had poured myself a wine, and was trying some soup, when they came to my seat and kicked me out. Turns out there was a small box in the corner of the voucher that was checked that said United First Class Lounge. I did not see it, and they initially did not see it. If they had pointed it out on entry, it would be annoying but understandable. As I said, rules are rules. But to come remove me from the lounge after already being admitted was unacceptable.


Reply
(@mark3)
Joined: 10 years ago

Posts: 239

What language is this: I do prefer Japan Airlines’ first class lounge at Haneda Airport for sure.


Reply
(@Jesper)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 475

@Ben, the review will be outdated very soon, as the renovated 4th floor lounge opens 1st of April and this lounge closes for renovation 1st of April. I don't expect any huge revolution, but the 4th floor lounge is getting some very nice looking ramen options.

Please fly JAL again this summer to review the new lounge.

And yes, as mentioned above you missed out on the shoe shine service by John Lobb (not Paul Stuart), they really do amazing work.


Reply
 AJO
(@AJO)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 231

BA's Concorde Room at LHR looks much more "first class" to me than this lounge...


Reply
 SK
(@SK)
Joined: 8 years ago

Posts: 126

Lucky, generally speaking, what do you consider a better choice: hotel breakfast or airport lounge breakfast? As we see here, you gave up hotel option in favor of the lounge. Any regrets?


Reply
Gold
(@cmorgan)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Thanks Lucky. I am flying First class out of Tokyo to Los Angeles in late April. Hopefully this lounge will be renovated by then or I will go to the 4th floor lounge. I would agree however that the Pier in HK is a very nice experience.


Reply
(@Jesper)
Joined: 9 years ago

Posts: 475

@CMORGAN, this lounge closes to begin renovation April 1st. The announced reopening is summer 2019. So late April it will not be available for sure.


Reply
(@THEsocalledfan)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 72

Ben it has a beer machine. Let that sink in a few minutes....

Hands down the coolest thing I've ever seen in a first class lounge!


Reply
 vand
(@vand)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Haneda first class lounge is definitely nicer in ambience - recently renovated


Reply
 OT
(@OT)
Joined: 10 years ago

Posts: 110

Ben, you forgot to mention one important feature which makes this lounge exceptional, in my view - it's dead quiet! phone calls are not allowed. For that reason I find it a more peaceful experience than pretty much any other lounge, including HKG's The Pier, which has nicer ambience but that can be easily ruined by a loud party in the dining room or someone having a loud phone call in the "living room" area.


Reply
Gold
(@kevinsac)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

I would expect so much more from JAL at Narita. I was in two ANA F Lounges in Narita last fall and was tremendously overwhelmed by both.


Reply
(@Maki Oryoji)
Joined: 7 years ago

Posts: 1

Its one of the world class lounge. I got a chance to visit there few weeks with a businessman. We were traveling to Sydney from there.


Reply
Diamond
(@brodie)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 161

Lounge is on point after the refurb. Much more modern and good use of space upstairs with the dining area. Ramen comes up fast and you still have the beef curry. Couldn’t help myself and indulged in both. Only problem was no room for sushi. Alcohol selection on the other hand is meh.


Reply