Is This The Dumbest...
 

Is This The Dumbest Award I Could Possibly Book?

55 Posts
17 Users
0 Reactions
486 Views
Posts: 40331
Admin
Topic starter
(@lucky)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago
[#3968]
wpf-cross-image

I'm on a bit of a kick this week when it comes to booking flights on new airlines I want to review (as I explained in my post from earlier about the 16 airlines I want to review in 2016). It started with booking Hainan Airlines business class, and I followed it up by booking…

Continue reading: Is This The Dumbest Award I Could Possibly Book?

Share your questions, experiences, and thoughts below.


54 Replies
54 Replies
(@marcus)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

I knew you were out of your mind when you booked the Air India award ticket but this Saudia award confirms it!


Reply
Diamond
(@bgriff)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

FWIW, SV does have some newer flat bed business class aircraft (BE Diamond seat like ex-CO UA and AA A321 business class). If the seat map shows business class starting from row 1 and a 3-3-3 configuration in coach it's the new configuration (Saudia oddly has moved from a 3-4-3 configuration on older planes to a 3-3-3 configuration on newer planes), though there is always a risk of an aircraft swap.

The 777-200ERs are even worse than the pictures you posted though, with a 2-3-2 not-even-angled-lie-flat configuration in business class. And on all aircraft it's a dry airline with heavily censored IFE, but the food is decent at least.


Reply
(@Julian)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 19
(@Yuri Torres)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 38

No, you are not, but indeed you'll regret after the first leg. 😀


Reply
 Ben
(@Ben)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 5

Do it so you can review Saudia Airlines instead of AeroMexico and read my trip reports on AM787 JFK/MEX/EZE and SCL/MEX/JFK for 125K SkyMiles + $88 tax/each for my parents and me. Email me!


Reply
(@Caneguy)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 1

Well you can always try to leave the airport there and as a gay guy request some public caning if you are into that sort of stuff.


Reply
(@mubashir farooq)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 5

U should definitely try this product. I live in SAUDIA and have travelled with them a million times. The service will be a hit or miss but u will surely enjoy the airline. They are in the process of retiring fleet and they even have the 787's coming which will be flying to Paris and Kuala lumpur. I and many others will love to read ur trip report on our countries flag carriers
Thanks


Reply
 Jeff
(@Jeff)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 315

if it makes sense for you to review Saudia airlines, go for it. But that layover is brutal. I would go through Mexico instead.


Reply
 Matt
(@Matt)
Joined: 18 years ago

Posts: 45

Ugh, dry airline... I wouldn't take Saudia.


Reply
Gold
(@travel4b)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Yes, you should take one for the team. Here's hoping there's a hotel in the airport.


Reply
 fanb
(@fanb)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

As a reader I'd say book it, book it,book it haha! I'm sure I'm not the only one :).. Also i think one does have to fly economy to appreciate business or maybe in your case one does have to fly angle beds..?
And it doesn't matter how long the layover or the flights are - wear fun socks! 🙂


Reply
(@Paul Rowland)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 96

Take a hit for the team! A dry airline? I cannot imagine what that is like, maybe hell?


Reply
(@Henry)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 1

Book it!!!!!!!! That would be an epic trip report. It can't be that bad!


Reply
(@No Name)
Joined: 13 years ago

Posts: 548

So with all these not very good airlines Lucky is going to to try when does the time comes to Norwegian?


Reply
(@nolan-snoeyink)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 130

Go for it! I'm all for interesting reviews! Although I still would like an Aeromexico review.

Also, the AF tool pulled up award space for China Southern J class from LHR-CAN-LAX. Wouldn't mind a CZ J review either... 🙂


Reply
(@Scott B)
Joined: 14 years ago

Posts: 44

Indeed you are, but I'm looking forward to reading about the experience! 😉


Reply
(@Joesph)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 1

@Lucky
I would suggest you to review AirAsia X Premium Flatbed (Best business class in low cost carrier) and Vitetnam Airlines (B789 and A350).


Reply
 Mike
(@Mike)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 2

Lucky, perhaps Nothing has illustrated to me your passion for encountering the full spectrum of possible "luxury" commercial aviation experiences quite like this post. You are a gem in a sometimes repetitive world my friend. If you do this- good luck!


Reply
 Tim
(@Tim)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 1

You should do it Ben if for no other reason than to appreciate that any business is better than economy. The complimentary in air detox is a bonus.


Reply
(@nolan-snoeyink)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 130

Oops... disregard my last post about CZ. I didn't notice the price was 200k miles! That's like Delta levels of insanity!


Reply
 Nic
(@Nic)
Joined: 14 years ago

Posts: 42

Speaking of Lifemiles, I actually flew SAW-LGW//LHR-BOG-MIA with my wife and kids. It worked for us, as kids got to see London during layover and we were able to bring some luggage on last leg for a relative that was moving to the U.S.


Reply
 Euro
Diamond
(@euro)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 243

I'd go with Aeromexico for that trip, and save Saudia for a shorter itin since that sounds like perhaps a little too much on Saudia. That and do they fly a 777 with flat-bed seats to London? Or is it a narrowbody with recliner seats?


Reply
 Tina
(@Tina)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 52

Why not kicking 2016 off with a "detox" in the air experience? How is it flying for that long "dry" and is it a different experience without the champange?

So, yes go for it! At least you could get maybe a visa for Saudi Arabia - as a women under 40 unmaried there is no chance to get into the country (if I would like to do that!)


Reply
(@erick-villalpando)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Hope you select Aeromexico, i want to read your review, I am mexican but most of the time I fly to Europe or Asia via US instead of Mexico City because is cheaper. I want to read the diferences between the US carries and the mexican leader carrier by you, this is something that i was waiting since i started reading this blog.
Regards


Reply
 Ken
(@Ken)
Joined: 13 years ago

Posts: 159

Are most of those 16 airline flights awards or revenue tickets? Earn and burn baby!


Reply
(@Paul Smith)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 3

I wouldn't say you were completely mad, but maybe you have taken leave of your senses, or to be kinder you are "barking", as we say in the UK. Barking as in woof!

It's bad enough flying Air India (try not to use the rest rooms, unless you are brave), but to add Saudia is totally fine the rails.

Maybe you should change your name from Lucky to "Unlucky". I wish you well, my friend.

Might I suggest Aeroflot in future, as they are much better.

You'll enjoy Finnair, but they are known for serving you reindeer meat dishes (i.e. soup and main course), as I had that a few years ago when I flew to Hong Kong, at Christmas (it may just have been a Christmas thing).

Loving your blog and look forward to reading more. May I suggest a vacation to a quiet Hawaiisn Island, with Hawaiian Airlines as your airline of choice. Aloha!


Reply
 ffi
(@ffi)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 200

Take one for the team Lucky
Just do not blog about it until well after the fact.
You do not want to be caught alone in an alley in KoSA after publishing bad stuff


Reply
(@BenjaminJ84)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 8

The out of the way routing to enjoy a new product? Certainly not a crazy idea.

But in reference to your post the other day regarding the UAE and the "openness" of the country, Saudi Arabia is over the line for me personally. I couldn't spend my money there.


Reply
(@michae)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 30

You should Pass sir don;t waste your time with an airline nobody cares about


Reply
(@colleen)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 210

Based on what I've read following this blog for a long time, I can't see how a review of this airline would be a useful data point for your audience. What percentage of your readers do you think are seriously considering booking Saudia but need a trip review to make a final decision?


Reply
Gold
(@tommy-trash)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Going without Krug that long, you'll go into DT's. Add me to the tiny minority who wants more Lufthansa reviews.


Reply
Diamond
(@ivar-nordberg)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

No. Don't bother. Saudia's premium cabins are flying nurseries: lots of screaming children. And you would have to endure it with no alcohol to dull the pain. The food is surprisingly good, though.

The worse element of this itinerary, though, is the long layover in Jeddah. JED is a horrifically awful airport; certainly the worse I have ever experienced. It's filthy, crowded, loud and obsolete. And that description goes for the premium lounges as well. An eight hour layover would be an inescapable hell. I'm actually fond of Jeddah as a city, but there would be no way for you to experience it.

Stick with Aeromexico. Or...how about Aeroflot!?!?


Reply
(@willettsworld-2)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Don't always believe everything you read! I flew AI in mid 2015 from Seoul to Hong Kong on one of their 787's and it was perfectly fine. Admittedly, it wasn't 30 hours but it was pretty damn good for the 2-3 hours. In fact, the chicken curry they served was on of the best meals I have ever had on an aircraft. The seats were fully lie flat and spacious, the service was impeccable. If you fly any of those US airlines regularly, and I assume as a Yank you do, then you are actually in for a treat. Nothing is worse than dirty ol' United, American or Delta.


Reply
(@Julian)
Joined: 14 years ago

Posts: 60

Book it already. People's descriptions of the experience sounds so miserable we need to hear your take on it 🙂


Reply
 Dan
(@Dan)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 2

the food IS good, if you like goat and camel!


Reply
(@TEX277)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 114

It's just the carrier and 'detention' that make this noteworthy - not the routing. However, it will make for an interesting trip report.

Is it the dumbest award? No. That would have to go to any BA multi-partner awards.


Reply
 ksa
(@ksa)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 5

If you cant leave JED airport its absolute hell! They dont even have "ok" food for purchase or an "ok" lounge. Do yourself a favor and atleast book through RUH. The lounge is great and you wont have to deal with all of the passengers coming from makkah! (First time flyers)


Reply
(@Michael Haddad)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 21

I lived in Jeddah on two ocassions and flew Saudia numerous times. The airline is generally ok in premium and service is pleasant. The fascinating event is when they fly from an Islamist culture to a different culture. The entire premium cabin changes in mid air to Western dress and vice versa when flying back to Jeddah. DONT MISS IT. Forget the booze. It won't kill you. Jeddah international is a hole sorry


Reply
(@John P)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 2

If you are crazy, I'm on my way. My wife and I are on the lax-csx flight in business class in March. I don't even know where Changsha is yet.


Reply
(@Klaus von stif)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 1

Im flying dat jew airline el al vomit.
Most fucked up airline there is.
Have you ever had anal sex while flying ben??


Reply
(@Michael Haddad)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 21

Klaus,

You are obnoxious. But you knew that already. I hope I am the first and the last to comment on your post.


Reply
 ABC
(@ABC)
Joined: 18 years ago

Posts: 141

@Ben,
You should expect a similar experience as this Saudi Business class review on VFTW http://viewfromthewing.boardingarea.com/2013/10/20/saudia-business-class-trip-report-award-availability-delta-miles-amazing-fly/

Bring your own bottle of gin or rum and you'll have a unique experience .


Reply
 Alan
(@Alan)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 40

Ben, have you flown AeroMexico? It looks like LHR-MEX is the 787; their Clase Premier has great seats but the service is quite lacking. I just flew it this past weekend:

http://singleflyer.com/2015/12/31/aeromexico-clase-premier-review/


Reply
 Joe
(@Joe)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 26

Delegate that one to Ford.


Reply
(@Sahir Siddiqui)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 27

You know, youtube is full of videos of people finding creative ways to smash or destroy their smart phones - and I always wondered WHY!!!
Well, congrats, you are now DOING THE SAME THING!

LHR - DEL - SFO???
LHR - JED - LAX???

Only one thing can be asked : why?


Reply
(@Susan B)
Joined: 15 years ago

Posts: 80

Ben. Step away from the computer. An 8 hour dry layover in what sounds like a hellhole followed by 12 hours in recliners without refreshment sounds like a recipe for one big whine. You probably can't even recharge your devices and get work done in Jeddah. There are more interesting ways to torture yourself.

@Paul Smith: nothing wrong with reindeer, if you like game. A Finnair flight probably isn't the best place to try it, though.


Reply
 A
(@A)
Joined: 16 years ago

Posts: 61

It's not the dumbest award you could possibly book. However, if it were in *coach*, that might be a possibility. You wouldn't be crazy to book it in business, though-reviewing airlines is kind of your job.

"viewer discretion advised"-cute.


Reply
 Joey
Diamond
(@joey-4)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 1216

I've flown on both Saudia and Aeromexico business class and both aren't SQ/EK/EY level but are still decent.
The Jeddah airport Saudia lounge doesn't have alcohol either not does it have showers. The most interesting thing is watching Saudia IFE.... Where they blur out women's chest if it is showing or lower thighs on all their movies.
I in particular enjoyed flying in Saudia whereas Aeromexico was a hit or miss. I wouldn't call either award dumb at all. In fact, Saudia has a lot of award seats available ---- heck I've seen 8 award seats on one flight in J so you can bring Ford and a few of your friends to enjoy this experience with you, Lucky! When I flew Saudia business, both times probably only 40% of J seats were occupied.


Reply
(@travel-wtih-massi)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Jeddah Airport is horrorable but the Saudi Arabian Airlines Alfursan Business Lounge is okay (much better as the partner Lounge you have to use flying with LH for example). IMHO definitely not worth for an extra visit but okay to spend few hours and a paradise compare to the public space. It´s cold as a fridge what could be a little bit annoying at the night time (or after a red-eye). Flying Saudia okay for a few hours but on long distance - no thank you: unfriendly and impersonal. Good luck and save trip.


Reply
 Wp01
Gold
(@wp01)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 0

Next time, you should fly Garuda between Tokyo and Amsterdam via Jakarta!


Reply
 Hiro
(@hiro)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 326

Like Bgriff mentioned, there are full-flat Business Class seats on selected aircraft. However, I do disagree that B772 with 2-3-2 arranged seats not comfortable. I've been on it and even though it was big squishy it did get angled lie-flat, and I felt pretty comfortable (similar to Space Bed on old SQ aircraft).

I think this will be a great trip. I found SV service pretty decent, and crews were polite. The only complaint, apart for being dry, is there were virtually no drink services and had to ask every time for a re-fill when needed (but then crews responded well). Food was great! I've had one of the best biryanis on plane. IFE selection was not bad either.

What I'll not like about your itinerary, is that there will no place for a shower (I may be wrong). In 2014 when I made a transit through Riyadh, despite being a decent lounge, there was no shower booth. And Riyadh lounge is (was) supposed to be better quality than Jeddah one.

Hope to see your report on SV experience!


Reply
 Tim
(@Tim)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 30

Lucky,

you need to try to book this as TIJ-MEX-LHR! dreamliner lie-flat on the TIJ-MEX segment. Les you try the Cross Border Xpress !

we just positioned ourselves in CUN, flew CUN-MEX (23hr stop to add passport pages), enjoyed NYE in Mexico City, and then flew the Aeromexico dreamliner from MEX-TIJ so we could try the Cross Border Xpress. Priced as an awesome 1 way fare in business class, and awesome experience. Enjoyed two Aeromexico Salon Premier lounges. Email me directly if you want me to send you photos and a quick write-up.


Reply
 PM1
Platinum
(@pm1)
Joined: 5 years ago

Member
Posts: 159

Take one for the team Lucky! I wanted to fly their business class product a couple of years ago (SkyMiles redemption) and my wife wouldn't let me fly them or transit through Jeddah. I've been curious ever since!


Reply
(@Abdulaziz)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 1

Michael Haddad as worker in Saudi Arabia, you can choose any airlines you want but for sure you travel by Saudia as your work pay it for you, no your self.
people here talking about the airlines and the route not about what you see in premium class ( ok we now know you travel in premium class).


Reply